Deputy compared with Magpie

Deputy vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Deputy and Magpie both plan shifts for a business's staff and publish the schedule to them. They are built around different things.

  1. Deputy is a workforce service for shift-based businesses: scheduling, time clocks, timesheets and labour law compliance, with HR and payroll add-ons. It is built for businesses that run on shifts, at one location or many.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Staff Scheduling is one part of it. Beside the rota it includes staff files, payroll, time tracking, hiring, daily checklists, reservations and the books. It is built for someone whose rota is one part of running the business.
Create account
Staff Scheduling week for a fictional café: open shifts on the top row, each person’s shifts by day with their position, time off and availability markers, one draft shift with a warning, and weekly hours.

How is Magpie different?

1. The rota comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Staff Scheduling for the rota, open shifts, swaps, availability and time off
  • Staff for each person's file, documents, leave balances and policies
  • Payroll for pay runs from worked shifts, with overtime and payslips
  • Time Tracking for the hours worked, and Hiring for jobs and candidates
  • Daily Operations for opening and closing checklists and the shift logbook
  • Restaurant Reservations, Inventory, Invoicing, Accounting, Team chat and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Deputy covers scheduling, time and attendance, compliance, HR and payroll. It connects to other software for the rest.

2. A team pays one price, not a price for each person

Staff Scheduling is on every plan, and a person's file needs no Magpie account until they are invited. People invited to see their own shifts take a member place: 3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan. Deputy charges for every user each month, managers included.

3. Worked shifts go straight into payroll and the books

A Payroll pay run reads each employee's worked shifts and works out daily and weekly overtime. Approving it adds the pay run to the team's books in Accounting. A hired candidate in Hiring goes into Staff or Payroll in one step.

Comparing Magpie and Deputy

Deputy does more around the clock-in and the timesheet; Magpie does more around the rota. Every line in the tables below was checked against Deputy's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatDeputyMagpie
Shift schedulingPlan shifts, copy weeks and publish them to staff Yes Yes
Open shifts and swapsStaff take open shifts and swap with suitable coworkers Yes Yes
Auto-schedulingEmpty shifts filled with suitable people Core and Pro Yes
Time-off requestsStaff ask, a manager approves Yes Yes
Leave balancesBalances that build up, with rules for each kind of leave Core and Pro Yes
Demand forecastingStaff needed each hour, worked out from past sales Core and Pro Typed by hand
Wage budgetsPlan the schedule against a budget and a share of sales Core and Pro Cost estimates only
Time clockClock in on a phone or a shared tablet Yes Partly
Face and location checks on clock-inProof that people clocked in at work, in person Yes No
Timesheet approvalManagers approve hours before payroll Yes No
PayrollPay staff from the hours they worked Add-on, United States Yes
Scheduling rulesRest, hours, overtime and breaks checked on every shift Yes Yes
Predictive scheduling lawsNotice, consent and predictability pay Yes No
Text messages to staffSchedules and changes sent by text Charged per message No
Phone appStaff and managers on iPhone and Android Yes In the browser
Team messagingOne-to-one and group messages Yes Yes
News with read confirmationPosts to staff, with who has read them Yes Partly
Checklists for each shiftTasks staff work through, with who did what Yes Yes
HiringJobs, candidates and offers Deputy HR add-on Yes
Onboarding and staff documentsNew hire forms, the handbook and who has read it Deputy HR add-on Yes
AI assistantBuild the schedule and approve hours by asking Yes No
Connections to HR and payroll softwareBambooHR, payroll services and Zapier Yes No
Single sign-onSign in through the company's identity provider Pro No
Restaurant reservationsDiners reserve a table No Yes
Stock and ordersCounts, purchasing and waste No Yes
Free planSchedule staff without paying Free trial Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Locations, areas and people

Both start with the workplaces and the jobs people do there, then the staff. Both remind staff before a certificate runs out. Deputy adds custom access levels on Pro.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Set up each workplace and the jobs people do there Source Yes Yes
Add staff and invite them to see their shifts Source Yes Yes
Stop a shift going to someone without the training its job needs Source Yes Yes
Remind staff before a certificate or licence runs out Source Yes Yes
Choose who manages which locations Source Yes Yes
Make our own access levels with exactly the permissions we choose Source Magpie: There are three scheduling roles: a Schedule editor can be allowed to publish and to decide requests, and a manager to see pay rates, but a team cannot make roles of its own. Yes Partly

Good to know: Starting Magpie's Staff Scheduling from a business type adds the usual positions and starter shifts. Staff can be imported from a CSV file, up to 1,000 people at a time.

