Slack compared with Magpie

Slack vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Slack and Magpie both give a team channels, direct messages and calls. Slack is built around the conversation; Magpie puts the conversation beside the rest of the business.

  1. Slack is a messaging platform for work, with channels, direct messages, huddles, lists and workflows. More than 2,600 apps bring other software's updates into its channels. It is built for a company whose work happens in conversation, from 10 people to 10,000.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Team chat is one part of it. Beside the channels it includes Walkie Talkie, Video Chat, To-dos, Documents, booking pages, invoicing and email at your domain. It is built for a small team whose chat is one part of running the business.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s team chat open at the Albers Coffee channel, with the morning’s messages about launching the client’s website and the team’s other channels and direct messages.

How is Magpie different?

1. Chat comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Team chat for channels, direct messages and groups, and Walkie Talkie for talking by voice
  • Video Chat for calls, and Documents with a conversation beside each one
  • To-dos and Kanban Boards for the work the team talks about
  • Mail for email at your domain, and Helpdesk for customer email
  • Meetings, Appointments, Invoicing, Store, Websites and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Slack brings other software into its channels through apps.

2. A team pays one price

The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, with every area included. A guest let into one channel takes no place on the plan. Slack's paid plans are priced per person.

3. Push-to-talk is in the same account

Walkie Talkie's Talk button speaks live to everyone listening in a conversation, group or channel. Each message is kept, so people who were not listening play it later. Transcripts are made where they are turned on.

Comparing Magpie and Slack

Slack does more inside the conversation; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Slack's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatSlackMagpie
ChannelsConversations for each topic or project Yes Yes
Private channelsA channel only its people can read Yes Partly
Direct messages and groupsTalk with one person or a few Yes Yes
Threads and reactionsReply to one message, or react with an emoji Yes Eight reactions
Formatting, links and mentionsBold and lists, links that open, @ a name Yes Partly
SearchFind any message or file Yes Messages, not files
Calls from a conversationStart a call with the people in a channel Huddles Video Chat, separate
Calls with several peopleA group on audio or video Paid plans Scheduled calls only
Screen sharingShow your screen during a call Yes Yes
Voice and video messagesRecord instead of typing Clips Walkie Talkie voice
Push-to-talkSpeak live to whoever is listening No Yes
Documents beside a conversationWrite together and talk about it Canvases Yes
Task listsItems with an owner and a due date Lists, paid plans To-dos and Kanban Boards
WorkflowsRoutine steps that run by themselves Paid plans No
Apps that post into channelsOther software's updates in the conversation Yes API and the assistant
AI summaries and answersCatch up on a channel, find what was said Pro and above The assistant
Working with other companiesShared channels and guests Slack Connect, paid plans Guests, one at a time
Phone and desktop appsChat with notifications on every device Yes In the browser
Single sign-on and audit logsCompany sign-in and a record of who did what Business+ and Enterprise+ Audit log of team changes
Email at your domainMailboxes and aliases at the business's domain No Paid plans
Booking pages and invoicingClients book a time and pay invoices online No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Channels and direct messages

Both hold a team's talk in channels and direct messages, and both archive a finished channel. Slack adds private channels, posting permissions, pins and sidebar sections of your own.

WhatSlackMagpie
Talk with my team in channels for each topic or project Source Yes Yes
Keep a channel private to the people in it Source Magpie: Every Team chat channel is read by the whole team. A channel opened to guests becomes members only, but anyone in the team can still join it from the channel list. A group of three or more people is private to them, and a Walkie Talkie channel can be closed to the team. Yes Partly
Message one person, or a few people, privately Source Yes Yes
Make a channel where only some people can post, such as announcements Source Magpie: Everyone who can read a Team chat channel can post in it. Walkie Talkie has Announcements channels, where only the people chosen speak and everyone else listens. Yes Partly
Archive a finished channel and bring it back later Source Yes Yes
Sort my channels and conversations into sections of my own Source Magpie: Chat lists conversations in fixed groups: Invitations, Support, Channels, Shared with you, Requests, Direct messages and Discussions. Yes No
Pin important messages and links to a channel Source Magpie: Team chat has no pinned messages and no saved links in a channel. In Walkie Talkie, Pinned keeps a conversation at the top of your own list. Yes No
Write a document with my team and talk about it beside it Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A Magpie direct message belongs to its people, not to a team. It is listed whichever team is selected. A free team has 5 active channels, and a paid one 100.

Writing messages

Both have threads, reactions, mentions, bold and code, and links that open, and both edit a sent message. Slack also formats lists and quotes, shows a link's preview, mentions a group and schedules a message. They do each of these better than we do today.

