Expensify compared with Magpie

Expensify vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Expensify and Magpie both record a business's expenses with their receipts. Both put them on reports that someone approves. They are built around different things.

  1. Expensify is software for expenses: receipts read from a photo, mileage, expense reports, approvals and paying people back. It also has company cards, travel booking, bills and invoices. It is built for a company whose staff spend money for work and are paid back.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Expenses is one part of it. Beside the expenses it includes Accounting, Invoicing, Payroll, a shop, booking pages and a website. It is built for someone whose expenses are one part of running the business.
Create account
All Expenses in Callahan Studio: the filters, then the studio’s expenses newest first, each with its merchant, date, category, receipt, reimbursement, who recorded it and the amount.

How is Magpie different?

1. Expenses comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Expenses, with receipts, recurring expenses and expense reports
  • Accounting for the books, with bills, budgets and bank reconciliation
  • Invoicing, with recurring invoices and online payment
  • Payroll and Time Tracking for the people you pay
  • Store, Meetings, Appointments, Websites, Mail and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Expensify covers expenses, cards, travel, bills and invoices. It exports approved reports to QuickBooks, Xero or another accounting system.

2. Expenses go into the books and onto invoices

When Accounting keeps the team's books, each expense posts to the account for its category. It is paid from the account for its payment method. A reimbursable expense is owed until it is marked reimbursed. Your own expense for a client goes onto their invoice with Add unbilled expenses. A recurring expense, such as rent, makes a draft on each date to confirm.

3. A whole team uses Expenses on the Free plan

Expenses has no plan limit. Personal and every team use all of it free, expense reports and approvals included. A free team has 3 members. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per member.

Comparing Magpie and Expensify

Expensify does more inside expenses; Magpie does more around them. Every line in the tables below was checked against Expensify's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Expenses and receiptsEach expense with its amount, category and receipt Yes Yes
Receipts read from a photoThe merchant, date and total filled in Yes No
Mileage and per diemDistance at a rate, and daily allowances Yes No
Recurring expensesRent or a subscription added on each date No Yes
Expense reports and approvalsExpenses submitted, approved or rejected Yes One approval step
Paying people backReimbursements sent from a business bank account Yes Recorded, paid from your bank
Company cardsCards issued with limits, and card purchases as expenses Yes No
Travel bookingFlights, hotels, cars and trains within a policy Yes No
InvoicingInvoices sent and paid online Yes Yes
Supplier billsBills received and paid Yes Recorded in Accounting
The booksExpenses in the accounts without typing them again QuickBooks, Xero and others, connected Yes
PayrollPay runs for employees Connects to payroll systems on Control Yes
Spending reportsTotals by category, merchant and person Yes Yes
AssistantExpenses recorded and questions answered in plain words Yes Partly
Phone appReceipts and reports on a phone Yes In the browser
Shop, booking pages and a websiteThe rest of a small business No Yes
Free plan for a teamReports and approvals without paying One person only Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Receipts and expenses

Expensify reads each receipt from a photo, an email or a text message. In Magpie, a receipt is uploaded, photographed or pasted, and its details are typed in.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Record an expense with its amount, date, merchant and category Source Yes Yes
Photograph a receipt and have its details filled in Source Magpie: A receipt photo, PDF or pasted image is kept with its expense or waits in Receipt Inbox, and in a phone's browser the upload offers the camera. The amount, date and merchant are typed in; nothing is read from the receipt. Yes Partly
Forward receipts by email, or send them by text message Source Magpie: Receipts are uploaded, dropped or pasted on Expenses, and in a phone's browser the upload offers the camera; there is no address or number to send them to. The Magpie app, not yet in the App Store or Google Play, also takes receipts shared from another app. Yes No
Upload a pile of receipts at once and fill them in later Source Yes Yes
Record an expense paid in another currency and see it in my own Source Magpie: An expense keeps the currency it was paid in, and Expenses totals each currency separately without converting. In Accounting, it waits under Needs an amount until its value in the books' currency is typed in. Yes Partly
Record the sales tax or VAT on an expense so it can be reclaimed Source Yes Yes
Be warned about an expense entered twice Source Yes Yes
Have a subscription or the rent added as an expense every month Source Expensify: No article in the Reports and Expenses help describes a repeating expense; Duplicate expense copies one by hand, dated today and without its receipt. No Yes
Record expenses and receipts in a phone app Source Magpie: Expenses works in a phone's browser, where a receipt's upload offers the camera, and reports, reimbursements, recurring expenses and settings work as on a computer. The Magpie app has all of Expenses, with + Receipt taking a photo with the expense's details, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Photograph receipts with no connection Source Magpie: Expenses needs a connection: a receipt or an expense is saved only when it reaches Magpie. Yes No

