OpenTable compared with Magpie

OpenTable vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

OpenTable and Magpie both give a restaurant a page where diners reserve a table. Both keep a book for each service and a plan of the dining room. They differ on what comes with it.

  1. OpenTable is a reservation system and a network where diners look for a table, on its app and partner sites such as Google. It is built for a restaurant that wants new diners, with deposits, texts, reviews and marketing beside the book.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Restaurant Reservations is one part of it. Beside the book it includes the rota, stock counts, daily checklists, payroll and accounting. It is built for a restaurant whose reservations are one part of running the business.
Create account
The Tables view of a fictional restaurant’s book during Dinner: the dining room’s map with each table free, due, seated or running late, and the party at each one.

How is Magpie different?

1. The book comes with the rest of the restaurant

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a restaurant would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Restaurant Reservations for the booking page, the book, the waitlist, the seating plan and the diner list
  • Staff Scheduling for the rota, planned and published in the same team
  • Inventory for stock counts, and Daily Operations for opening and closing checklists, temperatures and the logbook
  • Payroll, Accounting and Expenses for wages, the books and receipts
  • Websites, Store for gift cards, Forms, the Newsletter, Contacts and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. OpenTable's plans list no staff scheduling, so the rota is made in another product.

2. A diner costs nothing

Magpie charges nothing for a reservation, a cover or a diner, on any plan. Reservations, tables and diners have no limit. A diner who reserves on your booking page costs the same as one who phones. OpenTable charges a fee for each diner seated from its network, on every plan.

3. The Free plan takes reservations

Restaurant Reservations is on Magpie's Free plan with one venue. That includes the booking page, the book, the waitlist, the seating plan and the diner list. A paid plan has five venues. OpenTable's lowest plan, Basic, has a 30-day free trial and then a monthly price. Both prices are on Magpie's pricing page and OpenTable's plans page.

Comparing Magpie and OpenTable

OpenTable does more to bring diners in and talk to them; Magpie does more around the book. Every line in the tables below was checked against OpenTable's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Online reservationsDiners choose a party size, a date and a free time Yes Yes
Booking on your own websiteA booking widget inside the restaurant's website Yes A link
A network where diners look for a tableA website, an app and partner sites that send new diners Yes No
Reserve with GoogleA reservation button on the restaurant's Google listing Yes No
Seating plan and table managementThe dining room drawn, with each table's status during service Core and Pro Yes
WaitlistWalk-ins waiting for a table, with the wait quoted Core and Pro Yes
Guest profiles and tagsEach diner's visits, notes and tags Yes Yes
Confirmations and remindersEmails and texts sent to diners about their reservation Yes Email only
Deposits and no-show feesA deposit or a card hold taken when diners reserve Yes No
Set menus and ticketed eventsExperiences diners book and pay for ahead Yes Paid forms
Private dining enquiriesAn enquiry form and a list of leads Add-on Forms
Gift cardsCards diners buy and spend on a meal Yes Store
Pay at the tableDiners pay the bill from their phone Yes No
ReviewsReviews collected and answered in one place Yes No
Email marketing to dinersCampaigns sent by visits, birthdays and tags Pro Newsletter
ReportsCovers, no-shows and turn times over weeks and months Yes Today only
Till connectionTable status and spend from the POS Core and Pro No
Phone app for the floorSeat, move and finish parties from a phone Yes In the browser
Staff schedulingThe rota in the same account as the book No Yes
Free planReservations without a monthly price No Yes
No fee per dinerNothing charged for each diner seated No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Reservation management

Both take reservations online and by phone, with services, turn times, pacing, special days and a waitlist. Both email a diner when a time they wanted becomes free. OpenTable adds an online waitlist and Voice AI partners that answer the phone.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Let diners reserve a table online at any hour Source Yes Yes
Show the restaurant's description, hours, menu and photos where diners reserve Source Magpie: The booking page shows the venue's name, description, street address, phone number and one picture, with its cancellation rule. It has no menu, no opening hours and no gallery of photos. Yes Partly
Take reservations from my own website Source Magpie: Once published, the booking page's address is shown with Copy and Open, to link to from a website. There is no widget to put inside the website, and Websites has no reservations block. Yes Partly
Set the hours you seat diners and how many covers you take in each 15 minutes Source Yes Yes
Set how long a party keeps its table, by party size Source Yes Yes
Choose the party sizes, dates and tables diners can reserve online Source Yes Yes
Close for a holiday, or change the hours for one day Source Yes Yes
Add reservations taken by phone, and seat walk-ins Source Yes Yes
Let diners give the occasion and any special request when they reserve Source Yes Yes
Let diners change or cancel their own reservation Source Yes Yes
Show a cancellation policy diners agree to when they reserve Source Yes Yes
Tell a diner when a time they wanted becomes free Source Yes Yes
Have an AI voice assistant answer the phone and take reservations Source Magpie: A reservation taken by phone is added by a member in the book. Yes No
Keep a waitlist of walk-ins with the wait you quoted them Source Yes Yes
Let diners join the waitlist from their phone and be texted when their table is ready Source Magpie: Only the team puts a party on the waitlist, and no text is sent when their table is ready. Yes No