Scheduling

Both build the week by dragging and copying shifts. Both repeat shifts, post open shifts and fill them automatically. Deputy's auto-scheduling can also aim for the lowest cost.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Plan the week's shifts and publish them to staff Source Yes Yes
Fill a week from last week or from a saved week Source Yes Yes
Repeat a shift on a regular pattern Source Yes Yes
See the schedule by day, week or month, by person or by job Source Yes Yes
Post open shifts for staff to take Source Yes Yes
Have one person work in different areas during one shift Source Yes Yes
Have the schedule filled with suitable people for me Source Yes Yes
Say how many people each time needs, and see where the schedule falls short Source Yes Yes
Print the schedule or download it Source Yes Yes
See my shifts in Google Calendar or another calendar app Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie's publish review lists every change, who will be told and anything to look at. Each person then gets one email listing their changes.

Shift swaps, leave and availability

Both handle swaps, cover, availability and time off with a manager's say, and both keep leave balances. Deputy also asks staff to confirm new shifts and texts schedules. They do it better than we do today.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Let staff swap or hand over shifts, with a manager's say Source Yes Yes
Find cover when someone cannot come in Source Yes Yes
Let staff say when they cannot work Source Yes Yes
Let staff ask for time off, and approve it Source Yes Yes
Keep each person's leave balance and the rules for each kind of leave Source Yes Yes
Stop time off on busy dates, and limit how many people are off at once Source Magpie: Blackout periods mark dates when time off is not normally given, but people can still ask and the request is only marked. Requests shows who else is off; nothing limits how many people are off at once. Yes Partly
Have staff confirm they have seen their new shifts Source Magpie: Each person is told about every published change, but nobody confirms it; managers see only the notifications that could not be delivered. Yes No
Send schedules and changes to staff by text message Source Magpie: Schedule notifications and shift reminders go by email; the Magpie app, which also sends them as phone notifications, is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Nothing goes by text message. Yes No

Good to know: In Magpie, a person keeps their shift until a swap or cover request is settled. A blackout period marks dates when time off is not normally given.

Demand forecasting and labour budgets

Deputy works out the staff each hour needs from past sales. It plans against a wage budget. Magpie's coverage requirements are typed in by hand, with labour cost estimated from pay rates.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Work out how many staff each time needs from past sales Source Magpie: Coverage requirements say how many people each time needs, but they are typed in by hand; nothing forecasts them from sales. Yes Partly
Keep the schedule within a wage budget and a share of sales Source Magpie: Estimated pay shows on the publish review and in the labour cost report, but there is no wage budget, sales figure or labour target to plan against. Yes Partly
See what the schedule will cost while planning it Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie's schedule lists the times short of people. One button adds the open shifts needed.

Time and attendance, timesheets and payroll

Deputy clocks staff in on a phone or a kiosk and checks faces and location. Managers approve timesheets before payroll. They do it better than we do today. Magpie starts a Time Tracking timer from a shift and pays from worked shifts in Payroll.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Clock in and out of shifts on a phone or a shared tablet Source Magpie: From two hours before a shift, Start tracking time starts a Time Tracking timer for it, and a report compares worked time with the shift. It works only for people who can use Time Tracking, nothing stops an early start, and there is no clock on a shared tablet. Yes Partly
Make sure people clock in at work, and in person Source Magpie: A timer started from a shift records only its times. Yes No
See who is in, late or on a break, and be told when someone is late Source Magpie: With Compare with Time Tracking on, the Scheduled and worked report lists each shift with whether the person has clocked in or out, when, and shifts with no time entry, but it shows no breaks and nobody is told when someone is late. Yes Partly
Record breaks on the clock, and confirm they were taken Source Magpie: Breaks are planned on a shift and counted in its paid time, but a Time Tracking timer has no breaks and nobody confirms taking them. Yes No
Check and approve each person's hours before payroll Source Magpie: Time Tracking entries are not approved or locked; a team admin sees everyone's time in Reports. Yes No
Add or correct someone's hours as a manager Source Magpie: A person adds time they forgot to their own Time Tracking; a team admin cannot add or correct someone else's time. Yes Partly
Send the hours worked to the payroll service we use Source Magpie: Time Tracking reports and the Scheduled and worked report download as CSV for a payroll service to import, but nothing connects to one. Yes Partly
Pay staff from the hours they worked Source Yes Yes
See reports of hours, labour and attendance Source Yes Yes
Build our own reports and have them emailed Source Magpie: Staff Scheduling's reports are fixed, chosen by period and location with a CSV download; they cannot be rearranged, saved or emailed. Yes Partly

Good to know: Magpie's Scheduled and worked report shows when each person started and stopped against their shift. It marks a shift with no time entry.

