Harvest compared with Magpie

Harvest vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Harvest and Magpie both track a team's time by client and project, and both turn it into invoices. They are built around different things.

  1. Harvest is a time tracker with project budgets, expenses, invoicing and reports around it. It is built for a team that sells its hours: an agency, a studio, a consultancy. It shows what each project earns.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Time Tracking is one part of it. Beside the timer it includes proposals, invoices paid online, the books, payroll and booking pages. It is built for someone who tracks time in order to be paid for it.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s Time Tracking day view: three entries on client projects, among them a 1 hour 30 minute plan for the Wolcott Coffee packaging shoot, each with its times, project and Contact, and the day’s total of 4 hours 10 minutes.

How is Magpie different?

1. Tracked time goes straight into the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a business that bills by the hour would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Time Tracking, with projects, tags, rates and reports
  • Proposals, which make a Time Tracking project with its client, rate and hours when the client accepts
  • Invoicing, which adds unbilled time to an invoice the client pays online by card
  • Accounting, which records each invoice and payment and shows the profit on each project
  • Payroll, which reads each person's hours from Time Tracking
  • Contacts, Expenses, Staff Scheduling, Meetings and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Harvest copies invoices and payments to QuickBooks Online or Xero for the books. It plans people's weeks in Forecast, a separate product.

2. The Free plan has no project limit

On Magpie's Free plan, Time Tracking has no limit on entries, projects or tags. A team has 3 members. Rates, billing and invoices from time are included, with 5 invoices a month. Harvest's Free plan is for one person and 2 projects.

3. A team pays one price

The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, with every area included. Adding a person, up to that number, does not change the bill. Harvest's paid plans are priced for each person, each month.

Comparing Magpie and Harvest

Harvest does more inside time tracking and project budgets; Magpie does more with the time once it is tracked. Every line in the tables below was checked against Harvest's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatHarvestMagpie
Timer and time added by handStart and stop a timer, or add time already spent Yes Yes
Weekly timesheetType hours into a grid of projects and days Yes Partly
Calendar of time entriesEntries as blocks, dragged to add or move Yes No
Reminders to track timeAn email or browser reminder on chosen days Yes No
Projects, clients and tasksTime grouped under each client's projects, by kind of work Yes Tags, not tasks
Billable ratesA rate for the project, each person or each task Yes Project or client
Project budgetsHours or money used against a budget Yes Hours only
Budget alertsAn email when a project passes part of its budget Yes No
Fixed-fee and retainer projectsA set price, or a budget that starts again each month Yes No
Expenses with receiptsCosts on a project, with a photo of the receipt Yes Yes
MileageMiles entered at a rate per mile Yes No
Invoices from tracked timeBillable time and expenses brought onto an invoice Yes Your own time
Invoices paid onlineThe client pays the invoice online Card, ACH or PayPal Card
Quotes the client accepts onlineAn estimate or proposal accepted on its page Yes Yes
Proposal becomes a projectAn accepted offer sets up the project No Yes
BookkeepingBooks kept from invoices and payments Through QuickBooks Online or Xero Yes
PayrollPeople paid from their hours Through Gusto Yes
ReportsTime by client, project and person, and every entry Yes Yes
Saved and scheduled reportsA report kept, shared and emailed each week or month Yes No
Profit from cost ratesWhat people's time costs against what it earns Enterprise Partly
Capacity and schedulingPeople's hours against what they can work, and plans ahead Forecast, separate Shifts only
Timesheet approvalsA period of time approved, then locked Enterprise No
Editing a teammate's timeA manager adds or corrects someone's entries Yes No
Phone and desktop appsTrack time from an app on a phone or computer Yes In the browser
Timers inside other toolsA browser extension, and timers in Asana, Trello or Jira Yes Inside Magpie only
IntegrationsTime connected to other software 68 listed Magpie's own areas
Import from a spreadsheetBring entries and projects over from CSV Yes No
APIRead and record time from other software Yes Pro
Single sign-onSign in through the company's identity provider Enterprise No
Free plan for a teamSeveral people and any number of projects without paying One person, 2 projects Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Time tracking

Both run a timer and add past time as a length or a start and end. Harvest adds a weekly grid to type hours into, a calendar to drag on, reminders and an idle timer. They do it better than we do today.

