Raindrop.io compared with Magpie

Raindrop.io vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Raindrop.io and Magpie both save links, file them in collections with tags, and keep highlights from what you read. They are built around different things.

  1. Raindrop.io is a bookmark manager with apps for every device, a browser extension and a web archive of saved pages. It is built for someone whose saved links, files and highlights are a library to search and share.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Bookmarks is one part of it. Beside the saved links it includes RSS Reader, Notes, To-dos, Calendar and the other areas a business runs on. It is built for someone whose reading list is one part of their work.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s Bookmarks: saved articles on packaging, colour, type and photography, newest first, each with its site, collection, read state and tags, one marked as a favourite.

How is Magpie different?

1. Bookmarks comes with the rest of your work

One Magpie subscription includes the areas you would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Bookmarks for saved links, Reader view and highlights
  • RSS Reader for the sites you follow, with entries saved to Bookmarks in one step
  • Notes, where Send to a new note puts a bookmark's link, note and highlights
  • To-dos, Calendar, Documents, Secure Files and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Raindrop.io covers saved links and files, and leaves notes, tasks and feeds to other software.

2. Bookmarks keeps a read-later list

A new bookmark is unread, and the Unread tab lists what is left. At the end of an article, Mark read and open next opens the next unread one. The j, k, m and r keys move through the list without the mouse. A bookmark's site can be followed in RSS Reader from its page.

3. A team's bookmarks belong to the team

Bookmarks saved in a team are shared with everyone in it, with their notes and highlights. A team can give members view access only, or give a guest the Bookmarks area. Personal bookmarks stay yours. A free team has 3 people, and the Team plan 25.

Comparing Magpie and Raindrop.io

Raindrop.io does more inside the library; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Raindrop.io's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
Bookmark managerLinks saved with collections, tags and notes Yes Yes
Browser extensionSave the page you are on from the browser Yes Browser button
Phone appsBookmarks on iPhone and Android, saved from the share sheet Yes In the browser
Desktop appsAn app for Mac and Windows Yes No
Reader view and highlightsArticles read without clutter, with passages kept Yes Yes
Read-later listUnread bookmarks, and the next one opened No Yes
Files beside linksPDFs, pictures and documents in collections Yes Secure Files, apart
Full-text searchThe words inside saved pages and PDFs found Pro No
Web archiveA full copy of each saved page kept Pro Article text
RemindersA bookmark brought back on a chosen day Pro No
Shared collectionsChosen people add to one collection Yes Whole team
Public collection pagesA collection published for anyone to read Yes Yes
AI assistantA chat that finds and tidies bookmarks Pro, in beta Partly
AI apps over MCPClaude or ChatGPT uses your bookmarks Yes Partly
AutomationsIFTTT, Zapier and others save links for you Yes No
RSS ReaderFollow sites and save their entries No Yes
Notes, To-dos and CalendarThe rest of your work in the same account No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Saving

Raindrop.io saves from an extension, the share sheet on a phone, and many other bookmarking apps' exports. Magpie saves from a browser button, a pasted address, a browser's bookmarks file or a CSV file.

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
Save the page I am on in one click from the browser Source Magpie: The Save to Magpie button, dragged to the browser's bookmarks bar, opens a small window with the page's address, title and any selected text, says if the page is already saved, and saves it with a collection, tags and a note. There is no browser extension for Bookmarks, so no keyboard shortcut, right-click saving or sidebar; Magpie's extension is for Password Vault only. Yes Partly
Save a link by pasting its address Source Yes Yes
Save a link from any app on my phone through the share sheet Source Magpie: On a phone, the website saves a link pasted into Add bookmark; Magpie is not in the share sheet. Choosing Magpie in another app's share sheet, then Bookmarks, opens Add bookmark with the link and its title filled in, but only in the Magpie app, which is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes No
Save every open tab at once and open them all again later Source Magpie: Each page is saved on its own with the Save to Magpie button; there is no way to save or reopen a set of tabs together. Yes No
Keep PDFs, pictures, videos and other files beside my links Source Magpie: A bookmark is a web address. Files are kept in Secure Files, encrypted, apart from Bookmarks. Yes No
Bring in the bookmarks from my browser Source Yes Yes
Move my saved links over from Pocket, Instapaper, Pinboard or another bookmarking app Source Magpie: Any HTML file of links is read, as Pinboard's export is, and so is a CSV file with a url column, including Raindrop.io's own CSV export with its folders, excerpts and dates. JSON exports, Evernote files and plain lists of addresses are not read. Yes Partly