Good to know: A time a diner chooses is held for 5 minutes while they enter their details. Pacing caps the new covers in each interval, even when tables are free.

Deposits, Experiences and private dining

OpenTable takes deposits and card holds, sells Experiences and gift cards, and lets diners pay at the table. They do it better than we do today. Magpie sells events through paid forms and gift cards through Store.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Take a deposit or hold a card when diners reserve, and charge for a no-show Source Magpie: A service can be given a deposit or card rule, but the booking page then asks the diner to call the venue for that time, because taking the payment is not built yet. Yes No
Sell a set menu, a tasting evening or an event that diners book and pay for ahead Source Magpie: A paid Form can sell a tasting evening or another event for one fixed price paid ahead, through the team's Stripe account. It offers no times to choose from, does not stop when the event is full, and does not reach the book or hold tables. Yes Partly
Take enquiries for private dining and large events, and keep track of each one Source Magpie: A Form takes private dining enquiries online, can charge a fixed deposit with each one, and lists the responses as New, Reviewed or Archived. Nothing links an enquiry to the book or holds tables for the event, and a party larger than a service takes online is asked to call. Yes Partly
Sell gift cards that diners spend on a meal Source Magpie: Store sells gift cards, emailed with a code, and a card's Adjust balance takes off what a diner spent, by hand. Restaurant Reservations has no way to take a gift card against a bill. Yes Partly
Let diners pay the bill from their phone at the table Source Magpie: Magpie takes no payment for a meal; the bill is paid on the restaurant's own till. Yes No

Good to know: A paid Form takes 4% and Store takes 4% of each sale. Buyers pay through your own Stripe account, and Stripe's card fees apply too.

Table management

Both draw the dining room, join tables for larger parties and show each table's status during service. OpenTable also rearranges tables to fit more parties, gives servers sections and reads the till.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Draw the dining room with every table where it stands Source Yes Yes
Join tables for a larger party Source Yes Yes
See who is at each table during service, and seat, move and finish parties Source Yes Yes
Have tables chosen for each reservation and rearranged to fit more parties Source Magpie: Each new reservation is given the free table that fits with the fewest spare seats, single tables before combinations, and Seat lists the best free tables first. Reservations that already have a table are never rearranged to make room. Yes Partly
Give each server a section of tables and balance their covers Source Magpie: Sections are the venue's rooms, such as Main room or Terrace; servers are not given tables. Yes No
See which course each table is on, from the till Source Magpie: Staff mark a party Arrived, Seated and Finished by hand; Magpie connects to no till. Yes No
Run the floor from a phone Source Yes Yes
Keep the book working when the internet goes down Source Magpie: The book needs a connection to show or change reservations. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's seating plan is on every plan, Free included. A plan written with an assistant, from a photo of the room, can be pasted in. Undo reverses a change in the book within 5 minutes.

Guest profiles

Both keep each diner's visits, notes and tags, and both run several restaurants under one account. OpenTable adds automatic tags, spend from the till, loyalty points and roles for each job.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Keep each diner's visits, notes and preferences Source Yes Yes
Tag diners, such as VIP or allergy, so staff see it on their next visit Source Yes Yes
Tag diners automatically by how often they come or what they spend Source Magpie: Tags are added by hand; the Diners list counts each diner's visits and no-shows. Yes No
See what each diner spends Source Magpie: A diner's page shows their reservations, not what they spent. Yes No
Keep diners in the same contact list as the rest of the business Source OpenTable: Guests stay in OpenTable's own guestbook. A guest report can be exported as a file, and email lists go to Mailchimp or Emma. Partly Yes
Reward regulars with a membership or points Source Magpie: Magpie has no membership or points for diners; a tag such as Regular marks them by hand. Yes No
Run several restaurants with one guest list Source Yes Yes
Give each staff member their own sign-in with only the access their job needs Source Magpie: Each person signs in with their own Magpie account. A member who can only view reads the book, members with edit access run it, and team admins also set up services and the booking page. There are no other roles. Yes Partly

Good to know: Add to Contacts keeps a diner in Contacts. The contact's history lists their reservations beside their invoices and other work.

