Asana compared with Magpie

Asana vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Asana and Magpie both let a team plan its work as projects of tasks. Each task has an assignee, a due date and comments. They are built around different things.

  1. Asana is a work management product for projects, tasks, goals and reporting. It is built for teams that run many projects at once. They plan them on timelines, with rules, forms and AI moving the work along.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Kanban Boards is one part of it. Beside the boards it includes To-dos, Time Tracking, Invoicing, Mail, Documents, Calendar and more. It is built for someone whose projects are one part of running the business.
Create account
Robin Mazur’s Autumn launch board in Personal, with cards in Inbox, To do, In progress and Done, some with a due date and To-dos.

How is Magpie different?

1. Projects come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Kanban Boards for work that moves through stages, with To-dos on a card
  • To-dos and Calendar for each person's day, across Personal and every team
  • Issues for bugs and product work, with projects, milestones and custom fields
  • Time Tracking and Invoicing, so tracked time becomes a line on an invoice
  • Mail, Documents, Team chat, Contacts, Meetings and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Asana manages projects and tasks, and connects to the apps that hold email, documents, calendars and invoices.

2. A team pays one price

The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, with no limit on boards. Adding a person to the team does not change the bill. Guests take no place on the plan. Asana's paid plans are priced per user.

3. A card's To-dos are part of each person's day

Each To-do on a card is an ordinary To-do in the team. It shows in To-dos and on the team's Calendar on its date, with its own reminder, repeat and assignee. Ticking it off in either place ticks off the same To-do. A To-do starts a Time Tracking timer, and billable time goes onto an invoice.

Comparing Magpie and Asana

Asana does more inside the project; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Asana's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatAsanaMagpie
Projects as boardsCards in columns that move through stages Yes Yes
List, calendar and timeline viewsThe same project seen another way Yes No
SubtasksSmaller steps, each with a person and a date Yes To-dos on a card
Custom fieldsYour own fields, such as a priority or a cost Starter and above No
Dependencies and milestonesWaiting on another task, and a project's checkpoints Starter and above No
My tasks and InboxYour work and updates from every project Yes Partly
Rules and automationTasks that move or change by themselves Starter and above No
Request formsEach answer added as a task Starter and above Partly
TemplatesStart a project or a task from a ready-made one Yes JSON import
Goals and portfoliosTargets, and every project's progress on one page Advanced and above No
Charts and dashboardsA project's tasks as charts Starter and above No
Workload and capacityHow busy each person is, and plans for the months ahead Advanced and above No
Time trackingA timer and totals for the work Advanced and above Yes
InvoicingBill a client for the work and the time No Yes
An assistant for the workAsk how it is going and have it make changes Yes Yes
AI that works by itselfAI steps that run without being asked Paid plans No
AI apps through MCPClaude or ChatGPT working on your projects Yes Yes
IntegrationsSlack, Google, Microsoft 365 and more Yes No
Phone and desktop appsApps for phones, Mac and Windows Yes In the browser
SAML single sign-onSign in through the company's identity provider Enterprise No
Mail, documents and calendarThe rest of the work in the same account No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Projects and views

Both hold a project's work as cards in columns that move through stages. Asana also shows a project as a list, a calendar or a timeline, with saved views. They do it better than we do today.

