Gusto compared with Magpie

Gusto vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Gusto and Magpie both pay a small business's employees and keep track of the people who work there. They start from different places.

  1. Gusto is a payroll, HR and benefits service for employers in the United States. It is built for a business that wants its payroll taxes worked out, paid and filed. Health insurance, a 401(k) and HR help are in the same account.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Payroll is one part of it. Beside the pay runs it includes staff files, the rota, time tracking, hiring, expenses and the books. It is built for someone whose payroll is one part of running the business.
Create account
A draft pay run for a fictional studio with Approve and Work out again: its pay date, pay schedule and net pay, one thing to check (a timer still running), and the first rows of its table of employees with gross pay, deductions, net pay and employer contributions.

How is Magpie different?

1. Payroll comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Payroll for pay runs, overtime and payslips
  • Staff for each person's file, time-off balances, checklists and policies
  • Staff Scheduling for the rota, open shifts and swaps
  • Time Tracking for the hours a pay run reads
  • Hiring for a job board and candidates, and Expenses for expense reports
  • Accounting for the books, with every pay run in them
  • Invoicing, Appointments, Store, Websites, Mail and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Gusto covers payroll, HR and benefits, and sends each payroll to QuickBooks Online or Xero for the books.

2. Payroll and the books are one record

Approving a pay run adds it to the team's books in Accounting on its pay date. Marking it paid moves net pay to the bank account it left from. The entries name no employee, so the books show nobody's pay. A hired candidate in Hiring becomes an employee in Payroll in one step.

3. Payroll works in any currency, on the Free plan too

Payroll pays in the team's currency. Year-to-date totals count from the tax year start you choose, such as 1 January or 6 April. On the Free plan a pay run pays 2 employees. Paid plans pay everyone, with no price for each person paid.

Comparing Magpie and Gusto

Gusto does more inside payroll; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Gusto's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatGustoMagpie
Pay runs and payslipsPay employees on a schedule, with a payslip for each Yes Yes
Payroll taxes worked out and filedWithholding, tax payments and year-end forms Yes No
Direct depositPay sent to each employee's bank Yes No
Contractor payments and 1099sPay contractors and file their forms Yes No
Expense reimbursementsClaims with receipts, approved and paid back Yes Partly
Time clockClock in and out on a phone or a kiosk Plus and Premium Partly
Shift schedulingPlan, publish and swap shifts Plus and Premium Yes
Time offRequests, approvals and balances Yes Yes
HiringA job board and applicant tracking Plus and Premium Yes
New hire paperworkTax, work-eligibility and bank forms signed online Yes Partly
Employee recordsA file for each person, with an org chart Yes Partly
Performance reviewsSelf-reviews and manager reviews Plus and Premium No
BenefitsHealth insurance, 401(k) and workers' comp Yes No
HR advice and compliance alertsHR experts and employment law changes Premium No
Company filingsState annual reports and a registered agent Add-on Reminders only
BookkeepingPayroll recorded in the books QuickBooks or Xero Yes
AI assistant for payrollQuestions answered and tasks done for you to confirm Yes No
Phone supportA person on the phone Yes Chat only
Payroll outside the United StatesEmployees paid in another currency Remote, separate Yes
Free planRun payroll without paying No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Payroll

Both run pay runs on a schedule, pay off-cycle bonuses and give each employee a payslip. Gusto also works out, pays and files the taxes, and pays by direct deposit. They do it better than we do today.

