PandaDoc compared with Magpie

PandaDoc vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

PandaDoc and Magpie both send a priced proposal that the client signs and pays for online. They are built around different things.

  1. PandaDoc is document software for proposals, quotes and contracts, with templates, e-signatures, payments and a contract repository. It is built for a sales team that sends many documents, often from a CRM.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Proposals is one part of it. Beside the proposal it includes E-Signatures, Invoicing, Contacts, Client Portal and the other areas a business runs on. It is built for someone whose proposals are one part of running the business.
Create account
A client’s proposal page for a fictional bakery brand refresh, with the cover, a list of contents, the recommended Complete package chosen, and the total in a bar at the foot of the screen.

How is Magpie different?

1. Proposals come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Proposals, with packages, options, a deposit and a payment schedule
  • E-Signatures for any PDF, and Agreements for standard contracts filled in from your answers
  • Invoicing, with recurring invoices and payment by card
  • Client Portal, Contacts and Company Records for the clients and the contracts
  • Time Tracking, To-dos, Meetings, Mail, Websites and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. A contact's page lists their proposals beside their invoices and bookings.

2. An accepted proposal becomes the work

The payment schedule splits the total into up to 10 payments: a deposit, dated payments, milestones and a final payment. Each becomes an invoice in Invoicing, and they add up exactly to the accepted total. When the work starts, Magpie can make a Time Tracking project and a To-do List. It can also share the proposal in the client's portal and start the recurring invoices.

3. The Free plan sends priced proposals

Magpie's Free plan sends 5 proposals a month with every part of Proposals: packages, options, deposits, approvals and reports. A paid plan has no limit. E-Signatures has no limit on any plan. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people.

Comparing Magpie and PandaDoc

PandaDoc does more inside the document; Magpie does more after it is signed. Every line in the tables below was checked against PandaDoc's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Proposals and quotesA document with prices the client reads online Yes Yes
Electronic signaturesSend a document or a PDF to people to sign Yes Yes
Sending without payingSend priced proposals on a free plan Simple quote, 5 a month Yes
Content librarySections and pictures the team reuses in any document Business and above Yes
Tables and custom fieldsTables in the text, and fields you name yourself Yes No
Sections chosen by rulesContent put in from the client's details or the quote Enterprise No
Payment when signingThe client pays as part of accepting Business and above Yes
Invoices from the proposalThe deposit, milestones and monthly fees billed Through QuickBooks Online Yes
Client portalOne page for a client's documents and next steps Rooms, Business and above Yes
Contract registerSigned agreements with their dates and renewals Yes Yes
Bulk sendOne document to a list, each person signing their own copy Business and above No
Forms that make a documentA form on a website that anyone fills in and signs Business and above No
Identity checksA code by text message, or a photo ID Business No
Online notaryA notary over video US only No
AI writing and questionsAI writes text and answers questions about a document Beta Partly
CRM connectionsDocuments made from deals in Salesforce, HubSpot and others Business and above No
API and webhooksWork with documents from your own software Yes Pro
Phone appsMake, send and track documents in an iPhone or Android app Yes In the browser
Security audit and single sign-onSOC 2, and sign-in through the company's identity provider Yes No

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Creating documents

Both start a document from a starter, with your brand, reusable sections and the client's details filled in. PandaDoc adds tables, fields you name yourself, sections chosen by rules and Word files made editable. They do it better than we do today.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Start each document from a template my team keeps Source Yes Yes
Start from a ready-made template for my kind of work Source Yes Yes
Turn a Word file I already have into a document I can edit Source Magpie: Text pasted from a word processor keeps its headings, lists, bold, italic and links, and Documents imports a Word file as a document. A Word file cannot be made into a proposal: a Files section only offers it to the client as a download. Yes Partly
Upload a finished PDF and add fields for people to fill in and sign Source Yes Yes
Build a document from blocks of text, pictures, video and prices Source Yes Yes
Put a table in a document, such as a comparison or a schedule Source Magpie: Proposal text has headings, lists, checklists and quotes but no tables; prices go in pricing sections and dates in a timeline section. Yes No
Make every document look like my brand, with my logo, colours and fonts Source Yes Yes
Keep approved text, sections and pictures to reuse in any document Source Yes Yes
Have the client's name, company and other details filled in by themselves Source Yes Yes
Add my own fields, such as a purchase order number or a start date, to fill in for each document Source Magpie: The fields are a fixed set of the client's, the proposal's, the business's and the writer's details. A detail such as a purchase order number is typed into the text. Yes No
Have the right sections put in for me from the client's details or what I am quoting Source Magpie: Sections are added, hidden and removed by hand. The client's choice of package and options changes the totals, not which sections show. Yes No
Stop team members changing parts of a document, such as the terms Source Yes Yes
Have AI write or rewrite a document's text Source Magpie: Copy the prompt, in the JSON import box, gives an assistant you use, such as Claude or ChatGPT, what it needs to write a whole proposal as JSON, which is pasted in as a draft. Nothing in the proposal editor writes or rewrites text with AI. Yes Partly
Place fields for each person to fill in, such as text, dates, checkboxes, option buttons and drop-downs Source Magpie: E-Signatures places Signature, Initials, Date signed, Name, Email, Text and Checkbox fields for each signer on a PDF, each required or optional. There are no option buttons, drop-downs or file uploads. Yes Partly
Have the client fill in details, such as a billing address or a purchase order number, in the proposal as they sign Source Magpie: A proposal's acceptance step asks only for the signer's full name and signature. The client can ask a question or request changes instead. Yes No
Put a form on my website that anyone can fill in to make and sign a document Source Magpie: Forms collects answers without a signature, and every E-Signatures request and proposal names its signers by email address before it is sent. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's starters for kinds of work mark their sample text and example prices. A proposal cannot be sent while one is left.

