QuickBooks compared with Magpie

QuickBooks vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

QuickBooks and Magpie both keep a small business's books, invoices, expenses and payroll. QuickBooks does more of the accounting for you; Magpie does more of the business around it.

  1. QuickBooks is accounting software from Intuit, with invoicing, expenses and bills, and payroll as an add-on. It is built for a business that wants its bank feeds, receipts and payroll tax handled for it.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Accounting is one part of it. Beside the books it includes Invoicing, Expenses, Payroll, Store, booking pages and a website. It is built for someone whose books are one part of running the business.
Create account
Accounting overview for a fictional studio with transactions to review, bills due, cash by account and this year’s income.

How is Magpie different?

1. The books fill in from the rest of the business

Magpie's other areas add their records to the books by themselves:

  • Invoices and their payments from Invoicing, and proposals' deposits and stages from Proposals
  • Store orders, refunds, gift cards and the cost of what sold
  • Supporter and Form payments, Stripe fees and Stripe payouts
  • Expenses, and the expense reports a team member is paid back for
  • Approved pay runs from Payroll, with no employee's pay shown in the books

QuickBooks has no shop of its own. It brings in sales from Shopify, Amazon and other shops through connected apps.

2. Every plan has the whole of Accounting

Budgets, fixed assets, expense reports, inventory and purchase orders are on every Magpie plan, Free included. The Free plan limits how much, such as 2 bank and card accounts. QuickBooks keeps budgets, inventory and projects for Plus and above. Fixed assets and expense claims need Advanced.

3. Payroll comes in the same subscription

Payroll is in every Magpie plan, not an add-on. A pay run reads hours from Time Tracking or from shifts in Staff Scheduling. It works out overtime and salaries, and each employee reads a payslip in their Magpie account. The Free plan pays up to 2 employees a pay run. QuickBooks Payroll is a separate subscription. It works out, pays and files the taxes, which Magpie does not.

Comparing Magpie and QuickBooks

QuickBooks does more inside the books; Magpie does more around them. Every line below was checked against QuickBooks' own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
Double-entry booksChart of accounts, journal entries, closing a period Yes Yes
Bank feedsBank and card transactions come in by themselves Yes CSV statements
ReconcilingCheck the books against a statement Yes Yes
InvoicingInvoices with reminders and recurring schedules Yes Yes
Invoices paid onlineCustomers pay from the invoice Cards, bank, PayPal, Venmo Cards
Estimates and proposalsAccepted online, with a deposit, then invoiced Yes Yes
Expenses and receiptsEach expense with its category and receipt Yes Yes
Receipt readingA photo of a receipt fills in its details Yes No
MileageTrips logged and valued per mile Yes No
BillsWhat the business owes suppliers, and when Yes Yes
Paying bills by bank transferSuppliers paid from the program Yes No
Reports and budgetsProfit and loss, balance sheet, cash flow, budget against actual Budgets on Plus and above Yes
Classes and locationsTag income and spending by department or place Plus and above No
ForecastsCash and profit projected forward Advanced No
Fixed assetsEquipment depreciated every month Advanced Yes
Inventory and purchase ordersStock, low-stock alerts, orders to suppliers Plus and above Yes
PayrollPay runs from salaries and hours, with payslips Separate subscription Yes
Payroll tax worked out and filedWithholding calculated, paid and reported Yes No
Direct depositEmployees paid from the program Yes No
Contractor payments and 1099sContractors paid, and their forms filed Separate subscription No
Online shopProducts, a cart and checkout Connected apps Yes
Free planKeep books without paying Yes Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Setting up and working together

Both set up the books with a chart of accounts and let an accountant in. QuickBooks has more roles for who sees what, and a phone app on its paid plans.

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
Set up the books with the business's details and a chart of accounts Source Yes Yes
Bring customers, suppliers, products and balances over from another program Source Magpie: A chart of accounts and a trial balance import as CSV files to set the opening balances, and Store products import as CSV. Contacts come in as JSON written with the assistant, and unpaid invoices and bills arrive only as totals in the trial balance, not one by one. Yes Partly
Give my accountant access to the books Source Yes Yes
Give each person only the part of the money they need Source Magpie: Team members use Invoicing and their own Expenses without seeing the books, and only the team's admins and accountants open Accounting. No role reads the books without changing them, or keeps someone to bills alone. Yes Partly
Keep the books from a phone Source Yes Yes

Good to know: An accountant joins a Magpie team as a guest with Accounting and sees nothing else. A free team can have 10 guests, and a paid one 100.

