What is the difference between Memberful and Magpie?
Memberful is a membership platform, with checkout, plans, newsletters, private podcasts and a WordPress plugin. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Supporters area is one part, beside a shop, courses, a newsletter, booking pages and a website. Memberful does more for the membership; Magpie does more around it.
Does Magpie replace Memberful?
Yes, for someone whose paid posts are one part of a business. Supporters has free and paid tiers, monthly or yearly, and posts for chosen tiers. Payments go to your own Stripe account, for 4%.
Consider keeping Memberful if you lock pages on your own WordPress site or give members private podcast feeds. Keep it too if you need weekly billing, trials, coupons, group plans or Discord roles. Memberful does each of these better than Magpie does today.
How much does Memberful cost?
Memberful's Standard plan has a monthly price and takes 4.9% of each payment. Stripe's fees come on top. You can set up and test for free, and you pay once you go live. Enterprise has custom pricing. The prices are on Memberful's pricing page.
How much does Magpie cost?
Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free allows 3 paid tiers and 200 posts; a paid plan has no limit. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments, and Stripe's fees come on top. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.
Does Magpie have yearly memberships?
Yes. A paid Supporters tier can offer a yearly price beside its monthly one, at an amount you set. Supporters choose monthly or yearly when they join. There is no weekly or quarterly billing. Memberful bills weekly, monthly, every 3 or 6 months, yearly or on a custom period.
Can I offer a free trial or a coupon on Magpie?
No. A paid tier has a fixed monthly price, and a yearly one if you offer it, with no trial and no discount code. You can give someone complimentary access to any tier, with an end date if you want one. Memberful has free and paid trials and coupons.
Does Magpie email each post to supporters?
No. A Supporters post is read on the Supporters page, and nothing emails it out. Newsletter emails go to every subscriber, with no link to tiers. Memberful sends a post by email, on the member website or both.
Can members comment on posts in Magpie?
No. Supporters posts have no comments or likes. A Message Board is separate from the Supporters page. Memberful posts take comments and likes, with replies.
Can I schedule a Supporters post?
No. A post is a draft or published, and it cannot be set to publish later. Memberful posts can be set to publish and be emailed at a future time.
Can I run a members-only podcast on Magpie?
No. A Podcast's RSS feed is public, and there is no private feed for supporters. You can host a public show and list it in Spotify and Apple Podcasts. Memberful gives each member a private feed from your podcast host.
Does Magpie work with WordPress?
No. Supporters posts are read on the Supporters page, and nothing locks pages on another website. Each tier's join link works from any site. Memberful's WordPress plugin locks posts, pages and blocks to plans.
Does Magpie connect to Discord?
No. Supporters connects to no other software and sends no webhooks. Memberful gives members a Discord role for their plan and syncs them to Mailchimp, Kit and other email tools.
Can my Supporters page be at my own domain?
No. The Supporters page is at Magpie's /support/ address. Websites and Store can use your own domain. Memberful's sign-up, checkout and member website can be at your own domain.
Does Magpie add sales tax to supporters' payments?
No. Supporters charges no tax, and you are responsible for taxes. Store can work out tax with Stripe Tax for its own sales. Memberful works out tax at checkout in the United States, the European Union, the United Kingdom, Canada and Australia.
Can I test Supporters before taking real payments?
No. Supporters has no test mode. Once Stripe is connected, a paid tier charges real cards. A free tier can be joined to see the member's side. Memberful stays in test mode for as long as you like.
Can Memberful sell physical products?
No. Memberful sells plans and downloads, and a plan can ask for a mailing address. Magpie's Store sells physical products with stock and shipping rates, through the same Stripe account as Supporters.
Does Memberful have polls?
No. A Memberful post holds text, pictures, links and one video, with comments and likes. In Magpie, a published Form can be shown under a Supporters post as a poll.
Does Memberful have booking pages?
No. Memberful's pricing page lists no booking pages. Magpie's Meetings gives you a booking page where people choose a time with you. Appointments can take payment or a deposit when someone books.
Can I use Memberful and Magpie together?
Yes. Memberful can run the membership while Magpie runs your shop, courses, booking pages, invoices and website. A Magpie website can link to each Memberful plan's purchase link.
How do I move from Memberful to Magpie?
Set up Supporters and add your tiers, then publish the page. Paying members cannot be imported: each one joins again through the page and Stripe's checkout. Memberful exports members as a CSV file. Newsletter imports a CSV file of people who gave permission. Then you can email them the new address.
What is included in Magpie's Free plan?
Supporters with a free tier, 3 paid tiers and 200 posts. Store, Courses, booking pages, Invoicing, a podcast, the Newsletter with 250 subscribers, Forms and a team of 3. A paid plan removes the tier and post limits and raises the others.