Teachable compared with Magpie

Teachable vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Teachable and Magpie both let a teacher sell online courses, coaching, downloads and memberships from a school of their own. They are built around different things.

  1. Teachable is a platform for selling courses, coaching, digital downloads and memberships. It is built for a creator whose school is the business. Payments, sales tax, affiliates, a student app and AI that drafts a course come with it.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Courses is one part of it. Beside the school it includes Coaching, Store, Supporters, Invoicing, booking pages and the rest. It is built for someone whose teaching is one part of running the business.
Create account
Courses list for a fictional design studio: published courses, each with its cover, lessons, students and completions, a draft, and the address of the school's catalogue.

How is Magpie different?

1. The courses come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Courses, with quizzes, assignments, cohorts, live sessions and certificates at a school of your own
  • Coaching for programs, sessions, habits and check-ins, in each client's Client Portal
  • Store for courses, downloads and physical products, and Supporters for paid posts
  • Meetings, Appointments and Invoicing for booked time and invoices paid online
  • Newsletter, Websites, Mail, Contacts, Helpdesk and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Teachable has no booking page of its own and links coaching sessions to Calendly or another booking page.

2. The Free plan publishes a course

Magpie's Free plan publishes 1 course for up to 50 students, and a paid plan has no limit on either. Certificates, cohorts, assignments and imports from a CSV file are on every plan. Teachable starts with a free trial, and a school needs a paid plan after it.

3. Cohorts and live sessions are part of the course

A Magpie course can run in cohorts, each with its own dates, seats, enrolment window and waiting list. A live session is a lesson with a Zoom meeting or a Video Chat call, calendar invitations, reminders and attendance. Teachable's courses are self-paced, and a live session is a stream or a Zoom block in a lesson.

Comparing Magpie and Teachable

Teachable does more to sell a course and to take it on a phone; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Teachable's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatTeachableMagpie
Online coursesSections of lessons, quizzes and certificates Yes Yes
Cohorts and live sessionsA group that starts together, with live lessons Partly Yes
Learning pathsSeveral courses in an order, sold as one Yes No
CoachingSell coaching and work with each client Yes Yes
Session bookingClients book from your free times Calendly or a link Yes
Digital downloadsFiles people buy and download Yes Yes
Free downloads for an email addressA lead magnet that builds a list Yes Partly
MembershipsTiers people pay for again and again Yes Supporters
BundlesSeveral products at one price Yes Yes
Payment plans and subscriptionsInstalments, or billing while access lasts Yes Partly
UpsellsAn add-on at checkout or in a lesson Yes Partly
AffiliatesCommission on sales others send you Builder and Growth No
Student referralsA link each student shares with friends Yes No
Sales tax handled for youTax worked out, collected and paid Yes Stripe Tax
Prices in the buyer's currencyConverted at checkout Yes No
Site builder at your own domainPages built without code Yes Yes
Your brand onlyNo platform name on the school or its emails Growth Partly
Student phone appCourses on iOS and Android, offline too Yes No
Student discussionPosts and replies between students Lesson comments Yes
AI course draftsAn outline, lessons and quiz questions from a description Yes Partly
Automatic captionsSubtitles made and translated for you Yes No
Free plan that sellsPublish and sell without a monthly fee No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Online courses

Both build a course of lessons with video, quizzes, open answers, comments and certificates, opened on a schedule. Teachable adds learning paths; Magpie adds cohorts and live sessions with attendance.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Make an online course of sections and lessons with video, audio, text and files, and sell it from its own page Source Yes Yes
Open course sections on a date, or a number of days after each student enrols Source Yes Yes
Make students take lessons in order, watch each video and pass each quiz before going on Source Yes Yes
Check what students learned with quizzes that mark themselves Source Yes Yes
Ask students open questions and read what they write Source Yes Yes
Give students a certificate when they complete a course Source Yes Yes
Let students comment under lessons and reply to each other Source Yes Yes
Teach a live session inside a course, with a recording afterwards Source Teachable: Courses are self-paced by default. A live session is a stream from YouTube, Vimeo or Twitch pasted into a lesson as code, or a block from the Zoom app, which schedules the Zoom meeting and records it. Partly Yes
Run a course for a group that starts on a date and moves through it together Source Teachable: There is no cohort of its own: Teachable suggests a drip schedule for a group that moves through a course together, and live sessions through embeds. Partly Yes
Put several courses in an order for students to take one after another Source Magpie: A Store bundle can sell several self-paced courses together at one price, in no order; nothing puts courses in an order. Yes No
Enrol students myself, one at a time or from a spreadsheet Source Yes Yes
Limit how many students can enrol, or how long each keeps access Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A Magpie lesson can require 90% of its video to be watched before it counts. A course can have up to 20 instructors.