Banking and bookkeeping

Both sort bank transactions with rules, match payments, reconcile and close a period. QuickBooks connects to the bank and learns from your earlier choices. They do it better than we do today.

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
Have bank and card transactions come into the books by themselves Source Magpie: Each statement is downloaded from the bank's website as CSV and imported into its account, and overlapping statements add each transaction once. No bank connects to Magpie directly. Yes Partly
Say what each bank transaction was and add it to the books Source Yes Yes
Set rules that sort repeating transactions Source Yes Yes
Have transactions sorted from how I sorted them before Source Magpie: Suggestions come from rules, from entries already in the books with the same amount, and from open invoices and bills; nothing is learned from earlier choices. Yes Partly
Match a bank payment to an invoice or bill so it is not counted twice Source Yes Yes
Check the books against a bank or card statement Source Yes Yes
Post a journal entry to any account Source Yes Yes
Close a period so its figures cannot change Source Yes Yes
Keep books with customers, suppliers and accounts in other currencies Source Magpie: Invoices, expenses and bills can be in other currencies, but someone types what each was worth in the books' currency, and the difference on payment goes to Exchange gains and losses. Magpie fetches no exchange rates. Yes Partly
Tag income and spending by department or location, and report on each Source Magpie: Accounting reports by account, by customer or supplier, and by Time Tracking project; there are no classes, departments or locations. Yes No

Good to know: In Magpie, a bank statement is imported as a CSV file. Overlapping statements add each transaction once. A transaction matches an entry of the same amount within 10 days.

Invoices and getting paid

Both send invoices with reminders, recurring schedules and online payment. QuickBooks adds bank payments, statements, credit memos and seeing when an invoice was opened.

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
Send an invoice with my logo and details Source Yes Yes
Choose how invoices look: layout, colours, fonts and extra fields Source Magpie: Every invoice uses one layout with the logo, business name, address and tax ID from Settings; colours, fonts and extra fields cannot be chosen. Yes Partly
Let customers pay an invoice online Source Magpie: With Stripe connected, the invoice email has Pay online for a card payment, with Apple Pay and Google Pay where the Stripe account offers them, and Magpie takes no fee beyond Stripe's. There is no bank (ACH) payment, PayPal or Venmo. Yes Partly
Remind customers automatically when an invoice is due or late Source Yes Yes
Invoice the same thing on a schedule Source Yes Yes
Have a client's recurring invoices charged automatically Source Magpie: A schedule started from an accepted proposal charges the client's saved card for each invoice; one made with Make recurring cannot, so its invoices are paid from their emails. Yes Partly
See when a customer has opened an invoice Source Magpie: An invoice's Activity shows each email and whether the email service accepted it, then the payments; it does not record the customer opening it. Proposals do show each time they are opened. Yes No
Send an estimate the customer accepts online, then invoice it Source QuickBooks: An estimate with a deposit is emailed, and the customer can accept it and pay the deposit in an online portal that the page says has limited availability. An accepted estimate converts to an invoice. QuickBooks Free sends 1 estimate a month, and the page's questions list accepting digital signatures without saying how. Partly Yes
Take a deposit, then bill a job in stages Source Yes Yes
Put employees' billable time on a customer's invoice Source Magpie: Add unbilled time lists only the admin's own billable Time Tracking entries for the contact; a teammate's time has to be typed in. Yes Partly
Bill a customer for an expense Source Magpie: Add unbilled expenses lists only your own expenses marked reimbursable for the contact, so a purchase on the business card, or a teammate's, can only be typed onto the invoice. Yes Partly
Charge the right sales tax on each invoice Source Magpie: Invoices use the tax rates the team sets, including two taxes combined or compounded; Magpie does not work out a rate from the customer's location. Store can calculate its tax with Stripe Tax. Yes Partly
Send customers a statement of what they owe Source Magpie: Invoices shared to a client's Client Portal are listed there, and the Accounts receivable report shows what each customer owes; there is no statement to send. Yes No
Give a customer a credit that comes off a later invoice Source Magpie: Record refund notes money given back on an invoice, and Void invoice cancels an unpaid one; no credit carries over to a later invoice. Store gives store credit on its own orders. Yes Partly

Good to know: Customers pay a Magpie invoice by card through your own Stripe account. Magpie takes no fee on invoice payments; Stripe's fees apply.

Expenses and bills (QuickBooks Expenses)

Both record expenses with receipts, repeat them and keep bills. QuickBooks reads receipts, takes them by email, logs mileage and pays bills. They do it better than we do today.