Good to know: + Receipt in Magpie uploads several receipts at once, up to 10 MB each. They wait in Receipt Inbox until each has an amount.

Distance, per diem, time and splits

Expensify claims distance, daily allowances and hours at set rates, and splits one receipt several ways. Magpie records each of these as an ordinary expense amount.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Track the miles driven for work and claim them at a rate Source Magpie: Expenses records amounts spent; there is no trip log or rate per mile, so a mileage claim is typed in as an amount. Yes No
Claim a daily allowance for a trip at set rates Source Magpie: Each day's meals and lodging are entered as ordinary expenses with their amounts. Yes No
Claim hours worked at an hourly rate Source Magpie: Time Tracking records hours at a rate and bills them to a client on an invoice, but a person's hours cannot be submitted for approval and paid back like an expense. Yes Partly
Split one receipt across several categories, projects or days Source Magpie: An expense has one category and one project. In Accounting, an imported bank transaction can be split across accounts, but an expense cannot. Yes No
Record who was at a meal, and the cost for each person Source Magpie: The people at a meal can be written in the expense's description or notes; nothing divides the cost between them. Yes No
Split a bill with friends or colleagues Source Magpie: An expense belongs to the person who recorded it; there is no way to share one or ask others for their part. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's Time Tracking records hours at a rate and bills them on an invoice. The hours are not paid back as an expense.

Expense reports and approvals

Both put expenses on a report that is submitted, then approved or rejected with a reason. Expensify adds approval chains, scheduled submission and a chat on every expense. They do it better than we do today.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Put expenses on a report and submit it for approval Source Yes Yes
Approve or reject a report, and say why Source Yes Yes
Send each person's reports to the right approver, with another approver above an amount Source Magpie: Any team admin can approve any submitted report, in one step; no approver is named for a person, and nothing goes to a second approver or is approved automatically. Yes Partly
Have expenses gathered into a report and submitted on a schedule Source Magpie: Each member makes a report, ticks its expenses and submits it. Yes No
Ask and answer questions about an expense where it is Source Magpie: A rejected report carries the admin's reason, which the submitter sees. Other questions go through Chat or email, away from the expense. Yes Partly
Let an assistant or a bookkeeper handle my expenses for me Source Magpie: Only the person who recorded an expense can change it or put it on a report; team admins see everyone's expenses but cannot change them. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie report holds expenses in one currency. While it is submitted, the report and its expenses cannot be changed.

Categories, rules and budgets

Both sort expenses into categories and tag them. Expensify adds spending rules, categories learned from the merchant and budgets with warnings.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Sort expenses into categories, and tag them by project or department Source Yes Yes
Flag expenses that break the team's spending rules Source Magpie: Needs attention, on Overview, lists expenses with no receipt, no category or no merchant; no amount, age or other limit can be set. Yes Partly
Have an expense's category filled in from its merchant Source Magpie: Each expense's category is chosen by hand. Accounting's rules suggest an account for imported bank transactions, not for expenses. Yes No
Set a spending budget and be warned as it is used up Source Magpie: Accounting keeps a budget for each income and expense account month by month, and Budget against actual compares it with what happened. Nothing warns as spending nears it, and a budget cannot be set for a project or a person. Yes Partly

Good to know: A Magpie team starts with 14 categories, which admins rename, add to or archive. Needs attention lists expenses with no receipt, category or merchant.