Coaching

Both sell coaching from a page with questions to answer first. Each client gets a space with goals, files and messages. Magpie books the sessions from your own free times.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Sell coaching, one to one or in a small group, from a page with an intake form Source Yes Yes
Give each coaching client a page of milestones with meetings, messages and files Source Yes Yes
Let coaching clients book their sessions from my free times, without another scheduling tool Source Teachable: A milestone can carry a calendar link: Calendly opens inside the milestone, and any other booking page opens in a new tab. Teachable has no booking page of its own. Partly Yes

Good to know: A Magpie Coaching program holds goals, habits, check-ins and its sessions. A client pays in full or monthly, and Free coaches 3 clients.

Digital downloads, memberships and bundles

Both sell downloads, bundles and memberships paid monthly or yearly. Teachable gives a download away for an email address, which Magpie does only through Social Media's offers.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Sell files people download, such as ebooks, templates and audio Source Yes Yes
Give a download away free in return for an email address Source Magpie: Every Store price must be above zero, so Store cannot give a file away. Social Media's offers can: a person types their email address on the offer's page, with no account, and Magpie emails them a link to one PDF or ZIP file. An offer is made for a social post, and its file is not a Store product. Yes Partly
Sell a membership in tiers, each opening a set of my courses, coaching and downloads Source Magpie: Supporters has a free tier and paid tiers, charged monthly or yearly, that open the posts written for them, and a tier can include courses; Store products cannot be included. Magpie takes 4% of each payment. Yes Partly
Let members pay yearly as well as monthly Source Yes Yes
Let members move to another tier, or cancel, by themselves Source Magpie: A supporter cancels at the end of a billing period from Stripe's customer portal, which does not switch tiers; a different tier is joined from the public page once the current paid tier has ended. Yes Partly
Sell several products together at one price Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A Supporters tier can include courses, so a supporter on that tier opens them without paying again. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments.

Payments and pricing

Teachable Payments shows local ways to pay and converts prices into the buyer's currency. It handles sales tax where the platform is responsible. They do it better than we do today.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Take cards, wallets and local ways to pay, such as Apple Pay or pay later Source Yes Yes
Show buyers the price in their own currency Source Magpie: A Store has one currency, chosen when it is set up, and every buyer pays in it. Yes No
Have sales tax, VAT and GST worked out, collected and paid for me Source Magpie: Store can turn on Stripe Tax, which works out and charges the tax at checkout in your own Stripe account; registering, filing and paying it stay with you. Yes Partly
Let buyers pay in instalments Source Magpie: A course price in Store can be bought in a set number of monthly payments, with access from the first. Other Store products, and bundles, are paid in full at checkout. Yes Partly
Charge a subscription for a course or coaching, with a free trial Source Magpie: Supporters charges its paid tiers monthly or yearly, and recurring invoices from an accepted proposal charge a client's card every month, quarter or year; neither has a free trial, and Store sells nothing by subscription. Yes Partly

Good to know: Magpie's checkout is Stripe's, in your own Stripe account, with every payment method you turn on there. A course price can be paid in 2 to 12 monthly payments.

