Smallpdf compared with Magpie

Smallpdf vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Smallpdf and Magpie both merge, compress, edit, protect and sign PDFs in a web browser. They are built around different things.

  1. Smallpdf is a set of PDF tools on the web, with phone and Windows apps and signing through Sign.com. It is built for someone who wants to fix, convert or sign a file in a few clicks. Most tools work without an account.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and PDF Editor is one part of it. Beside it are E-Signatures, Secure Files, Documents, Invoicing and the rest of the areas a business runs on. It is built for someone whose PDFs are one part of running the business.
Create account
PDF Editor home page with Open PDF, a drop area for files and the list of quick tools such as Merge PDFs, Split PDF and Compress PDF.

How is Magpie different?

1. PDFs come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • PDF Editor, for merging, splitting, compressing, marking up, redacting and filling in PDFs
  • E-Signatures, with starters, signing order, reminders and a certificate of completion
  • Secure Files, for PDFs kept encrypted and shared by links that expire
  • Documents for writing, and Proposals and Invoicing for what you send clients
  • Mail, Contacts, Websites and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. A PDF attached in Mail, Invoicing, Expenses or a Client Portal opens in PDF Editor.

2. The PDF stays on your computer

Every PDF Editor tool runs in your browser tab, recognising text included. A PDF reaches Magpie only when you send it for signature or save it to Secure Files, encrypted first. Smallpdf's online tools upload each file and delete it after an hour unless you save it.

3. PDF Editor is on the Free plan, with no limit

PDF Editor, all its quick tools and E-Signatures are on every Magpie plan, the Free plan included. No plan limits how many files you work on or how many requests you send. Compress, batch work and recognising text have no paid level.

Comparing Magpie and Smallpdf

Smallpdf does more with a PDF's contents; Magpie does more around the PDF. Every line in the tables below was checked against Smallpdf's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Merge, split and compressPut PDFs together, take them apart, make them smaller Yes Yes
Mark up and fill inAdd text, highlights, drawings and form answers Yes Yes
Change the words in a PDFFix a typo in the text already there Pro No
PDF to Word, Excel and PowerPointTurn a PDF into an Office file to edit Yes No
Office files to PDFTurn a Word file, spreadsheet or deck into a PDF Yes Partly
Recognise text in scansMake a scanned PDF searchable Yes Yes
Redact and protectRemove text for good, add or remove a password Yes Yes
Compare and Bates numberingSee what changed between versions; number legal sets No Yes
Signature requestsSend a PDF for other people to sign Sign.com, with Pro Yes
AI summaries and questionsSummarise, ask about or translate a PDF Yes No
Storage and sharingKeep PDFs online and share them by link Yes Secure Files
Phone appScan and work on PDFs on a phone Yes In the browser
Desktop appWork on PDFs offline on a computer Windows No
Browser extensionOpen a PDF you are viewing in the tools Chrome No
Google Drive and DropboxOpen PDFs kept in another service Yes No
Without an accountFix a PDF without signing up Yes No
Security certificationAn independent certificate such as ISO 27001 Yes No
Documents, Proposals and InvoicingWrite documents and send clients proposals and invoices No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Merge, split and organise

Both merge PDFs, put pages in a new order, split files, crop and number pages. Smallpdf also merges Word, Excel and picture files, which it turns into PDFs first.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Combine several files into one PDF Source Yes Yes
Reorder, rotate, duplicate and delete pages Source Yes Yes
Split a PDF into several files, or take some pages out Source Yes Yes
Crop the margins off one page or every page Source Yes Yes
Number the pages of a PDF Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Every change in Magpie's editor has Undo. Page actions apply to the pages you tick, or to the current page when none are ticked.