Guest messaging

Both email diners a confirmation, a reminder and any change to their reservation. OpenTable also texts diners, and the team can message them from the book. They do it better than we do today.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Send diners a confirmation and a reminder automatically Source Yes Yes
Confirm and remind diners by text message Source Magpie: Magpie sends no texts to diners. The booking page has a question for diners who want texts, but it stays hidden because no venue can turn texts on yet, though the Pro plan already lists 500 texts a venue each month. Yes No
Message a diner about their reservation and read their reply Source Magpie: The team keeps notes on a reservation, and its page lists the emails sent about it. A diner's reply to one of them goes to the venue's Email for replies, but there is no way to write to a diner from the book. Yes No

Good to know: A diner who replies to one of the venue's emails reaches the address set in Email for replies. A reservation's page lists the emails sent about it, with Resend for one that was not sent.

Marketing and the OpenTable network

OpenTable lists the restaurant where diners search, on its own app and on partner sites, and promotes quiet times. Magpie's booking page is a public address you share yourself.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Be found by new diners where they search for a table Source Magpie: The booking page is public and has its own link preview, but Magpie has no app or directory where diners look for a restaurant. Yes No
Let diners reserve from my Google listing, Instagram and Facebook Source Magpie: The booking page's address can be added to a profile as a link; no reservation button reaches Google, Instagram or Facebook. Yes No
Email past diners automatically, such as on their birthday or when they have not been back Source Magpie: The Newsletter emails people who subscribed, and its signup page can be shared with diners. The booking page offers no sign-up, and nothing is sent because of a diner's visits or birthday. Yes Partly
Fill quiet times by offering diners something for booking them Source Magpie: Every free time on the booking page is shown the same way; nothing can be offered for a quiet one. Yes No
See which ads bring in reservations Source Magpie: Each reservation records how it was made, such as online, by the team, as a walk-in or in the app, but not which ad or link brought the diner. Yes No

Good to know: The booking page has its own link preview with the venue's picture. The Newsletter's sign-up page can be shared with diners.

Reviews and feedback

OpenTable collects reviews from diners who kept their reservation and answers Google's and Facebook's beside them. Magpie has no reviews.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Collect reviews from diners and answer them, with Google's and Facebook's, in one place Source Magpie: Magpie does not ask diners for a review or show reviews from other sites. Yes No
Send diners a short survey after their visit Source Magpie: A Form can ask diners anything and its link can be shared, but nothing sends it after a visit or links the answers to the diner. Yes Partly
Answer diners' questions about the restaurant with AI Source Magpie: The booking page shows the venue's description and phone number; nothing answers a diner's question. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie form can ask diners anything. It emails you each response and exports a CSV file.

Reports

OpenTable reports each shift's covers, spend, ratings and no-shows, and compares turn times with the settings. Magpie shows the figures for one day at a time.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
See covers, no-shows and turn times over weeks and months Source Magpie: Today shows the day's reservations, covers, seated and waiting parties and no-shows. There are no reports over a period of time. Yes Partly

Good to know: Today shows the day's reservations, covers, seated and waiting parties and no-shows. The book refreshes itself while it is open.

Plans and pricing

OpenTable charges a monthly price and a fee for each diner seated from its network. Magpie charges by plan and nothing for a diner.

WhatOpenTableMagpie
Take reservations without paying for each diner seated Source OpenTable: Every plan charges a fee for each diner seated from the OpenTable network, higher on Basic than on Core and Pro, and Basic also charges for each diner from the restaurant's own website, or a monthly fee instead. No-shows and cancellations are not charged. No Yes
Start taking reservations without a monthly fee Source OpenTable: Basic, the lowest plan, has a monthly fee after a 30-day free trial. No Yes
Plan which staff work each service, in the same place as the book Source OpenTable: OpenTable's plans list no staff scheduling; rotas are made in another product. No Yes

Good to know: Staff Scheduling, Inventory, Daily Operations and Payroll are in the same team as the book, on the same bill.