WhatGustoMagpie
Pay employees on a schedule, as often as needed, with a pay stub for each Source Yes Yes
Have the taxes withheld from each paycheck worked out for me Source Magpie: In Payroll, the tax to withhold is entered by hand as a standing line on each employee, a percentage of gross pay or a fixed amount, as the accountant or the tax authority gives it. Yes No
Have payroll taxes paid and payroll tax forms filed for me, W-2s included Source Magpie: Payroll's Summary totals what was withheld for a month, a quarter or a tax year, with a CSV, to pay and report by hand. It files nothing and makes no tax forms. Yes No
Pay employees by direct deposit, faster when needed Source Magpie: The team pays employees from its own bank and then marks the pay run paid in Payroll. Magpie moves no money. Yes No
Pay employees who live or work in different states Source Magpie: Payroll pays employees wherever they work, but it holds no state's tax rules: what is withheld is a standing line entered for each employee. Yes Partly
Pay a bonus, a correction or a reimbursement outside the normal payday Source Yes Yes
Have payroll run by itself each payday for employees whose pay does not change Source Magpie: Each pay run starts when someone chooses Start pay run, and pays once someone approves it. Yes No
Take a child support order or another garnishment from an employee's pay and send it on Source Magpie: In Payroll, a fixed amount or a percentage can be taken from every pay run as a standing deduction, and the team pays the agency itself. Yes No
Let employees read their pay stubs and tax forms online and on their phone Source Magpie: Each payslip is released to the employee's Magpie account when the pay run is marked paid, with a PDF, and an email links to it without the amount. Payroll makes no tax forms, and the Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Let employees get part of their pay before payday Source Magpie: Magpie moves no money, so employees are paid when the team pays them. Yes No
Pay employees who work outside the United States Source Gusto: Gusto's own payroll is for employees in the United States. Employees in other countries were hired through an employer of record service run by Remote, at a monthly fee for each employee; since May 2026 new customers go to Remote directly.Magpie: Payroll is not tied to one country: it pays in the team's currency, counts from a tax year start such as 6 April, and takes the tax as entered. It does not employ anyone on the team's behalf. Partly Partly
Have each payroll recorded in my books Source Yes Yes
Let my accountant run payroll and read the reports Source Yes Yes
Build my own payroll reports and have them emailed to me on a schedule Source Magpie: Magpie's reports are fixed: Payroll's Summary and the Staff Scheduling reports each download as a CSV, and none is emailed. Yes No

Good to know: Before approval, a Magpie pay run lists what to check, such as a timer still running or net pay below zero. Each payslip keeps its year-to-date totals as approved.

Contractors

Gusto pays contractors in the United States and in more than 120 other countries, and files their 1099 forms. Magpie's Payroll pays employees only.

WhatGustoMagpie
Pay contractors, with their tax form and bank details collected online Source Magpie: A contractor is paid at the bank and recorded in Accounting as a bill, or in Expenses. Payroll pays employees only. Yes No
Pay contractors in other countries in their own currency Source Magpie: Magpie moves no money. A payment to a contractor abroad is recorded in Accounting as a bill. Yes No
File 1099 forms for the contractors I paid Source Magpie: Accounting and Expenses record what contractors were paid, but Magpie prepares and files no 1099 forms. Yes No

Good to know: A payment to a contractor is recorded in Accounting as a bill, beside the team's other costs.

Expenses and reimbursements

Both let staff claim expenses with a receipt for an admin or manager to approve. Gusto adds the claim to the next paycheck, reads receipts from a photo and pays mileage at a set rate.

WhatGustoMagpie
Have employees claim expenses and pay them back on their next paycheck Source Magpie: In Expenses, a member marks an expense reimbursable, puts it on an expense report and submits it; an admin approves it and records when it was paid back. Magpie sends no money, and a reimbursement reaches a payslip only as a line added to a pay run by hand. Yes Partly
Claim miles driven for work at a set rate Source Magpie: Expenses records an amount; it has no mileage rate or distance. Yes No
Have a receipt's amount and date read from a photo Source Magpie: A receipt is attached as a photo or a file, and its details are typed in by hand. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's Expenses keeps each receipt with its expense, up to 10 MB a file. An admin approves an expense report and records when it was paid back.

Time tracking, scheduling and time off

Both plan shifts, publish them, hand them to a coworker, approve time off and keep time-off balances. Gusto adds a time kiosk, location on clock-in and timesheet approval.

WhatGustoMagpie
Clock in and out of work on a phone or a shared tablet Source Magpie: A person can start Time Tracking from their published shift on the website, from two hours before it, in a phone's browser too, and Staff Scheduling's Scheduled and worked report compares that time with the shift. There is no kiosk, nothing stops a clock-in up to two hours early, and a late or missed one shows only in the report. Yes Partly
Know where each person was when they clocked in Source Magpie: A Time Tracking entry records its start and stop times only, with no place or photo. Yes No
Approve each person's hours before they are paid Source Magpie: Time Tracking entries are not approved: each person changes their own, and only invoiced time is locked. Yes No
Have tracked hours and overtime go into payroll Source Yes Yes
Track hours against projects Source Yes Yes
Plan shifts and publish the schedule to staff Source Yes Yes
Let staff hand a shift to a coworker Source Yes Yes
Let staff say when they can work, and warn me when I schedule outside it Source Yes Yes
See the hours and cost of the schedule while I plan it Source Yes Yes
See who started late, left early or missed a shift Source Yes Yes
Post a shift nobody has yet for staff to pick up Source Gusto: Only shifts with a person on them can be published; staff can claim a shift only when a coworker asks for cover. No Yes
Stop a shift going to someone without the certificate it needs Source Gusto: Gusto's scheduling help describes availability, time off and required breaks on shifts, and does not mention qualifications or certificates. Not stated Yes
Let staff ask for time off and approve it Source Yes Yes
Keep each person's time-off balance, with accrual, carryover and holidays Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A Magpie shift can be posted for Nobody yet, offered to the people who could work it, and filled by Auto-fill. A position can require a qualification, such as Food safety.