Good to know: Magpie reads Raindrop.io's own CSV export, with its folders, excerpts and dates. An import reads up to 5,000 entries and 8 MB a file, and skips addresses already saved.

Organizing

Both file bookmarks in collections with tags, rename tags everywhere and change many bookmarks at once. Raindrop.io adds nested collections, icons, your own order and reminders. It also finds duplicates and broken links, and does all of this better than we do today.

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
File bookmarks in collections, with a place for ones not yet filed Source Yes Yes
Put collections inside other collections Source Magpie: Collections are one flat list, and an imported folder inside a folder becomes one collection named after the inner folder. Yes No
Give each collection an icon so it is easy to spot Source Magpie: A collection has a name and a description, and no icon. Yes No
Tag bookmarks and show everything with a tag Source Yes Yes
Rename a tag everywhere, or merge two tags into one Source Yes Yes
Have a collection and tags suggested as I save Source Magpie: Magpie suggests tags as you save and on a bookmark's page: tags on your other bookmarks from the same site and tags whose words are in the title. It does not suggest a collection. Yes Partly
Move, tag or delete many bookmarks at once Source Yes Yes
Put bookmarks in my own order by dragging them Source Magpie: The list orders by newest, oldest, title, site or recently changed; there is no order of your own. Yes No
Find bookmarks I saved twice and remove the extra copies Source Magpie: Saving a page that is already saved says when it was saved and offers to open it or save another copy, ignoring tracking parameters, and an import skips addresses already saved. There is no list of duplicates already in the library. Yes Partly
Find saved links that no longer work Source Magpie: A bookmark's page says when the page was last checked and whether it could be reached, and Check again checks it now. Saved links are not checked on a schedule, and nothing lists the broken ones. Yes Partly
Be reminded to come back to a bookmark on a day I choose Source Magpie: Bookmarks has no reminders; the Unread tab keeps what you have not read yet. Yes No
Get back a bookmark I deleted Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie suggests tags as you save: the tags on your other bookmarks from the same site, and tags whose words are in the title. A suggestion is added only when you choose it.

Reading and highlights

Both open an article without clutter and keep highlights with notes. Raindrop.io also previews videos, PDFs and books, and highlights on the page itself. Magpie keeps a read-later list.

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
Read a saved article without ads or clutter Source Yes Yes
Watch a saved video or read a saved PDF without leaving my bookmarks Source Magpie: Only articles have Reader view; a video, PDF or picture opens on its own site. Yes No
Highlight passages and find them again later Source Yes Yes
Write a note on a highlight Source Yes Yes
Highlight in different colours Source Magpie: Every highlight looks the same. Yes No
Highlight on the web page itself, and see my highlights when I go back to it Source Magpie: Highlights are made in Magpie's Reader view, not on the original page. Yes No
Take my highlights out to another app Source Magpie: Send to a new note puts the link, your note and your highlights in a new note in Notes, and the REST API returns each bookmark's highlights. The bookmark export files leave highlights out. Yes Partly
See bookmarks as a list, or as cards with pictures Source Yes Yes
Keep a read-later queue: see what I have not read, and open the next one Source Raindrop.io: A bookmark has no read or unread state; what you add to one is a note, tags, a collection, a reminder and a favorite mark. No Yes
Follow a saved site's feed, and save feed entries, in the same place Source Raindrop.io: Raindrop.io has no feed reader of its own: articles come in from a feed reader's own share option, or from a feed through an IFTTT applet. No Yes

Good to know: Saving an RSS Reader entry to Bookmarks keeps the entry's text for Reader view. It stays readable after the entry leaves your feed.