WhatAsanaMagpie
Make a project for a piece of work and split it into stages Source Yes Yes
Move tasks through stages as cards on a board Source Yes Yes
See a project's tasks as a list, with a column for each detail Source Magpie: A board is seen only as columns of cards. Issues has a list with columns that sorts and groups, for issues. Yes No
See a project's tasks on a calendar by their dates Source Magpie: Card due dates are not on Calendar. A To-do on a card shows on its team's Calendar on its date. Yes Partly
See tasks on a timeline from start to finish, and drag to change their dates Source Magpie: A card has no start date and a board is seen only as columns. Issues' Roadmap lists projects that have dates, earliest first, but not as bars. Yes No
Filter and sort a project's tasks, and keep the view for next time Source Magpie: A board always shows every card in column order. The assistant finds a team's cards by their words, column or due date and says who each is assigned to, and Issues has filters and saved views for issues. Yes No
Keep a project's brief, key links and who does what in one place Source Magpie: A board has a description of up to 500 characters, shown under its name and changed from Edit details. There is no place for roles or a longer brief. Yes Partly
Keep one task in several projects at once Source Magpie: A card belongs to one board. Its To-dos also show in To-dos, but the card itself is seen only on its board. Yes No
Copy a task or a whole section to start similar work Source Magpie: A card or a column cannot be copied, and a card moves only between the columns of its own board. To have it elsewhere, it is added again. Yes No
Select several tasks and change them together Source Magpie: Each card is changed on its own; the assistant can make several changes asked for in one message. Issues changes the status, priority, assignee, project or labels of many selected issues at once. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie board has up to 20 columns and 500 cards. Free has 1 board; Pro and the Team plan have no limit.

Tasks

Both give a task one assignee, a due date, a description, comments and smaller steps. Asana adds start dates, custom fields, dependencies, milestones, approvals and proofing.

WhatAsanaMagpie
Write a task's details and talk about it in comments Source Yes Yes
Give each task one person who is responsible for it Source Yes Yes
Give a task a due date and time, a start date, and tick it off when done Source Magpie: A card has a due date with no time, shown on its front. It has no start date and cannot be marked done: a finished card is moved to a Done column. A To-do on the card has a date, a time, a reminder and a tick. Yes Partly
Break a task into smaller steps, each with its own person and date Source Yes Yes
Attach files to a task Source Magpie: A card holds up to 10 images or screenshots from Your images, and comments can carry images. Other files, such as a PDF or a spreadsheet, cannot be attached; a link can go in the description. Issues attaches any file. Yes Partly
Mark a task as waiting on another, and know when it can start Source Magpie: Cards have no links between them. Issues can mark one issue as blocking another, shown on both issues as Blocks and Blocked by. Yes No
Have a task come round again on a schedule Source Magpie: A card does not repeat. A To-do on the card can, such as every Thursday, and each occurrence comes back in To-dos. Yes Partly
Keep my own fields on tasks, such as a priority, a number or a person Source Magpie: A card has its title, description, column, assignee, due date and colour only. Issues has custom fields of seven types. Yes No
Mark the checkpoints of a project Source Magpie: A board has no milestones. Issues projects have milestones that count how many of their issues are complete. Yes No
Ask someone to approve a piece of work Source Magpie: A card has no approval step; a reviewer comments on it or moves it to another column. Yes No
Leave feedback on a spot in an image or a PDF Source Magpie: Images on a card are commented on as a whole, in the card's comments. Design files take comments pinned to a spot on the design. Yes No

Good to know: Issues, in the same team, has custom fields, milestones and Blocked by links for issues. A Kanban card holds up to 10 images.

My tasks, Inbox and Home

Asana's My tasks and Inbox gather your tasks and their updates from every project. Magpie's To-dos gathers your To-dos from Personal and every team; cards assigned to you are on each board.

WhatAsanaMagpie
See everything assigned to me, from every project, in one list Source Magpie: To-dos lists the To-dos assigned to you in Personal and every team, To-dos on cards included. Cards assigned to you are shown only on each board; the assistant lists the cards of the team you are in, with who each is assigned to. Yes Partly
Be told about changes to my tasks, and when someone mentions me Source Magpie: The person who added a card gets one email about the changes others make to it, comments included. There are no mentions on cards, nobody else can follow a card, and an assignee is not told. The Magpie app also notifies the card's author of each comment, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Start the day on one page of my work and notes Source Yes Yes
Turn an email into a task Source Magpie: Mail cannot make a To-do or a card from a message, and a board has no email address. A Note can be turned into a To-do. Yes No

Good to know: Dashboard shows To-dos from Personal and every team, Notes, unread mail and recent work, such as boards.