WhatSlackMagpie
Reply to one message in a thread, without filling up the channel Source Yes Yes
React to a message with an emoji Source Magpie: A message takes reactions from a set of eight emoji, such as 👍, ❤️ and 🎉, and a double tap on a phone adds 👍. You cannot react to your own message or add emoji of your own. Yes Partly
Format a message with bold, lists, quotes and code Source Magpie: Team chat shows bold, italic, code and blocks of code typed as in Markdown, on the website and in the app. Lists and quotes stay plain text, and there is no formatting toolbar. Yes Partly
Open a link someone posts, and see a preview of the page Source Magpie: A web address in a Team chat message opens with one click, on the website and in the app. No preview of the page is shown. Yes Partly
Mention someone, or a whole group, so they are told Source Magpie: An @handle mentions one person who can read the conversation. On the website they get the dot on their avatar and the message sound; the Magpie app sends them a notification. A group of people or a whole channel cannot be mentioned at once. Yes Partly
Edit or delete a message I sent Source Yes Yes
Share files and pictures in a conversation Source Magpie: On the website a message carries up to 10 pictures and no other files, and nothing lists the files shared in Chat. The Magpie app, which is not yet in the App Store or Google Play, also attaches PDF, Office, text or archive files of up to 25 MB each. Yes Partly
Write a message now and have it sent later Source Magpie: Team chat sends a message as soon as it is written. Yes No
See whether someone has read my message Source Slack: No Slack feature page or help article checked describes seeing whether a message has been read; the dot beside a name shows only whether the person is active or away. Not stated Yes

Good to know: In a Magpie direct message or group, Seen appears under your newest message once the others have opened it. Either person can turn read receipts off.

Search, history and saved messages

Both search messages by their words. Slack also searches files, with filters, and sets reminders on a message.

WhatSlackMagpie
Search every message and file Source Magpie: Search messages, in Chat on the website and in the app, finds messages by their words in the team's channels and your own conversations. Files are not searched, and the Search page does not cover chat. Yes Partly
Keep and read the whole message history Source Yes Yes
Save a message to come back to, or be reminded about it Source Magpie: Team chat has no saved messages and no reminder on a message; Copy text puts a message's words on the clipboard. Walkie Talkie has Save message, which keeps a message under Saved. Yes Partly

Good to know: Team chat's search covers the team's channels and your own conversations, on the website and in the app. On the free plan each channel shows its 2,000 most recent messages; older ones are hidden, not deleted.

Notifications, status and blocking

Slack chooses which conversations notify you, pauses notifications out of hours and shows a status. Magpie's choices are fewer: a sound for direct messages and mentions, browser notifications for direct messages, and muting one person.

WhatSlackMagpie
Choose which conversations notify me, such as only when I am mentioned Source Magpie: On the website, direct messages, groups, support and mentions play a sound and mark the browser tab, and direct messages and groups can show a browser notification; each can be switched off in Account settings. A team channel without a mention only marks the channel unread in Chat. You can mute one person, but one conversation cannot be chosen on its own. The Magpie app, which is not yet in the App Store or Google Play, notifies your phone of every message in the channels you read. Yes Partly
Pause notifications outside my working hours Source Magpie: Chat has no notification schedule and no do-not-disturb; muting one person, or the phone's own settings, are the ways to quiet it. Yes No
Show a status, such as in a meeting or on holiday, and whether I am around Source Magpie: Walkie Talkie shows On Walkie Talkie now beside someone who has it open, to people on the same team. Team chat on the website shows nobody's presence, and there is no status message. The Magpie app, which is not yet in the App Store or Google Play, shows who has a conversation open as Active now. Yes Partly
Block someone so I no longer see their messages and they cannot contact me Source Slack: A person can block someone from sending them Slack Connect invitations. The help describes no way to block someone in your own workspace. Partly Yes

Good to know: Block in Magpie hides a person's messages everywhere in Chat and stops them contacting you. They are not told.

Huddles and clips

Slack starts a huddle from any conversation, for up to 50 people on a paid plan. Huddles share a screen, and clips record a message. Magpie's calls are in Video Chat, and its voice messages in Walkie Talkie.