Web archive and backups

Both download every bookmark as a file. Raindrop.io's Pro plan also keeps a full copy of each page and makes a backup each day.

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
Keep a full copy of each saved page in case the site removes it Source Magpie: Magpie keeps a saved article's text for Reader view, and the page's icon and preview image, so they open after the page is gone. Pictures and layout are not kept, and a page that is not an article keeps no copy. Yes Partly
Download all my bookmarks Source Yes Yes
Have my bookmarks backed up automatically every day Source Magpie: Bookmarks are downloaded by hand from Import and export; nothing makes a copy for you on a schedule. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's export includes archived bookmarks, as HTML, CSV or JSON. A bookmark in Trash is restored with its note and highlights for 30 days.

Sharing and teamwork

Both publish a collection as a page with an RSS feed. Raindrop.io also shares one collection with chosen people and embeds a collection in another website. A profile page lists your public collections.

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
Share a collection with chosen people, who can add to it or only read it Source Magpie: Bookmarks saved in a team are shared with everyone in that team, and a team can give members view access only, or give a guest the Bookmarks area. One collection cannot be shared with chosen people; an Unlisted link lets anyone signed in read it, not add to it. Yes Partly
Publish a collection as a web page anyone can read Source Yes Yes
Have one page that lists all my public collections Source Magpie: Each public collection has its own link; no page lists them together. Yes No
Show a collection inside my own website Source Magpie: A public collection is shared as a link to its page on Magpie, or as its RSS feed. Yes No
Give a collection an RSS feed people can follow Source Yes Yes

Good to know: An Unlisted Magpie collection opens for anyone signed in to Magpie who has the link. They can follow it in RSS Reader from its page.

Integrations, API and AI

Raindrop.io connects to IFTTT, Zapier, Make and Notion, and its MCP server lets AI apps change bookmarks. Magpie's assistant and Connected apps find and save bookmarks, and its REST API changes them.

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
Ask an assistant about what I have saved, and have it tidy my bookmarks Source Magpie: The assistant on Dashboard finds bookmarks by title, address, description or note and saves a new one from an address. It cannot read saved article text, summarize it, or change tags and collections. Yes Partly
Use my bookmarks from Claude, ChatGPT or another AI app Source Magpie: Connected apps lets Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor and other apps use Bookmarks through MCP, 2 apps on Free and 10 on Pro. They can find bookmarks and save new ones, the assistant's own abilities, but not edit, tag, file or highlight them. Yes Partly
Save things automatically from other services, such as liked YouTube videos Source Magpie: Nothing saves bookmarks from other services by itself. Bookmarks reaches other apps only through the REST API, Connected apps and a public collection's RSS feed. Yes No
Build my own tools on my bookmarks through an API Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Connected apps lets Claude, ChatGPT or Cursor use Magpie through MCP. Free connects 2 apps and Pro 10.

Apps

Raindrop.io has apps for iPhone, Android, Mac and Windows. Magpie's Bookmarks is used in the browser, on a computer or a phone.

WhatRaindrop.ioMagpie
Use my bookmarks on iPhone and Android, kept in step with the computer Source Yes Yes
An app for Mac and Windows Source Magpie: Magpie is used in a browser on a computer. Yes No
Use a dark theme Source Yes Yes

Good to know: The Magpie app has the same bookmarks and saves from the share sheet. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play.