Compress and convert

Both compress PDFs, make them from pictures and recognise text in scans. Smallpdf turns PDFs into Word, Excel and PowerPoint files and back. They do it better than we do today.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Make a PDF smaller to email or upload it Source Yes Yes
Do the same job to many PDFs at once Source Yes Yes
Turn a PDF into a Word, Excel or PowerPoint file to edit Source Magpie: PDF Editor turns PDF pages only into pictures, and Documents cannot import a PDF. Yes No
Turn a Word file, a spreadsheet, a slide deck or another kind of file into a PDF Source Magpie: A Word, OpenDocument, Markdown, HTML or text file imported into Documents can be downloaded as a PDF, and a deck made in Presentations exports a PDF. A spreadsheet, a PowerPoint file, an Apple Pages file or an ebook cannot be turned into a PDF. Yes Partly
Save the pages of a PDF as pictures Source Yes Yes
Turn photos and pictures into a PDF Source Yes Yes
Make a scanned PDF searchable, so its words can be found and copied Source Yes Yes
Save a PDF as PDF/A for long-term archiving Source Magpie: PDF Editor saves ordinary PDFs. It does not make or check PDF/A. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie recognises text in 15 languages, in your browser, and the pages are not uploaded. Every level of Compress PDF is on every plan.

Edit, mark up and fill in

Both add text, highlights, drawings and notes, fill in forms and add watermarks. Smallpdf also changes the words already in a PDF, places pictures and strikes text through.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Change the words already in a PDF, such as fixing a typo Source Magpie: Text already in a PDF cannot be changed. Add text types new words on top of the page, and Redact removes old words for good, so a typo is covered or removed rather than corrected. Yes No
Type new text onto a PDF, such as on a form with no fields Source Yes Yes
Put a picture, such as a logo or a stamp, anywhere on a page Source Magpie: There is no tool that places a picture on a page. Insert pages adds a picture as a page of its own, and Watermark centres one picture, such as a logo, on every page or on the pages you list. Yes Partly
Highlight, draw shapes and add notes on a PDF Source Yes Yes
Underline or strike through words in a PDF Source Magpie: Highlight is the only mark that follows the text. There is no underline or strike-through, so a deletion has to be shown with a drawn line or a note. Yes No
Fill in a PDF form and save it Source Yes Yes
Add a watermark, such as DRAFT or my logo, to every page Source Smallpdf: Watermark PDF adds text in the font, size, colour and opacity you choose to every page, and to several PDFs at once. It takes text only; a logo has to be placed in Edit PDF. Partly Yes
Compare two versions of a PDF and see what changed Source Smallpdf: Comparing two PDFs is not among the tools in Smallpdf's full tool list. No Yes
Number every page of a set of legal documents with Bates numbers Source Smallpdf: Bates numbering is not among Smallpdf's tools; Number Pages adds plain page numbers to each file. No Yes

Good to know: Magpie saves highlights, drawings and notes as PDF annotations, so other PDF apps can select, move or delete them. A watermark can be text or a logo.

Protect and redact

Both add and remove passwords and redact text for good. Smallpdf also flattens form answers, markup and layers, and holds an ISO/IEC 27001 certificate.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Protect a PDF with a password Source Yes Yes
Remove the password from my own PDF Source Yes Yes
Remove text and pictures from a PDF for good Source Yes Yes
Flatten a PDF so its form answers and markup can no longer be changed Source Magpie: Export can flatten form fields, and redacted pages become pictures. Highlights, drawings and notes stay as annotations that other PDF apps can move or delete. Yes Partly
Work on a confidential PDF without uploading it Source Smallpdf: The online tools upload files over TLS and delete them after an hour unless you save them to your account. Only the Windows app reads PDFs offline. Partly Yes
Use a PDF service with an independent security certification Source Magpie: Magpie has no independent security certification or audit report to show. Yes No

Good to know: Find and redact in Magpie finds words, email addresses, phone numbers and web addresses on every page. Export then checks that nothing under a redaction is left.

