Loom compared with Magpie

Loom vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Loom and Magpie both record your screen with your camera and give you a link to send. Loom is built around the video; Magpie puts it beside the rest of the business.

  1. Loom is a video messaging product, now part of Atlassian, with apps, a Chrome extension and AI. It is built for teams that send each other video: walkthroughs, updates, bug reports and feedback.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Screen Recorder is one part of it. Beside the recorder it includes Video Chat, booking pages, invoicing, Documents, Forms, a website and more. It is built for someone whose videos are one part of running the business.
Create account
The recording editor showing a fictional website walkthrough, with a studio card image selected over the video and its timing and layer settings beside it.

How is Magpie different?

1. Video comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Screen Recorder, the area this page is about, with an editor, a teleprompter and a share page
  • Video Chat for calls, and Meetings and Appointments for booking pages
  • Documents, Forms and Proposals, which a recording works with
  • Supporters for paid posts, where a recording plays inside a post
  • Invoicing, Store, Websites, Newsletter, Mail and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Loom covers recording, sharing and AI for video, and connects to the other tools a team uses.

2. Editing and downloads are on every plan

The Free plan trims a recording, cuts out a part and places pictures over the video. You choose the thumbnail frame and download an MP4 with your cuts. The share page shows up to 12 link buttons. Analytics names each person who watched and how far. Loom keeps editing, downloads and calls to action for Business and above.

3. A recording works with your other work

The teleprompter reads a script from a Magpie Document, at a pace set from the length you want. A Document can be the recording's transcript on its share page. A published Form can be shown beside the video, and its answers arrive with the Form's other responses. The recording also plays inside a Supporters post or a proposal.

Comparing Magpie and Loom

Loom does more for recording and for a team's library of video; Magpie does more around the video. Every line in the tables below was checked against Loom's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatLoomMagpie
Screen and camera recordingRecord the screen with your camera in a bubble Yes Yes
Camera onlyRecord yourself without a screen Yes No
Camera backgroundBlur the room behind you, or hide it Yes Yes
Desktop app and Chrome extensionRecord from an app or the browser's toolbar Yes In the browser
Phone appsRecord and share from a phone Yes No
ScreenshotsCapture, mark up and share a picture Yes No
Trim and cutEdit the start, the end and the middle Business and above Yes
Download as MP4Save the video as a file Business and above Yes
TeleprompterRead a script while you record Speaker notes, desktop app Yes
Transcripts and captionsWritten automatically from what was said Yes Your own Document
AI summaries, chapters and guidesWritten from the video Business + AI No
Team library with foldersShared spaces the team browses Yes No
Watch without an accountAnyone with the link watches Yes Free Magpie account
Named viewers and passwordsKeep a video to chosen people Yes No
Comments, reactions and video repliesViewers answer on the video Yes No
Calls to actionButtons with the video Business and above Yes
Form beside the videoCollect viewers' answers on the share page No Yes
Who watchedEach viewer, and how far they got Yes Yes
Your own brandingYour logo and colours on the player Business and above No
Meeting notetakerZoom, Meet and Teams calls recorded with notes Yes No
Connections to Slack, Jira and othersRecord and share from other tools Yes No
Restore a deleted videoGet back a video deleted by mistake No Yes
Booking, invoicing and a websiteThe rest of the business in the same account No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Recording

Both record a screen, a window or a tab with your camera in a bubble. Loom also records the camera alone, pauses, blurs private details and records up to 4K. They do it better than we do today.

