Buy Me a Coffee compared with Magpie

Buy Me a Coffee vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Buy Me a Coffee and Magpie both give a creator a page where fans support them. Both have paid levels, a shop and posts. They are built around different things.

  1. Buy Me a Coffee is a page where fans send one-off support, join memberships and buy from a shop. It adds posts, a gallery and messages. It is free to use and takes 5% of payments. It is built for creators, streamers and writers whose fans pay them directly.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Supporters is one part of it. Beside the paid posts it includes a shop, a newsletter, a podcast, booking pages and a website. It is built for someone whose supporters are one part of running the business.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s Supporters posts: a draft and five published posts, each with its date and who it is for, from everyone to paying supporters and chosen tiers, one with a poll.

How is Magpie different?

1. Paid posts come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a creator would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Supporters, the area this page is about, for free and paid tiers and the posts kept for them
  • Store for downloads and physical products, and Courses for lessons at a school of your own
  • Newsletter for email to subscribers, and Podcast for a show with its own feed
  • Meetings and Appointments for booking pages, and Invoicing for invoices paid online
  • Websites, QR Codes, Social Media, Forms, Contacts and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Buy Me a Coffee covers support, memberships, a shop, posts and messages. Its help centre describes no podcast feed and no booking calendar.

2. Store is a whole shop

Store sells downloads and physical products from the same cart. It tracks stock for each variant and charges shipping by zone. It offers free shipping over an amount, and local pickup. Buyers are emailed tracking numbers and can be asked for a review. A discount takes money or shipping off, or gives buy X get Y. It works as a code or applies automatically.

3. Every payment is in your own Stripe account

Each paid tier is a price in your team's own Stripe account. Each paying supporter is a subscription there. Store and paid Forms use the same account. Stripe pays the balance to your bank on its own schedule. Buy Me a Coffee takes payments itself. It pays out every Wednesday to the Stripe account you connect.

Comparing Magpie and Buy Me a Coffee

Buy Me a Coffee does more for the fan who wants to give; Magpie does more around the creator's business. Every line in the tables below was checked against Buy Me a Coffee's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Creator pageA free page where fans support you Yes Yes
One-off support with a messageA fan pays once and writes a note Yes Partly
Monthly support without a tierA fan gives monthly, with no perks promised Yes Partly
Paying without an account firstSupport with no sign-up Yes No
Membership levelsLevels with their own price and rewards Yes Yes
Yearly and lifetime membershipsMembers pay once a year, or once for good Yes Partly
Free trialsA first week free, then the price Yes No
Discord rolesMembers get a role that follows their level Yes No
Shop for downloadsEbooks, music, templates and art Yes Store
Physical products with shippingStock, shipping prices and tracking Partly Store
CommissionsCustom work with a limited number of slots Yes Partly
Posts with text, pictures and videoKept for everyone, supporters or chosen levels Yes Yes
Audio postsRecord or upload audio for a post Yes No
Posts emailed to fansA new post goes to followers or chosen levels Yes Partly
GalleryPictures, some kept for supporters Yes No
MessagesWrite to supporters, and let them write to you Yes Partly
Stream alerts and goalsSupport shown on a live stream, and a goal that fills Yes No
Button or widget for your websiteTake support on your own site Yes A link
QR code for your pageFor posters, cards and flyers Yes QR Codes
Webhooks and ZapierNew supports and sales sent to other software Yes Store only
Phone app for creatorsNotices of each support, and replies Yes Email notices
Podcast hostingA show with an RSS feed for podcast apps No Yes
Booking pagesFans choose a time from your availability Calls sold in the shop Yes
Other ways to payCash App, crypto and local currencies Yes Cards only
Download your supportersExport the list at any time Yes No
Monthly feeWhat the creator pays to use it None Free plan, or a paid plan
Platform feeWhat comes off each payment 5% 4%

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Your page

Both give you a free page with a cover, a name and a description, at a short address. Buy Me a Coffee adds your own colours, a featured video, social links and the order of its sections.