WhatSlackMagpie
Start a call with the people in a conversation, right from it Source Magpie: Video Chat is its own area and is not started from a conversation: one person starts a call and sends its code or link. A call is for two people and lasts 2 or 5 minutes on the free plan, or 2, 5 or 10 on Pro and the Team plan. In Walkie Talkie, people talk live in a conversation by pressing Talk. Yes Partly
Have a call with several people at once Source Magpie: A Video Chat call is for two people. A scheduled call takes up to 6 people, but only Hiring interviews, Courses live sessions and Coaching sessions create one, on Pro and Team plans. Yes Partly
Share my screen during a call, and draw on it Source Magpie: In a Video Chat call in a computer's browser, Share screen shows everyone in the call a screen, a window or a tab in place of the camera. Nobody can draw on the shared screen, and a phone's browser and the Magpie app cannot share one. Yes Partly
Have notes written for me from a call Source Magpie: Video Chat calls are not recorded, and nothing is written from them. Yes No
Send a short voice or video message instead of typing Source Magpie: Walkie Talkie sends voice messages, live or recorded, with transcripts where they are turned on. A Team chat message on the website carries no voice or video; a video is made in Screen Recorder and its link pasted into Chat. The Magpie app, which is not yet in the App Store or Google Play, adds voice notes of up to 2 minutes to Team chat. Yes Partly
Talk to my team push-to-talk, heard live by whoever is listening Source Slack: A huddle is a call that people choose to join, and an audio clip is recorded before it is sent; neither plays a message to listeners as it is spoken. No Yes

Good to know: A Video Chat call is for two people. It lasts 2 or 5 minutes on the free plan, or 2, 5 or 10 on a paid plan. Walkie Talkie speaks live to everyone listening, which Slack does not.

Slack Connect, guests and team size

Slack Connect shares a channel with other companies, each managing its own people. Magpie lets people from outside the team into a channel one at a time, as guests.

WhatSlackMagpie
Work in a shared channel with another company Source Magpie: A team admin lets people from outside the team into one channel, one at a time, as guests of the team, by handle or with an invite link. The other company does not bring its own team or manage its own people there. Yes Partly
Message someone at another company directly Source Yes Yes
Let a client or freelancer into one channel only Source Yes Yes
Have everyone in the company in one place, however many people that is Source Magpie: A team has places for 3 members on the free plan and 25 on the Team plan. Guests take no place. Yes Partly

Good to know: A guest takes no place on the plan. A team has up to 10 guests on the free plan and 100 on a paid plan.

Lists

Slack's lists track items with owners and due dates inside a channel. Magpie's To-dos and Kanban Boards are areas of their own in the same team.

WhatSlackMagpie
Track tasks with an owner and a due date Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A To-do in a team has an assignee, a deadline and reminders. A Kanban board moves cards through columns.

Apps and workflows

Slack connects to more than 2,600 apps and runs workflows from Workflow Builder. Magpie has no app directory and nothing in Chat that runs by itself.

WhatSlackMagpie
Have my other tools post updates into a chat channel Source Magpie: Team chat has no app directory, bots or incoming webhooks. A script with a Pro API key can post a message through the REST API, as the person who made the key, and a connected app such as Claude, or the assistant on Dashboard, can post in a channel you name. Meetings can send its notices to a Slack channel. Yes Partly
Automate routine steps, such as welcoming new people or collecting requests with a form Source Magpie: Nothing in Chat runs by itself. Forms collects requests, and the assistant does one task at a time when asked. Automations, which can post a message in a channel, is not open to members yet. Yes No

Good to know: A script with a Pro API key can post a Team chat message. So can a connected app such as Claude. Meetings can send its notices to a Slack channel.

Slack AI and Slackbot

Slack AI sums up channels and threads, translates messages and answers questions in search, on paid plans. Magpie's assistant reads chat beside the other areas.

WhatSlackMagpie
Get a summary of a channel or thread I missed Source Magpie: Chat has no summary of its own. The assistant on Dashboard reads recent chat messages, up to 100 at a time from all your channels and conversations together, or those with given words, and sums them up when asked; it cannot ask for just one channel or thread, so earlier messages in a busy channel can be missed. Yes Partly
Read messages in my own language Source Magpie: Messages are shown as they were written. Yes No
Ask an AI assistant to find something in our conversations and work Source Yes Yes
Search our other tools from the same search box Source Magpie: Search covers Magpie's own areas in Personal and every team, but no tool outside Magpie. Yes Partly

Good to know: The assistant on Dashboard searches your channels and conversations, counts unread messages and posts in a channel you name. It works in Magpie's other areas too.

Apps for each device, security and admin

Slack has apps for phones and computers, single sign-on, directory sync, exports, retention rules and audit logs. Magpie's Team chat is used in the browser, with fewer controls for an admin.

