Memberful compared with Magpie

Memberful vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Memberful and Magpie both let people join a membership, free or paid, through your own Stripe account. They are built around different things.

  1. Memberful is a membership platform for creators and publishers, with checkout, plans, newsletters, private podcasts and a member website. It is built for someone whose membership is the business. That is often on their own WordPress site, or with a Discord server.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Supporters is one part of it. Beside the paid posts it includes a shop, courses, a newsletter, booking pages and a website. It is built for someone whose members are one part of running the business.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s Supporters posts: a draft and five published posts, each with its date and who it is for, from everyone to paying supporters and chosen tiers, one with a poll.

How is Magpie different?

1. Paid posts come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a membership business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Supporters, the area this page is about, for free and paid tiers and the posts kept for them
  • Store for downloads and physical products, and Courses for lessons at a school of your own
  • Newsletter for email to subscribers, and Podcast for a show with its own feed
  • Meetings for booking pages, and Invoicing for invoices paid online
  • Websites, Mail, Forms, Contacts, Accounting and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Memberful covers memberships, posts, newsletters, podcasts and downloads, and connects to other software for the rest.

2. The Free plan takes real payments

Supporters is on every plan, Free included, with no monthly price for the area. Magpie takes 4% of each payment, and Stripe's processing fee comes on top. Free allows 3 paid tiers and 200 posts. Pro and the Team plan have no limit.

3. One Stripe account for supporters, the shop and courses

Your team connects one Stripe account. Supporters tiers, Store products, courses and paid Forms are all paid into it. A Supporters tier can include courses, which its supporters open without paying. Supporters › Payments lists every payment with its fees.

Comparing Magpie and Memberful

Memberful does more for the membership; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Memberful's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Your own Stripe accountMembers' payments paid out to your bank Yes Yes
Free and paid plansPeople join free or pay for more Yes Yes
Yearly and weekly billingPlans billed other than monthly Yes Partly
Trials, coupons and giftsA lower first price, discount codes, a membership bought for someone Yes No
Group plansOne subscription for a whole team Yes No
Sales tax at checkoutTax and VAT added to members' payments Yes No
Members-only postsPosts kept for members or chosen plans Yes Yes
Posts emailed to membersEach post sent to the members it is for Yes No
Comments on postsMembers reply and like Yes No
Polls under a postAsk members a question No Yes
Private podcast feedsEach member's own feed for their podcast app Yes No
Podcast hostingA show with a public RSS feed From your podcast host Yes
CoursesLessons included with a membership LearnDash or Sensei on WordPress Yes
Member websiteA hosted page for your posts and plans Yes Yes
Your own domainMembership pages at your domain Yes No
WordPress paywallLock pages on your own WordPress site Yes No
Discord rolesMembers let into Discord by plan Yes No
Email tools and webhooksMembers synced to Mailchimp, Kit and others Yes No
Retention toolsCancellation survey, retention discounts, referrals Yes No
Shop for physical productsThings you make and ship No Store
Booking pagesMembers book a time with you No Yes
Free plan that takes paymentsReal payments without a monthly price No Yes
Platform feeWhat comes off each member payment 4.9% on Standard 4%

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Checkout and payments

Both take payments into your own Stripe account, with cards, Apple Pay and Google Pay. Memberful makes the member's account at checkout, adds sales tax, asks your own questions and has a test mode. They do it better than we do today.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Take members' payments into my own Stripe account, paid out to my bank Source Yes Yes
Run a paid membership without a monthly fee, paying only a share of each payment Source Memberful: The Standard plan has a monthly price, and Memberful takes 4.9% of each payment beside Stripe's own fee. It is free only while you test, until you go live and take real payments. No Yes
Let people pay and join in one step, with their account made at checkout Source Magpie: A visitor signs in to Magpie or makes an account before joining any tier, free or paid, and Stripe's checkout opens after that. Yes No
Let members pay with Apple Pay or Google Pay as well as a card Source Yes Yes
Have sales tax and VAT added to members' payments at checkout Source Magpie: Supporters charges no tax, and the seller is responsible for taxes. Store can work out tax with Stripe Tax for its own sales. Yes No
Show checkout, the member account and emails in my members' language Source Magpie: The Supporters page follows the team's Language for customers, and supporter emails follow the reader's language: English, French, Spanish or German. Yes Partly
Ask new members my own questions when they join Source Magpie: Joining asks for nothing beyond a Magpie account. Stripe's checkout asks for the card and, where needed, a billing address. Yes No
Try the checkout and what members see before going live, without real payments Source Magpie: Supporters has no test mode. Once Stripe is connected, a paid tier charges real cards; a free tier can be joined to see the member's side. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie supporter signs in to a Magpie account before joining. Then they pay on Stripe's own checkout page. A free tier needs no Stripe account at all.

