Tally compared with Magpie

Tally vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Tally and Magpie both build online forms that anyone answers from a link. Neither limits forms or responses on the Free plan. They are built around different things.

  1. Tally is a form builder you type into like a document, made and hosted in the EU. Its Free plan has no limit on forms or responses, and includes logic, payments, embeds and integrations. It is built for someone who makes a lot of forms: a startup, a maker, a team that keeps its work in Notion or Airtable.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Forms is one part of it. Beside the forms it includes booking pages, invoicing, contacts, e-signatures, a website and more. It is built for someone whose forms are one part of running the business.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s draft Project request Form in the Form builder: a heading, then questions for a name, an email, the project, its stage, a budget and a target date, each with its answer type and reorder controls.

How is Magpie different?

1. Forms come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Forms, with pages, conditions, file uploads and paid forms
  • Meetings and Appointments for booking pages
  • E-Signatures for documents people sign
  • Contacts for the people you work with
  • Invoicing, with recurring invoices and online payment, and Store for selling online
  • Websites, Newsletter, Courses, Spreadsheets, Helpdesk and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Tally covers forms, and sends their responses to the other software you use.

2. A team builds forms together on the Free plan

A free Magpie team has places for 3 members. They build forms and read responses by the team's permissions. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Collaborators gives someone Can view or Can edit on one form. Someone from outside the team joins as a guest and sees that form only.

3. Each response keeps the form it answered

Edits to a published form stay a draft until you choose Publish changes. Each response stays attached to the version of the form it answered. A question removed later is still shown on the responses that included it.

Comparing Magpie and Tally

Tally does more inside the form; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Tally's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatTallyMagpie
Forms and surveysQuestions anyone can answer from a link Yes Yes
Build by typingA slash on a blank page adds each question Yes Partly
AI that builds formsA form written or changed from a request Yes Partly
Conditional questionsQuestions shown by earlier answers Yes Yes
Calculations and quizzesScores and prices worked out from answers Yes No
Payments in a formCard payment as part of a response Yes Fixed amount
SignaturesPeople sign as part of a form A form question E-Signatures, by email
Embed on your websiteThe form inside a page of another site, or a pop-up Yes In a page
Forms at your own domainYour domain, at an address you choose Pro No
Your own colours, fonts and logoA form in the business's own look Yes Seven themes
Charts and scores of the answersCharts, NPS and CSAT Yes Summary table
Partial responses and drop-offAnswers from people who stopped, and where they stopped Pro No
Integrations and webhooksEach response sent to Google Sheets, Notion, Slack or Zapier Yes Webhooks
APIRead and change forms from your own programs Yes Pro
AI that reads responsesClaude or ChatGPT sums up the answers Yes No
A team on the Free planSeveral people building the same forms Pro Yes
View-only access to one formSomeone reads a form and its responses without changing them No Yes
Forms and responses without a limitAny number on the Free plan Yes Yes
Booking pagesPeople choose a time with you Calendly or Cal.com, inside a form Meetings and Appointments
InvoicingInvoices paid online No Yes
Website and shopPages and products for sale No Yes
Email newslettersEmails to a list of subscribers No Yes
Data kept in EuropeAnswers stored and processed in the EU Yes No

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Building a form

Tally's editor is a blank page you type on, with a slash for each question. Tally AI builds and changes a form from a request, and Tally imports Typeform forms and PDFs. They do it better than we do today.