Wage and hour compliance

Both check rest, hours, overtime and breaks while scheduling, and limit when a person may work. Deputy adds pay rules for premiums and the predictive scheduling laws of four American cities.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Keep shifts within limits on rest, hours and days in a row Source Yes Yes
Be warned about overtime while scheduling Source Yes Yes
Plan meal and rest breaks on each shift Source Yes Yes
Keep younger workers within the hours they may work Source Yes Yes
Have overtime, weekend and holiday rates worked out from our pay rules Source Magpie: Payroll works out daily and weekly overtime from worked shifts, at a multiplier such as 1.5 times, but no weekend, holiday or other premium is worked out by itself, and Staff Scheduling's labour estimates use the base rate only. Yes Partly
Follow predictive scheduling laws, with notice, consent and predictability pay Source Magpie: A setting stops schedule editors changing a shift close to its start, and publication history records every change, but nothing tracks notice, consent or predictability pay. Yes No

Good to know: Each Magpie scheduling rule blocks or warns, as the team chose. Publishing over a warning needs a reason, which is recorded with the publication.

Employee app and communication

Deputy's employee app carries shifts, clock-ins, leave, news, messages and tasks on iPhone and Android. Magpie's Staff Scheduling works in a phone's browser. Team chat and Daily Operations are in the same team.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Use the schedule on a phone, as staff and as a manager Source Yes Yes
Post news for staff, and see who has read it Source Magpie: In Daily Operations, a shift lead writes an announcement in a location's Logbook that stays on each person's Today until they mark it read, with a count of readers. Team chat channels reach the whole team, with no read receipts. Neither shows who has not read it. Yes Partly
Message staff one to one and in groups Source Yes Yes
Give staff checklists to work through, and see what is done Source Yes Yes
Ask staff how their shift went Source Magpie: Nothing asks staff how a shift went; Daily Operations handoff notes record what the next shift needs to know. Yes No

Good to know: A Daily Operations routine makes a checklist for each business day. It can be tied to a position. Each answer records who gave it and when.

Deputy HR

Deputy HR hires, onboards, shares documents and keeps performance notes. It is an add-on in the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia. Magpie's Hiring and Staff are on every plan. Staff onboards, keeps documents and notes, and publishes policies for staff to acknowledge.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Hire someone and put them straight onto the schedule Source Yes Yes
Post jobs to Indeed and other job boards in one step Source Magpie: Each job's public page carries the details Google uses to list jobs in search, and Share job starts a Social Media post, but nothing posts to Indeed or other job boards. Yes Partly
Have new hires send their details and documents before their first shift Source Yes Yes
Share the handbook and policies with staff, and see who has read them Source Yes Yes
Keep notes on how each person is doing, and share them when I choose Source Magpie: Staff keeps dated notes on each person's file, written by team admins and the person's managers and never shown to the person. A note cannot be shared with them. Yes Partly

Good to know: On a hired candidate's page in Hiring, Add to Staff starts their file. Their details and application files are filled in.

Deputy AI, integrations and plans

Deputy AI builds schedules and approves timesheets from typed or spoken requests. Deputy connects to payroll, HR software and Zapier. Magpie has an API for Staff Scheduling on Pro.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Ask in plain words to build the schedule, find cover or approve hours Source Magpie: The assistant reads nothing from Staff Scheduling yet, since it cannot keep to each person's scheduling role and locations. Yes No
Connect our own software to the schedule Source Magpie: On Pro, an API key reaches the Staff Scheduling routes in the OpenAPI file, but no webhook reports a change to a shift. Yes Partly
Connect the schedule to HR software or Zapier Source Magpie: Staff Scheduling connects to no HR software or Zapier. People are added by hand, from a CSV file, from the team's members or from Hiring, and Staff's Import people reads another app's export once turned into its JSON format. Yes No
Sign in through our company's identity provider Source Magpie: People sign in with a password and a two-factor code, a passkey, or a Google, Apple, LinkedIn or GitHub account. Yes No
Give every employee the schedule, however many there are Source Magpie: Staff Scheduling comes with every plan at one price for the team, and staff profiles have no limit, but each person invited to see their shifts takes a member place: 3 on Free and 25 on the Team plan. Yes Partly

Good to know: Every Magpie area is in the same team and on the same bill. Payroll reads the worked shifts with no connection to set up.