Plans and subscriptions

Both have free registration and several paid plans, billed monthly or yearly. Memberful adds weekly and custom billing, trials, gifts, group plans, chosen amounts and plan changes by members themselves.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Offer several paid plans, each with its own price and benefits Source Yes Yes
Let people join free before they pay Source Yes Yes
Bill members weekly, monthly, every few months or yearly Source Magpie: A paid tier is charged monthly, and can offer a yearly price beside it that supporters choose when they join. There is no weekly or quarterly billing. Yes Partly
Let someone pay once for access instead of subscribing Source Magpie: Paid tiers are monthly or yearly subscriptions. Complimentary access can last with no end date, but nobody pays for it. Yes No
Let members choose how much they pay, at or above a minimum Source Magpie: Each paid tier has one fixed monthly price, and a fixed yearly one if you offer it. Yes No
Win new members with a free or paid trial Source Magpie: A paid tier's monthly or yearly price is charged from the start, with no trial. An admin can give complimentary access instead. Yes No
Sell one subscription that covers a whole team or company Source Magpie: Each supporter joins and pays for themselves. Yes No
Let someone buy a membership as a gift for another person Source Magpie: An admin can give anyone complimentary access, with an end date if wanted, but nobody can buy it for someone else. Yes Partly
Let members move to another plan themselves, paying the difference Source Magpie: Stripe's portal does not switch tiers. A paid supporter cancels and joins another tier once the current one has ended. Yes No
Change a plan's price, and move the members already on it Source Magpie: A paid tier's monthly price cannot change once it is set, so a different amount needs a new tier. Its yearly price can be changed for new supporters, and people already on it keep their price. Yes Partly

Good to know: Give complimentary access opens any Magpie tier to someone for free. It can have an end date and a note only admins see.

Member management

Both let members update their card and cancel by themselves, and both list members with their history. Memberful also pauses payments, asks why members cancel, offers retention discounts and imports members from another platform.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Let members sign in without a password, with an emailed link or code Source Yes Yes
Let members update their card, see receipts and cancel by themselves Source Yes Yes
See every member, filter them by plan and status, and open each one's history Source Yes Yes
Give chosen people free access to a paid plan Source Yes Yes
Change a member's subscription myself, such as its renewal date or amount, or cancel it Source Magpie: A supporter's page shows their Stripe amount, card and renewal date, but the subscription is changed or cancelled in the Stripe dashboard. Magpie gives and ends only complimentary access. Yes Partly
Pause a member's payments, or many members' at once Source Magpie: Nothing in Magpie pauses a supporter's payments. Closing or archiving a tier stops new supporters joining, while everyone on it keeps paying. Yes No
Refund a member's payment Source Magpie: Refunds are made in the Stripe dashboard. They then show on Supporters › Payments, and Magpie returns its fee in proportion to the amount refunded. Yes Partly
Keep members whose card payment failed Source Magpie: A supporter keeps access while a failed renewal is retried, as the Stripe account's settings decide, and Who you support marks the payment as failed. Magpie sends no reminder of its own. Yes Partly
Ask members why they cancel Source Magpie: A supporter cancels in Stripe's portal with no question. A supporter's page shows a reason only when Stripe recorded one. Yes No
Offer a discount to members who cancel, so they stay Source Magpie: Cancelling in Stripe's portal makes no offer. Yes No
Bring my members and their subscriptions over from another platform Source Magpie: Supporters cannot be imported. Each paying supporter joins again through the page and Stripe's checkout. Yes No
Download my members, orders and cancellations as spreadsheets Source Magpie: Team admins see each supporter's email address on their page, but the Supporters list and Payments cannot be downloaded. Yes Partly
Let staff help run the membership, limited to the parts they need Source Magpie: Every team admin runs Supporters in full. Other team members see the overview but cannot write posts, see supporters or change anything, and nobody's access can be limited to posts or to supporters alone. Yes Partly
Write the emails members get in my own words, and send them from my own address Source Magpie: New supporters are emailed the page's one welcome message, set in Supporters settings. The rest of each email is Magpie's wording, sent from Magpie. Yes Partly

Good to know: Each supporter's page in Magpie shows their tier, payments and a History of every change. A refund made in Stripe returns Magpie's fee in proportion.