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Publish a free page where fans can support me Source Yes Yes
Choose a short address for my page Source Yes Yes
Give my page my own colours, cover and featured video, and choose what visitors see first Source Magpie: The page shows the cover image, name and description, then the tiers, the About section and the posts, inside Magpie's own top bar and footer. Its colours and the order of its sections cannot be changed, and it has no featured video or social links of its own. Yes Partly
Show how many people support me and what I earn, or keep it private Source Yes Yes
Let fans follow me for free Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Supporters settings can show how many support you and how many are on each tier. They can also show what the paid tiers add up to. All three are off until you turn them on.

One-time and monthly support

Buy Me a Coffee's first way to earn is a one-off payment with a message. It needs no sign-up. They do it better than we do today. Supporters joins fans to a free or a paid tier, after signing in.

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Let fans send me a one-off payment with a message Source Magpie: Supporters has no one-off payment: support is a free tier or a paid tier billed monthly or yearly. A Store product can be pay what you want, with a minimum and a suggested price, and a Long text personalisation field can take the fan's message, so a fan can pay a one-off amount through the Store's cart and checkout. It is not shown on the Supporters page. Yes Partly
Let fans give monthly without joining a tier Source Magpie: Monthly support means joining a paid tier, which has one fixed monthly price. A tier can offer nothing but thanks, but a fan cannot choose their own monthly amount. Yes Partly
Let fans pay without making an account first Source Magpie: Joining any tier, free or paid, starts with signing in to Magpie or making an account; Stripe Checkout opens after that. Yes No
Thank each supporter with my own message or a short video Source Magpie: Supporters settings hold one written welcome message that every new supporter reads and is emailed. There is no video, and a supporter's page offers Email, which opens your own mail program. Yes Partly

Good to know: A Store product can be pay what you want, with a minimum and a suggested price. It can ask the buyer for a message. A Store purchase needs no sign-in first: the order goes into a Magpie account for the buyer's email address.

Memberships

Both offer paid levels with their own price and description, paid monthly or yearly. Buy Me a Coffee adds lifetime prices, trials and member limits. It also changes prices for members already on a level, switches levels, makes offers to leaving members and gives Discord roles.

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Offer membership levels, each with its own price and rewards Source Yes Yes
Let members pay yearly as well as monthly Source Yes Yes
Sell lasting access to a level for one payment Source Magpie: Paid tiers are monthly or yearly subscriptions that run until the supporter cancels. Complimentary access with no end date lasts, but nobody pays for it. Yes No
Limit how many people can join a level Source Magpie: A tier is open to join or closed, with no limit on how many people join it. Yes No
Win new members with a free trial or a discount code Source Magpie: Supporter checkout has no trial and takes no promotion code: everyone on a tier pays its price from the start. Yes No
Give chosen people a level for free, for a while or for good Source Yes Yes
Greet new members of each level with a welcome note of its own Source Magpie: Supporters settings hold one welcome message that every new supporter reads, whatever their tier. Yes Partly
Stop new members joining a level, or pause billing while I take a break Source Magpie: Turning off Open to join, or Archive tier, takes a tier off the public page while everyone on it keeps their access and their payments. Payments cannot be paused. Yes Partly
Change a level's price, for new members or for everyone on it Source Magpie: A paid tier's monthly price is a Stripe Price and cannot change once set; a different amount needs another tier. Its yearly price can be changed for new supporters, and people already paying keep their price. Yes Partly
Let members move to another level themselves, with what they paid counted Source Magpie: Stripe's portal for supporters does not switch tiers. A supporter joins another tier from the public page once the current paid tier has ended. Yes No
Ask leaving members why, and offer them a reason to stay Source Magpie: A supporter cancels in Stripe's portal, at the end of the billing period, with no question or offer. A supporter's page shows why they left only when Stripe recorded a reason. Yes No
Give members a role in my Discord server that follows their level Source Magpie: Supporters does not connect to Discord. Yes No
Keep members whose card payment fails Source Magpie: Stripe retries a failed renewal, and the supporter keeps access while it does. Who you support marks the payment as failed and opens Stripe's portal to update the card, but Magpie sends no reminder of its own. Yes Partly
See how my members and earnings change over time, by level Source Magpie: The Supporters overview shows how many support you, how many pay, what the paid tiers bring in a month, and how many joined and ended in the last 30 days, and Payments lists every payment with totals. There is no chart over time or by tier. Yes Partly