WhatSlackMagpie
Chat from my phone, with notifications Source Magpie: Team chat works in a phone's browser, but the website sends a phone no notifications; browser notifications reach a computer only. The Magpie app for iPhone and Android has Team chat with push notifications, photos, files and voice notes, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Use it as an app on my computer Source Magpie: Magpie runs in the browser on a computer; there is no Mac or Windows app. Yes No
Sign in through our company identity provider Source Magpie: People sign in with a password, a passkey, an emailed link or code, or Google, Apple, LinkedIn or GitHub. There is no SAML single sign-on. Yes Partly
Add and remove people automatically from our company directory Source Magpie: Team admins invite and remove people on the team's Members page. Yes No
Download all our messages Source Magpie: Team chat has no export; messages are read in Chat or found through the assistant. Yes No
Delete old messages automatically after a set time Source Magpie: Team chat keeps every message until someone deletes it. A Walkie Talkie conversation can be set to delete its messages after a time. Yes Partly
See a log of who in our team did what Source Magpie: A team's admins open its audit log: who changed its members, invitations, guests, API keys, Stripe account and owner, when, and from which IP address. Each change is kept 12 months, and the log downloads as CSV. Messages, files and other work inside the areas are not in it. Yes Partly
Choose the country where our data is kept Source Magpie: Magpie offers no choice of where data is kept; its privacy policy says data may be processed in other countries. Yes No
Keep health information in chat under a HIPAA agreement Source Magpie: Magpie's privacy and security pages offer no business associate agreement. Yes No

Good to know: The Magpie app has Team chat with push notifications, files and voice notes. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play.

Price comparison

How Slack charges

Slack charges by plan: Free, Pro, Business+ and Enterprise+, priced per person and billed monthly or yearly. Free shows 90 days of messages, connects 10 apps and holds huddles for two. Pro adds unlimited history, group huddles, guests, Slack Connect and AI summaries. Business+ adds single sign-on, translation and data residency. Prices are on Slack's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. Team chat is on every plan; a paid plan raises the channels, the history and the people. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per person. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planSlackMagpie
How a team paysPer person, per monthOne Team plan for up to 25 people
History on the free plan90 days of messages and filesThe 2,000 most recent messages in each channel
GuestsPaid plans; five single-channel guests free for each paid member10 on Free, 100 on a paid plan, taking no place
Group callsPaid plans, up to 50 peopleTwo people; scheduled calls of up to 6 from Hiring, Courses and Coaching on paid plans
AISummaries on Pro; translation and Slackbot on Business+The assistant, included
Single sign-onBusiness+ and Enterprise+Not available
Email, booking pages and invoicingNot offeredIncluded; Mail needs a paid plan

When to choose Magpie or Slack

  • Want team chat beside your bookings, invoices, email and To-dos, for one price for the whole team? Go with Magpie.
  • Want huddles from any channel, workflows, group mentions and thousands of apps, for a company of any size? Slack is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a company of more than 25 people
Slack. Slack holds a company from 10 people to 10,000. A Magpie team has places for 25 members.
For a team that runs on other software
Slack. Slack's apps bring other software's updates into a channel, and Workflow Builder runs the routine steps. Magpie has no app directory or workflows.
For a small service business
Magpie. Team chat, booking pages, invoices, email at your domain and a helpdesk are in one team. The Team plan covers up to 25 people for one price.
For a crew on the move: a café, a trade, a shop floor
Magpie. Walkie Talkie speaks live to the people listening and keeps each message to play later. Staff Scheduling and Daily Operations are in the same team.
For a team that works with clients in chat
Either. Slack Connect shares a channel with a client's whole company on a paid plan. Magpie lets clients into one channel as guests, who take no place on the plan. Choose by whether the client brings a team of their own.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Slack and Magpie?

Slack is a messaging platform for work, with huddles, lists, workflows and more than 2,600 apps. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Team chat is one area beside Walkie Talkie, Video Chat, To-dos, Mail, Invoicing and booking pages. Slack does more inside the conversation; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Slack?

Yes, for a small team that wants channels and direct messages beside the rest of its work. Magpie has channels, threads, reactions, guests and read receipts, and the same team holds the bookings, invoices and email.

Consider keeping Slack if you mention groups of people or start group calls from a channel. Keep it too if you run workflows or rely on apps posting into channels. Slack does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Slack cost?

Slack has four plans: Free, Pro, Business+ and Enterprise+, priced per person. Free shows 90 days of messages and connects 10 apps. Pro adds unlimited history, group huddles and guests; Business+ adds single sign-on and translation. The prices are on Slack's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. A free team has 3 members and 5 channels. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, with 100 channels and every message kept. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have @mentions?