Sales and marketing

Both send a checkout reminder and take discount codes. Teachable adds upsells at checkout and in lessons, affiliates, student referrals and ad pixels.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Offer an add-on at checkout, or another product inside a lesson or after buying Source Magpie: A Store product's Goes with list shows other products on its page and in the Cart; nothing is offered at checkout, after paying or inside a lesson. Yes Partly
Email people who started checkout and did not pay Source Yes Yes
Give discount codes for one product, one kind of product or everything Source Yes Yes
Pay people a commission on the sales they send me Source Magpie: Store has no affiliates. A partner can be given a discount code, or a link with UTM tags that Sales by source counts, but nothing works out or pays a commission. Yes No
Give each student a link to refer friends Source Magpie: Nothing gives a buyer or a student a referral link; a discount code can only be shared by hand. Yes No
Share each sale automatically with a co-instructor Source Teachable: An author on a course or coaching product earns a set share of each sale and has an author dashboard; on Teachable Payments the school pays authors by hand until automatic payouts arrive.Magpie: Courses names instructors and teaching assistants, but no sale is split: every Store payment goes to the team's own Stripe account. Supporters crews, which divide each supporter's payment between several teams by shares, are open only to site administrators. Partly No
Email my students, or only those in one course or with a tag Source Magpie: Courses emails the chosen students of one course, narrowed by cohort, progress or how they joined, and sends announcements. Students have no tags, and nothing emails every student of the school at once; Newsletter and Outreach reach subscribers and a Contacts tag. Yes Partly
Collect email addresses with a sign-up form on my pages Source Magpie: Newsletter has its own signup page with double opt-in, and Newsletter settings gives the signup form's code to paste into a page of another website. Store checkout can add buyers to the Newsletter. A course school and a Magpie editor website have no sign-up section. Yes Partly
Measure my ads with Google Analytics and the Meta, TikTok or Pinterest pixel Source Magpie: Store reports count visits and show sales by source, from UTM tags or the website that linked, and Store has no setting for Google Analytics or an ad pixel. An analytics tag pasted into a website's layout runs on its pages at your own domain, but not on its shop's pages. Yes Partly

Good to know: Store discounts can be a percentage, an amount, free shipping or buy one get one, with a code or automatically. Store reports show sales by source from UTM tags.

Site builder and branding

Both build pages without code, at your own domain, with your own CSS. Teachable's Growth plan takes its name off the school entirely.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Build my site's pages in an editor, without code Source Yes Yes
Show my site at my own domain Source Yes Yes
Change the site with my own CSS and code Source Yes Yes
Show my school and its emails under my own brand only, without the platform's name Source Magpie: A course school has its own name, logo, colours and fonts and shows its catalogue and course pages at your domain, but lessons, sign-in and buying stay at Magpie's address and its emails go out as the school via Magpie. Yes Partly
Show the pages my customers see in their language Source Magpie: Language for customers sets the words Magpie adds to your Store, booking pages, Forms and Client Portals, and the emails they send, in English, French, Spanish or German. Yes Partly

Good to know: A Magpie school has its own name, logo, colours and fonts. Its catalogue and course pages show at your own domain.

Student experience and mobile app

Teachable has an iOS and Android app where students watch lessons offline. Magpie's students take courses in a browser, and each course has a discussion of its own.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Let students take courses in a phone app Source Magpie: Students take courses at the school's address in a browser; the Magpie app, not yet in the App Store or Google Play, has no Courses screens. Yes No
Give students a community where they talk with each other Source Teachable: The student experience page offers discussion boards, but Community is in maintenance mode, with no new features or fixes, and a school that never made one cannot start one. Teachable points to lesson comments, or to Discord or Slack. Partly Yes

Good to know: Teachable's Community is in maintenance mode, and a school that never made one cannot start one. Magpie's course discussion has posts, replies, lesson comments and announcements.

Analytics and reporting

Both report each student's progress, where students stop watching a video, quiz scores and sales, with CSV exports.

WhatTeachableMagpie
See each student's progress and where students stop watching Source Yes Yes
See my sales, refunds and earnings in reports Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Store reports also show Stripe fees, margins and visits for any dates, and can send a weekly summary by email.

AI

Both connect to Claude and ChatGPT. Teachable drafts a course and its sales page from a description, and makes and translates video subtitles.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Have AI draft a course: its outline, lessons, quiz questions and sales page Source Magpie: The assistant on Dashboard writes a Store product's description and a website's home page, but not a course. Courses gives a prompt to copy into a chatbot of your own and imports the whole course it writes, quiz questions included. Yes Partly
Have subtitles made and translated automatically for my videos Source Magpie: A course video takes caption files you upload, WebVTT or SRT, in up to 10 languages, shown to students as a transcript; nothing is made or translated automatically. Yes No
Run my business from Claude or ChatGPT Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Courses gives you a prompt to copy into a chatbot of your own. It imports the course the chatbot writes, quiz questions included. Caption files you upload work in up to 10 languages.

Team, integrations and developer tools

Both give the team its own sign-ins and have an API and webhooks. Teachable connects Mailchimp, Kit and other email services, and builds custom roles on Growth.