Sign, with Sign.com

Both send a PDF to several signers in order, track each one and send reminders. Smallpdf signs a PDF yourself in a few clicks, without an account. Sign.com Premium seals the signed file.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Sign a PDF myself in a few clicks Source Magpie: To sign a PDF yourself, choose Send for signature in PDF Editor, add yourself with Add me, place your fields, send it and sign it in your account. A drawn or typed signature is used in that document only, and Draw in PDF Editor is not a signature. Yes Partly
Send a PDF to other people to sign, in a set order if needed Source Yes Yes
See who has signed and remind the people who have not Source Yes Yes
Keep a contract with its signature fields to send again Source Yes Yes
Get a record of who signed, when and how Source Yes Yes
Make sure only the right person can open a document sent for signature Source Yes Yes
Seal the signed PDF so a PDF reader can show it has not been changed Source Magpie: The signed PDF keeps the original bytes with the values added after them, and the certificate lists SHA-256 hashes, but the file carries no digital signature a PDF reader can check. Yes No
Send a Word file or a picture for signature without making a PDF first Source Magpie: E-Signatures takes PDFs only. A Word file has to be made into a PDF first, such as by importing it into Documents and downloading it as a PDF. Yes No

Good to know: E-Signatures is on every Magpie plan with no limit on requests. Each signer gets a free Magpie account, and their signed copy stays in it.

AI PDF tools

Smallpdf summarises a PDF, answers questions about it, translates it and writes practice questions from it. Magpie has none of these for a PDF.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Get a summary of a PDF and ask questions about it Source Magpie: PDF Editor has no AI, and the assistant cannot read a PDF: PDF Editor keeps nothing on Magpie's servers, and Secure Files are encrypted. Yes No
Tell an assistant in plain words what to do with a PDF Source Magpie: PDF Editor's tools are chosen on its pages, and the assistant cannot open or change a PDF. Yes No
Translate a PDF into another language Source Magpie: No area translates a PDF, and the assistant cannot read one. Yes No
Make practice questions with answers from a PDF Source Magpie: Flashcards' import gives a prompt to use with an outside AI assistant and your material, and imports the cards it writes after a preview. Magpie does not read the PDF or write the questions itself. Yes Partly

Good to know: The assistant cannot read a PDF, because PDF Editor keeps nothing on Magpie's servers and Secure Files are encrypted. Flashcards imports cards written by an outside AI assistant.

Storage, sharing and apps

Smallpdf has apps for phones and Windows, a Chrome extension and connections to Google Drive and Dropbox. Magpie's PDF Editor is used in the browser, on a computer or a phone.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Keep my PDFs online and open them on any device Source Yes Yes
Share a PDF by link Source Yes Yes
Go from one tool to the next without downloading in between Source Yes Yes
Scan paper with my phone and make a PDF Source Magpie: In a phone's browser, Images to PDF takes photos with the camera and makes a PDF, without finding the page's edges. The Magpie app's document scanner, which finds and straightens each page, is built but not yet in the App Store or Google Play, so it counts as no for now. Yes Partly
Work on PDFs in an app on my phone Source Magpie: PDF Editor works in a phone's browser, with each toolbar in one row to swipe through. The Magpie app has the same tools and editor and works on PDFs without a connection, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Work on PDFs on my computer with no internet connection Source Magpie: PDF Editor runs in the browser and needs a connection to open. There is no app for Windows or Mac. Yes No
Open a PDF I am viewing in my browser in the PDF tools Source Magpie: Magpie's browser extension, not yet in the browsers' stores, fills Password Vault logins only. A PDF has to be downloaded first and then opened in PDF Editor. Yes No
Open and save PDFs in Google Drive, Dropbox or OneDrive Source Magpie: PDF Editor opens PDFs from the device and from Magpie's Secure Files, Mail, Invoicing, Expenses and Client Portals, but not from Google Drive, Dropbox or OneDrive. Yes No
Show a PDF inside a page of my own website Source Magpie: Magpie has no PDF viewer to put on another website. A files website can host the PDF for visitors to open in their browser. Yes No

Good to know: A PDF opens in Magpie's editor from Secure Files, Mail, Invoicing, Expenses and Client Portal. A result can go straight to Secure Files or to E-Signatures.

Plans and teams

Smallpdf's Free plan limits how much you use the tools. OCR, batch work and the desktop app need Pro. Magpie's PDF tools have no limit on any plan, but they need an account.