WhatTallyMagpie
Build a form as quickly as typing a document Source Magpie: The editor saves as you type, but each question is added with Add question and given an Answer type from a list, beside a list of pages; nothing is typed straight onto the form. Paste JSON builds a whole form from one document. Yes Partly
Describe a form and have AI build it or change it Source Magpie: The assistant, and Claude or ChatGPT connected through Connected apps, create a draft form from one of the starting points, and Copy the prompt has your own chatbot write a JSON document to paste. Nothing in Magpie writes or changes a form's questions from a description. Yes Partly
Start from a ready-made form, such as a sign-up or a feedback form Source Yes Yes
Copy a form, or save one as a template for my team Source Magpie: Forms has no Copy or Save as template. A new form starts from a built-in starting point or from a JSON document you paste. Yes No
Bring over the forms I made in Typeform Source Magpie: Paste JSON builds a form from a document, and Copy the prompt has a chatbot write that document from another tool's questions, but nothing reads a Typeform or a Google Form directly. Yes Partly
Turn a PDF, a Word file or a screenshot of a form into an online form Source Magpie: Forms builds a form only in its own editor or from a pasted JSON document; it reads no PDF, Word file or picture. Yes No
Go back to an earlier version of a form Source Magpie: Each published version is kept so that every response shows the questions it answered, and edits stay a draft until Publish changes, but no earlier version can be brought back. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie form can be built by pasting a JSON document. Copy the prompt gives a chatbot the format, so it can turn another form's questions into one.

Collecting any kind of answer

Both have the usual question types, file uploads and card payments. Tally adds ranking, grids, an Other choice and a signature question. It also works out a price from the answers and puts a booking calendar inside a form.

WhatTallyMagpie
Add questions of the usual kinds Source Yes Yes
Ask people to put a list of choices in order Source Magpie: No question puts choices in order; a Scale question for each choice stands in for it. Yes No
Ask the same question about several rows in one grid Source Magpie: Each row has to be its own Radio or Scale question. Yes No
Offer an Other choice where people type their own answer Source Magpie: Radio, Checkboxes and Select take only the choices listed; a Text question shown by a condition can follow up instead. Yes No
Set rules an answer must meet, such as how many boxes to tick or which dates are allowed Source Magpie: Email and URL answers must be valid addresses and choices must come from the list, but there are no number ranges, lengths, date limits or limits on how many boxes are ticked. Yes Partly
Let people send files of any kind and size with their answers Source Magpie: A File question takes one PDF, JPG, PNG, WebP or plain-text file of up to 10 MB; Word documents, videos, audio and several files at once are not taken, and the files count in the storage of the form's team, or of Personal. Yes Partly
Have people sign as part of a form, such as a waiver Source Magpie: Forms has no signature question. E-Signatures sends a PDF to the signers you name by email, not to anyone who opens a link. Yes No
Charge for a form response Source Yes Yes
Charge an amount worked out from the answers, such as a price for each item chosen Source Magpie: A paid form charges the same fixed amount for every response, whatever was answered. Yes No
Let people book a time as one step of a form Source Magpie: Meetings has its own booking page, which asks for a name, an email address, a phone number and notes; a form cannot include a booking. Yes No
Keep spam and bots out of my responses Source Magpie: A response can only be sent from the form's own page or its frame on another website, and one connection can send 20 files an hour, but there is no challenge or spam filter on a form's answers. Yes Partly

Good to know: A paid Magpie form charges one fixed amount through your own Stripe account. Magpie takes 4% of each payment, and Stripe's card fees apply too.

Logic, calculations and form settings

Both split a form into pages and show a question only when an earlier answer calls for it. Tally adds scores, recalled answers, link details and endings chosen by the answers. Its forms can also close on a date or a count.