WhatTeachableMagpie
Give my team their own logins Source Yes Yes
Choose exactly what each team member may do, such as refund orders but not edit courses Source Magpie: A team member is an admin, a member or view-only, and a guest uses only the areas given; only Store gives permissions one at a time, such as seeing orders, refunding or managing products. Yes Partly
Connect the email marketing tools I already use, such as Mailchimp or Kit Source Magpie: Magpie has its own Newsletter, Outreach and Contacts; another tool connects only through the API and webhooks, with no ready connection to Mailchimp, Kit or any other email service. Yes Partly
Connect other software through an API or webhooks Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A Magpie team member is an admin, a member, view only, or a guest limited to chosen areas. Webhooks and the API are on Pro.

Price comparison

How Teachable charges

Teachable charges by plan, Starter, Builder, Growth or Custom, billed monthly or yearly, after a free trial and with no free plan. The plan sets the products and admin users you have: 5, 10 or 50 products. Starter takes 7.5% of each sale; Builder and up take none on Teachable Payments. Recurring payments pay 0.7%, and Growth adds certificates, custom roles and imports. Prices are on Teachable's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan too, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account: courses, coaching, the shop, invoicing and the rest. The plan sets how many courses, students, clients and team members you have, not which areas you can use. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales, courses included, and 4% of Supporters payments. It takes 4% of payments for appointments. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planTeachableMagpie
Free planA free trial, then a paid plan1 published course and 50 students on Free
Fee on sales7.5% on Starter; none on Builder and up with Teachable Payments4% of Store sales
Fee on recurring payments0.7% of each subscription or payment plan payment4% of Supporters payments; course payment plans as Store sales
Card feesTeachable Payments: 2.9% plus a fixed amount for a US card, 3.9% for an international oneStripe's fees, through your own Stripe account
Products you can sell5 on Starter, 10 on Builder, 50 on GrowthNo limit on Store products
People who can run it1 admin user on Starter and Builder, 5 on Growth3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan
Certificates and student importsGrowthEvery plan
Booking pages and invoicingCalendly or another booking pageIncluded

When to choose Magpie or Teachable

  • Want your courses beside coaching, a shop, invoices and booking pages, with cohorts, one price for the team and a Free plan? Go with Magpie.
  • Want a student app, affiliates, upsells, sales tax handled for you and AI that drafts your course, all built around selling it? Teachable is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a creator selling self-paced courses
Teachable. Students take lessons in an app, offline too, and buyers pay in their own currency. Affiliates, referrals and upsells bring in more sales, which Magpie does not do.
For a school selling across borders
Teachable. Teachable Payments collects and pays sales tax and VAT where the platform is responsible. Magpie works out tax with Stripe Tax, and filing it stays with you.
For a teacher running cohorts
Magpie. Each cohort has its own dates, seats and waiting list, with live sessions, attendance and assignments you review. Teachable suggests a drip schedule and embedded streams instead.
For a coach with one-to-one clients
Magpie. Coaching runs the program, sessions, habits and check-ins, and clients book from your own free times. Teachable links each session to Calendly or another booking page.
For a business that sells courses beside products or services
Magpie. Store sells the course, the downloads and physical products in one Cart. Invoicing, Meetings and Appointments are in the same team.
For someone starting out
Either. Magpie's Free plan publishes 1 course for up to 50 students and takes 4% of each sale. Teachable's Starter plan takes 7.5% and drafts the course with AI. Choose by whether you want to start free or start with help writing.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Teachable and Magpie?

Teachable is a platform for selling courses, coaching, downloads and memberships, with payments, affiliates and a student app. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Courses is one area beside Coaching, Store, Invoicing, booking pages and the rest. Teachable does more to sell a course; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Teachable?

Yes, for a teacher or coach whose courses are one part of the business. Magpie's Courses has quizzes, assignments, cohorts, live sessions and certificates. Coaching, Store, Supporters and Invoicing are in the same team.

Consider keeping Teachable if your students learn in its app, or you sell through affiliates and upsells. Keep it too if you sell in many currencies, or want captions made for you. Teachable does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Teachable cost?

Teachable has Starter, Builder and Growth plans, billed monthly or yearly, and a Custom plan, with a free trial and no free plan. Starter takes 7.5% of each sale; Builder and up take none on Teachable Payments. Recurring payments pay 0.7%, and card fees come on top. The prices are on Teachable's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free publishes 1 course for up to 50 students, and a paid plan has no limit on either. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales, courses included. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have learning paths?