Good to know: Give complimentary access opens any Magpie tier to someone for free, with an optional end date. Free allows 3 paid tiers and 200 posts; Pro and the Team plan have no limit.

Shop and commissions

Both sell downloads, let buyers pay more than the price and ask buyers a question. Magpie's Store adds stock, shipping zones and tracking. Buy Me a Coffee adds commissions and lower prices for members.

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Sell digital downloads from my page Source Yes Yes
Sell physical products with shipping prices Source Buy Me a Coffee: Prints, stickers and other items can be sold with a limited number of slots, but the shop guide has the creator ask for the address with a question and describe shipping in the item. It names no shipping prices or tracking. Partly Yes
Sell a one-to-one call or session Source Buy Me a Coffee: The homepage shows one-to-one Zoom calls sold through the shop and paid up front. The help centre does not describe choosing a time from a calendar. Partly Yes
Take paid commissions for custom work, with a limited number of slots Source Magpie: Store can sell custom work as a product: tracked stock limits the slots, personalisation fields ask for the details and can add to the price, and Remove from store turns the product back into a draft to close it. The finished piece cannot be sent to the buyer through their order. Yes Partly
Let buyers pay more than an item's price Source Yes Yes
Give members a lower price, or the item free, in my shop Source Magpie: A Store discount can be kept for a saved group of customers, or its code shared in a post kept for supporters, but Store does not know who supports you and cannot price a product for them. Yes Partly
Make discount codes for my shop Source Yes Yes
Ask buyers a question when they buy Source Yes Yes
Show buyers' ratings in my shop Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Store takes 4% of each sale, through the same Stripe account as Supporters. It can email buyers a new version of a file they bought.

Posts, gallery and messages

Both publish posts with text, pictures and video for chosen readers, with polls. Buy Me a Coffee adds audio posts, scheduling, categories, a gallery, messages and posts emailed to fans.

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Publish posts with text, pictures and video Source Yes Yes
Keep a post for supporters, members or chosen levels Source Yes Yes
Record or upload audio for a post Source Magpie: A post holds text, pictures, Screen Recorder videos and a poll. It cannot carry an audio player or a file to download. Yes No
Ask supporters a question in a poll Source Yes Yes
Schedule a post to publish later Source Magpie: A post is a draft or published; it cannot be set to publish at a later time. Yes No
Sort my posts into categories readers can browse Source Magpie: The page lists posts newest first. Posts have no categories or series. Yes No
Email a new post to my followers, or only to the levels it is for Source Magpie: Supporters posts are read on the page and are not emailed. Newsletter emails each issue to its own subscribers, who are kept apart from supporters. Yes Partly
Email my fans as often as I like at no extra cost Source Magpie: Newsletter charges no fee per email, but Free allows 250 subscribers and 1,000 emails a month, and Pro and the Team plan 5,000 subscribers and 50,000 emails a month. Yes Partly
Show my work in a gallery, with some pictures kept for supporters Source Magpie: The page lists posts newest first, each with a cover image. There is no gallery of pictures. Yes No
Message my supporters one to one or all at once, and let them write to me Source Magpie: A supporter's page has Email in its More menu, which opens your own mail program, and Team chat reaches anyone by handle, as a request until they accept. Supporters cannot write to you from your page, and there is no message to all supporters. Yes Partly

Good to know: A Supporters post is written in the Notes editor, with videos from Screen Recorder. Readers a post is locked for see its title, cover and excerpt, and the tiers that open it.