Price comparison

How OpenTable charges

OpenTable charges by plan, Basic, Core or Pro, each a monthly price. Basic has a 30-day free trial, and there is no free plan. Every plan also charges a fee for each diner seated from the OpenTable network. Basic charges for diners from the restaurant's own website too, or a monthly fee instead. No-shows and cancellations are not charged. Private Dining is a monthly add-on on any plan. Prices are on OpenTable's plans page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan too, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. Restaurant Reservations is on every plan: one venue on Free and five on a paid plan. Magpie charges nothing for a reservation or a diner. It takes 4% of paid forms and 4% of Store sales, such as gift cards. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planOpenTableMagpie
Fee for each diner from the networkOn every plan, lower on Core and ProNo network, and no fee
Fee for diners from your own websiteOn Basic, per diner or a monthly fee; none on Core and ProNone
Starting without payingA 30-day trial of BasicThe Free plan, with one venue
Prepaid Experiences and eventsA 2% service fee, through Stripe or CardConnect4% on paid forms, through your own Stripe account
Deposits and card holdsIncluded from BasicNot available yet
Reminder wording and timingPremium Communications, in Pro and an add-on on CoreNot available: Magpie's own reminder goes 24 hours before
Private diningA monthly add-on on any planForms, included
Gift cardsThe OpenTable Gifts marketplaceStore, 4% of each sale
Several restaurantsOpenTable for GroupsFive venues on a paid plan
Staff scheduling, stock and checklistsNot on OpenTable's plansIncluded

When to choose Magpie or OpenTable

  • Want the book and the seating plan with no fee per diner, beside the rota, the stock count and the daily checklists? Go with Magpie.
  • Want new diners from OpenTable and Google, with deposits, reminder texts, reviews and marketing in the same place? OpenTable is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a restaurant that wants new diners
OpenTable. OpenTable lists the restaurant on its app and on partner sites such as Google, and promotes quiet times. Magpie's booking page reaches only the diners you send to it.
For a restaurant with many no-shows
OpenTable. Deposits, card holds and reminder texts are included from Basic. Magpie takes no payment when diners reserve, and reminds them by email only.
For a café or a bar with walk-ins and a few reservations
Magpie. The book, the waitlist and the seating plan are on the Free plan, with no fee per diner. Diners get a confirmation and a reminder by email.
For a restaurant that runs its rota and stock in one place
Magpie. Staff Scheduling, Inventory and Daily Operations are in the same team as the book. OpenTable's plans list no staff scheduling.
For a group of restaurants
Either. Both run several restaurants under one account. OpenTable for Groups adds group reporting, and roles choose what each login reaches. Magpie has five venues on a paid plan, with the rota beside them. Choose by whether reports and roles or the rest of the business matter more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between OpenTable and Magpie?

OpenTable is a reservation system and a network where diners look for a table. It adds deposits, texts, reviews and marketing. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Restaurant Reservations is one area beside the rota, stock counts, payroll and accounting. OpenTable does more to bring diners in; Magpie does more around the book.

Does Magpie replace OpenTable?

Yes, for a restaurant that takes reservations on its own page and by phone. Magpie gives it the book, the waitlist, the seating plan and the diner list, with no fee per diner.

Consider keeping OpenTable if new diners find you on OpenTable or Google. Keep it if you take deposits or charge for no-shows. Keep it too if diners need reminder texts, or if you collect reviews. OpenTable does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does OpenTable cost?

OpenTable has three plans: Basic, Core and Pro, each a monthly price. Basic has a 30-day free trial. Every plan also charges a fee for each diner seated from the OpenTable network. Basic charges for diners from your own website too. Private Dining is a monthly add-on. The prices are on OpenTable's plans page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Restaurant Reservations has one venue on Free and five on a paid plan. Magpie charges nothing for a reservation or a diner. It takes 4% of paid forms and 4% of Store sales. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does OpenTable charge for each diner?

Yes. Every plan charges a fee for each diner seated from the OpenTable network. The fee is lower on Core and Pro than on Basic. Basic also charges for diners from your own website, or a monthly fee instead. No-shows and cancellations are not charged. Magpie charges nothing for a diner.

Does Magpie send confirmation and reminder emails to diners?