WhatHarvestMagpie
Start a timer when work starts and stop it when it ends Source Yes Yes
Add time already spent, as a length or as a start and end Source Yes Yes
Fill in a week of hours in a grid of projects and days Source Magpie: Week shows time by project and day. Selecting a cell opens that day with the project chosen in Add time, so each day is added as its own entry; hours cannot be typed into the grid, and last week's rows cannot be copied. Yes Partly
See the day and week as blocks on a calendar, and drag to add or move time Source Magpie: Today lists the day's entries in order with their start and end times, and Week totals each project for each day; there is no calendar of entries to drag on. Yes No
Start again on something tracked before, in one tap Source Magpie: Each timer starts from a typed description and a chosen project. A Contact, Issue, To-do or Calendar event can start a timer named after itself. Yes No
Turn calendar events into time entries Source Magpie: A Magpie Calendar event's drawer has Start timer, which takes the event's title and links the entry to the event; the entry records when the timer actually ran. Google Calendar events show on the Personal Calendar but cannot start a timer, Outlook is not connected, and an event's planned time cannot be added as an entry. Yes Partly
Remind people to record their time Source Magpie: Nobody is reminded to record time; the only prompt is about a timer left running for several hours. Yes No
Be asked about time a running timer counted while I was away Source Magpie: When a timer has run for several hours, Magpie asks once whether to stop it or keep it running. It does not notice time away from the computer, and the recorded time changes only when the person edits it. Yes Partly
Move many entries to another project or task at once Source Magpie: An entry's project is changed on its own page, one entry at a time. Yes No
Round time up, or to the nearest step, for billing Source Magpie: A project rounds billed time to the nearest 5, 6, 10 or 15 minutes when it goes on an invoice, and the CSV shows billed time beside recorded time. It never rounds up, and report totals show recorded time. Yes Partly
Make sure every entry says what the work was Source Yes Yes
Make sure every entry has a project Source Magpie: Only a description is needed; a project, tag and Contact are always optional, and there is no setting to require one. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie timer can start from a Contact, an Issue, a To-do, a Calendar event or a shift. The entry is named after it and linked to it. Its time shows in the page bar on every page.

Projects, tasks and budgets

Both group time into projects for each client and mark it billable or not. Harvest adds tasks, a rate for each person, budgets in money, fixed fees, monthly budgets and alerts.

WhatHarvestMagpie
Group time into projects for each client Source Yes Yes
Choose the kinds of work each project uses, such as design or meetings, each billable or not Source Magpie: Team admins add tags, which label the kind of work across every project; an entry can have one, and Reports totals time by tag. A tag cannot be kept to some projects, and it does not set billing or a rate. Yes Partly
Mark time as billable or not, and keep some projects non-billable Source Yes Yes
Charge a different hourly rate for each person Source Magpie: A new entry's rate comes from its project, then its Contact, then the Invoicing default, and an admin can set a rate on the entry itself. No rate depends on who did the work. Yes Partly
Give a project a budget in hours, overall or for each task, and see how much is used Source Magpie: Hour budget on a project shows the completed time everyone in the team has recorded on it, on the project and in the list of projects. There is no budget for a task or a person. Yes Partly
Give a project a budget in money, and see how much the time and expenses have used Source Magpie: A project's budget is in hours only; nothing compares the value of its time or its expenses with a sum of money. Yes No
Compare the time spent on a fixed-price job with its price Source Magpie: A project has an hourly rate and an hour budget, not a price. A Proposal can price work as a one-off sum, but that price is not compared with the time tracked. Yes No
Give a project a budget that starts again every month, as for a retainer Source Magpie: A project's hour budget counts all the time ever recorded on it; it does not start again. Yes No
Be told when a project reaches part of its budget Source Magpie: The project shows time used against its hour budget; nobody is told when it gets close or goes over. Yes No
Start a new project as a copy of an earlier one, with its tasks, rates and people Source Magpie: A new project starts with only its name, and its settings are filled in on its page; an accepted Proposal can make one with its client, rate and hours. Yes No
Let each person track time only to the projects they are on Source Magpie: Every member of a team can choose every active project, and what members see of each other's time is one setting for the whole team. Yes No
Start a project from an accepted proposal, with its client, rate and hours Source Harvest: An accepted estimate becomes an invoice, but Harvest cannot turn it into a project; the project is set up by hand. No Yes