Collaborating

Both comment privately with the team and ask a manager to approve before a document goes out. PandaDoc lets several people edit at once and lets the client suggest changes in the text.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Write a document with teammates at the same time Source Magpie: Two people can edit one draft: changes to different sections are both kept, and when someone else changed a section first, your change to it is refused and their version is shown. The editor does not show who else has it open or their typing as it happens. Yes Partly
Comment on a document, privately with my team or openly with the client Source Yes Yes
Let the client suggest changes to the wording, and accept or reject each one Source Magpie: The client can Request changes, or ask about one section, in words; you revise the proposal and send a new version with a note on what changed. The client cannot mark changes in the text itself. Yes Partly
Have a manager approve large or discounted documents before they go out Source Yes Yes
Give a client one shared space with the documents, files and next steps for a deal Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie's approval rules ask again after any change to an approved proposal. A Client Portal shares the accepted proposal with its invoices and files.

Sending and signing

Both send by email or link, remind signers, set an expiry date and keep a signing certificate. PandaDoc adds signing in person, delivery by text message, bulk send, identity checks, qualified signatures and a notary.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Send the document by email with my own message, or as a link Source Yes Yes
Have people sign with a legally binding e-signature, with a record of who signed and when Source Yes Yes
Have people sign one after another, in the order I set Source Magpie: E-Signatures can email signers In the order listed. A proposal's signers sign in any order, and you can sign it yourself when you send it. Yes Partly
Remind people by themselves when they have not signed Source Yes Yes
Set a date after which the document can no longer be signed Source Yes Yes
Have someone sign in person on my tablet or phone Source Magpie: Each signer signs in the Magpie account at their own email address, so on your device they would first have to sign in there with a link or code emailed to them. Yes No
Send the document and reminders by text message Source Magpie: Invitations and reminders go by email. Copy link on a proposal's recipient, or Get signing link in E-Signatures, gives a link to send by text from your own phone. Yes Partly
Send the same document to a list of people, each getting their own copy to sign Source Magpie: Each proposal and each signature request goes to its own recipients, so sending to many people takes one for each, which a starter makes quicker. Yes No
Send the documents' emails from my own domain Source Magpie: Proposals open at Magpie's address, and their emails come from your business name via Magpie, with replies going to you. Yes No
Show the signing page and emails in my client's language Source Magpie: A proposal's client page, PDF and emails are in English, French, Spanish or German, chosen for each proposal; your own text is not translated. Yes Partly
Check who a signer is before they sign, with a passcode, a code by text or a photo ID Source Magpie: A document opens only in the Magpie account at the address it was sent to, whose address is confirmed with a code before signing, and an access code can be required. Nothing checks a phone number or an ID document. Yes Partly
Sign at the EU's qualified electronic signature level Source Magpie: Magpie's signatures are simple electronic signatures, backed by the signer's account and the signing certificate. Yes No
Have a document notarised online Source Magpie: Magpie does not notarise documents, as its Help says. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie proposal can be sent now or at a time you choose, to up to 20 recipients. An access code can be required before it opens.