Posts, newsletters, podcasts and downloads

Both keep posts for members or chosen plans and show others a preview. Memberful emails each post, schedules it, sorts posts into categories, takes comments and gives members private podcast feeds.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Publish posts only for members, or only for chosen plans Source Yes Yes
Send each post as an email newsletter to the members it is for Source Magpie: Supporters posts are not emailed. Newsletter emails its subscribers, with no link to who supports you or on which tier. Yes Partly
Show people without access a preview of a locked post, with a way to join Source Yes Yes
Schedule a post to go out later Source Magpie: A post is a draft or published; it cannot be set to publish at a later time. Yes No
See how many members opened each emailed post and clicked its links Source Magpie: Supporters posts are not emailed. A Newsletter email shows copies delivered, failed and skipped, but not opens or clicks. Yes Partly
Sort my posts into categories readers can browse Source Magpie: Posts are one list, newest first, with no categories, collections or search. Yes No
Let members comment on and like my posts Source Magpie: Supporters posts have no comments or likes. A Message Board is separate from the page. Yes No
Upload videos that only paying members can watch Source Magpie: A post's video from Screen Recorder plays only where the post opens, but the video file itself can be opened by anyone who has its address. Yes Partly
Sell files on their own, or include them with a membership Source Magpie: Store sells downloadable files to anyone. A Supporters tier cannot include a file, and a post cannot carry one. Yes Partly
Give paying members a private podcast feed for their own podcast app Source Magpie: A Podcast's RSS feed is public while the podcast is on, and there is no private feed for supporters. Yes No
Include courses with a membership Source Yes Yes
Ask members a question in a poll under a post Source Memberful: A post holds text, pictures, links and one featured video, and can take comments and likes; there are no polls. No Yes

Good to know: A Supporters post is written in the Notes editor and can show a poll from Forms. A tier can include courses from Courses.

Communities

Memberful lets members into Discord with a role for their plan. It signs them in to Discourse, Circle or BetterMode. Magpie's Message Boards are separate from the Supporters page.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Let members into my Discord server, with roles that follow their plan Source Magpie: Supporters does not connect to Discord. Yes No
Run a forum only members can join, with their membership sign-in Source Magpie: A Message Board is public to anyone or private to a team. It cannot be opened to supporters or to one tier. Yes Partly

Good to know: Magpie's Meetings gives you a booking page where members choose a time for a call with you. Appointments can take payment or a deposit when someone books.

Website, branding and WordPress

Both give you a hosted page for your posts and plans. Memberful adds a page builder, your own branding and domain, and a WordPress plugin that locks your own pages.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Have a website for my posts and plans without building one Source Yes Yes
Build pages from blocks, with some blocks only for members on chosen plans Source Magpie: Websites builds pages of sections, but no page or section can be kept for supporters. The Supporters page has one About section. Yes Partly
Give my membership pages, checkout and emails my logo, colours and fonts Source Magpie: The page shows your cover image, name and description inside Magpie's own top bar and footer. Its colours and fonts cannot be changed, and checkout is Stripe's page. Yes Partly
Show my membership pages at my own domain Source Magpie: The Supporters page lives at Magpie's /support/ address. Websites and Store can use your own domain; Supporters cannot. Yes No
Keep posts on my own WordPress site for paying members Source Magpie: Supporters posts are read only on the Supporters page; nothing locks pages on another website. Yes No
Sell my plans from my own website with a link or button Source Magpie: Each tier's join button on the public page is a link that works on any website and survives signing in. There is no button or widget to embed. Yes Partly

Good to know: Each tier's join button on the Supporters page is a link. It works from any website and survives signing in.