Good to know: When a client accepts a Proposal, Magpie can make the Time Tracking project for it. The project takes the client, the currency, the hourly rate and the hours as its budget.

Expenses

Both record an expense on a project with a photo of its receipt. Harvest adds a rate per mile and bills every billable expense to the client.

WhatHarvestMagpie
Record expenses on a project with a photo of the receipt Source Yes Yes
Claim mileage at a rate per mile Source Magpie: An expense is entered as an amount; a category has no rate per mile or other unit. Yes No
Have expenses approved before people are paid back Source Yes Yes
Put the team's billable expenses on the client's invoice Source Magpie: Add unbilled expenses lists only the admin's own reimbursable expenses with that contact; an expense the business paid, or one a teammate recorded, cannot go on the invoice. Yes Partly

Good to know: In Magpie, people put reimbursable expenses on a report and submit it. An admin approves it, or rejects it with a reason, then marks it reimbursed.

Invoicing and payments

Both turn billable time into an invoice, add tax and a discount, repeat invoices and remind late payers. Harvest also takes ACH and PayPal, holds retainers and bills the whole team's time.

WhatHarvestMagpie
Turn tracked time into an invoice for the client Source Yes Yes
Bill a client for the time the whole team tracked Source Magpie: Add unbilled time lists only the admin's own entries, so a teammate's billable time cannot go on the client's invoice. Yes Partly
See all the billable time and expenses not yet invoiced, for each client Source Magpie: Reports filters time by Contact and billing, but not by whether it was invoiced; an admin sees their own unbilled time for one contact at a time in Add unbilled time. Yes No
Send a quote that the client accepts online, then invoice it Source Yes Yes
Add tax and a discount to an invoice, in the client's currency Source Yes Yes
Let the client pay an invoice online by card, bank payment or PayPal Source Magpie: With the team's Stripe account connected, the invoice email has Pay online, and the client pays by card without signing in; Magpie takes no fee. Bank payments and PayPal are not taken online. Yes Partly
Send the same invoice every month or quarter Source Yes Yes
Remind a client automatically when an invoice is late Source Yes Yes
Take money up front as a retainer and have later invoices paid from it Source Magpie: A Proposal can take a deposit when it is accepted, and recurring invoices can bill a monthly retainer fee, but no balance is held for the client for later invoices to draw from. Yes Partly
Have invoices and payments go into the books without typing them again Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie takes no fee on invoices paid online. The client pays by card through your own Stripe account, and Stripe's card fees apply. Accounting records each invoice and payment by itself.

Reports and analysis

Both total time by client, project and person for any dates, and list every entry. Harvest adds visual reports, PDF and Excel files, saved and emailed reports, and an uninvoiced report.