WhatTallyMagpie
Show different questions depending on earlier answers Source Yes Yes
Skip pages, or make a question required, depending on earlier answers Source Magpie: A condition only shows or hides a question. Every page still comes in turn, even when all its questions are hidden, and no condition makes a question required or stops someone sending. Yes Partly
Score the answers, as a quiz or to rate leads Source Magpie: Forms has no right answers or scores. Courses has quizzes with a pass mark inside a course's lessons, but a form cannot be marked. Yes No
Pass details such as a campaign or a customer number through the form's link Source Magpie: The public form takes nothing from its link; every answer is typed by the respondent. Yes No
Send a link that opens the form with some answers already filled in Source Magpie: Every question opens empty, whatever the link. Yes No
Use earlier answers, such as a name, in later questions and on the closing page Source Magpie: Questions and the closing message are fixed text. Yes No
Write my own thank-you page for after someone sends the form Source Magpie: A form ends with a closing heading and message, which the starting points fill in, but the website's editor has no place to change them: on the website they are set only in a pasted JSON document. The app's editor changes them, but the app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Show a different closing page depending on the answers, such as a quiz result Source Magpie: A form has one closing heading and message, the same for everyone. Yes No
Send people to my own web page when they finish Source Magpie: After sending, the respondent sees the closing message on the form's page; a paid form goes to Stripe and comes back to it. Yes No
Close a form on a set date or once it has enough responses, with my own message Source Magpie: Close form, in Form settings, stops new responses by hand, and the public page shows a set closed message. Yes No
Stop the same person answering twice Source Magpie: One response per person lets each person send the form once, but only with Require sign-in on, so every respondent needs a Magpie account. Yes Partly
Let only the people I choose answer a form, such as those with a password or a checked email address Source Magpie: Require sign-in lets only people signed in to Magpie send a form, but anyone with an account can; there is no password, no list of who may answer, and an Email answer is not checked with a code. Yes Partly
Let people leave a long form and carry on later Source Magpie: Answers typed into a form that is not sent are lost when the page closes. Yes No
Show a progress bar, and move on as soon as a choice is made Source Magpie: A form of several pages shows one page at a time with Next and Back, but there is no progress bar and choosing an answer does not move on by itself. Yes Partly
Split a long form into pages Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A hidden question's answer is not stored in Magpie. A pasted JSON document adds not equals, contains, answered and not answered, with several rules on one question.

Design

Tally gives a form your own colours, fonts, logo and cover picture, with columns, pictures and video. Magpie offers seven themes and one column of questions, and nothing of your own beyond them.

WhatTallyMagpie
Give a form my own colours, fonts, logo and cover picture Source Magpie: Appearance offers seven themes, Plain, Paper, Blue, Dark, Magpie, Ink and Sage; there are no colours, fonts, logo or cover picture of your own, and nothing else about a form's look can be changed. Yes Partly
Put questions side by side in columns Source Magpie: Questions, headings and text run one under another down the page. Yes No
Put pictures, videos, maps and other web content in a form Source Magpie: A form holds questions, headings, text and dividers; there is no picture, video or other embedded content. Yes No
Use highlights, links and other formatting in a form's text Source Magpie: Headings, plain text and dividers can go between questions, but the text has no bold, links or lists. Yes Partly
Show a form's standard text, such as its messages, in my respondents' language Source Magpie: A form's buttons and messages follow the team's language for customers, which is English, French, Spanish or German; no other language is offered. Yes Partly
Remove the form tool's name from my forms Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A form's buttons and messages follow the team's language for customers: English, French, Spanish or German. On a paid plan the Magpie link under a form can be turned off.

Sharing

Both publish a form at a link of its own and embed it in a page of another website. Tally also opens a form as a pop-up, and on Pro it shows forms at your own domain.

WhatTallyMagpie
Publish a form and send people its link Source Yes Yes
Put a form inside my own website, or open it there as a pop-up Source Magpie: Form settings gives a published form's code to paste into a page of any website, where visitors answer it without a Magpie account. A form that takes a payment or needs a sign-in opens on its own page instead, and there is no pop-up. Yes Partly
Show a form at my own domain, at an address I choose Source Magpie: A form's address is made from its first title and cannot be changed. Store, websites and Link-In-Bio Lists connect a domain of their own; forms do not. Yes No

Good to know: Close form in Magpie stops new responses and keeps every one already sent. A published form can also be shown beside a screen recording or under a Supporters post.

Responses, insights and notifications

Both email you each new response and sum up each question's answers. Tally draws charts, works out NPS and makes a PDF of each response. On Pro it keeps partial responses and counts drop-off.