Sharing, streaming and integrations

Buy Me a Coffee makes buttons, widgets and QR codes, shows support on a live stream and sends webhooks. Magpie's supporters come from the page's address you share.

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Put a support button or widget on my website Source Magpie: The Supporters page has its own address to link to from anywhere, and a Link-In-Bio List can link to it, but there is no button or widget to put on a site. Yes Partly
Make a QR code for my page Source Yes Yes
Show an alert on my live stream when someone supports me Source Magpie: Nothing in Magpie shows a supporter or a payment on a live stream. Yes No
Show a funding goal and how close I am to it Source Magpie: There is no goal. Supporters settings can show what the paid tiers add up to each month, but not a target or progress toward one. Yes No
See my page's visitors in Google Analytics Source Magpie: A Supporters page puts no analytics code on the page; the overview counts supporters and payments only. Yes No
Thank supporters on X automatically Source Magpie: Social Media publishes the posts you write to Bluesky, Mastodon and LinkedIn, and keeps posts for X to share by hand. Nothing is posted when someone supports you. Yes No
Send new supports, members and sales to my other tools Source Magpie: Store sends signed webhooks for orders, Meetings for bookings and Forms for responses, but Supporters sends none, and Magpie has no Zapier app. Yes Partly
Hear about each new supporter on my phone and answer from an app Source Magpie: Team admins can be emailed about each new supporter. The Magpie app has Supporters, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly

Good to know: QR Codes makes a code for the Supporters page as SVG, PNG or PDF. A dynamic code can point elsewhere later and counts its scans.

Getting paid and fees

Both pay into a Stripe account. Buy Me a Coffee adds Cash App, crypto and local currencies. It also refunds from its dashboard and exports your supporters.

WhatBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Get paid into my own bank account Source Yes Yes
Pay the platform a small share of what fans pay, with no monthly fee Source Yes Yes
Let fans pay with Cash App or crypto as well as a card Source Magpie: Supporter checkout is Stripe Checkout limited to the card payment method, so Cash App, PayPal, bank payments and crypto are not offered. Yes Partly
Let fans pay in their own currency Source Magpie: A tier is priced and charged in the Stripe account's currency, and a Store has one currency; buyers abroad pay in it. Yes No
Have supporters cover the card fee Source Magpie: Stripe's fee comes out of what the team receives; a supporter always pays the tier's price. Yes No
Refund a supporter from my dashboard Source Magpie: Refunds are made in the Stripe dashboard. They then show on Supporters › Payments, marked Refunded or Partly refunded, and Magpie returns its fee in proportion. Yes Partly
Download my supporters' contact details Source Magpie: The Supporters list shows each supporter, with email addresses for team admins, but cannot be downloaded. Yes No
Let supporters see what they paid, get receipts and cancel themselves Source Yes Yes
Host my podcast with a feed for Apple Podcasts and Spotify Source Buy Me a Coffee: Audio posts play on the page, and the help centre says podcasts cannot be brought in through an RSS feed; no page offers a podcast feed. No Yes

Good to know: Supporters › Payments lists each payment with its fees and any refund. A refund made in Stripe returns Magpie's fee in proportion.

Price comparison

How Buy Me a Coffee charges

Buy Me a Coffee has no monthly fee, and every part of it is free to use. It takes 5% of each payment: one-off support, memberships and shop sales. Stripe's processing fee comes on top, and a creator can have supporters cover it. The details are in Buy Me a Coffee's FAQ.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for every area in the account. The plan sets how many paid tiers and posts you have, not which areas you can use. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments and 4% of Store sales. Stripe's fees come on top. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planBuy Me a CoffeeMagpie
Monthly feeNoneFree plan, or a paid plan
Fee on support and memberships5%4% on Supporters
Fee on shop sales5%4% on Store
Payment processingStripe's fee on top; supporters can cover itStripe's fees, through your own Stripe account
PayoutsTo your Stripe account every WednesdayStripe pays your bank on its own schedule
Email to fansFreeNewsletter: 250 subscribers on Free, 5,000 on a paid plan
Podcast hostingNot offeredIncluded
Booking pagesCalls sold in the shopIncluded; 4% of a payment taken at booking in Appointments