WhatSmallpdfMagpie
Use the PDF tools as often as I like without paying Source Smallpdf: Free covers the tools with limited use, which the help page puts at 2 conversions a day, and keeps OCR, batch conversion and the desktop app for Pro. Partly Yes
Fix a PDF without signing up Source Magpie: PDF Editor needs a Magpie account, which is free; a visitor who is not signed in gets the area's page or the sign-in page. Yes No
Pay for the whole team in one place and manage who has access Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A Magpie team has up to 3 members on the Free plan and 25 on the Team plan. Members do not pay.

Price comparison

How Smallpdf charges

Smallpdf charges by plan. Free uses the tools with limits. Pro is for one person, with a 7-day free trial. Team is priced per seat, for two people or more. Business is priced on request. Pro and Team are billed yearly or monthly, and Pro includes Sign.com Premium. Prices are on Smallpdf's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. PDF Editor and E-Signatures have no limit on any plan. A paid plan is Pro for Personal or the Team plan for a team. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planSmallpdfMagpie
PDF tools without payingFree, with limited useFree plan, with no limit
Batch work and the desktop appProBatch work on every plan; no desktop app
Changing the words in a PDFProNot available
Signature requests2 a month on a free Sign.com account; Sign.com Premium with ProNo limit on any plan
AI toolsLimited on Free; higher limits on ProNot available
How a team paysPer seat on TeamOne Team plan for up to 25 people
StorageFiles saved to your Smallpdf account5 GB on Free, 100 GB on Pro
Documents, Proposals and InvoicingNot offeredIncluded

When to choose Magpie or Smallpdf

  • Want your PDFs beside signing, encrypted files, documents and invoices, with no limit on any plan? Go with Magpie.
  • Want to turn PDFs into Word files, change their text, ask AI about them and use phone apps? Smallpdf is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For someone who edits PDFs others send them
Smallpdf. Smallpdf changes the text already in a PDF and turns it into a Word file. Magpie adds text on top of the page and cannot change the words there.
For a student or a researcher
Smallpdf. Smallpdf summarises a PDF, answers questions about it, translates it and writes practice questions. Magpie has no AI for a PDF.
For a law office or anyone with confidential files
Magpie. PDF Editor works in the browser tab without uploading the file. It redacts, compares versions and adds Bates numbers on every plan.
For a service business that sends contracts
Magpie. E-Signatures sends any PDF for signature with no limit on requests. The same team has Proposals, Invoicing and Contacts.
For someone who scans paper on a phone
Smallpdf. Smallpdf's phone app scans with the camera, crops and recognises text. Magpie makes a PDF from phone photos in the browser, without finding each page's edges.
For a business that wants both
Either. Smallpdf can convert and edit the text of a PDF, and Magpie can sign, store and send it. Choose by whether changing a PDF's contents or one place for the team's work matters more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Smallpdf and Magpie?

Smallpdf is a set of PDF tools on the web and in apps, with AI and signing through Sign.com. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its PDF Editor is one area beside E-Signatures, Secure Files, Documents and Invoicing. Smallpdf does more with a PDF's contents; Magpie does more around the PDF.

Does Magpie replace Smallpdf?

Yes, for a business that merges, compresses, marks up, redacts, protects and signs PDFs. PDF Editor does each of these in the browser, with no limit on any plan. E-Signatures sends a PDF to signers in order, with reminders and a certificate.

Consider keeping Smallpdf if you turn PDFs into Office files or change the words already in them. Keep it too if you use its AI tools, its phone or Windows app, or its Chrome extension. Smallpdf does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Smallpdf cost?

Smallpdf has a Free plan with limited use, Pro for one person and Team priced per seat. Business is priced on request. Pro has a 7-day free trial and includes Sign.com Premium. The prices are on Smallpdf's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. PDF Editor and E-Signatures have no limit on any plan. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per seat. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Can Magpie turn a PDF into a Word file?

No. PDF Editor turns PDF pages into pictures only, and Documents cannot import a PDF. Turning a PDF into a document is on Magpie's roadmap. Smallpdf turns a PDF into a Word, Excel or PowerPoint file, with OCR for scans on Pro.

Can I change the text already in a PDF with Magpie?

No. Add text types new words on top of the page, and Redact removes old words for good. So a typo is covered or removed, not corrected. Smallpdf's Edit Text changes the words already there, on Pro.