WhatTallyMagpie
See each question's answers as charts, with Net Promoter and satisfaction scores worked out Source Magpie: Summary lists each choice's count and percentage in a table and every text answer, but draws no chart and works out no score. Yes Partly
See how many people visit a form, where they came from and on what device Source Magpie: The Forms list shows each form's views; where visitors came from, their devices and their places are not shown. Yes Partly
See how many people start a form, how many finish, and where they stop Source Magpie: The Forms list shows each form's views and responses; there is no count of people who started, no completion rate or time taken, and no drop-off by question. Yes Partly
See what people answered before they gave up on a form Source Magpie: Only sent responses are kept; answers typed into a form that is never sent are lost. Yes No
Get each response as a PDF to keep or send Source Magpie: A response is read on its own page and in the CSV export; nothing makes a PDF of it. Yes No
Have each new response emailed to me and to other people Source Magpie: The form's creator gets an email with a link to each new response, unless Email me for new responses is off; nobody else is told. Yes Partly
Email the person who answered, such as a copy of their answers or their score Source Magpie: The respondent sees the closing message; Forms emails them nothing. Yes No
Have a form's responses deleted automatically after a set time Source Magpie: Responses are kept until someone deletes them one at a time, or the form itself is deleted. Yes No

Good to know: Each Magpie response keeps the version of the form it answered. Summary lists each choice's count and percentage, and every text answer.

Integrations and AI

Both send each response to a webhook as it arrives, which reaches Zapier and Make, and both have an API. On its Free plan, Tally also sends responses straight to Google Sheets, Notion, Airtable and Slack, and Claude can read them. They do it better than we do today.

WhatTallyMagpie
Have responses go into a spreadsheet as they arrive Source Magpie: Export CSV writes every response, and Spreadsheets can import that file as a new spreadsheet, but it is a copy that new responses do not reach. A webhook sends each new response to another app, such as Zapier or Make, as it arrives. Yes Partly
Send each response to my other tools, such as Notion, Airtable, Slack or Zapier Source Magpie: A webhook in Forms sends each new response to Zapier, Make or your own server as it arrives, signed and tried again if it fails, on every plan. Magpie connects directly to no Notion, Airtable, Slack or Google Sheets for form responses. Yes Partly
Measure a form's visits in Google Analytics or a Meta Pixel Source Magpie: The Forms list counts each form's views; nothing is sent to analytics or advertising tools. Yes No
Read and change forms and responses from my own programs Source Yes Yes
Ask Claude or ChatGPT to read my responses and sum them up Source Magpie: Claude or ChatGPT connected through Connected apps can, like the assistant, list a form's responses by status and date, but cannot read their answers. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie webhook signs each response it sends and tries a failed one again over about two days. Webhooks work on every plan, the Free plan included.

Teams, plans and privacy

Both have no limit on forms or responses on the Free plan. Building Tally forms with other people needs Pro; a free Magpie team has 3 places.

WhatTallyMagpie
Build forms with my team without paying Source Tally: Inviting team members to shared workspaces needs Pro. No Yes
Have as many people in my team as I need Source Magpie: A team on the Team plan has places for 25 members; a larger group needs more than one team. Yes Partly
Let someone read one form and its responses without being able to change them Source Tally: Every member of a workspace has the same rights to create, edit, view and delete its forms; only the organisation's owner has more. No Yes
Make as many forms and take as many responses as I need, free Source Yes Yes
Keep my forms' answers in Europe Source Magpie: Magpie follows GDPR and signs data processing agreements, but its data may be processed outside Europe, and there is no choice of where it is kept. Yes No

Good to know: Collaborators in Magpie gives someone Can view or Can edit on one form. Someone from outside the team joins as a guest and sees nothing else in the team.