WhatLoomMagpie
Record my screen with my camera in a bubble Source Yes Yes
Choose whether to record the whole screen, one window or one browser tab Source Yes Yes
Record just myself on camera, without a screen Source Magpie: Screen Recorder always records a screen, window or tab that you choose; the camera is added to it as a bubble or a side panel and is never recorded on its own. Yes No
Choose the camera's size, shape and place in the video Source Yes Yes
Blur or replace the background behind me on camera Source Yes Yes
Record the sound playing on my computer, such as a video or a call Source Magpie: Sharing a tab or a window with audio in the browser's chooser records its sound together with your microphone. Anything beyond that depends on what the browser and the computer allow, since Screen Recorder runs in a browser page with no app to install. Yes Partly
Reduce background noise from my microphone Source Yes Yes
Pause and carry on, or start again, while recording Source Magpie: Stop ends the take, and Discard throws it away so you can record again, but a recording cannot be paused and carried on. Yes Partly
Read a script on a teleprompter while recording Source Loom: Speaker notes, in the Mac and Windows desktop app, opens a window of up to 10,000 characters that stays above other windows and is not recorded. The help does not say that it scrolls, and the Chrome extension has none. Partly Yes
Draw on the screen and highlight my clicks while I record Source Magpie: Screen Recorder records what the screen shows and adds nothing over it while recording. Pictures can be placed over the video afterwards in the recording editor. Yes No
Hide private details on a page before I record it Source Magpie: Whatever the shared screen shows is recorded. Afterwards, a picture placed over the video in the recording editor can cover part of it. Yes No
Record only part of my screen Source Magpie: The browser's chooser records a whole screen, a window or a tab. Screen position places a screen whose shape differs from the video's. Yes No
Record in high definition or 4K Source Magpie: The free plan records at 720p and Pro at 1080p. Higher video quality, on Pro, records at a higher bit rate and uses more storage. There is no 4K. Yes Partly
Record long videos, as many as I need Source Magpie: The free plan records 3 minutes a video and 1 a week; Pro records up to 30 minutes, with no weekly limit. Recordings use the plan's storage: 5 GB on the free plan and 100 GB with Pro. Yes Partly
Take a screenshot, mark it up and share it by link Source Magpie: Screen Recorder records video only. A picture is added to Your images by uploading it. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's camera can be a bubble of the shape you choose or a split-screen panel. Camera background blurs the room behind you, or removes it so you appear over your screen. Your browser does that work, and the camera picture is not sent anywhere.

Apps and integrations

Loom records from a desktop app, a Chrome extension and phone apps. It connects to Slack, Jira and Gmail. Magpie's Screen Recorder runs in a browser page on a computer, with nothing to install.

WhatLoomMagpie
Record from an app on my computer or a browser extension Source Magpie: Screen Recorder runs in a browser page, with nothing to install. Magpie's browser extension is for Password Vault and does not record. Yes No
Record my screen or camera from my phone Source Magpie: Screen Recorder records in a browser on a computer: a phone's browser cannot share its screen, and the page says so. The Magpie app does not record either; it uploads a video made with the phone's own screen recording, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes No
Upload a video I recorded elsewhere Source Magpie: On the website, a Supporters post can upload a video into Screen Recorder, but Screen Recorder itself has no upload. An upload counts toward the weekly recordings and must fit the plan's recording length. The Magpie app uploads an MP4 or WebM from Photos or Files, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Record and share from Slack, Jira, Gmail and the other tools my team uses Source Magpie: Screen Recorder connects to no other tool. A recording's link can be pasted anywhere, and opens for people signed in to Magpie. Yes No
Show a preview when I paste a video's link into a chat Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A pasted Magpie link shows the recording's thumbnail, title and length in a chat. The requests that build the preview are not counted as views.

Editing

Both trim a recording and cut out a part. Loom joins recordings, adds text and arrows, and edits by transcript on its paid plans.