Quoting and getting paid

Both price lines with tax, recurring fees, optional extras and packages, and take payment on acceptance. PandaDoc discounts each line and offers payment by bank; Magpie turns the proposal into invoices.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Add a priced list of work that adds up the lines, tax and total Source Yes Yes
Let the client choose a package, tick optional extras and change quantities Source Yes Yes
Show monthly or yearly fees beside one-time ones Source Yes Yes
Give a discount on one line or on the whole quote Source Magpie: A proposal has one discount, a fixed amount or a percentage of its one-time lines. One line cannot be discounted on its own, and recurring lines are not discounted. Yes Partly
Keep a list of my products and prices to add to quotes Source Yes Yes
Have the client pay when they sign Source Yes Yes
Turn the accepted proposal into invoices for its deposit, milestones and monthly fees Source PandaDoc: PandaDoc keeps no invoices of its own: on Business and Enterprise, the QuickBooks Online connection makes an invoice in QuickBooks when a document is completed. Partly Yes
Let the client pay from their bank account instead of by card Source Magpie: Deposits and invoices made from a proposal are paid online by card through the team's Stripe account; a bank transfer is recorded on the invoice by hand. Yes No

Good to know: Pay deposit pays the deposit's invoice by card through your own Stripe account. Magpie takes no fee on it; Stripe's fees apply.

Storing and managing documents

Both keep a list of documents and a register of signed contracts with renewal reminders. PandaDoc adds folders, tags, and AI that reads terms from a contract and answers questions about it.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Sort my documents into folders or tag them, and filter the list Source Magpie: Proposals has a tab for each state, search by title, number or client, a filter by owner and an archive, and E-Signatures has tabs, search and filters. Neither has folders or tags. Yes Partly
Keep signed agreements in one register, with their dates, value and a reminder before they renew Source Yes Yes
Have a signed contract's dates, value and renewal terms read from it for me Source Magpie: Add contract asks for the company, the title, who it is with, the kind and the dates, and the key terms are typed on the contract's page. Yes No
Have a document summed up, and ask questions about what it says Source Magpie: The assistant and connected apps such as Claude find proposals by title, number or client, with their state, total and dates, and signature requests by title and status. Neither reads what a document says. Yes No

Good to know: Company Records' Contracts reminds you before the last day to give notice. A contract nobody gives notice on renews by itself.

Tracking and reports

Both list every opening, signature and payment, and show time spent on each part. Both report on what the team sends and closes.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
See when each person opens and signs, and be told as it happens Source Yes Yes
See how long each person spent on each part of the document Source Yes Yes
See how many documents my team sends and closes, by person and template Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie's reading time counts each section while it is on screen. The client's page tells them so.

Integrations and AI

PandaDoc connects to CRMs, Zapier, Slack, cloud storage, Claude and ChatGPT. Magpie works inside its own areas, and they do this better than we do today.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Make documents from the deals in my CRM, and move a deal on when it is signed Source Magpie: Proposals use Magpie's own Contacts, which show each client's proposals and what happened to them; there is no connection to a CRM. Yes No
Write, send and track documents from Claude or ChatGPT Source Magpie: A connected app such as Claude or ChatGPT can search proposals by title, number or client, with their state and total, but cannot read, write or send one. A proposal an assistant writes as JSON can be pasted in. Yes Partly
Have the next steps happen by themselves once the client signs Source Yes Yes
Connect it to the other tools I use, such as Zapier, Slack and Google Drive Source Magpie: On Pro, a signed webhook set up through the API is sent when a proposal is sent, viewed, accepted or declined, so Zapier or any service that takes webhooks can act on it, but Magpie has no Zapier app to choose and no Slack or Google Drive connection. Yes Partly
Work with documents from my own software, and be told when they change Source Yes Yes

Good to know: On Pro, Magpie's version 1 API lists, starts, reads and downloads proposals. Webhooks report each one sent, viewed, accepted or declined.

Security and compliance

PandaDoc has a SOC 2 Type II report on every plan and single sign-on on Business and Enterprise. Magpie has neither yet.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
See an independent security audit before trusting it with clients' details Source Magpie: Magpie has no independent security audit report to show. Yes No
Sign in through the company's identity provider Source Magpie: Members sign in with a password, a passkey, a link Magpie emails, or an account they already have with Google, Apple and others. There is no SAML single sign-on. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie proposal opens only in the account at the address it was sent to. Its certificate holds the SHA-256 of the signed PDF.

Admin, teams and plans

Both give each department or client its own documents and starters, and both have a free plan. PandaDoc adds custom roles on Enterprise, and apps for iPhone and Android.