Price comparison

How Tally charges

Tally charges by plan: Free, Pro and Business, billed monthly or yearly. Free has no limit on forms or responses, under a fair use policy, and includes logic, payments and integrations. Pro adds your own domain, team members, partial responses, drop-off and removing the Tally badge. Business adds email checks and responses deleted after a set time. Tally adds no fee to Stripe's. Prices are on Tally's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account: Forms, bookings, invoicing, a website and the rest. The plan sets how many team members you have and whether the Magpie link shows under a form. It does not limit forms or responses. Magpie takes 4% of paid forms. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planTallyMagpie
Forms and responsesNo limit on Free, under a fair use policyNo limit on any plan
Fee on payments in a formNone from Tally; Stripe's fees apply4% of each payment, and Stripe's fees
Removing the brandingProAny paid plan
People who build formsPro, with any number of members3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan
File uploads10 MB a file on Free, any size on Pro10 MB a file: PDF, pictures or plain text
Forms at your own domainProNot available
Partial responses and drop-offProNot available
Version history7 days on Free, 30 on Pro, 90 on BusinessNot available; each response keeps its version
Email checks and response deletionBusinessNot available
Booking pages, invoicing and a websiteNot offeredIncluded

When to choose Magpie or Tally

  • Want your forms beside your bookings, invoices, contacts and website, with a free team that builds them together? Go with Magpie.
  • Want to build forms as fast as typing, with calculations, your own look and integrations, all free? Tally is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a startup or a maker who builds many forms
Tally. The editor is a page you type on, and the Free plan has logic, calculations and integrations. Magpie adds each question from a list, in one of seven themes.
For a team that keeps its work in Notion or Airtable
Tally. Each response goes to Notion, Airtable, Google Sheets or Slack as it arrives, on the Free plan. Magpie sends each response to a webhook, such as Zapier's, and connects to none of these directly.
For a researcher running surveys
Tally. Ranking, grids, recalled answers, charts and NPS scores cover a survey from start to finish. Magpie's Summary lists each choice's count and percentage in a table.
For a service business taking enquiries or applications
Magpie. The form, the booking page, the contact and the invoice are in the same team. No plan limits how many responses the forms take.
For a small team on no budget
Magpie. A free team has places for 3 members, who build the same forms. Inviting other people to build Tally forms needs Pro.
For a paid registration or an order
Either. Tally takes no fee and works out a price from the answers. Magpie charges one fixed amount, with the payer's contact and invoices in the same team. Choose by whether the price changes with the answers.
For a teacher setting quizzes
Either. Tally scores a quiz in a form that anyone can answer from a link. Magpie's quizzes are inside Courses, with a pass mark. Choose by whether the quiz stands alone or belongs to a course.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Tally and Magpie?

Tally is a form builder you type into like a document. Its Free plan has logic, payments, embeds and integrations. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Forms is one area beside booking pages, invoicing, contacts, e-signatures and a website. Tally does more inside the form; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Tally?

Yes, for a business whose forms are enquiries, registrations, applications, feedback and RSVPs. Magpie builds them with pages and conditions, takes files and payments, and has no response limit.

Consider keeping Tally if you send responses straight to Notion, Airtable or Google Sheets. Keep it too for calculations, quizzes, your own look or forms at your own domain. Tally does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Tally cost?

Tally has Free, Pro and Business plans, billed monthly or yearly. Free has no limit on forms or responses, under a fair use policy. Pro adds team members, your own domain, partial responses and removing the badge. Business adds email checks and responses deleted after a set time. The prices are on Tally's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. No plan limits a form's responses. A paid plan removes the Magpie link under a form. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Magpie takes 4% of paid forms. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Can I build a Magpie form by typing, like in Tally?

Partly. The editor saves as you type. Each question is added with Add question and given an answer type from a list. Nothing is typed straight onto the form. Paste JSON builds a whole form from one document. Tally's editor is a blank page where a slash adds each question.

Does Magpie use AI to build forms?

Partly. The assistant can make a draft form from one of the starting points. So can Claude or ChatGPT through Connected apps. Copy the prompt has your own chatbot write a JSON document to paste. Nothing in Magpie writes or changes a form's questions from a description. Tally AI does both inside the editor.

Can I embed a Magpie form on my website?

Yes, in a page. Form settings gives a published form's code to paste into a page of your website, and visitors answer it there. A form that takes a payment or needs a sign-in opens on its own page instead, and there is no pop-up. Tally's embed code puts a form in a page, across a whole page or in a pop-up.