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
Photograph a receipt and have its details filled in Source Magpie: A receipt photo or file is kept with its expense or waits in Receipt Inbox, but its amount, date and merchant are typed in; nothing is read from it. Yes Partly
Forward receipts and bills by email Source Magpie: Receipts are uploaded, dropped or pasted on Expenses, and on a phone the file chooser offers the camera; there is no address to forward them to. The Magpie app, not yet in the App Store or Google Play, also takes receipts shared from another app, such as a mail app. Yes No
Record an expense with its category and receipt Source Yes Yes
Track business miles and what they are worth Source Magpie: Expenses records amounts spent; there is no trip log or rate per mile, so a mileage claim is typed in as an expense. Yes No
Record a repeating expense such as rent or a subscription Source Yes Yes
Have employees claim expenses for approval and be paid back Source QuickBooks: Only on Advanced, employees upload and submit receipts as expense claims, which are reviewed and recorded against matching transactions; the page does not say how employees are paid back. Partly Yes
Record bills and see what is owed and when Source Yes Yes
Pay a supplier's bill by bank transfer from the program Source Magpie: Record payment notes a payment made from the bank's own website, and the bank transaction is matched to it; Magpie sends no money. Yes No
Have bills approved before they are paid Source Magpie: Any admin or accountant enters and pays a bill; only expense reports are approved. Yes No
Prepare and file 1099 forms for contractors Source Magpie: Payments to contractors are recorded as bills or expenses, and Spending by supplier totals them; no tax form is prepared. Yes No

Good to know: Any member of a Magpie team can put expenses on an expense report. An admin approves it and marks it paid back. Until then, Accounting holds it as owed.

Reports, planning and tax

Both give profit and loss, the balance sheet, cash flow, sales tax and budgets. QuickBooks adds custom reports and forecasts on Advanced.

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
See profit and loss, the balance sheet and cash flow Source Yes Yes
See who owes the business, whom it owes, and how late Source Yes Yes
Know how much sales tax to pay, and record the return Source Yes Yes
Set a budget and compare it with what happened Source Yes Yes
Build my own reports and dashboards Source Magpie: Each report takes dates, a basis and a comparison and exports as PDF or CSV, but its rows and columns are fixed and nothing can be saved as a new report. Yes Partly
See a forecast of cash and profit for the months ahead Source Magpie: Reports and the overview show what has happened, and Budgets hold a plan; nothing projects cash forward. Yes No
Ask questions about the business's money in plain words Source Yes Yes
Depreciate equipment every month Source QuickBooks: Fixed assets are on Advanced only: each asset gets a schedule and its depreciation is posted monthly, by straight line or a declining balance. Disposal works out the gain or loss, but its entries are posted by hand. Partly Yes

Good to know: Each Magpie report exports as PDF or CSV, on the accrual or cash basis. On Dashboard, the assistant answers questions about the books for the team's admins and accountants.

Inventory, projects and selling

Both track stock and send purchase orders. Magpie also sells online through Store, and every sale, fee and payout goes into the books.

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
See the profit on each project, counting labour Source Magpie: Profit by project shares invoice income and expense and bill costs across Time Tracking projects, but time worked is not counted as a cost. Yes Partly
Track stock, be told when it runs low, and count what it cost Source Yes Yes
Order from suppliers and turn the order into a bill Source Yes Yes
Sell online and have every sale, fee and payout in the books Source QuickBooks: Orders and refunds come in from Shopify, Amazon and other shops through connected apps; QuickBooks has no shop of its own. Partly Yes

Good to know: When Store sells an item, its cost moves to Cost of goods sold in Accounting. A delivery from a purchase order is received into stock at cost, with its bill.

Payroll (QuickBooks Payroll)

Both pay employees on a schedule from salaries and hours, with payslips. QuickBooks works out, pays and files payroll tax, and pays by direct deposit. They do it better than we do today.

WhatQuickBooksMagpie
Pay employees on a schedule and give each a pay stub Source Yes Yes
Have each paycheck's taxes worked out for me Source Magpie: Payroll takes the tax to withhold as a standing line on each employee, a percentage of gross pay or a fixed amount, entered as the accountant or tax authority gives it. Yes No
Have payroll taxes paid and payroll forms filed for me Source Magpie: Payroll's Summary totals what was withheld for a month, a quarter or a tax year, to pay and report by hand. It files nothing and pays no tax authority. Yes No
Pay employees by direct deposit Source Magpie: The team pays employees from its own bank, then marks the pay run paid, which releases the payslips. Magpie moves no money. Yes No
Pay hourly staff from the hours they tracked Source Yes Yes
Keep each employee's paid time off balance Source Yes Yes
Pay contractors, with their tax and bank details collected online Source Magpie: A contractor is paid at the bank and recorded as a bill or an expense; Payroll pays employees only. Yes No
Offer health cover, a retirement plan and workers' comp through payroll Source Magpie: A pension deduction and the team's contribution are standing lines in Payroll, entered by hand. Magpie arranges no benefits. Yes No

Good to know: In Magpie, the tax to withhold is a standing line your accountant gives you. Summary totals what was withheld for a month, a quarter or a tax year.