WhatPandaDocMagpie
Give each department, branch or client its own space, with its own templates and documents Source Yes Yes
Choose exactly what each person may do with documents Source Magpie: A team member uses Proposals with view or edit access, and team admins change Proposals settings and locked sections. There are no custom roles, so edit access writes, sends and deletes drafts alike. Yes Partly
Make, send and track documents from my phone Source Magpie: The Magpie app for iPhone and Android, which lists, writes, sends, revises, reminds and withdraws proposals and answers clients' questions, is built but not yet in the App Store or Google Play, so on a phone Proposals is used on the website. Starters, saved sections, the price list, reports and settings are on the website only. Yes Partly
Send priced proposals with online signing and payment without paying Source PandaDoc: Free sends 5 documents a month, from up to 5 templates, with a simple one-section quote; the document editor is for paid plans, and pricing tables, payments and branding for Business and up. Partly Yes

Good to know: Each Magpie team has its own proposals, starters, saved sections, price list and settings. One person can belong to several teams.

Price comparison

How PandaDoc charges

PandaDoc charges by plan: Free, Starter, Business and Enterprise. Starter and Business are priced per seat, and Enterprise is priced on request. Free sends 5 documents a month from up to 5 templates. The content library, product catalog, approvals, reports and payments need Business. Bulk send, forms, the API and automations also use usage credits. Prices are on PandaDoc's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The Free plan sends 5 proposals a month with every part of Proposals; a paid plan has no limit. E-Signatures has no limit on any plan. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planPandaDocMagpie
Sending without paying5 documents a month, with a simple quote5 proposals a month, with every part of Proposals
How a team paysPer seat on Starter and BusinessOne Team plan for up to 25 people
Content library, catalog, approvals and reportsBusiness and EnterpriseIncluded
Payment when signingBusiness and Enterprise, through a payment gateway you connectIncluded, by card through your own Stripe account
Bulk send, forms, API and automationsBusiness and Enterprise, with usage creditsAPI and webhooks on Pro; no bulk send or forms
Locked sectionsAn add-on on Business, included on EnterpriseIncluded
Emails from your own domainAn add-on on Business annual plans, included on EnterpriseNot offered
Qualified signatures and a notaryPaid for by each signer or each transactionNot offered
InvoicingThrough QuickBooks Online, Business and EnterpriseIncluded

When to choose Magpie or PandaDoc

  • Want proposals that turn into invoices, a project and a client portal, with a Free plan that sends them? Go with Magpie.
  • Want tables, smart content, bulk send, identity checks and documents made from the deals in your CRM? PandaDoc is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a sales team on Salesforce or HubSpot
PandaDoc. Its CRM connections make documents from deals and map products into quotes. Magpie connects to no outside CRM.
For a business that sends one agreement to many people
PandaDoc. Bulk send makes a copy for each row of a spreadsheet. A form on your website makes a document anyone can sign. Magpie needs a proposal or a request for each person.
For a firm with set paperwork
PandaDoc. Tables, fields you name yourself and sections chosen by rules fit documents that change by client. Magpie's proposals are built from sections you add by hand.
For a freelancer, an agency or a consultant
Magpie. The client chooses a package, signs and pays the deposit on one page. The deposit, milestones and monthly fees then become invoices, and the hours become a Time Tracking project.
For a service business with monthly clients
Magpie. Recurring lines in an accepted proposal become recurring invoices when the work starts. The client can have each one charged to their card.
For a small team that sends a few proposals a month
Either. Both send a priced proposal with options, reminders and online signing. Choose PandaDoc for more control over the document, and Magpie for what happens after it is signed.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between PandaDoc and Magpie?

PandaDoc is document software for proposals, quotes and contracts, built for sales teams that send many documents. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Proposals area sits beside E-Signatures, Invoicing, Contacts and Client Portal. PandaDoc does more inside the document; Magpie does more after it is signed.

Does Magpie replace PandaDoc?

Yes, for a business that writes its own proposals and contracts and sends them a few at a time. Magpie sends priced proposals with packages and options, takes the deposit, and turns the proposal into invoices.

Consider keeping PandaDoc if you make documents from a CRM or send one to a list. Keep it if you need tables and fields you name yourself. Keep it too for identity checks, delivery by text message, qualified signatures or phone apps. PandaDoc does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does PandaDoc cost?

PandaDoc has Free, Starter, Business and Enterprise plans. Starter and Business are priced per seat, and Enterprise is priced on request. Free sends 5 documents a month. Bulk send, forms, the API and automations also use usage credits. The prices are on PandaDoc's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. The Free plan sends 5 proposals a month, and a paid plan has no limit. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per seat. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Can I send proposals for free?

Yes, in both. Magpie's Free plan sends 5 proposals a month with packages, deposits, approvals and reports. PandaDoc's Free plan sends 5 documents a month from up to 5 templates, with a simple one-section quote.

Does Magpie have a content library?

Yes. Keep as saved section stores any section under a name, and Add section copies it into a proposal. Pictures come from Your images. Saved sections have no folders, which PandaDoc's content library has.