Running the rest of the business

Deputy runs the workforce and connects to other software for the rest. Magpie also takes table reservations and keeps the stock, in the same team as the rota.

WhatDeputyMagpie
Take table reservations in the same place as the staff schedule Source Deputy: Deputy's features cover scheduling, time and attendance, compliance, HR and payroll; it takes no reservations. No Yes
Keep track of stock, counts and orders Source Deputy: Deputy keeps no stock; its till connections bring in sales for forecasting only. No Yes

Good to know: Restaurant Reservations publishes a page where diners reserve a table. Each service runs from the book and the seating plan.

Price comparison

How Deputy charges

Deputy charges by plan, Lite, Core or Pro, for each user each month, billed monthly or yearly. Managers and admins count as users, and monthly plans have a minimum spend. Core adds auto-scheduling, forecasting, budgets and biometric clock-in; Pro adds custom access levels and single sign-on. Deputy HR, Deputy Payroll, Messaging+ and Analytics+ are add-ons, and text messages are charged as they are sent. Prices are on Deputy's pricing page, in your currency.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan too, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The plan sets limits, such as team members, not which areas you can use. Staff Scheduling is on every plan, and on the Free plan a pay run pays 2 employees. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planDeputyMagpie
How a team paysEach user, each month, managers included; a minimum on monthly plansOne plan for the team: 3 members on Free, 25 on the Team plan
Trying it without payingA free trial of Lite and CoreThe Free plan
Auto-schedulingCore and ProIncluded
Forecasting and wage budgetsCore and ProNot offered
Custom access levels and single sign-onProThree scheduling roles; no single sign-on
Text messages to staffCharged for each message sent, at rates that vary by countryNot offered; notifications go by email
PayrollDeputy Payroll with Paycor, an add-on on annual Core and Pro in the United StatesIncluded; 2 employees a pay run on Free
Hiring, onboarding and staff documentsDeputy HR, an add-on in the United States, the United Kingdom and AustraliaIncluded
Custom reports and pollsAnalytics+ and Messaging+, add-ons included with ProFixed reports and Team chat, included
Reservations, stock and the booksNot offeredIncluded

When to choose Magpie or Deputy

  • Want the rota beside payroll, hiring, daily checklists, reservations and the books, for one price for the team, with a Free plan? Go with Magpie.
  • Want staff to clock in on a kiosk, managers to approve timesheets, and the schedule forecast from your sales, with an app on every phone? Deputy is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a business with many locations and a labour budget
Deputy. Forecasting from sales, wage budgets, auto-approved timesheets and custom access levels are made for it. Magpie estimates labour cost but plans against no budget.
For an employer under predictive scheduling laws
Deputy. Deputy tracks notice, consent and predictability pay in Chicago, Los Angeles, Philadelphia and New York City. Magpie records every change but tracks none of these.
For a café, a shop or a restaurant with a small team
Magpie. Staff Scheduling, Payroll, Daily Operations and Restaurant Reservations are in one team, for one price. A person's file needs no account until they are invited.
For a business outside the United States that runs payroll itself
Magpie. Magpie's Payroll pays in the team's currency from worked shifts, with overtime. Deputy Payroll is for the United States.
For a team whose staff clock in at work
Either. Deputy has kiosks, face checks and timesheet approval. Magpie starts a timer from each shift and compares it with the schedule. Choose by how much proof of each clock-in you need.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Deputy and Magpie?

Deputy is a workforce service for shift-based businesses: scheduling, time clocks, timesheets and labour law compliance. HR and payroll are add-ons. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Staff Scheduling is one area beside Payroll, Hiring, Daily Operations, Restaurant Reservations and the books. Deputy does more around the clock-in and the timesheet; Magpie does more around the rota.

Does Magpie replace Deputy?

Yes, for a small team that plans a weekly rota and pays from its own bank. Staff Scheduling handles open shifts, swaps, availability, time off and scheduling rules. Payroll pays from the worked shifts.

Consider keeping Deputy if staff clock in on a kiosk or managers approve timesheets. Keep it too if you forecast from sales or text schedules to staff. Deputy does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Deputy cost?

Deputy has three plans, Lite, Core and Pro, priced for each user each month. Managers and admins count as users, and monthly plans have a minimum spend. Deputy HR, Deputy Payroll, Messaging+ and Analytics+ cost extra, and so do text messages. The prices are on Deputy's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Staff Scheduling is on every plan, with no price for each person. People invited to see their shifts take a member place: 3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

How many staff can I schedule in Magpie?

Staff files have no limit, and a file needs no Magpie account. Each person invited to see their own shifts joins the team and takes a member place. A free team has 3 and the Team plan 25. Deputy charges for each user instead.