Price comparison

How Raindrop.io charges

Raindrop.io charges by plan, Free or Pro, billed monthly or yearly; its help centre says yearly is about 20% cheaper. Free includes saving, collections, tags, highlights and sharing collections with other people. Pro adds full-text search, the web archive, reminders, notes on highlights, the duplicate and broken-link finders, daily backups and the Stella assistant. Prices are on Raindrop.io's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. Bookmarks has no limit on how many links you save on either plan. The plan sets limits elsewhere, such as 10 RSS Reader feeds on Free and 100 on Pro. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planRaindrop.ioMagpie
Sharing collections with other peopleIncluded on FreeEveryone in the team: 3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan
Notes on highlightsProIncluded
Full-text search and the web archiveProNot available; article text is kept for Reader view
RemindersProNot available
BackupsA backup each day on Pro, also to Dropbox, Google Drive or OneDriveDownloaded by hand on every plan
Files beside links100 MB a month on Free, 10 GB a month on ProNot in Bookmarks; files go in Secure Files
AI apps over MCPA limited set on Free, all of it on Pro2 apps on Free, 10 on Pro
REST APIOfferedPro
RSS ReaderNot offered10 feeds on Free, 100 on Pro
Notes, To-dos and CalendarNot offeredIncluded

When to choose Magpie or Raindrop.io

  • Want a read-later list beside your feeds, notes and to-dos, shared with your team, in one subscription? Go with Magpie.
  • Want a bookmark library with apps and an extension everywhere, nested collections, reminders, and search inside every saved page? Raindrop.io is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a researcher or a student
Raindrop.io. PDFs, books and articles are kept in one library, with highlights on each and search inside every page on Pro. Magpie keeps links and article text, and files go to Secure Files apart from them.
For someone who reads what they save
Magpie. Every bookmark starts unread, and Mark read and open next moves through the list. RSS Reader is in the same account, and an entry saved from it keeps its text.
For a curator who publishes lists of links
Raindrop.io. A profile page lists every public collection, and a collection embeds in another website. Magpie publishes each collection on its own page with an RSS feed.
For a small team that shares links
Either. Raindrop.io shares one collection at a time with chosen people, free. Magpie shares a team's whole library, with view-only access and guests. Choose by whether people share a few collections or all the team's links.
For a small business that keeps links beside its work
Magpie. Bookmarks is in the same team as Notes, To-dos, Calendar and the areas the business runs on. A bookmark's link and highlights go into a new note in one step.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Raindrop.io and Magpie?

Raindrop.io is a bookmark manager with apps on every device, an extension, file uploads and a web archive. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Bookmarks is one area beside RSS Reader, Notes, To-dos and the rest. Raindrop.io does more inside the library; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Raindrop.io?

Yes, for someone who saves articles to read and keeps them in collections with tags. Magpie saves links with a browser button, keeps article text for Reader view, and keeps highlights with notes. It reads Raindrop.io's CSV export.

Consider keeping Raindrop.io if you save from an extension or a phone's share sheet, or nest collections. Keep it too if you keep PDFs with your links or set reminders. The same goes for search inside saved pages and a full copy of each page. Raindrop.io does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Raindrop.io cost?

Raindrop.io has a Free plan and a Pro plan, billed monthly or yearly. Its help centre says yearly billing is about 20% cheaper. Pro adds full-text search, the web archive, reminders, daily backups and the Stella assistant. The prices are on Raindrop.io's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Bookmarks has no limit on how many links you save on either. A paid plan raises limits such as connected apps and adds the REST API. The Team plan has 25 people. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have a browser extension for bookmarks?

No. Magpie's browser button, dragged to the bookmarks bar, opens a small window with the page's address, title and selected text. It says if the page is already saved, and saves it with a collection, tags and a note. There is no keyboard shortcut, right-click saving or sidebar. A Bookmarks extension is on Magpie's roadmap.

Does Magpie have nested collections?

No. Magpie's collections are one flat list, and a folder inside a folder imports as one collection named after the inner folder. Nested collections are on Magpie's roadmap. In Raindrop.io, a collection dragged onto another becomes its child.

Can Magpie remind me about a bookmark?

No. Bookmarks has no reminders; the Unread tab keeps what you have not read yet. Reminders are on Magpie's roadmap. Raindrop.io's Pro plan sends a reminder for a date and time, as a phone notification or by email.

Can Magpie search the text inside saved pages?

No. Magpie's search looks in titles, addresses, sites, descriptions, notes, tags and collection names. It does not read a saved article's text or your highlights. Full-text search is on Magpie's roadmap. Raindrop.io's Pro search reads saved pages, PDFs, books and YouTube transcripts.

Does Magpie keep a copy of a page if the site removes it?

Partly. Magpie keeps a saved article's text for Reader view, with the page's icon and preview image. Pictures and layout are not kept, and a page that is not an article keeps no copy. Raindrop.io's Pro plan keeps a full copy of each page's text, pictures and layout.

Can I keep PDFs and files in Magpie Bookmarks?

No. A Magpie bookmark is a web address, and files are kept in Secure Files, encrypted, apart from Bookmarks. Files beside links are on Magpie's roadmap. Raindrop.io uploads PDFs, pictures and documents into collections.

Does Magpie have a phone app for bookmarks?

Bookmarks works in a phone's browser, with its views, search, Reader view, highlights, import and export. The Magpie app has the same bookmarks and saves from the share sheet. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Raindrop.io has apps for iPhone, Android, Mac and Windows.

Does Raindrop.io have a read-later list?

No. A Raindrop.io bookmark has no read or unread state. You add a note, tags, a collection, a reminder or a favorite mark. Magpie marks each new bookmark unread and lists what is left in the Unread tab. At the end of an article, it opens the next one.

Does Raindrop.io have an RSS reader?

No. Articles come into Raindrop.io from a feed reader's own share option or through an IFTTT applet. Magpie's RSS Reader is in the same account as Bookmarks. Follow site in RSS Reader subscribes to a bookmark's site, and an entry saved to Bookmarks keeps its text.

Can I share one collection with chosen people in Magpie?

Partly. Bookmarks saved in a team are shared with everyone in it, and a team can give a guest the Bookmarks area. One collection cannot be shared with chosen people to add to. An Unlisted link lets anyone signed in to Magpie read it. Raindrop.io shares one collection with any number of people, free.

Can I publish a collection as a web page?

Yes, in both. A Public Magpie collection is a page anyone can read, with an RSS feed, and search engines may list it. It shows each bookmark's title, site and description. Raindrop.io also has a profile page of all your public collections, and a widget that embeds one in another website. Magpie has neither.

Does Magpie find duplicates and broken links?

Partly. Saving a page already saved says when you saved it, ignoring tracking parameters, and an import skips addresses already saved. A bookmark's page says whether the page could be reached when last checked. There is no list of duplicates or broken links. Raindrop.io's Pro plan has both.

Can an AI app use my Magpie bookmarks?

Partly. Connected apps lets Claude, ChatGPT and Cursor find bookmarks and save new ones through MCP. They cannot edit, tag, file or highlight them. The assistant on Dashboard does the same. Raindrop.io's MCP server and its Stella assistant also tidy tags and collections.

Can I use Raindrop.io and Magpie together?

Yes. A Raindrop.io collection's RSS feed can be followed in Magpie's RSS Reader, and its entries saved to Bookmarks. A public Magpie collection has an RSS feed too. Magpie reads Raindrop.io's CSV export, and Magpie's HTML export is a browser bookmarks file, which Raindrop.io imports.

How do I move from Raindrop.io to Magpie?

Export your bookmarks from Raindrop.io as CSV. In Magpie, open Import and export under Bookmarks, choose the file and select Import. Folders become collections, and excerpts and dates come with them. Highlights and uploaded files are not brought in.

Does Magpie have a desktop app?

No. Magpie is used in a browser on a computer. A desktop app is on Magpie's roadmap. Raindrop.io has apps for macOS 12 or later and Windows 10 or later.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Bookmarks with no limit on links, Reader view, highlights with notes, public collections, and import and export. RSS Reader with 10 feeds, Notes, To-dos and the other areas, and a team of 3. Connected apps links 2 AI apps.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Raindrop.io changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Raindrop.io's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Keep your reading list beside the rest of your work.

Create a Magpie account, then import your bookmarks.

Create account