Reimbursements, bills and invoices

Expensify pays people back from a connected bank account and pays suppliers' bills. Magpie records each payment, and the money is sent from your bank.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Pay people back for their expenses from inside the product Source Magpie: Magpie records that a reimbursement was paid, with its date and a reference; the money is sent from the bank. Yes No
Pay back people in another country, in their own currency Source Magpie: Reimbursements are paid outside Magpie and recorded with a date and a reference, and a report holds expenses in one currency. Yes No
Record a payback made outside the product Source Yes Yes
Send an invoice and be paid online Source Yes Yes
Bill a client for an expense Source Expensify: Expenses can be marked billable, by default or for a merchant; the invoice help describes no way to put them on an Expensify invoice.Magpie: Add unbilled expenses, in the invoice editor, adds your own expenses marked reimbursable for that Contact as draft lines. A purchase on the business card, or a teammate's, can only be typed in. Partly Partly
Receive suppliers' bills by email and pay them Source Magpie: Accounting's Bills records each supplier bill, typed in, and its payments from a bank, card or cash account; the money is sent from the bank, and bills cannot be emailed in. Yes Partly
Have bills approved before they are paid Source Magpie: Admins and accountants enter and pay bills in Accounting; nothing asks anyone to approve them first. Yes No

Good to know: Mark reimbursed in Magpie takes the date and a reference. In Accounting, the amount then leaves Reimbursements owed.

Company cards and travel

Expensify issues its own Visa card, brings in other company cards' purchases and books travel. Magpie does none of these today.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Have company card purchases come in as the cardholder's expenses Source Magpie: A payment method records a card's label and last four digits. Card statements are imported into Accounting as CSV for the books, but they do not become anyone's expenses. Yes No
Check card spending against the card's statement Source Yes Yes
Give the team company cards with spending limits Source Magpie: Magpie does not issue cards; Expenses records which payment method paid. Yes No
Book flights, hotels, cars and trains for the team within a travel policy Source Magpie: Travel is booked elsewhere and its receipts added to Expenses. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's Accounting imports a card statement as CSV. Reconcile ticks each line until the difference is zero.

Reporting, exports and accounting

Both total spending by category, merchant and person, and export expenses with their receipts. Expensify connects to QuickBooks, Xero, NetSuite and Sage Intacct; Magpie keeps the books itself.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
See spending by category, merchant and person for any dates Source Yes Yes
Export expenses and their receipts Source Yes Yes
Download an expense report as a PDF with its receipts Source Magpie: A report's page has no PDF; expenses go out as a CSV, or a ZIP of the CSV and receipts, from All Expenses. Yes No
Have approved expenses go into the books without typing them again Source Yes Yes
Connect to the accounting software I already use Source Magpie: Expenses go into Magpie's own Accounting, or out as a CSV; nothing connects to QuickBooks, Xero or another accounting system. Yes No
Keep the team's people and approvers in step with the HR system Source Magpie: People are invited to a team one at a time, and a team admin changes their role. Yes No

Good to know: Export receipts in Magpie downloads a ZIP with a CSV file and every receipt. Each receipt is named by date, merchant and amount.

Teams, plans and AI

Both invite a team and let admins manage it. Expensify's Concierge does more with expenses than Magpie's assistant does, and Control adds single sign-on.

WhatExpensifyMagpie
Invite the team and choose who manages it Source Yes Yes
Use it free Source Expensify: The free Submit workspace is for one person's expenses, without approvals, payments, company cards or accounting connections. A team pays for each member every month on Collect or Control, and Control costs less on a yearly plan and less again with the Expensify Card. Partly Yes
Ask an assistant to record expenses and answer questions about spending Source Magpie: On Dashboard, the assistant finds your expenses and records a new one from an amount, a merchant and a date. It does not change, submit or approve them, and spending totals come only from Accounting, for admins. Yes Partly
Sign in through a company identity provider Source Magpie: People sign in with a password and two-factor code, a passkey, a sign-in link, or an Apple, Google, LinkedIn or GitHub account. Yes No

Good to know: In Magpie, members see their own expenses and admins see the team's. Only admins approve reports and manage categories.