Does Magpie connect forms to Notion, Airtable, Slack or Zapier?

Partly. A webhook in Forms sends each new response to Zapier, Make or your own server as it arrives, on every plan. Magpie connects to no Notion, Airtable or Slack directly. On Pro, an API key reads forms and their responses through the REST API. Tally sends responses to each of these, and to webhooks, on its Free plan.

Can Magpie send form responses to a spreadsheet?

Not within Magpie. Export CSV writes every response, and Spreadsheets can import that file as a new spreadsheet. New responses do not reach that copy. A webhook sends each new response to another app, such as Zapier, as it arrives. Tally adds each new response to Google Sheets as a row.

Does Magpie have conditional logic?

Yes. A question is shown only when another question's answer equals a value you enter. A pasted JSON document adds not equals, contains, answered and not answered, with several rules on one question. A condition does not skip a page or make a question required, as Tally's logic can.

Does Magpie have quizzes or calculations?

No, not in Forms: a form has no right answers, scores or totals. Courses has quizzes with a pass mark inside a course's lessons. Tally's calculated fields add up points, show a score and set a payment amount.

Can I take payments in a Magpie form?

Yes. A paid form charges one fixed amount for each response by card, through your team's own Stripe account. Magpie takes 4% of each payment, and Stripe's card fees apply. Tally adds no fee to Stripe's and can work out the amount from the answers.

Does Magpie have a signature question?

No. Forms has no signature question. E-Signatures sends a PDF by email to the signers you name. Tally's Signature question saves each signature with the answers, on every plan.

Can I show a Magpie form at my own domain?

No. A form's address is made from its first title and cannot be changed. Store, websites and Link-In-Bio Lists connect a domain of their own; forms do not. Tally shows forms at your own domain on Pro, each at a path you choose.

Can I give a Magpie form my own colours and logo?

No. Appearance offers seven themes: Plain, Paper, Blue, Dark, Magpie, Ink and Sage. There are no colours, fonts, logo or cover picture of your own. Tally takes all four on every plan, and custom CSS on Pro.

Does Magpie save partial responses?

No. Magpie keeps only the responses people send. Answers typed into a form that is never sent are lost. Tally keeps partial submissions on Pro, and can save a respondent's answers in their browser for later.

Can I go back to an earlier version of a Magpie form?

No. Edits stay a draft until you choose Publish changes, and each response keeps the version it answered. No earlier version can be brought back. Tally restores a version from the last 7 days on Free, 30 on Pro and 90 on Business.

Can my team build forms together for free?

Yes, in Magpie. A free team has places for 3 members, and the Team plan 25. Collaborators gives someone Can view or Can edit on one form. Inviting other people to build Tally forms with you needs Pro.

Does Tally have booking pages or invoicing?

No. Tally puts a Calendly or Cal.com calendar inside a form, and has no invoices. Magpie includes Meetings, Appointments and Invoicing in every plan, in the same team as Forms.

Does Magpie keep my data in Europe?

No. Magpie follows GDPR and signs data processing agreements, but its data may be processed outside Europe. There is no choice of where it is kept. Tally is made and hosted in the EU.

Can I use Tally and Magpie together?

Yes. A Tally form can send people to a Magpie booking page or a Store product when they finish. Magpie runs the bookings, invoices, contacts and website, and Tally the forms.

How do I move my forms from Tally to Magpie?

Make each form again in Forms, or have a chatbot write it. Copy the prompt in Forms gives a chatbot the JSON format. Paste JSON builds the form from what it writes. Nothing reads a Tally form directly. Your old responses stay in Tally, which downloads them as a CSV file.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Forms with every question type, paid forms and no response limit, with the Magpie link under each form. Booking pages, Invoicing, Contacts, Store, 1 website, the Newsletter and a team of 3. A paid plan removes the Magpie link and adds the API and email at your domain.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Tally changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Tally's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Make a form on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then make your first form.

Create account