Revenue and growth

Memberful has coupons, referrals, revenue and churn charts, and Google Analytics. Magpie's Supporters overview counts supporters and payments, and Store sells physical products beside them.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Give discount codes that apply once, for a few payments, or for good Source Magpie: A paid tier has one fixed price, with no discount codes. Store has discount codes for its own products. Yes No
Reward members who bring in new paying members Source Magpie: Supporters has no referral links or rewards. Yes No
See recurring revenue, churn, trials and paying members over time Source Magpie: The Supporters overview shows how many support you, how many pay, what they pay each month, and how many joined and ended in the last 30 days. Payments lists each payment with its fees. There are no charts over time and no churn rate. Yes Partly
Track sign-ups and purchases in Google Analytics or an ad pixel Source Magpie: A Supporters page has no analytics code; the overview counts supporters and payments. Yes No
Sell physical products and merch beside memberships Source Memberful: Memberful sells plans and downloads; a plan can ask for a mailing address, but there is no shop for physical products. No Yes

Good to know: The Supporters overview shows how many support you, how many pay and what they pay each month. It also counts who joined and left in the last 30 days.

Integrations and developers

Memberful syncs members to email marketing tools, sends webhooks and has a GraphQL API. Magpie's Supporters has a REST API and no other connections.

WhatMemberfulMagpie
Keep my members in my email marketing tool, grouped by plan Source Magpie: Supporters connects to no email tool, and Magpie's own Newsletter does not know who supports you. Yes No
Have my other tools told when someone joins, renews or leaves Source Magpie: Supporters sends no webhooks, and Magpie has no Zapier app. Store, Meetings, Forms and Courses send webhooks of their own. Yes No
Read and change my membership from my own code Source Yes Yes

Good to know: With a Pro API key, Magpie's REST API reads the Supporters page, tiers, supporters and payments. It also gives and ends complimentary access.

Price comparison

How Memberful charges

Memberful has no free plan. The Standard plan has a monthly price and takes 4.9% of each payment. Stripe's fees come on top. You can set up and test for free for as long as you like. You pay once you go live. Every feature is on Standard, with no limit on members. Enterprise has custom pricing by volume. The details are on Memberful's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for every area in the account. The plan sets how many paid tiers and posts you have, not which areas you can use. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments and 4% of Store sales. Stripe's fees come on top. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planMemberfulMagpie
Fee on member payments4.9% on Standard4% on Supporters
Payment processingStripe's fees, through your own Stripe accountStripe's fees, through your own Stripe account
Monthly price to take paymentsStandard plan's priceNone on Free
Sales tax and VATWorked out at checkout; filing stays with youYour responsibility
Shop for physical productsNot offered4% of each Store sale
NewsletterPosts emailed to members250 subscribers on Free, 5,000 on a paid plan
Booking pagesNot offeredIncluded; 4% of a payment taken at booking in Appointments
MembersNo limitNo limit on supporters

When to choose Magpie or Memberful

  • Want paid posts beside a shop, courses, a newsletter and booking pages, with no monthly price before your first member pays? Go with Magpie.
  • Want weekly plans, trials, coupons, posts emailed to members, private podcast feeds, Discord roles and a paywall on your own WordPress site? Memberful is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a publisher on WordPress
Memberful. The plugin locks posts, pages and blocks on your own site, with a metered paywall. Magpie's Supporters posts are read only on the Supporters page.
For a podcaster with paying listeners
Memberful. Each member gets a private feed for their own podcast app, Spotify included. Magpie's Podcast feeds are public today.
For a community on Discord
Memberful. Members get a Discord role for their plan and lose it when they leave. Supporters does not connect to Discord.
For a coach, a teacher or a consultant
Magpie. Paid posts sit beside courses, booking pages, invoices and a newsletter in one account. A tier can include courses, and supporters book a call from a booking page.
For a maker who sells things too
Magpie. Store sells physical products and downloads beside the Supporters page, through the same Stripe account. Memberful sells plans and downloads, with no shop for physical products.
For a writer with paying readers
Either. Both keep posts for free members, paying members or chosen plans. Memberful emails each post and takes comments. Magpie has no monthly price on Free. Choose by whether readers' inboxes or the monthly price matter more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Memberful and Magpie?

Memberful is a membership platform, with checkout, plans, newsletters, private podcasts and a WordPress plugin. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Supporters area is one part, beside a shop, courses, a newsletter, booking pages and a website. Memberful does more for the membership; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Memberful?