WhatHarvestMagpie
See total time by client, project and person for any dates Source Yes Yes
List every entry for a period, filtered Source Yes Yes
Download a report as a spreadsheet or a PDF Source Magpie: Export CSV downloads every matching entry with its billed time and amount; there is no PDF or Excel file of a report. Yes Partly
Save a report's settings and share it with the team Source Magpie: A report is chosen afresh from its filters each time. Its filters are in the page address, but nothing is saved or shared. Yes No
Get a time report by email every week or month Source Magpie: Reports are opened when someone wants them; nothing is emailed on a schedule. Yes No
See the profit on projects and clients from what people's time costs Source Magpie: Accounting's Profit by project report shows each Time Tracking project's income from invoices billed from its time or expenses, its costs from expenses and bills given the project, and the profit. A person's time has no cost rate, so time worked is not counted as a cost. Yes Partly
See each person's hours against how many they can work Source Magpie: When a team compares its schedule with Time Tracking, Staff Scheduling's Scheduled and worked report shows when each person started and stopped against their shift, and each person's preferred and maximum weekly hours guide the schedule. Nothing compares tracked or billable time with the hours someone can work. Yes Partly
See who changed which entries and projects, and when Source Magpie: Each person changes only their own entries, and no history of changes to entries or projects is kept. A team's Audit log lists changes to its members, roles and settings, not to time. Yes No
Plan who works on which project in the weeks ahead Source Harvest: Forecast, a separate Harvest product with its own price, schedules people onto projects and shows their capacity; connected to Harvest, it compares scheduled time with tracked time.Magpie: Staff Scheduling plans shifts with people's availability and time off, but no project work is planned against people's hours. Partly No

Good to know: Accounting's Profit by project shows each Time Tracking project's income from invoices and its costs from expenses and bills. Export CSV gives every entry with its billed time.

Teams, approvals and security

Both choose what members see of each other's time and of rates. Harvest adds managers, approvals, locked periods, editing a teammate's time, a log of changes to entries and single sign-on.

WhatHarvestMagpie
Add or correct a teammate's time Source Magpie: Each person adds and changes only their own entries; admins see the team's time, read only, in Reports. Yes No
Have each person's timesheet approved before it is billed Source Magpie: Time is not submitted or approved. Staff Scheduling approves shift changes and time off, and Expenses approves expense reports, but nothing approves tracked time. Yes No
Stop time before a date being changed Source Magpie: Time on a draft invoice cannot change until its line is removed, and invoiced time never changes. Other past time can be changed by its owner at any time. Yes Partly
Give project managers rights over only their projects and people Source Magpie: A team's people are admins, members or guests, and admins choose the areas each member can use and whether members can edit or only view. There is no role between admin and member, and nothing is limited to some projects. Yes Partly
Choose what members see of each other's time and of rates Source Yes Yes
Bring time, projects and people over from a spreadsheet Source Magpie: Time is added in Magpie or through the API; there is no import of entries or projects. Yes No
Sign in through the company's identity provider Source Magpie: Magpie signs in with a password, a passkey, or a Google, Apple, GitHub or LinkedIn account, but not through a company identity provider. Yes No
Track time for a team of any size Source Magpie: A team has up to 3 members on Free and up to 25 on the Team plan, which is one price for the whole team. Yes Partly
Track time for free on any number of projects Source Harvest: The Free plan is for one person and 2 projects; more people or projects need a paid plan. Partly Yes

Good to know: A Magpie team has up to 3 members on Free and 25 on the Team plan. Admins choose the areas each member can use.

Apps and integrations

Harvest has apps for iPhone, Android, Mac and Windows, browser extensions, and timers inside Asana, Trello, Jira and Slack. Magpie's Time Tracking works in the browser, on a computer or a phone.

WhatHarvestMagpie
Track time from an app on the phone or the computer Source Magpie: Time Tracking works in a phone's browser, and the timer is kept by Magpie, so it carries between devices. The Magpie app for iPhone and Android is built but not yet in the App Store or Google Play, and there is no desktop app. Yes No
Start a timer from inside the other tools the team uses Source Magpie: Contacts, Issues, To-dos, Calendar events and Staff Scheduling shifts start a timer linked to themselves inside Magpie; nothing adds a timer to other websites or to Slack. Yes Partly
Connect time tracking to the other apps the business uses Source Magpie: Time links to Magpie's own Issues, To-dos, Contacts, Calendar events and shifts, and goes onto Magpie invoices, which Accounting records; it does not connect to Zapier, QuickBooks or Xero. Yes Partly
Read and record time through an API Source Yes Yes

Good to know: The timer is kept by Magpie, so a timer started on the computer is still running on the phone. The Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play.