Does Magpie have a time clock?

Partly. From two hours before a published shift, Start tracking time starts a timer for it. The Scheduled and worked report compares that time with the shift. There is no kiosk for a shared tablet, and no face or location check. Deputy has all three.

Does Magpie approve timesheets before payroll?

No. Time Tracking entries are not approved or locked. A team admin cannot correct someone else's time. The pay run itself is approved before anyone is paid. Deputy's managers approve timesheets, and Core and Pro approve the routine ones automatically.

Does Magpie forecast staffing from sales?

No. Coverage requirements say how many people each time needs, but you type them in. Estimated pay shows on the publish review and in the labour cost report. There is no budget to plan against. On Core and Pro, Deputy forecasts from a connected till's sales and plans against wage budgets.

Does Magpie fill the schedule automatically?

Yes. Auto-fill open shifts proposes people by availability, preferred hours, qualifications and fairness. Every scheduling rule is checked. Nothing changes until you choose Apply as drafts. It does not aim for the lowest cost, which Deputy's auto-scheduling can.

Does Magpie send schedules by text message?

No. Schedule changes and shift reminders go by email. The Magpie app sends phone notifications, but it is not yet in the app stores. Deputy publishes schedules by text, charged for each message.

Can staff confirm they have seen their shifts in Magpie?

No. Each person is told about every published change, but nobody confirms it. Managers see the notifications that could not be delivered. Deputy can ask for confirmation by an email link or a reply to the text.

Does Magpie track leave balances?

Yes. Staff's time-off policies give each person an allowance that builds up yearly, monthly or by hours worked. Part-time allowances are pro rata, and unused time can carry over. A request that would take a balance too low is refused. Deputy keeps balances on Core and Pro, with more rules in Leave Management+.

Does Magpie help with predictive scheduling laws?

No. A setting stops schedule editors changing a shift close to its start. Publication history records every change. Nothing tracks notice, consent or predictability pay. Deputy does, for Chicago, Los Angeles, Philadelphia and New York City.

Does Magpie have a phone app for staff?

Every Staff Scheduling page works in a phone's browser. Staff see their shifts, take open shifts, swap and ask for time off. Managers build, publish and approve. The Magpie app does the same, but it is not yet in the app stores. Deputy has apps for iPhone and Android.

Does Magpie have an AI assistant for scheduling?

No. The assistant reads nothing from Staff Scheduling yet. It cannot yet keep to each person's scheduling role and locations. Deputy AI builds schedules, finds cover and approves timesheets, with a summary to confirm first.

Does Magpie run payroll?

Yes. Payroll pays employees from their worked shifts, with overtime, and releases a payslip to each. The team pays from its own bank. The Free plan pays 2 employees a pay run. Deputy Payroll, run with Paycor, is an add-on for annual Core and Pro. It is for the United States.

Does Magpie have onboarding and staff documents?

Yes. Staff starts an Onboarding checklist when someone is added with a start date. It keeps documents on each person's file and publishes policies for staff to acknowledge. Hiring takes a candidate into Staff in one step. Both areas are on every plan, and Deputy HR does all of this as an add-on.

Does Magpie connect to payroll or HR software?

No. Staff Scheduling's reports and Time Tracking's reports download as CSV for a payroll service to import. On Pro, an API key reaches the Staff Scheduling routes, with no webhooks. Deputy connects to payroll services, HR systems such as BambooHR and HiBob, and Zapier.

Does Deputy take restaurant reservations or keep stock?

No. Deputy covers scheduling, time and attendance, compliance, HR and payroll. Its till connections bring in sales for forecasting. Magpie's Restaurant Reservations and Inventory are in the same team as the rota.

Can I use Deputy and Magpie together?

Yes. Deputy can run the schedule and timesheets while Magpie runs the reservations, stock, invoices and books. Nothing passes between them by itself. Deputy's payroll export keeps sending approved hours to your payroll service.

How do I move from Deputy to Magpie?

Add your locations and positions in Staff Scheduling, or start from a business type. Import your staff from a CSV file, up to 1,000 people at a time. Plan your usual week and save it as a starter week. Then invite each person to see their shifts. Keep Deputy until your last timesheets are paid.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Staff Scheduling, Staff, Time Tracking, Hiring, Daily Operations and Team chat are included. Payroll pays 2 employees a pay run. A free team has 3 members. A paid plan pays every employee and raises the other limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Deputy changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Deputy's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Plan your rota beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then set up Staff Scheduling in your team.

Create account