Yes. A diner who gave an email address gets a confirmation, a reminder 24 hours before asking them to confirm, and notices of any change or cancellation. Each links to the reservation's own page, where they change the time or cancel. The emails come from the venue's name, and replies go to the address you set. OpenTable confirms and reminds diners by email and text.

Does Magpie send text messages to diners?

No. Magpie sends no texts to diners about a reservation or the waitlist. Texts are on Magpie's roadmap. OpenTable texts diners about their reservation and when their table is ready.

Can Magpie take a deposit or charge for a no-show?

No. A service can be given a deposit or card rule. The booking page then asks the diner to call for that time. Taking the payment is on Magpie's roadmap. OpenTable takes deposits and card holds from Basic, by party size, date or time.

Will diners find my restaurant through Magpie?

No. Magpie has no app or directory where diners look for a restaurant. The booking page is a public address with its own link preview, and you share it yourself. OpenTable lists the restaurant on its website and app and on more than 140 partner sites.

Can diners reserve from my Google listing with Magpie?

No. The booking page's address can be added to a Google, Instagram or Facebook profile as a link. No reservation button reaches those sites. OpenTable's Reserve with Google puts a Reserve a table button on the Google listing.

Does Magpie have a seating plan?

Yes, on every plan. Seating plan draws each section from above, with tables in five shapes, chairs, walls, the bar and doors. Tables join into combinations for larger parties. During service, the book's Tables view shows each table free, due, arrived, seated or running late. OpenTable's floor plans are on Core and Pro.

Does Magpie have a waitlist?

Yes. Add walk-in puts a party on the Waitlist with the wait you quoted them. The book seats them when a table frees. Only the team adds a party, and no text goes out when the table is ready. OpenTable's online waitlist lets diners join from their phone and texts them.

Does Magpie collect reviews?

No. Magpie does not ask diners for a review or show reviews from other sites. A Form can ask diners anything, but nothing sends it after a visit. OpenTable collects reviews from diners who kept their reservation and answers Google's and Facebook's beside them.

Does Magpie have reports on covers and no-shows?

Only for one day. Today shows the day's reservations, covers, seated and waiting parties and no-shows. There are no reports over weeks or months; they are on Magpie's roadmap. OpenTable reports each shift's covers, spend, ratings and no-shows, and compares them with nearby restaurants.

Does Magpie connect to my till?

No. Staff mark a party Arrived, Seated and Finished by hand. A diner's page shows their reservations, not their spend. OpenTable connects to Toast, Square and other tills on Core and Pro.

Can I put Magpie's booking page on my website?

Yes, as a link. Once published, the booking page's full address is shown with Copy and Open. There is no widget to place inside a website yet. OpenTable's widget goes on your own website with a short piece of code.

Can I sell a set menu or a ticketed evening with Magpie?

Partly. A paid Form sells an event for one fixed price paid ahead, through your own Stripe account. It offers no times, does not stop when the event is full, and holds no tables. OpenTable's Experiences are booked like a reservation and paid ahead or at the restaurant.

Does OpenTable have staff scheduling?

No. OpenTable's plans list no staff scheduling, so the rota is made in another product. Magpie's Staff Scheduling plans and publishes the team's shifts in the same account as the book.

Can I run the book from a phone?

Yes, in a phone's browser. Today, the waitlist and the Tables maps fit a phone's screen. You can seat a party, finish a table and add a reservation. The Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. The book needs a connection; OpenTable's iPad app keeps working offline.

Can I use OpenTable and Magpie together?

Yes. OpenTable can take the reservations while Magpie runs the rest. Staff Scheduling has the rota, Inventory the stock and Daily Operations the checklists. Magpie's Store can sell your gift cards and its Forms can take private dining enquiries.

How do I move from OpenTable to Magpie?

Add your services and tables in Restaurant Reservations, or paste in a seating plan written with an assistant. Publish the booking page and link to it where the OpenTable widget was. Restaurant Reservations cannot import reservations or guests from OpenTable, so add upcoming reservations in the book by hand. Keep OpenTable until those reservations have passed.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Restaurant Reservations with one venue: the booking page, the book, the waitlist, the seating plan and the diner list, with no fee per diner. Also Store, Forms, Contacts, a website, the Newsletter and a team of 3. A paid plan has five venues and raises the other limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

OpenTable changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for OpenTable's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Take reservations on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then open Restaurant Reservations and publish your booking page.

Create account