Workflows and automation

Asana runs rules, request forms and templates, and connects to over 100 other apps. Magpie moves cards by hand or through the assistant.

WhatAsanaMagpie
Have tasks move or change by themselves when something happens Source Magpie: Cards move only by hand or through the assistant. Issues has rules that set an issue's status or priority when it changes. Yes No
Take requests through a form that adds each one as a task Source Magpie: On a board that takes suggestions, anyone signed in to Magpie suggests a card with a title, a description and images, and it lands in the Inbox column. The questions cannot be changed. Forms asks any questions but keeps its responses in Forms, and Issues' public forms make issues. Yes Partly
Start a project from a template, or from one we already run Source Magpie: A new board starts with Inbox, To Do, In Progress and Done. There are no ready-made boards and a board cannot be copied, but a board can be built from a JSON document, and Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write one. Yes Partly
Make new tasks from a template Source Magpie: Each card starts empty. Import JSON adds a set of prepared cards, with descriptions, due dates and colours, to a board in one step. Yes No
Connect projects to the other tools we use, such as Slack, Google or Microsoft Source Magpie: Kanban Boards connects to no other apps. Magpie's API and Connected apps reach its boards from outside. Yes No

Good to know: Import a board from JSON builds a board with its columns and cards. Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write that JSON, from a spreadsheet for example.

Goals and reporting

Asana has status updates, goals, portfolios and charts of a project's tasks. Magpie counts the cards in each column, and has no charts.

WhatAsanaMagpie
Tell everyone how a project is going: on track, at risk or off track Source Magpie: A board has no status. An Issues project has a status, such as In Progress or Paused, but no written updates. Yes No
Set goals and see the projects that move them forward Source Magpie: Magpie has no goals linked to boards or projects. Yes No
See how all my projects are going on one page Source Magpie: Kanban Boards lists each board with its description and number of cards, but no status or progress. Issues' Projects page lists each project with its status and how many of its issues are complete. Yes No
See charts of a project's tasks Source Magpie: Each column's header shows how many cards it holds; there are no charts. Yes No
Search every project for a task Source Magpie: Search and Command-K find boards by name, not cards. The assistant searches the cards on every board in a team by their title or description, and their comments by their words. Yes Partly
Take a project out as a file Source Magpie: A board cannot be exported. The assistant and Connected apps can read its cards, and Issues exports CSV and JSON. Yes No
Bring tasks in from a spreadsheet or another app's export Source Magpie: Import a board from JSON builds a board with its columns and cards, and Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write the JSON, from a spreadsheet for example. A CSV file does not load as it is. Issues imports CSV. Yes Partly

Good to know: The assistant finds a team's cards by their words, column or due date. It says who each card is assigned to.

Resource management

Asana plans people's time ahead with Workload and capacity planning. Magpie records the time already spent, in Time Tracking, and bills it through Invoicing.

WhatAsanaMagpie
See how much work each person has, and even it out Source Magpie: Nothing adds up the cards assigned to each person across boards. Yes No
Plan who works on which project over the coming months Source Magpie: Time Tracking records time already spent; it does not plan people's time ahead. Yes No
Record the time spent on a task and compare it with the estimate Source Magpie: A To-do on a card, or an issue, starts a Time Tracking timer linked to it, and Time Tracking reports totals by project, Contact or tag. A card itself has no timer, and nothing records an estimate to compare with. Yes Partly
Approve people's timesheets and keep projects within budget Source Magpie: Time Tracking projects have an hourly rate, billing rounding and an hour budget, and team reports total the billable amounts. Nobody approves timesheets, and a rate is set for a project or a Contact, not for each person. Yes Partly
Bill a client for the time tracked on the work Source Asana: The Timesheets and Budgets add-on records billable time and rates, but Asana makes no invoices; they are made in another app.Magpie: A team admin adds their own completed, billable Time Tracking entries for a Contact to an invoice in Invoicing, each as a line priced at its rate. Teammates' time cannot be added yet. No Partly

Good to know: Time Tracking projects have an hourly rate, billing rounding and an hour budget. Team reports total the billable amounts.