Partly. An @handle mentions one person who can read the conversation. On the website they get the dot on their avatar and a sound; the Magpie app sends a notification. A group of people or a whole channel cannot be mentioned at once. In Slack, @ and a name notifies that person, and @channel or a user group notifies many.

Can I format messages or post links in Magpie's Team chat?

Yes. Bold, italic, code and blocks of code typed as in Markdown show formatted, and a web address opens with one click. Lists and quotes stay plain text, and a link shows no preview. Slack formats bold, lists, quotes and code, and shows a preview under a link.

Can I edit a message I sent in Magpie?

Yes. Edit message, in your message's menu, changes its words, and the message shows Edited. Its author can delete it too, and a team admin can delete any message in the team's channels. Slack edits and deletes sent messages too.

Can I search Team chat?

Yes, for messages. Search messages, at the top of Chat on the website and in the app, finds messages by their words in the team's channels and your own conversations. Files are not searched, and the Search page does not cover chat. Slack searches every message and file, with filters such as from: and in:.

Does Magpie have huddles?

No. A call is not started from a conversation. Video Chat starts a call for two people, and you send its code or link; it lasts 2, 5 or 10 minutes on a paid plan. Walkie Talkie lets people talk live in a conversation by pressing Talk. Slack's huddles start from any channel, for up to 50 people on a paid plan.

Can I share my screen in a Magpie call?

Yes, from a browser on a computer. Share screen shows everyone in the call a screen, a window or a tab in place of your camera. Nobody can draw on it. Slack's huddles share a screen, and people can draw on it.

Does Magpie have workflows like Slack's Workflow Builder?

No. Nothing in Team chat runs by itself. Forms collects requests, and the assistant does one task at a time when asked. Automations, which can post a message in a channel, is not open to members yet. Slack's Workflow Builder runs steps from a link, on a schedule or when someone joins a channel.

Can my other software post into Magpie's Team chat?

Partly. Team chat has no app directory, bots or incoming webhooks. A script with a Pro API key can post a message through the API. A connected app such as Claude can post in a channel you name. Slack connects to more than 2,600 apps.

Does Slack have push-to-talk?

No. A Slack huddle is a call people choose to join, and a clip is recorded before it is sent. Magpie's Walkie Talkie speaks live to everyone listening and keeps each message to play later.

Does Slack have booking pages, invoicing or email?

No. Slack is for conversations, and its apps connect it to other software for the rest. Magpie includes Meetings, Appointments, Invoicing and Mail in the same team as Team chat. Mail needs a paid plan.

Does Magpie have a phone or desktop app?

Not yet. Team chat works in a phone's browser, but the website sends a phone no notifications. The Magpie app has Team chat with push notifications. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. There is no Mac or Windows app. Slack has apps for iPhone, Android, Mac, Windows and Linux.

Can I chat with people at another company?

Yes, one at a time. A team admin lets someone into a channel as a guest, by handle or with an invite link. Anyone with a Magpie account can be sent a direct message. Slack Connect shares a whole channel with another company on a paid plan, and that company manages its own people.

Does Magpie have private channels?

Partly. Every Team chat channel is read by the whole team. A group of three or more people is private to them. A channel opened to guests becomes members only, but anyone in the team can still join it. Slack's private channels are read only by the people in them.

How long does Magpie keep messages?

Every message is kept until someone deletes it. On the free plan each channel shows its 2,000 most recent messages; older ones are hidden, not deleted, and show again on a paid plan. Slack's Free plan shows 90 days and deletes messages after a year.

Does Magpie have single sign-on?

No. People sign in with a password, a passkey, an emailed link or code, or Google, Apple, LinkedIn or GitHub. SAML single sign-on is on Magpie's roadmap. Slack has it on Business+ and Enterprise+.

Can I use Slack and Magpie together?

Yes. Meetings can post each new, confirmed, cancelled or moved booking to a Slack channel or a direct message. A team can keep Slack for chat and use Magpie for bookings, invoices, email and the rest.

How do I move from Slack to Magpie?

Create a team, invite your people, and add a channel for each one you use. Magpie does not read Slack's export, so your messages stay in Slack; keep it until you no longer need them.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

A team of 3, with Team chat in 5 channels. It also includes Walkie Talkie, Video Chat, To-dos, booking pages, Invoicing, Store, a website and the Newsletter. Mail is not on the Free plan: email at your domain needs Pro or the Team plan.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Slack changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Slack's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Put your team's chat beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then make a team and invite the people in it.

Create account