When to choose Magpie or Buy Me a Coffee

  • Want paid posts beside a full shop, a newsletter, a podcast and booking pages, paid into your own Stripe account? Go with Magpie.
  • Want fans to tip you in one tap with no sign-up, with lifetime memberships, stream alerts, a gallery and messages, free to use? Buy Me a Coffee is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a streamer
Buy Me a Coffee. Each support shows on your stream with your own sounds and colours. A goal fills as support comes in. Magpie shows nothing on a live stream today.
For a creator who wants tips
Buy Me a Coffee. A fan pays once with a message, in one tap and with no sign-up. Magpie takes a one-off payment only as a Store product.
For a maker who sells things
Magpie. Store ships physical products with stock, shipping zones and tracking, and sells downloads too. Buy Me a Coffee's shop guide asks for the address with a question and names no shipping prices.
For a coach, a teacher or a podcaster
Magpie. Paid posts sit beside booking pages that take payment, Courses, a podcast feed and a newsletter in one account. Buy Me a Coffee hosts no podcast feed.
For an artist with paying members
Either. Both keep posts for chosen levels and sell downloads. Buy Me a Coffee adds a gallery, commissions and lifetime memberships. Magpie adds a full shop and your own Stripe account. Choose by whether the gallery or the shop matters more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Buy Me a Coffee and Magpie?

Buy Me a Coffee is a page where fans tip you, join memberships and buy from a shop. It is free to use and takes 5% of payments. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Supporters area is one part, beside Store, Newsletter, Podcast and booking pages. Buy Me a Coffee does more for the fan who wants to give; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Buy Me a Coffee?

Yes, for a creator whose memberships are one part of a business. Supporters has free and paid tiers, monthly or yearly, and posts for chosen tiers. Store sells downloads and physical products. Payments go to your own Stripe account.

Consider keeping Buy Me a Coffee if your fans tip you once, with no sign-up. Keep it if you stream, or want lifetime memberships, a gallery or messages with fans. Buy Me a Coffee does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Buy Me a Coffee cost?

Buy Me a Coffee has no monthly fee, and every part of it is free to use. It takes 5% of each payment, and Stripe's processing fee comes on top. A creator can have supporters cover the card fee. The details are in Buy Me a Coffee's FAQ.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free allows 3 paid tiers and 200 posts; a paid plan has no limit. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments and 4% of Store sales, and Stripe's fees come on top. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Can fans send me a one-off tip on Magpie?

Partly. Supporters has no one-off payment: a fan joins a free tier or a paid tier, billed monthly or yearly. A Store product can be pay what you want, with a minimum and a suggested price. It can ask the buyer for a message. It is sold in the Store, not on the Supporters page. Buy Me a Coffee's one-off support is the first thing on its page.

Can fans support me on Magpie without making an account?

No. Joining any tier starts with signing in to Magpie or making an account, then Stripe's checkout. A Store purchase needs no sign-in first. The order goes into an account for the buyer's email address. Buy Me a Coffee's one-off support needs no sign-up.

Does Magpie have yearly or lifetime memberships?

Partly. A paid Supporters tier can offer a yearly price beside its monthly one, and supporters choose when they join. There is no lifetime price: complimentary access can last with no end date, but nobody pays for it. Buy Me a Coffee levels can have a yearly price, and a page can have one lifetime level.

Can I offer a free trial or a discount on a Magpie tier?

No. Supporter checkout has no trial and takes no promotion code. You can give someone complimentary access to any tier, with an end date if you want one. Buy Me a Coffee levels can have a 7-day free trial.

Can I change a tier's price on Magpie?

Partly. A paid tier's monthly price cannot change once it is set; a different amount needs another tier. Its yearly price can be changed for new supporters, and people already paying keep their price. Buy Me a Coffee changes a level's price for new members, and for existing members after notice.