Asana AI

Both have an assistant that answers questions about the work and changes it. Both connect to AI apps such as Claude and ChatGPT. Asana's AI Teammates also do steps of the work by themselves.

WhatAsanaMagpie
Have AI summarise a task, break it into steps or write its text Source Magpie: The assistant adds and edits cards and their descriptions from a message, and Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write a whole board. Nothing inside a card writes for you. Yes Partly
Ask an assistant how the work is going, and have it make changes Source Yes Yes
Have AI agents do steps of the work by themselves, such as sorting new requests Source Magpie: The assistant acts only when asked in a message; nothing on a board runs AI by itself. Yes No
Let an AI app such as Claude or ChatGPT work on my projects Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Connected apps link Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor and others through MCP. Free connects 2 apps and Pro 10.

Admin, security and apps

Both bring a team into the same projects and keep a log of what changed. On both, teammates' changes appear on an open project as they make them. Asana adds private projects, comment-only access, SAML sign-in, required two-factor sign-in and apps for phones and computers.

WhatAsanaMagpie
Bring the whole team into the same projects Source Magpie: Every member of the board's team opens its boards and adds, moves and edits cards. A team has 3 members on Free and 25 on the Team plan. Yes Partly
Let a client or freelancer work on one project without seeing the rest Source Magpie: Guests take no place on the plan, up to 10 on Free and 100 on a paid plan, but a guest given Kanban Boards opens every board in the team. A board's outside access lets anyone signed in to Magpie view it, or also suggest cards, comment and heart. Yes Partly
Keep a project to some people, or let some only comment Source Magpie: Every member who can use Kanban Boards opens all of the team's boards, and a team admin can keep a member out of the area as a whole. Member access, set for the whole team, makes members View only or able to edit; a board cannot be kept to some members. Yes Partly
See everything that happened on a project Source Yes Yes
See teammates' changes as they make them Source Yes Yes
Work from the keyboard Source Yes Yes
Sign in through our company's Google, Microsoft or identity provider account Source Magpie: People sign in with a password and two-factor code, a passkey, or a Google, Apple, LinkedIn or GitHub account. There is no Microsoft or SAML sign-in, and a team cannot require one way of signing in. Yes Partly
Require two-factor sign-in for everyone in the team Source Magpie: Each person turns on two-factor sign-in for their own account; a team admin cannot require it. Yes No
Use projects on a phone Source Yes Yes
Use projects in an app on Mac or Windows Source Magpie: Kanban Boards is used in a browser on a computer. Yes No
Keep working with no connection Source Asana: The iPhone and Android apps let you read notifications, comment, change dates and assignees and complete tasks offline, and sync later. The desktop app and the browser need a connection.Magpie: Boards need a connection. The Magpie app keeps a card's text on the phone while it is being written, until it is saved, but the app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Partly No
Run the rest of the business from the same account: mail, documents, calendar and invoices Source Asana: Asana manages projects and tasks; email, documents, calendars and invoicing stay in other apps it connects to. No Yes

Good to know: Guests take no place on the plan: up to 10 on Free and 100 on a paid plan. A guest given Kanban Boards opens every board in the team.