Price comparison

How Harvest charges

Harvest charges for each person, each month, on Teams or Enterprise, with a lower price paid yearly. Its Free plan is for one person and 2 projects. Enterprise adds timesheet approvals, the Profitability report, the activity log and single sign-on. Forecast, for planning people's weeks, is a separate product. Prices are on Harvest's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. Time Tracking has no plan limit, and its rates and billing are on every plan. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planHarvestMagpie
How a team paysFor each person, each monthOne Team plan for up to 25 people
Free planOne person and 2 projectsA team of 3, with no limit on projects
Invoices from tracked timeEvery planEvery plan; 5 invoices a month on Free
Invoices paid onlineThrough your Stripe or PayPal accountStripe's card fees, through your own Stripe account
Timesheet approvals and profitabilityEnterpriseProfit by project in Accounting; no approvals
Planning people's weeksForecast, a separate productStaff Scheduling for shifts, included
BookkeepingQuickBooks Online or Xero, Teams and aboveAccounting, included
APIIncludedPro
Single sign-onEnterpriseNot available

When to choose Magpie or Harvest

  • Want tracked time to become proposals, invoices paid online, the books and payroll, for one price for the team? Go with Magpie.
  • Want weekly timesheets, budgets in money with alerts, approvals and apps on every device? Harvest is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For an agency or a studio with fixed-fee and retainer work
Harvest. Fixed Fee projects, budgets in money, monthly budgets and alerts show how each job is going. Magpie's projects have an hour budget only.
For a team that approves timesheets before billing
Harvest. People submit each period, managers approve it, and approved time is locked, on Enterprise. Magpie has no approval of tracked time.
For a freelancer
Magpie. Any number of projects, rates and invoices are on the Free plan, and the client pays online. Harvest's Free plan has 2 projects.
For a consultancy that sends proposals
Magpie. An accepted proposal becomes the project, its time goes on an invoice, and Accounting records it. Harvest turns an estimate into an invoice, and the project is set up by hand.
For a small team that bills by the hour
Either. Harvest bills the whole team's time on one invoice and edits a teammate's time. Magpie costs one price for the team and keeps the books. Choose by whether the timesheet or the rest of the business matters more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Harvest and Magpie?

Harvest is a time tracker with project budgets, expenses, invoicing and reports, and apps on every device. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Time Tracking is one area beside proposals, invoices paid online, the books and payroll. Harvest does more inside time tracking; Magpie does more with the time once it is tracked.

Does Magpie replace Harvest?

Yes, for a business that tracks its own time and bills clients for it. Magpie runs the timer and groups time by project and client. Billable time goes on an invoice the client pays online.

Consider keeping Harvest if your team fills in a weekly timesheet and has it approved. Keep it if you work to budgets in money. Keep it too for the phone and desktop apps, reminders to track, or timers inside Asana or Jira. Harvest does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Harvest cost?

Harvest has a Free plan for one person and 2 projects. Its paid plans, Teams and Enterprise, are priced for each person each month. Paying yearly costs less. Approvals, the Profitability report and single sign-on need Enterprise. The prices are on Harvest's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Time Tracking has no plan limit, and a team has 3 members on Free. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have a weekly timesheet?

Partly. Week shows time by project and day, and selecting a cell opens that day to add an entry. Hours cannot be typed into the grid, and last week's rows cannot be copied. Harvest's Week view takes hours typed into each day and copies the last timesheet's rows.

Does Magpie remind people to track their time?

No. Magpie asks only about a timer left running for several hours. Reminders are on Magpie's roadmap. Harvest sends each person email or browser reminders on the days they choose.