Price comparison

How Expensify charges

Expensify charges by plan. Submit is free, for one person's expenses. Collect and Control are for a team, priced per member each month. Collect adds approvals, payments and QuickBooks or Xero. Control adds per diem, spending rules, NetSuite, Sage Intacct and single sign-on. Spending on the Expensify Card takes up to 50% off the subscription. Prices are on Expensify's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. Expenses has no plan limit, so reports and approvals are on Free. The plan sets how many people a team has, not which areas it uses. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planExpensifyMagpie
How a team paysPer member, per month, on Collect or ControlOne Team plan for up to 25 people
Using it freeSubmit, for one person's expensesAll of Expenses, in a team of 3
Expense reports and approvalsCollect and ControlEvery plan
Per diem, spending rules and multi-level tagsControlNot available
Paying people backFrom a business bank account in USD, CAD, GBP, EUR or AUDRecorded in Magpie, sent from your bank
Paying suppliers' billsNo fee by bank transfer, 2.9% by card, in USD onlyRecorded in Accounting, sent from your bank
Travel bookingA fee per tripNot available
The booksQuickBooks and Xero on Collect; NetSuite and Sage Intacct on ControlAccounting, included
Single sign-onControlNot available

When to choose Magpie or Expensify

  • Want expenses beside the books, invoices and payroll, with the whole team on the Free plan? Go with Magpie.
  • Want receipts read from a photo, mileage by GPS, company cards and bank reimbursements? Expensify is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a company whose staff travel for work
Expensify. SmartScan reads each receipt, the app logs drives by GPS, and per diem pays daily allowances. Travel books the trip within a policy. Magpie has none of these today.
For a team with company cards
Expensify. Card purchases arrive as the cardholder's expenses, and the Expensify Card sets limits on each card. Magpie records which card paid, and its details are typed in.
For a sole trader or a freelancer
Magpie. Expenses, recurring expenses and the books are on the Free plan. An expense for a client goes onto their invoice, and Time Tracking bills the hours.
For a small business that keeps its own books
Magpie. Each expense posts to the books by itself, beside invoices, Store sales and pay runs. Expensify exports approved reports to QuickBooks, Xero or another accounting system.
For a small team with a few claims a month
Either. Both put expenses on a report that an admin approves. Expensify reads the receipts and sends the money. Magpie is free for the team and keeps the books. Choose by whether reading receipts or keeping the books matters more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Expensify and Magpie?

Expensify is software for expenses: it reads receipts, logs mileage, approves reports and pays people back. It also has company cards and travel booking. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Expenses is one area beside Accounting, Invoicing, Payroll and Store. Expensify does more inside expenses; Magpie does more around them.

Does Magpie replace Expensify?

Yes, for a small business that records its own expenses and approves a few reports. Magpie keeps receipts, repeats recurring expenses and posts each expense to the books. An admin approves each report and marks it reimbursed.

Consider keeping Expensify if you want receipts read from a photo, mileage or per diem. Keep it too for company cards, travel booking, or people paid back from the bank. Expensify does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Expensify cost?

Expensify's Submit is free, for one person's expenses. A team uses Collect or Control, priced per member each month. Spending on the Expensify Card takes up to 50% off the subscription. Travel has a fee per trip. The prices are on Expensify's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Expenses has no plan limit, so reports and approvals are on Free. A free team has 3 members. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie read receipts?

No. A receipt is kept with its expense or waits in Receipt Inbox. Its amount, date and merchant are typed in. Reading receipts is on Magpie's roadmap. Expensify's SmartScan reads the merchant, date, total and currency from a photo.

Can I email receipts to Magpie?

No. Receipts are uploaded, dropped or pasted on Expenses, and a phone's browser offers the camera. There is no address or number to send them to. Expensify scans receipts forwarded to receipts@expensify.com, and photos texted from a US phone number.