Hiring, onboarding and leaving

Both post jobs on a careers page and track applicants. Gusto posts to LinkedIn and Indeed in one step, sends offer letters and collects a new hire's W-4, I-9 and bank details.

WhatGustoMagpie
Post jobs on a careers page and keep track of applicants Source Yes Yes
Post a job to LinkedIn, Indeed and other job boards in one step Source Magpie: A job's page and the job board have addresses to share, and each job page has the details search engines read to list jobs. Nothing posts to other job boards. Yes No
Send an offer letter for the candidate to sign Source Magpie: Hiring has no offer letters. An offer can be sent as a PDF through E-Signatures. Yes No
Have new hires fill in and sign their tax, work-eligibility and bank forms online Source Magpie: Staff sends a document to sign from a person's file and files the signed copy there, and the person enters their own details and emergency contacts on My file. Magpie has no ready-made tax or work-eligibility forms, and Payroll stores no bank details. Yes Partly
Give each new hire a checklist of tasks for them and their manager Source Yes Yes
When someone leaves, pay their final paycheck and work through a leaving checklist Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Add to Payroll on a hired candidate in Hiring makes them an employee in Payroll, with their name and email filled in.

People management

Both keep a file for each person and publish a staff handbook. Gusto adds an org chart, performance reviews, surveys and pay benchmarks.

WhatGustoMagpie
Keep a file for each employee with their details, job and pay Source Yes Yes
Have employees sign documents such as agreements and waivers Source Yes Yes
Write an employee handbook and have everyone acknowledge it Source Yes Yes
See who reports to whom in an org chart Source Magpie: Each person's file in Staff names their manager, but Magpie draws no org chart and lists no one's reports. Yes Partly
Run performance reviews with a self-review and the manager's review Source Magpie: Magpie has no performance reviews. Staff keeps Notes on each file that only managers read. Yes No
Ask employees anonymously how things are going Source Magpie: A form in Forms can be shared with staff as a link, and its responses page shows only the answers, but it is not anonymous to anyone signed in: their account is kept with the response, and the assistant can name them. Nothing sends it to staff, and there are no results by team. Yes Partly
Compare what I pay with the market for each job Source Magpie: Magpie has no market pay data; pay is set by hand in Payroll, Staff and Staff Scheduling. Yes No
Choose what each admin and manager can see and do Source Magpie: A team member is an admin, a member or a guest, and a team admin can limit a member to some areas. Staff names managers for some locations or all, each with or without Can see pay. Staff Scheduling gives a manager, schedule editor or schedule viewer role, and Payroll is open only to team admins and the payroll administrators they name. Yes Partly

Good to know: Payroll is open only to team admins and the payroll administrators they name. In Staff, pay rates show only to team admins and to managers given Can see pay.

Benefits

Gusto offers health insurance, 401(k) plans and workers' comp, and takes the deductions in payroll. Magpie arranges no benefits.

WhatGustoMagpie
Offer employees health insurance paid through payroll Source Magpie: Magpie arranges no insurance. In Payroll, a deduction and the team's contribution are standing lines entered by hand. Yes No
Offer a 401(k) retirement plan with contributions taken from pay Source Magpie: Magpie arranges no retirement plan. Payroll starts with Employee pension and Employer pension pay items, entered as standing lines. Yes No
Get workers' compensation insurance paid from payroll Source Magpie: Magpie arranges no insurance. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie pay run takes a pension deduction and the team's contribution as standing lines, entered once for each employee.

Compliance, support and AI

Gusto's Premium plan includes HR experts and alerts when employment law changes, and Business Compliance files state annual reports. Magpie gives no HR advice and files nothing.