Price comparison

How Asana charges

Asana charges by plan and by user. Personal is free for 2 people. Starter, Advanced, Enterprise and Enterprise+ are priced per user, billed monthly or yearly, and Enterprise prices are quoted. The plan sets what a project can do: Starter adds timelines, rules and custom fields, and Advanced adds goals, portfolios, workload and time tracking. Prices are on Asana's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The plan sets how many boards, team members and guests you have, not which areas you can use. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per user. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planAsanaMagpie
How a team paysPer user, per month, on Starter and aboveOne Team plan for up to 25 people
Free planPersonal, for 2 people, with no limit on projectsA team of 3, with 1 board
GuestsFree and unlimited on Starter and above10 on Free, 100 on a paid plan
Timelines, rules and custom fieldsStarter and aboveNot available
Goals, portfolios and workloadAdvanced and aboveNot available
Time trackingAdvanced and aboveIncluded
Timesheets and budgetsA separate add-on, for Starter and aboveHour budgets and rates in Time Tracking, included
AIAI Assists on Starter and above; AI Teammates within a monthly allowance on paid plansThe assistant, on every plan
Invoicing, mail and documentsNot offeredIncluded; Mail needs a paid plan

When to choose Magpie or Asana

  • Want your projects on boards beside time tracking, invoices, mail and documents, for one price for the whole team? Go with Magpie.
  • Want timelines, custom fields, rules, goals and workload across many projects, with apps on every device? Asana is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a team running many projects at once
Asana. Timelines with dependencies, portfolios and Workload show where every project stands and who is too busy. Magpie shows each board on its own, as columns of cards.
For a company that plans by goals
Asana. Goals take their progress from the projects linked to them, and status updates go to each project's members. Magpie has no goals or status updates.
For a creative or marketing team that reviews work
Asana. Approvals and proofing put feedback on a spot of an image or a PDF. Magpie's cards take comments on the card as a whole.
For a freelancer or a studio that bills by the hour
Magpie. A To-do on a card starts a Time Tracking timer, and billable time goes onto an invoice in Invoicing. Asana records billable time in an add-on and makes no invoices.
For a small service business
Magpie. The board for each job is beside the client's contact, the invoices, Mail and the calendar, in one team. Asana connects to other apps for each of these.
For a small team with a few projects
Either. Both put cards in columns with an assignee, a due date, comments and smaller steps. Choose by whether you need list and timeline views and rules, or the rest of the business in the same account.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Asana and Magpie?

Asana is a work management product for projects, tasks, goals and reporting. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Kanban Boards is one area beside To-dos, Time Tracking, Invoicing, Mail and Documents. Asana does more inside the project; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Asana?

Yes, for a small team that runs its projects on boards. A Magpie card has an assignee, a due date, comments, images and To-dos, and the board keeps an activity log. The same team has Time Tracking, Invoicing, Mail, Documents and Calendar.

Consider keeping Asana if you plan work on a timeline, sort tasks by your own fields, or let rules move the work. Keep it too if you report on goals and portfolios, balance each person's workload, or need SAML sign-in. Asana does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Asana cost?

Asana's Personal plan is free for 2 people. Starter, Advanced, Enterprise and Enterprise+ are priced per user, billed monthly or yearly, and Enterprise prices are quoted. Timesheets and Budgets is a separate add-on. The prices are on Asana's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free includes 1 Kanban board and a team of 3. Pro and the Team plan have no limit on boards. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per user. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have a list view or a timeline?

No. A Kanban board is seen only as columns of cards. A card has a due date but no start date. A To-do on a card shows on the team's Calendar on its date. Asana shows a project as a list, a board or a calendar on every plan. Its timeline is on Starter and above.

Does Magpie have custom fields on cards?

No. A card has a title, a description, a column, an assignee, a due date and a colour. Issues, in the same team, has custom fields of seven types for issues. Asana has text, number, date, choice, people and formula fields on Starter and above.

Does Magpie have automation rules?

No, not on boards. Cards move by hand or through the assistant. Issues has rules that set an issue's status or priority when it changes. Asana's rules pair a trigger, such as a date, with an action, such as assigning or moving a task.

Does Magpie have subtasks?

Yes, as To-dos on a card. Each has its own date, reminder, repeat and assignee, and shows in To-dos and on Calendar. The card shows how many are done, such as 2 of 5. Asana's subtasks are tasks inside a task, on every plan.

Does Magpie have task dependencies?

No. Cards have no links between them, and a board has no milestones. Issues can mark one issue as blocking another, and its projects have milestones. Asana marks a task as blocked by another on Starter and above, and tells the assignee once it can start.