No. A Store bundle sells several courses together at one price, but in no order. Learning paths are on Magpie's roadmap. Teachable's learning paths put up to 25 courses in a recommended order and sell them as one product.

Does Magpie have a student app?

No. Students take courses at the school's address in a browser, on a computer or a phone. The Magpie app has no Courses screens, and it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Teachable's iOS and Android apps open bought courses and download lessons to watch offline.

Does Magpie have affiliates?

No. A partner can be given a Store discount code or a link with UTM tags. Store reports count the sales it sends. Nothing works out or pays a commission. Teachable's affiliates, on Builder and up, get their own links and a commission rate.

Does Magpie have student referrals?

No. Nothing gives a student a referral link of their own; a discount code can only be shared by hand. Referrals are on Magpie's roadmap. Teachable gives each student a link to send to friends.

Does Magpie caption course videos automatically?

No. A course video takes caption files you upload, WebVTT or SRT, in up to 10 languages. Students read them as a transcript. Teachable makes subtitles by itself and translates them into more than 70 languages.

Can I give away a free download for an email address?

Partly. Every Store price is above zero, so Store cannot give a file away. Social Media's offers can: a person types their email address on the offer's page, and Magpie emails them a link to one PDF or ZIP file. Free products in Store are on Magpie's roadmap. Teachable sells free downloads as lead magnets that build an email list.

Does Magpie handle sales tax for me?

Partly. Store can turn on Stripe Tax in your own Stripe account, which works out and charges the tax at checkout. Registering, filing and paying it stay with you. Teachable Payments collects and pays US sales tax, EU and UK VAT and more, where the platform is responsible.

Does Magpie have cohorts and live classes?

Yes. A course can run in cohorts, each with its own dates, seats, enrolment window, waiting list and live session times. A live session meets on Zoom or a Video Chat call, with invitations, reminders and attendance. Teachable's courses are self-paced, with streams or a Zoom block in a lesson.

Does Magpie have coaching?

Yes. A Coaching program holds goals, habits, check-ins and the sessions it includes. A client applies or joins from the program's page and pays in full or in monthly instalments. They book each session from your free times. Messages and files go both ways in their Client Portal.

Can students pay for a course in instalments?

Yes, on both. A Magpie course price can be paid in 2 to 12 monthly payments through Store, with access from the first. Teachable's payment plans cover courses, coaching, downloads and bundles, and its subscriptions can start with a free trial.

Does Magpie have memberships?

Yes, in Supporters: a free tier and paid tiers that open the posts written for them, and a tier can include courses. A paid tier is charged monthly, or yearly where you offer a yearly price. Store products cannot be included. Teachable's tiers open courses, coaching and downloads, monthly or yearly.

Does Teachable have a community?

Partly. Teachable's Community is in maintenance mode, with no new changes or fixes. A school that never made one cannot start one. Teachable points to lesson comments, Discord or Slack. Each Magpie course has a discussion where students post, reply and comment under lessons.

Does Teachable have a free plan?

No. Teachable starts with a free trial, and a paid plan follows it. Magpie's Free plan publishes 1 course for up to 50 students, and runs a Store and a website.

Can I use Teachable and Magpie together?

Yes. Teachable can run your courses while Magpie runs your coaching, invoices, shop or email. A Teachable coaching milestone can link to a Magpie booking page. A Teachable page can link to a Form or a Store product.

How do I move my courses from Teachable to Magpie?

Make the outline in Courses, or paste it in as JSON written by an assistant with Copy the prompt. Upload each video again, then add students by pasting them or from a CSV file. A paid course is sold through Store once your Stripe account is connected. Keep Teachable until every student has moved.

Can my team work in it with me?

Yes. A free Magpie team has 3 people and the Team plan 25, as admins, members, view-only members or guests. A course can have up to 20 instructors. Teachable includes 1 admin user on Starter and Builder and 5 on Growth.

Can an AI app work with my school?

On both, from Claude or ChatGPT. Teachable's MCP server reads students, courses and sales and enrols people, on Growth and up. Magpie's Connected apps read and change your records, and Courses takes an outline written as JSON. Teachable's course starter also drafts the course and its sales page, which Magpie's assistant does not.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

1 published course for up to 50 students, and Coaching for 3 clients. Store, Supporters, a website, the Newsletter with 250 subscribers, booking pages, Invoicing and a team of 3. A paid plan raises the limits and adds Mail.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Teachable changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Teachable's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Publish a course on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then make your first course.

Create account