Can supporters move to another tier themselves on Magpie?

No. A supporter joins another tier from the page once their current paid tier has ended. Buy Me a Coffee members switch level from their account, with the unused part counted toward the new price.

Can I post audio on Magpie?

No. A Supporters post holds text, pictures, Screen Recorder videos and a poll. Podcast hosts episodes with a public page and an RSS feed, with no feed kept for supporters. Buy Me a Coffee records or uploads audio for a post.

Does Magpie email new posts to supporters?

No. A Supporters post is read on the page, and nothing emails it out. Newsletter emails go to its own subscribers, who are kept apart from supporters. Buy Me a Coffee can email a post to followers, or only to the levels it is for.

Does Magpie have a gallery?

No. The Supporters page lists posts newest first, each with a cover image. Buy Me a Coffee's Gallery tab shows pictures, some kept for supporters or members.

Can I message my supporters on Magpie?

Partly. A supporter's page has Email, which opens your own mail program, and Team chat reaches anyone by handle. Supporters cannot write to you from your page, and there is no message to all of them. Buy Me a Coffee messages one supporter or a group of members at once.

Does Magpie have stream alerts or a funding goal?

No. Nothing in Magpie shows a supporter on a live stream, and the page has no goal. Supporters settings can show what the paid tiers add up to each month. Buy Me a Coffee's stream alerts work in OBS, Streamlabs and Twitch Studio, free for every creator.

Does Magpie connect to Discord?

No. Supporters does not connect to Discord, and it sends no webhooks. Buy Me a Coffee gives each level its own Discord role, removed when the member cancels.

Can fans pay with Cash App or in their own currency on Magpie?

No. Supporter checkout takes cards through Stripe, and a tier is charged in your Stripe account's currency. Buy Me a Coffee takes Cash App and other methods, and crypto in the United States. Localized pricing takes more than 15 currencies.

Can I download my supporter list from Magpie?

No. The Supporters list shows each supporter, with email addresses for team admins, but cannot be downloaded. Buy Me a Coffee lets creators export their supporters at any time.

Can fans pay for a call with me on Magpie?

Yes. An Appointments service can take its full price or a deposit by card when someone books, paid into your team's Stripe account. Magpie takes 4% of the payment, and the time is held while they pay. Buy Me a Coffee's homepage shows one-to-one calls sold through its shop and paid up front.

Does Buy Me a Coffee host podcasts?

No. Audio posts play on the page. The help centre says podcasts cannot be brought in through an RSS feed. Magpie's Podcast gives a show its own page and an RSS feed for Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Can I sell physical products on Buy Me a Coffee?

Partly. Its shop sells prints and stickers with a limited number of slots. The shop guide asks for the address with a question and names no shipping prices or tracking. Magpie's Store tracks stock, charges shipping by zone and emails tracking numbers.

Does Magpie have an app?

No. The Magpie app has Supporters, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Team admins can be emailed about each new supporter. Buy Me a Coffee has apps for iPhone and Android.

Can I use Buy Me a Coffee and Magpie together?

Yes. Buy Me a Coffee can take tips and memberships while Magpie runs your shop, booking pages, newsletter and website. A Magpie website or Link-In-Bio List can link to your Buy Me a Coffee page.

How do I move from Buy Me a Coffee to Magpie?

Set up Supporters and add your tiers, then publish the page. Paying members cannot be imported: each one joins again through the page and Stripe's checkout. Buy Me a Coffee lets you export your supporters. Newsletter imports a CSV file of people who agreed to hear from you. Then you can email them the new address.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Supporters with a free tier, 3 paid tiers and 200 posts. Store, a podcast, booking pages, Invoicing, the Newsletter with 250 subscribers, QR Codes and a team of 3. A paid plan removes the tier and post limits and raises the others.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Buy Me a Coffee changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Buy Me a Coffee's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Start a Supporters page on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then set up Supporters.

Create account