Can I see everything assigned to me in Magpie?

Partly. To-dos lists every To-do assigned to you in Personal and every team, To-dos on cards included. A card assigned to you is shown only on its board. Asana's My tasks lists every task assigned to you, from every project, as a list, a board or a calendar.

Does Magpie tell me when someone mentions me on a card?

No. Cards have no mentions, and nobody can follow a card. The person who added a card gets one email about the changes others make to it, comments included. An assignee is not told. Asana's Inbox collects updates on the tasks you follow or are mentioned in.

Does Magpie have goals and portfolios?

No. Kanban Boards lists each board with its description and number of cards, without a status or progress. Issues' Projects page lists each project with its status and how many of its issues are complete. Asana's goals and portfolios are on Advanced and above.

Does Magpie show each person's workload?

No. Nothing adds up the cards assigned to each person across boards, and nothing plans people's time ahead. Time Tracking records the time already spent. Asana's Workload is on Advanced and above, and capacity planning on Enterprise and Enterprise+.

Can I track time on a task in Magpie?

Yes, through a To-do on a card or an issue, which starts a Time Tracking timer linked to it. Time Tracking reports totals by project, Contact or tag. A card has no timer of its own, and nothing records an estimate. Asana's time tracking, with estimates, is on Advanced and above.

Does Asana have invoicing?

No. Asana's Timesheets and Budgets add-on records billable time and rates, and invoices are made in another app. Magpie's Invoicing is in the same team as Kanban Boards. A team admin adds their own billable Time Tracking entries to a Contact's invoice. Each becomes a line at its rate.

Does Asana have email, documents or a calendar?

No. Asana manages projects and tasks. It connects to the apps that hold email, documents and calendars, such as Google and Microsoft 365. Magpie's Mail, Documents and Calendar are areas in the same account as Kanban Boards. Mail needs a paid plan.

Does Magpie have AI like Asana AI?

Partly. The assistant finds cards, reads their comments, makes boards and columns, and adds, edits and moves cards from a message. It deletes only after you confirm. Nothing inside a card writes for you, and nothing on a board runs AI by itself. Asana's AI Teammates do steps of the work on their own.

Can a client see one board without seeing the rest?

Partly. Guests take no place on the plan, up to 10 on Free and 100 on a paid plan. A guest given Kanban Boards opens every board in the team. A board's outside access lets anyone signed in to Magpie view it, or also suggest cards and comment. Asana's guests see only the projects shared with them.

Does Magpie have phone and desktop apps?

No. Kanban Boards works in a phone's browser, where a card opens to edit, comment and move. The Magpie app shows a board a column at a time. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. There is no app for Mac or Windows. Asana has apps for iPhone, iPad, Android, Mac and Windows on every plan.

Does Magpie connect to Slack, Google or Microsoft?

No. Kanban Boards connects to no other apps. Magpie's API and Connected apps reach its boards from outside, and Claude or ChatGPT can work on them through MCP. Asana has over 100 integrations, free on every plan.

Can I use Asana and Magpie together?

Yes. Asana can run the team's projects while Magpie runs the invoices, time tracking, mail, bookings and website. Nothing links the two by itself, so a task in Asana and an invoice in Magpie are not connected.

How do I move from Asana to Magpie?

Export each project from Asana as CSV or JSON. In Magpie, Import a board from JSON builds a board with its columns and cards. Each card keeps its title, description, due date and colour. A CSV file does not load as it is; Copy the prompt has an AI assistant turn it into the JSON. Cards arrive unassigned, without comments or attachments.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

1 Kanban board with up to 500 cards, To-dos, Issues, Time Tracking, Calendar and Invoicing. A team of 3, 10 guests and 2 connected apps. Pro and the Team plan have no limit on boards, and Mail needs a paid plan.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Asana changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Asana's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Plan your team's work on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then make your first Kanban board.

Create account