Does Magpie have AI to summarise a PDF?

No. PDF Editor has no AI, and the assistant cannot read a PDF. PDF Editor keeps nothing on Magpie's servers, and Secure Files are encrypted. Smallpdf summarises a PDF, answers questions about it and translates it, with limits on Free.

Does Magpie have a phone app for PDFs?

PDF Editor works in a phone's browser, with each toolbar in one row to swipe through. Images to PDF takes photos with the camera and makes a PDF. The Magpie app has a document scanner, not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Smallpdf's app for iPhone and Android scans, edits and converts PDFs.

Does Magpie work offline or on the desktop?

No. PDF Editor runs in the browser and needs a connection to open. There is no app for Windows or Mac. The Magpie app's PDF tools work without a connection, but the app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Smallpdf's Windows app reads, compresses, converts and merges PDFs offline.

Does Magpie have a browser extension for PDFs?

No. Magpie's browser extension fills Password Vault logins only, and it is not yet in the browsers' stores. A PDF is downloaded first and then opened in PDF Editor. Smallpdf's free Chrome extension opens the tools from a PDF in the browser.

Can I open PDFs from Google Drive or Dropbox in Magpie?

No. PDF Editor opens PDFs from your device and from Secure Files, Mail, Invoicing, Expenses and Client Portal. Smallpdf's Google Workspace and Dropbox apps open files kept in those services.

Can I use Magpie's PDF Editor without an account?

No. PDF Editor needs a Magpie account, which is free. Smallpdf's tools, such as PDF to Word, work without an account within the free limits.

Are my PDFs uploaded?

Not in Magpie. Every PDF Editor tool runs in the browser tab, recognising text included. A PDF reaches Magpie only when you save it to Secure Files, encrypted first, or send it for signature. Smallpdf's online tools upload files over TLS and delete them after an hour unless you save them.

Can I sign a PDF myself in Magpie?

Yes, in more steps than Smallpdf. Choose Send for signature in PDF Editor and add yourself with Add me. Place your fields, then sign in your account. Smallpdf's Sign PDF adds a signature in a few clicks, without an account. Quicker signing for yourself is on Magpie's roadmap.

Can I send a PDF to other people to sign?

Yes, in both. Magpie's E-Signatures sets the signing order, tracks each signer and sends reminders, on every plan with no limit. Smallpdf does this through Sign.com, which comes with Pro. A free Sign.com account sends 2 documents a month.

Does Smallpdf compare two PDFs or add Bates numbers?

No. Neither is among Smallpdf's tools; Number Pages adds plain page numbers to each file. Magpie's Compare PDFs lists the words removed and added on each page. Its Bates numbering continues from file to file.

Can Magpie turn a Word file into a PDF?

Partly. A Word, OpenDocument, Markdown, HTML or text file imported into Documents downloads as a PDF. A deck made in Presentations exports one too. A spreadsheet or a PowerPoint file cannot be turned into a PDF. Smallpdf converts Word, Excel, PowerPoint and many other files.

Does Magpie make PDF/A files?

No. PDF Editor saves ordinary PDFs and does not make or check PDF/A. Smallpdf converts a file to PDF/A at the conformance level you choose.

Does Magpie have a security certification?

No. Magpie has no independent security certification or audit report to show, and one is on its roadmap. Smallpdf is ISO/IEC 27001 certified.

Can I use Smallpdf and Magpie together?

Yes. Smallpdf can turn a PDF into a Word file or change its text. The result can then be stored in Secure Files and sent for signature in Magpie. Each works on its own files, with no connection between them.

How do I move from Smallpdf to Magpie?

Download the PDFs you keep in Smallpdf's storage. Then upload them to Secure Files, or open them in PDF Editor. Download your signed documents from Sign.com too.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

PDF Editor with every quick tool, and E-Signatures with no limit on requests. Secure Files has 5 GB of storage, and a team has up to 3 members. Invoicing sends 5 invoices a month, and most of the other areas are included too.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Smallpdf changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Smallpdf's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Work on your PDFs beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then open a PDF in PDF Editor.

Create account