WhatGustoMagpie
Ask an HR expert about a staff problem, and hear when employment law changes Source Magpie: Magpie gives no HR or legal advice; its Help explains how each area works. Yes No
Have my company's state annual reports filed for me Source Magpie: Company Records keeps each company's filings and renewals with their due dates, reminds the owner before each, and records when one is done. It files nothing. Yes Partly
Have a registered agent for my company in each state Source Magpie: Company Records keeps the registered agent's address for each company; Magpie is not a registered agent. Yes No
Get the workplace posters the law requires, and new ones when the law changes Source Magpie: Magpie provides no workplace posters. Yes No
Have the research and development tax credit worked out and claimed Source Magpie: Accounting keeps the books and their reports; it works out no tax credits. Yes No
Talk to a person by phone or chat when stuck Source Magpie: Contact support opens a conversation with the Magpie team in Chat on the website. There is no phone line. Yes Partly
Ask an AI assistant about payroll and staff, and have it do tasks for me to confirm Source Magpie: The assistant and connected apps read nothing from Payroll, Staff, Staff Scheduling or Hiring, because those areas limit who sees what in ways the assistant's reader does not check. Yes No

Good to know: Company Records keeps each company's filings and renewals with their due dates, and reminds the owner before each one.

Price comparison

How Gusto charges

Gusto charges by plan, Simple, Plus or Premium, with a monthly base price and a price for each person paid. Simple pays employees in one state. Plus and Premium add several states, time tracking, scheduling, hiring and performance reviews. Premium adds HR experts and custom reports. Contractors are charged only in months they are paid. Prices are on Gusto's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan too, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The plan sets limits, not which areas you can use. On the Free plan a pay run pays 2 employees; paid plans pay everyone. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planGustoMagpie
Price for each person paidOn every plan, each monthNone
ContractorsPaid on every plan, charged only in months they are paidRecorded as bills in Accounting
Payroll taxes worked out and filedIncluded on every planNot offered; you enter what to withhold
Direct depositIncluded; next-day on Plus and Premium, or an add-on to SimpleNot offered; you pay from your bank
Time tracking and schedulingPlus and Premium, or the Time and Attendance add-onIncluded
HiringPlus and PremiumIncluded
HR experts and compliance alertsPremiumNot offered
Annual reports and a registered agentBusiness Compliance, an add-on on Simple and Plus, included with PremiumCompany Records keeps the due dates; files nothing
BenefitsThrough Gusto as the broker; your own broker on Plus and Premium for a fee for each employeeNot offered
BookkeepingQuickBooks Online or Xero, a separate subscriptionAccounting, included
Research and development tax credit15% of the credit Gusto findsNot offered
People in the teamAdmins and managers by role3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan; employees read payslips without joining

When to choose Magpie or Gusto

  • Want payroll beside the rota, time tracking, hiring and your books, in any currency, with a Free plan that pays 2 employees? Go with Magpie.
  • Want payroll taxes worked out, paid and filed for you in every state, with direct deposit, health insurance and a 401(k) for your employees? Gusto is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For an employer in the United States that wants the taxes filed
Gusto. Gusto works out federal, state and local payroll tax, pays it and files the forms, W-2s included. Magpie's Payroll takes off the tax you enter and files nothing.
For a business that offers benefits
Gusto. Health insurance, 401(k) plans and workers' comp come through Gusto, with the deductions taken in payroll. Magpie arranges no benefits.
For a café, a shop or a restaurant with a rota
Magpie. Staff Scheduling plans shifts, posts open ones and handles swaps and time off on every plan. A pay run reads the worked shifts and works out overtime. Restaurant Reservations and Daily Operations are in the same team.
For a business outside the United States
Magpie. Payroll pays in the team's currency from the tax year start you choose. Gusto's own payroll is for employees in the United States.
For a small team with a bookkeeper
Either. Gusto files the taxes and sends each payroll to QuickBooks Online or Xero. Magpie puts each pay run into its own books, and the bookkeeper can be a payroll administrator. Choose by whether you want the filing done for you or payroll and books in one place.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Gusto and Magpie?

Gusto is a payroll, HR and benefits service for employers in the United States. It works out, pays and files payroll taxes. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Payroll is one area beside the rota, time tracking, hiring and the books. Gusto does more inside payroll; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Gusto?

No, for an employer in the United States that wants its payroll taxes handled. Magpie's Payroll works out pay runs, overtime and payslips. It does not work out, pay or file tax, or pay by direct deposit.

Yes, for a business that pays a few employees from its own bank, or one outside the United States. It also suits a business whose accountant files the tax. Consider keeping Gusto if you want payroll taxes filed for you, W-2s and 1099s made, direct deposit, or benefits through payroll. Gusto does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Gusto cost?

Gusto has three plans, Simple, Plus and Premium, each a monthly base price and a price for each person paid. Contractors are charged only in months they are paid. Next-day direct deposit, priority support and Business Compliance cost extra on some plans. The prices are on Gusto's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. On the Free plan a pay run pays 2 employees. Paid plans pay everyone, with no price for each person paid. A free team has 3 members and the Team plan 25. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie calculate payroll taxes?