Price comparison

How QuickBooks charges

QuickBooks charges by plan: Free, Simple Start, Essentials, Plus and Advanced, billed monthly. The plan sets how many users there are and what the books can do. Plus and above add budgets, classes, inventory and projects. Payroll and Contractor Payments are separate subscriptions. QuickBooks Payments takes 2.99% of card payments and 1% of bank payments. Prices are on QuickBooks' pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan too, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The plan sets how much you can do, not which areas you can use. Magpie takes no fee on invoice payments, and 4% of Store sales. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planQuickBooksMagpie
PayrollA separate subscriptionIncluded: 2 employees a pay run on Free, everyone on a paid plan
Payroll tax worked out and filedIncluded with PayrollNot available
Paying contractorsContractor Payments, a separate subscriptionRecorded as bills or expenses
Fee on card payments of invoices2.99% through QuickBooks Payments, and 1.75% more for an instant depositNo Magpie fee; Stripe's fees apply
Fee on bank payments of invoices1% through QuickBooks PaymentsBank payments not offered
Invoices2 a month on Free, or no limit with QuickBooks Payments; no limit on paid plans5 a month on Free; no limit on paid plans
Bank and card accountsOne on Free2 on Free; no limit on paid plans
Budgets, inventory and projectsPlus and aboveEvery plan
Fixed assets and expense claimsAdvancedEvery plan
Accountant accessTwo accountant users on paid plans, three on AdvancedAs guests: 10 on Free, 100 on a paid plan
An online shopThrough connected appsStore, for 4% of each sale

When to choose Magpie or QuickBooks

  • Want your books filled in by your invoices, shop, expenses and pay runs, with payroll included? Go with Magpie.
  • Want your bank connected, receipts read for you, and payroll taxes worked out, paid and filed? QuickBooks is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a US business with employees
QuickBooks. QuickBooks Payroll works out federal and state payroll tax, pays it and files the forms. It pays by direct deposit. Magpie's Payroll takes the tax you enter and leaves paying and filing to you.
For a business with many bank and card accounts
QuickBooks. Bank feeds bring every transaction in by themselves, and Auto-categorize sorts familiar ones. In Magpie, each statement is downloaded and imported as a CSV file.
For someone who drives for work
QuickBooks. The phone app logs drives by GPS and reads receipts from a photo. Magpie has no mileage log, and a receipt's details are typed in.
For a shop selling online
Magpie. Store's orders, refunds, fees, payouts and costs go into the books by themselves. QuickBooks has no shop and brings in sales through connected apps.
For a consultant or a freelancer
Magpie. A proposal is accepted and signed online, then its deposit and stages become invoices. Time Tracking, Expenses and booking pages are in the same account.
For a small team with hourly staff
Either. Magpie's Payroll, in every plan, pays from shifts in Staff Scheduling and works out overtime. QuickBooks works out and files the payroll tax. Choose by whether you want the tax done for you, or the rota and pay together.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between QuickBooks and Magpie?

QuickBooks is accounting software with invoicing, expenses, bills and payroll as an add-on. It connects to the bank, reads receipts and files payroll tax. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Accounting is one area beside Invoicing, Expenses, Payroll and Store. QuickBooks does more inside the books; Magpie does more around them.

Does Magpie replace QuickBooks?

Yes, for a small business whose books are mostly its own invoices, sales and expenses. Magpie adds them to the books by themselves. It reconciles, closes periods and gives the standard reports.

Consider keeping QuickBooks if you want your bank connected, receipts read from a photo, or mileage logged. Keep it too for payroll tax worked out and filed, direct deposit, or bills paid by transfer. QuickBooks does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does QuickBooks cost?

QuickBooks has Free, Simple Start, Essentials, Plus and Advanced plans, billed monthly. Payroll and Contractor Payments are separate subscriptions. QuickBooks Payments takes 2.99% of card payments and 1% of bank payments on invoices. The prices are on QuickBooks' pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area, Accounting and Payroll included. Free includes 5 invoices a month and 2 bank and card accounts. Its pay runs pay up to 2 employees. A paid plan removes those limits, and the Team plan has 25 people. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie connect to my bank?