WhatLoomMagpie
Trim the start and end, and cut out a part in the middle Source Yes Yes
Join several recordings into one video Source Magpie: Each recording is edited on its own; two recordings cannot be put together. Yes No
Cut words out of a video by deleting them from its transcript Source Magpie: Cuts are made on the timeline. A recording has no transcript of its own to edit from. Yes No
Have filler words and long silences taken out for me Source Magpie: Every cut is made by hand in the recording editor. Yes No
Put text, arrows and boxes on the video to point things out Source Magpie: The recording editor places pictures from Your images over the video for a time you set, and they show on the share page and in the downloaded MP4. There is no text, arrow or box of its own. Yes Partly
Use my own picture as the video's thumbnail Source Magpie: Thumbnail makes the frame on screen the picture shown before the video plays and when its link is shared. An uploaded picture cannot be used. Yes Partly
Show a moving preview of the video in an email Source Magpie: Share by email shows a still of the thumbnail, with a play badge and the length drawn on it. Yes No
Download the video as a file Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie's editor keeps the original file, and Reset cuts puts the whole recording back. Every plan has the editor, the free plan included.

Transcripts and Loom AI

Loom writes a transcript and captions for every video. Its AI writes titles, summaries, chapters and guides. Magpie writes nothing from a recording.

WhatLoomMagpie
Have a transcript and captions made automatically Source Magpie: A recording's Transcript is a Magpie Document you choose in Share page settings, shown beside the video with its links. Nothing is transcribed automatically, and the video has no captions. Yes Partly
Have a title, summary and chapters written from what I said Source Magpie: The title is typed before recording and can be renamed afterwards. A recording has no summary, and nothing is written from what was said. Yes No
Split a video into chapters viewers can jump to Source Magpie: The share page plays the video with the browser's own controls, with no chapters or timestamps. Yes No
Turn a recording into a written guide, a ticket or instructions for an AI agent Source Magpie: Nothing is written from a recording. A Document can be chosen as a recording's transcript or as the teleprompter's script. Yes No
Record a bug with the page's console and network logs attached Source Magpie: A recording holds the video and its sound only. Yes No
Add tasks to a video that viewers tick off Source Magpie: The share page can show Important links and an attached Form, but no tasks. Yes No
Ask questions about my videos, or let an AI app I use read them Source Magpie: The assistant finds your recordings by title, and can change a recording's sharing, images and cuts or move it to Trash. On Pro, an app such as Claude or ChatGPT connected through Connected apps can do the same. Neither can say what a video contains: spoken words are not searched. Yes Partly

Good to know: A Magpie Document you choose shows beside the video as its transcript, with its links. Editing the Document changes the transcript.

Library and spaces

Loom keeps videos in folders and in spaces the team shares. Magpie's Recordings is one list of your own recordings.

WhatLoomMagpie
Sort videos into folders, and archive old ones out of the way Source Magpie: Recordings is one list, with each recording's length, size, date and views. It has no folders and no archive. Yes No
Keep the team's videos in a shared library everyone in the team can browse Source Magpie: A recording belongs to the person who made it, whichever team is selected, and only they see it in Screen Recorder. Others watch it through its link or under Sent to you. Yes No
Find a video by its title or by something said in it Source Magpie: On the website, the assistant finds recordings by title, but the Recordings list has no search, Magpie's Search does not include recordings, and nothing said in a recording is searched. The Magpie app's Recordings list searches by title, but the app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
See the videos people sent me in one place Source Yes Yes
Get back a video I deleted by mistake Source Loom: A deleted video is removed at once and for good, and support cannot recover it. Archiving is the way to hide a video and keep it. No Yes

Good to know: Move to Trash keeps a recording for 30 days. Restoring it brings back its link, video and download.

Sharing and privacy

Both give you a link when the recording is done, and both send it by email. Loom's link can open for anyone, and a video can be kept to named people.

WhatLoomMagpie
Get a link to share as soon as I stop recording Source Yes Yes
Let anyone with the link watch without signing in Source Magpie: Anyone with the link watches after signing in to Magpie, and someone without an account gets a free one: the owner's rule for a link to private work. A recording placed in a Supporters post open to everyone plays there for anyone. Yes Partly
Let only my team, or only the people I name, watch a video Source Magpie: Anyone signed in to Magpie who has the link can watch. Share by email sends it to chosen people but does not stop others with the link. