What is the difference between Buy Me a Coffee and Magpie?
Buy Me a Coffee is a page where fans tip you, join memberships and buy from a shop. It is free to use and takes 5% of payments. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Supporters area is one part, beside Store, Newsletter, Podcast and booking pages. Buy Me a Coffee does more for the fan who wants to give; Magpie does more around it.
Does Magpie replace Buy Me a Coffee?
Yes, for a creator whose memberships are one part of a business. Supporters has free and paid tiers, monthly or yearly, and posts for chosen tiers. Store sells downloads and physical products. Payments go to your own Stripe account.
Consider keeping Buy Me a Coffee if your fans tip you once, with no sign-up. Keep it if you stream, or want lifetime memberships, a gallery or messages with fans. Buy Me a Coffee does each of these better than Magpie does today.
How much does Buy Me a Coffee cost?
Buy Me a Coffee has no monthly fee, and every part of it is free to use. It takes 5% of each payment, and Stripe's processing fee comes on top. A creator can have supporters cover the card fee. The details are in Buy Me a Coffee's FAQ.
How much does Magpie cost?
Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free allows 3 paid tiers and 200 posts; a paid plan has no limit. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments and 4% of Store sales, and Stripe's fees come on top. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.
Can fans send me a one-off tip on Magpie?
Partly. Supporters has no one-off payment: a fan joins a free tier or a paid tier, billed monthly or yearly. A Store product can be pay what you want, with a minimum and a suggested price. It can ask the buyer for a message. It is sold in the Store, not on the Supporters page. Buy Me a Coffee's one-off support is the first thing on its page.
Can fans support me on Magpie without making an account?
No. Joining any tier starts with signing in to Magpie or making an account, then Stripe's checkout. A Store purchase needs no sign-in first. The order goes into an account for the buyer's email address. Buy Me a Coffee's one-off support needs no sign-up.
Does Magpie have yearly or lifetime memberships?
Partly. A paid Supporters tier can offer a yearly price beside its monthly one, and supporters choose when they join. There is no lifetime price: complimentary access can last with no end date, but nobody pays for it. Buy Me a Coffee levels can have a yearly price, and a page can have one lifetime level.
Can I offer a free trial or a discount on a Magpie tier?
No. Supporter checkout has no trial and takes no promotion code. You can give someone complimentary access to any tier, with an end date if you want one. Buy Me a Coffee levels can have a 7-day free trial.
Can I change a tier's price on Magpie?
Partly. A paid tier's monthly price cannot change once it is set; a different amount needs another tier. Its yearly price can be changed for new supporters, and people already paying keep their price. Buy Me a Coffee changes a level's price for new members, and for existing members after notice.
Can supporters move to another tier themselves on Magpie?
No. A supporter joins another tier from the page once their current paid tier has ended. Buy Me a Coffee members switch level from their account, with the unused part counted toward the new price.
Can I post audio on Magpie?
No. A Supporters post holds text, pictures, Screen Recorder videos and a poll. Podcast hosts episodes with a public page and an RSS feed, with no feed kept for supporters. Buy Me a Coffee records or uploads audio for a post.
Does Magpie email new posts to supporters?
No. A Supporters post is read on the page, and nothing emails it out. Newsletter emails go to its own subscribers, who are kept apart from supporters. Buy Me a Coffee can email a post to followers, or only to the levels it is for.
Does Magpie have a gallery?
No. The Supporters page lists posts newest first, each with a cover image. Buy Me a Coffee's Gallery tab shows pictures, some kept for supporters or members.
Can I message my supporters on Magpie?
Partly. A supporter's page has Email, which opens your own mail program, and Team chat reaches anyone by handle. Supporters cannot write to you from your page, and there is no message to all of them. Buy Me a Coffee messages one supporter or a group of members at once.
Does Magpie have stream alerts or a funding goal?
No. Nothing in Magpie shows a supporter on a live stream, and the page has no goal. Supporters settings can show what the paid tiers add up to each month. Buy Me a Coffee's stream alerts work in OBS, Streamlabs and Twitch Studio, free for every creator.
Does Magpie connect to Discord?
No. Supporters does not connect to Discord, and it sends no webhooks. Buy Me a Coffee gives each level its own Discord role, removed when the member cancels.
Can fans pay with Cash App or in their own currency on Magpie?
No. Supporter checkout takes cards through Stripe, and a tier is charged in your Stripe account's currency. Buy Me a Coffee takes Cash App and other methods, and crypto in the United States. Localized pricing takes more than 15 currencies.
Can I download my supporter list from Magpie?
No. The Supporters list shows each supporter, with email addresses for team admins, but cannot be downloaded. Buy Me a Coffee lets creators export their supporters at any time.
Can fans pay for a call with me on Magpie?
Yes. An Appointments service can take its full price or a deposit by card when someone books, paid into your team's Stripe account. Magpie takes 4% of the payment, and the time is held while they pay. Buy Me a Coffee's homepage shows one-to-one calls sold through its shop and paid up front.
Does Buy Me a Coffee host podcasts?
No. Audio posts play on the page. The help centre says podcasts cannot be brought in through an RSS feed. Magpie's Podcast gives a show its own page and an RSS feed for Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Can I sell physical products on Buy Me a Coffee?
Partly. Its shop sells prints and stickers with a limited number of slots. The shop guide asks for the address with a question and names no shipping prices or tracking. Magpie's Store tracks stock, charges shipping by zone and emails tracking numbers.
Does Magpie have an app?
No. The Magpie app has Supporters, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Team admins can be emailed about each new supporter. Buy Me a Coffee has apps for iPhone and Android.
Can I use Buy Me a Coffee and Magpie together?
Yes. Buy Me a Coffee can take tips and memberships while Magpie runs your shop, booking pages, newsletter and website. A Magpie website or Link-In-Bio List can link to your Buy Me a Coffee page.
How do I move from Buy Me a Coffee to Magpie?
Set up Supporters and add your tiers, then publish the page. Paying members cannot be imported: each one joins again through the page and Stripe's checkout. Buy Me a Coffee lets you export your supporters. Newsletter imports a CSV file of people who agreed to hear from you. Then you can email them the new address.
What is included in Magpie's Free plan?
Supporters with a free tier, 3 paid tiers and 200 posts. Store, a podcast, booking pages, Invoicing, the Newsletter with 250 subscribers, QR Codes and a team of 3. A paid plan removes the tier and post limits and raises the others.