No. The tax to withhold is a standing line on each employee, as your accountant or your tax authority gives it. It is a percentage of gross pay or a fixed amount. Every pay run then takes it off and shows it on the payslip. Working out the tax is on Magpie's roadmap. Gusto works out federal, state and local payroll tax on every plan.

Does Magpie file payroll taxes or make W-2s?

No. Payroll's Summary totals what was withheld for a month, a quarter or a tax year, with a CSV for your accountant. You pay and report it yourself. Gusto pays and files payroll taxes on every plan and makes each employee's W-2.

Does Magpie pay employees by direct deposit?

No. Magpie moves no money: you pay employees from your bank, then mark the pay run paid. That releases each payslip to the employee. Gusto pays by direct deposit, next day on Plus and Premium.

Can Magpie pay contractors or file 1099s?

No. Payroll pays employees only, and a payment to a contractor is recorded in Accounting as a bill. Magpie makes no 1099 forms. Gusto pays contractors in the United States and more than 120 other countries and files their 1099s.

Does Magpie offer health insurance or a 401(k)?

No. Magpie arranges no insurance or retirement plan. A pension deduction and the team's contribution can be standing lines on each employee. Gusto offers medical, dental and vision plans, 401(k) plans and workers' comp through payroll.

Does Magpie have a time clock?

Partly. A person starts Time Tracking from their published shift, from two hours before it, in a phone's browser too. The Scheduled and worked report compares that time with the shift and marks a shift with no time entry. There is no kiosk for a shared tablet and no location on clock-in. Gusto has both on Plus and Premium.

Does Magpie approve timesheets before payroll?

No. A pay run reads each employee's hours from Time Tracking or their worked shifts, and works out overtime. Nobody approves the hours first, but the pay run is approved before it pays. Gusto's managers approve timesheets, which locks them.

Does Magpie track paid time off balances?

Yes. Staff keeps each person's balance for each time-off policy. A balance accrues at the start of the year, each month or by hours worked, with pro rata allowances and carryover. Gusto keeps balances that accrue by hours worked, each pay period or once a year.

Does Gusto have shift scheduling?

Yes, on Plus and Premium or with the Time and Attendance add-on. Managers build and publish a schedule, staff swap shifts and set their availability. A shift needs a person on it to be published. Magpie's Staff Scheduling is on every plan and can post an open shift for anyone who could work it.

Does Magpie have performance reviews?

No. Magpie has no review cycles. Performance reviews are on Magpie's roadmap. Gusto runs reviews with a self-evaluation and the manager's review on Plus and Premium.

Does Magpie have hiring?

Yes. Hiring publishes each job on the team's job board and its own page, and takes applications through a form. Candidates move through stages with notes, scorecards and interviews. A hired candidate goes into Payroll in one step. Gusto's Recruiting, on Plus and Premium, also posts to LinkedIn and Indeed and sends offer letters.

Does Gusto keep the books?

No. Gusto sends each payroll to QuickBooks Online or Xero as a journal entry. Magpie's Payroll adds each approved pay run to the team's books in Accounting, in the same team.

Can my accountant run payroll in Magpie?

Yes. A team admin can give an outside bookkeeper Payroll as a guest and name them a payroll administrator. They can do everything a team admin can in Payroll except name payroll administrators. Gusto adds an accountant through its partner dashboard.

Can Magpie pay employees outside the United States?

Yes. Payroll pays in the team's currency and counts from the tax year start you choose. It takes off the tax as you enter it. It does not employ anyone for you. Gusto's own payroll is for employees in the United States.

Does Magpie have an AI assistant for payroll?

No. The assistant and connected apps read nothing from Payroll, because pay is shown only to payroll administrators and each employee. Gusto's Gus answers questions, and Cofounder runs payroll after you confirm.

Can I use Gusto and Magpie together?

Yes. Gusto can run payroll and file the taxes while Magpie runs the rota, time tracking, hiring and the books. Staff Scheduling's reports download as CSV files for the hours. Magpie does not send anything to Gusto by itself.

How do I move from Gusto to Magpie?

Add your pay schedules in Payroll, then your employees one by one or with Import employees. An import takes each employee's pay, standing lines and what they were paid and had withheld so far this tax year. Payslips add those totals to the year to date. Keep Gusto until your tax filings for the year are done.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Payroll for 2 employees a pay run, with Staff, Staff Scheduling, Time Tracking, Hiring, Expenses and Accounting. A free team has 3 members. Employees read their payslips with their own Magpie account without joining the team. A paid plan pays every employee and raises the other limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Gusto changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Gusto's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Run payroll beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then set up Payroll in your team.

Create account