Does Magpie have a product catalog?

Yes, the price list. It keeps each price with a name, description, unit, currency, tax rate and billing. Import prices adds many at once from JSON. It has no SKUs, pictures or categories. PandaDoc's catalog, on Business, has those, with bundles and tiered prices.

Can the client pay when they sign?

Yes, in both. In Magpie the deposit's invoice is issued on acceptance. The client pays it by card through your own Stripe account. PandaDoc takes payment on the document, at once, in instalments or as a subscription, on Business and Enterprise.

Does PandaDoc make invoices?

Not of its own. On Business and Enterprise, its QuickBooks Online connection makes an invoice in QuickBooks when a document is completed. Magpie's Invoicing makes an invoice for each payment in the schedule, and recurring lines become recurring invoices.

Can I put a table in a Magpie proposal?

No. Proposal text has headings, lists, checklists and quotes, but no tables. Prices go in pricing sections and dates in a timeline section. Tables are on Magpie's roadmap. PandaDoc has a table block on every plan.

Does Magpie have custom variables?

No. Insert field adds a fixed set of the client's, the proposal's, the business's and the writer's details. A detail such as a purchase order number is typed into the text. Fields you name yourself are on Magpie's roadmap. PandaDoc has custom variables on Starter and above.

Does Magpie have bulk send?

No. Each proposal and each signature request goes to its own recipients. Sending to many people takes one for each. A starter makes each one quicker. Bulk send is on Magpie's roadmap. PandaDoc's bulk send takes a spreadsheet of up to 1,000 recipients.

Can a client suggest changes to a proposal?

Partly, in Magpie. The client can Request changes, or ask about one section, in words. You revise the proposal and send a new version with a note on what changed. PandaDoc's Suggest edits, on Business, lets the client mark changes in the text for you to accept or reject.

Can several people edit a Magpie proposal at once?

Partly. Two people can edit one draft, and changes to different sections are both kept. A change to a section someone else changed first is refused, and their version is shown. The editor does not show who else has it open. PandaDoc shows each editor's picture as they work.

Does Magpie connect to Salesforce or HubSpot?

No. Proposals use Magpie's own Contacts, which show each client's proposals and what happened to them. A CRM connection is on Magpie's roadmap. PandaDoc connects to Salesforce, HubSpot, Pipedrive, Microsoft Dynamics, Zoho and others on Business and Enterprise.

Can AI write a proposal in Magpie?

Not in the editor. Copy the prompt gives an assistant you use, such as Claude or ChatGPT, what it needs to write a proposal as JSON. You paste that in as a draft. Nothing reads or rewrites a proposal's text with AI. PandaDoc's AI assistant writes and rewrites text, in a beta that is rolling out.

Does Magpie check a signer's identity?

No, beyond the signer's Magpie account at the invited address and an optional access code. The address is confirmed with a code before signing. Nothing checks a phone number or an ID document. PandaDoc offers a passcode, a code by text and a photo ID check on Business.

Can a form on my website make a document to sign?

Not in Magpie. Forms collects answers without a signature. Every proposal and signature request names its signers before it is sent. PandaDoc's forms, on Business and Enterprise, make a document from a template for whoever fills them in.

Does Magpie have SOC 2 or single sign-on?

No. Magpie has no independent security audit report and no SAML single sign-on yet; both are on its roadmap. Members sign in with a password, a passkey, an emailed link, or Google or Apple. PandaDoc has SOC 2 Type II on every plan, and single sign-on on Business and Enterprise.

Does Magpie have a phone app for proposals?

Proposals works in a phone's browser. The Magpie app writes, sends and revises proposals. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. PandaDoc has apps for iPhone and Android on every plan, except for EU accounts.

Do my clients need an account?

In Magpie, yes, and Magpie makes it. When a proposal is sent, each recipient gets a free Magpie account at that address. The email's button signs them in the first time. The proposal and its signed copy stay in that account.

Can I use PandaDoc and Magpie together?

Yes, side by side, though they do not connect. A business might send CRM and bulk documents from PandaDoc, and its proposals, invoices and client work from Magpie.

How do I move from PandaDoc to Magpie?

For each template you send often, start a proposal in Magpie and paste in its text. Add your prices to the price list, then use Save as starter. Keep your PandaDoc account until you have the signed copies you need from it.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Proposals sends 5 a month, with packages, deposits, approvals and reports. E-Signatures has no limit, and Invoicing sends 5 invoices a month. Contacts, Client Portal, a team of 3 and the other areas are included too.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

PandaDoc changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for PandaDoc's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Send your first proposal on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then start a proposal from one of Magpie's starters.

Create account