Does Magpie track mileage?

No. A mileage claim is entered as an ordinary expense amount. There is no trip log or rate per mile. Mileage is on Magpie's roadmap. Expensify tracks a drive by GPS, from a map, from odometer readings or a typed distance.

Does Magpie have per diem?

No. Each day's meals and lodging are entered as ordinary expenses with their amounts. Expensify's Control plan imports per diem rates by destination. A member chooses the destination, the dates and the sub-rates.

Can Magpie pay people back for their expenses?

No. Magpie records that a reimbursement was paid, with its date and a reference. You send the money from the bank. Expensify pays an approved report from a connected business bank account. It pays in USD, CAD, GBP, EUR or AUD, and abroad with Global reimbursement.

Does Magpie connect to company cards?

No. A payment method records a card's label and its last four digits. Accounting imports a card statement as CSV for the books. Its lines do not become anyone's expenses. Expensify brings company card purchases in as the cardholder's expenses.

Does Magpie issue company cards?

No. Expenses records which payment method paid. Expensify issues the Expensify Visa card in the US, the UK and some EU countries. Its virtual cards can be locked to a merchant, an amount or dates.

Can I send reports to different approvers in Magpie?

No. Any team admin can approve any submitted report, in one step. Nothing goes to a second approver or is approved by itself. Expensify sends each report through its approvers, and a further one above a set amount.

Can I split an expense in Magpie?

No. An expense has one category and one project. In Accounting, an imported bank transaction can be split across accounts, but an expense cannot. Expensify splits one expense by amount, percentage or day.

Does Magpie flag expenses that break a policy?

Partly. Needs attention, on Overview, lists expenses with no receipt, no category or no merchant. No amount or age limit can be set. Expensify's Control plan flags expenses above an amount or older than a number of days.

Does Expensify have recurring expenses?

No. Expensify's help describes no repeating expense. Duplicate expense copies one by hand, dated today, without its receipt. Magpie's recurring expense repeats weekly, monthly, quarterly or yearly. It makes a draft on each date to confirm or discard.

Does Magpie connect to QuickBooks or Xero?

No. Expenses go into Magpie's own Accounting, or out as a CSV file. Each expense posts to the account for its category by itself. Expensify connects to QuickBooks and Xero on Collect, and to NetSuite and Sage Intacct on Control.

Can I bill a client for an expense?

Yes, in Magpie, for your own expenses. Mark the expense reimbursable and choose its Contact, then use Add unbilled expenses on their invoice. A teammate's expense is typed in as a line. Expensify marks expenses billable. Its invoice help describes no way to add them to an invoice.

Can my assistant or bookkeeper handle my expenses?

Not in Magpie. Only the person who recorded an expense can change it or put it on a report. Team admins see everyone's expenses but cannot change them. Expensify's Copilot gives another person full or limited access to an account.

Does Magpie have a phone app for expenses?

Expenses works in a phone's browser, where a receipt's upload offers the camera. The Magpie app has all of Expenses. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Expensify has apps for iPhone and Android. A receipt photographed offline is scanned once the phone reconnects.

Can I use Expensify and Magpie together?

Yes. Expensify can read the team's receipts and pay people back. Magpie runs the invoices, payroll and website. Expensify's expenses do not go into Magpie's Accounting by themselves. The reimbursements reach the books through your bank statement, imported as CSV.

How do I move from Expensify to Magpie?

Export your reports from Expensify as CSV, and their receipts as a ZIP file. In Magpie, + Receipt uploads many receipts at once into Receipt Inbox. Open each one and enter its amount. Magpie does not import expenses from a CSV file.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

All of Expenses: receipts, recurring expenses, expense reports and approvals, reports and exports. Accounting, Invoicing with 5 invoices a month, and Payroll for 2 employees a pay run. Store, booking pages, a website and a team of 3. A paid plan raises the limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Expensify changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Expensify's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Keep your expenses beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then add your first expense.

Create account