Does Magpie have tasks on projects?

Partly. Tags label the kind of work across every project, and Reports totals time by tag. A tag cannot be kept to some projects, and it sets no rate or billing. Harvest's tasks are chosen for each project, each billable or not, with a rate of its own.

Does Magpie have project budgets in money?

No. A Magpie project's budget is in hours, counting all the time recorded on it. There is no budget in money, no fixed fee and no alert. The budget does not start again each month. Harvest has all four on every plan.

Can I set a different hourly rate for each person?

No. A Magpie entry's rate comes from its project, its Contact or the Invoicing default. A team admin can change it on the entry. No rate depends on who did the work. Harvest sets rates for the project, each person or each task.

Can I invoice the time my whole team tracked?

Not yet in Magpie. Add unbilled time lists only the invoicing admin's own entries. Harvest's invoice brings in the billable hours everyone tracked on the project in the chosen dates.

Does Magpie have timesheet approvals?

No. Tracked time is not submitted or approved. Staff Scheduling approves shift changes and time off, and Expenses approves expense reports. Harvest has people submit each period's time and expenses for approval, on Enterprise.

Can I see the profit on each project?

Partly. Accounting's Profit by project shows each project's income from invoices and its costs from expenses and bills. A person's time has no cost rate, so it is not counted as a cost. Harvest's Profitability report counts each person's cost rate, on Enterprise.

Can clients pay a Magpie invoice by bank payment or PayPal?

Not online. Pay online takes a card through your Stripe account, and Magpie takes no fee. A bank payment is recorded on the invoice by hand. Harvest takes card and ACH through Stripe, and PayPal.

Does Harvest have proposals or accounting?

Harvest sends estimates the client accepts online, and an accepted estimate becomes an invoice, not a project. It copies invoices and payments to QuickBooks Online or Xero. Magpie's Proposals turn an accepted offer into a Time Tracking project, and Accounting keeps the books.

Does Magpie have a phone or desktop app for time tracking?

Time Tracking works in a phone's or a computer's browser, and the running timer carries between them. The Magpie app tracks time on a phone. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. There is no desktop app or browser extension. Harvest has apps for iPhone, Android, Mac and Windows, and extensions for Chrome and Edge.

Can I track time from Asana, Trello or Jira?

Not in Magpie. A timer starts inside Magpie from a Contact, an Issue, a To-do, a Calendar event or a shift. Harvest puts a timer inside Asana, Basecamp, Trello, Jira, ClickUp and Slack.

Can a manager add or correct a teammate's time in Magpie?

No. Each person adds and changes only their own entries, and team admins see everyone's time in Reports. Harvest lets admins, and managers given permission, change a teammate's timesheet.

Can I import my Harvest time into Magpie?

No. Magpie has no import of entries or projects. Time is added in Magpie, or through the API on Pro. Importing time is on Magpie's roadmap. Harvest exports reports as CSV, Excel or PDF, so earlier time can be kept as files.

How do I move from Harvest to Magpie?

Add your projects and tags in Time Tracking, and link each project to its client in Contacts. Set each project's rate and billing, then start tracking in Magpie. Export your Harvest reports before you stop paying for it.

Can I use Harvest and Magpie together?

Yes. A team can track time in Harvest and use Magpie for proposals, booking pages, payroll or the books. Harvest's time does not reach Magpie by itself, so each invoice's lines are added by hand.

Does Magpie have an API for time tracking?

Yes, on Pro. An API key reaches entries, the timer, splitting, projects, tags and reports. Harvest's API covers time, expenses and projects, with OAuth2 or a personal access token.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Time Tracking with rates, billing and reports, and Invoicing with 5 invoices a month. Proposals with 5 a month, 100 contacts, Expenses and Accounting are included. So are Payroll for 2 employees, booking pages and a team of 3.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Harvest changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Harvest's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Track time and bill it on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then start a timer in Time Tracking.

Create account