No. You download each statement from your bank as a CSV file and import it. Overlapping statements add each transaction once, and rules can add matching ones by themselves. Bank feeds are on Magpie's roadmap. QuickBooks connects to banks and cards and downloads their transactions.

Does Magpie read receipts?

No. A receipt is kept with its expense or waits in Receipt Inbox. Its amount, date and merchant are typed in. Reading receipts is on Magpie's roadmap. QuickBooks reads a photographed or uploaded receipt and offers matching transactions.

Does Magpie calculate payroll taxes?

No. In Magpie's Payroll, the tax to withhold is a standing line on each employee. It is a percentage of gross pay or a fixed amount, as your accountant gives it. Summary totals what was withheld, to pay and report yourself. QuickBooks Payroll works out federal and state tax, pays it and files the forms.

Does Magpie pay employees by direct deposit?

No. You pay employees from your own bank, then mark the pay run paid. That releases each payslip. Magpie moves no money. QuickBooks Payroll pays by direct deposit, next-day or same-day depending on the plan.

Does Magpie track mileage?

No. A mileage claim is entered as an ordinary expense amount, with no trip log or rate per mile. Mileage is on Magpie's roadmap. The QuickBooks phone app records drives by GPS and totals the deduction.

Can I pay bills from Magpie?

No. Bills lists what you owe and when. Record payment notes a payment made from your bank's website. The bank transaction then matches the bill. QuickBooks sends bill payments to suppliers by bank transfer.

Does Magpie prepare 1099 forms?

No. Payments to contractors are recorded as bills or expenses, and Spending by supplier totals them. QuickBooks finds the contractors to report, e-files 1099-NEC and 1099-MISC forms and emails each contractor a copy.

Does Magpie have classes or locations?

No. Accounting reports by account, by customer or supplier, and by Time Tracking project. QuickBooks tags income and spending by class and location on Plus and above, and reports on each.

Can customers pay a Magpie invoice by bank transfer?

Not online. Pay online takes a card, with Apple Pay and Google Pay where your Stripe account offers them. A bank transfer is recorded as a payment by hand. QuickBooks Payments takes bank payments, PayPal and Venmo too.

Does QuickBooks have an online shop?

No. QuickBooks brings in orders and refunds from Shopify, Amazon and other shops through connected apps. Magpie's Store sells online, and its orders, refunds, fees and payouts go into Accounting by themselves.

Does Magpie have estimates?

Yes, as proposals. A proposal opens in the client's Magpie account, where they choose a package, sign and accept it. Its deposit and each later stage become invoices. Magpie's Free plan sends 5 proposals a month.

Can my accountant work in Magpie?

Yes. Invite them as a guest of the team with Accounting. They keep the books and see nothing else. Accountants can keep Personal books too. QuickBooks' paid plans include two accountant users, and Advanced three.

Does Magpie work out sales tax?

Partly. Invoices use the tax rates you set, including two taxes combined or compounded. The Sales tax report totals what to pay. Magpie does not work out a rate from the customer's location, except in Store with Stripe Tax. QuickBooks works out each invoice's rate from the location and the product.

Does Magpie handle other currencies?

Partly. Invoices, expenses and bills can be in other currencies. You type what each was worth in the books' currency. The difference on payment goes to Exchange gains and losses. QuickBooks fills in exchange rates by itself on Essentials and above.

Can I keep the books on my phone?

Yes, in a phone's browser: review bank transactions, enter bills, read reports, photograph a receipt and send invoices. The Magpie app has them too, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. QuickBooks has a phone app on its paid plans.

Can I use QuickBooks and Magpie together?

Yes, but they do not connect. You could invoice and sell in Magpie, and enter the totals in QuickBooks. Accounting's reports and journal lines export as CSV for your accountant.

How do I move from QuickBooks to Magpie?

Export the chart of accounts and the trial balance from QuickBooks as CSV files. Import the chart into Accounting, then the trial balance as your opening balances. Unpaid invoices and bills arrive as totals, not one by one. Keep QuickBooks until you no longer need its history.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Free includes Accounting with 2 bank and card accounts, and Invoicing with 5 invoices a month. Expenses is included, and Payroll pays up to 2 employees a pay run. Store, booking pages, a website, Proposals and a team of 3 are included too. A paid plan raises the limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

QuickBooks changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Intuit's own team as much as for anyone who uses QuickBooks.

Keep your books beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then set up Accounting.

Create account