Yes, for someone whose paid posts are one part of a business. Supporters has free and paid tiers, monthly or yearly, and posts for chosen tiers. Payments go to your own Stripe account, for 4%.

Consider keeping Memberful if you lock pages on your own WordPress site or give members private podcast feeds. Keep it too if you need weekly billing, trials, coupons, group plans or Discord roles. Memberful does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Memberful cost?

Memberful's Standard plan has a monthly price and takes 4.9% of each payment. Stripe's fees come on top. You can set up and test for free, and you pay once you go live. Enterprise has custom pricing. The prices are on Memberful's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free allows 3 paid tiers and 200 posts; a paid plan has no limit. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments, and Stripe's fees come on top. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have yearly memberships?

Yes. A paid Supporters tier can offer a yearly price beside its monthly one, at an amount you set. Supporters choose monthly or yearly when they join. There is no weekly or quarterly billing. Memberful bills weekly, monthly, every 3 or 6 months, yearly or on a custom period.

Can I offer a free trial or a coupon on Magpie?

No. A paid tier has a fixed monthly price, and a yearly one if you offer it, with no trial and no discount code. You can give someone complimentary access to any tier, with an end date if you want one. Memberful has free and paid trials and coupons.

Does Magpie email each post to supporters?

No. A Supporters post is read on the Supporters page, and nothing emails it out. Newsletter emails go to every subscriber, with no link to tiers. Memberful sends a post by email, on the member website or both.

Can members comment on posts in Magpie?

No. Supporters posts have no comments or likes. A Message Board is separate from the Supporters page. Memberful posts take comments and likes, with replies.

Can I schedule a Supporters post?

No. A post is a draft or published, and it cannot be set to publish later. Memberful posts can be set to publish and be emailed at a future time.

Can I run a members-only podcast on Magpie?

No. A Podcast's RSS feed is public, and there is no private feed for supporters. You can host a public show and list it in Spotify and Apple Podcasts. Memberful gives each member a private feed from your podcast host.

Does Magpie work with WordPress?

No. Supporters posts are read on the Supporters page, and nothing locks pages on another website. Each tier's join link works from any site. Memberful's WordPress plugin locks posts, pages and blocks to plans.

Does Magpie connect to Discord?

No. Supporters connects to no other software and sends no webhooks. Memberful gives members a Discord role for their plan and syncs them to Mailchimp, Kit and other email tools.

Can my Supporters page be at my own domain?

No. The Supporters page is at Magpie's /support/ address. Websites and Store can use your own domain. Memberful's sign-up, checkout and member website can be at your own domain.

Does Magpie add sales tax to supporters' payments?

No. Supporters charges no tax, and you are responsible for taxes. Store can work out tax with Stripe Tax for its own sales. Memberful works out tax at checkout in the United States, the European Union, the United Kingdom, Canada and Australia.

Can I test Supporters before taking real payments?

No. Supporters has no test mode. Once Stripe is connected, a paid tier charges real cards. A free tier can be joined to see the member's side. Memberful stays in test mode for as long as you like.

Can Memberful sell physical products?

No. Memberful sells plans and downloads, and a plan can ask for a mailing address. Magpie's Store sells physical products with stock and shipping rates, through the same Stripe account as Supporters.

Does Memberful have polls?

No. A Memberful post holds text, pictures, links and one video, with comments and likes. In Magpie, a published Form can be shown under a Supporters post as a poll.

Does Memberful have booking pages?

No. Memberful's pricing page lists no booking pages. Magpie's Meetings gives you a booking page where people choose a time with you. Appointments can take payment or a deposit when someone books.

Can I use Memberful and Magpie together?

Yes. Memberful can run the membership while Magpie runs your shop, courses, booking pages, invoices and website. A Magpie website can link to each Memberful plan's purchase link.

How do I move from Memberful to Magpie?

Set up Supporters and add your tiers, then publish the page. Paying members cannot be imported: each one joins again through the page and Stripe's checkout. Memberful exports members as a CSV file. Newsletter imports a CSV file of people who gave permission. Then you can email them the new address.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Supporters with a free tier, 3 paid tiers and 200 posts. Store, Courses, booking pages, Invoicing, a podcast, the Newsletter with 250 subscribers, Forms and a team of 3. A paid plan removes the tier and post limits and raises the others.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Memberful changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Memberful's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Start a Supporters page on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then set up Supporters.

Create account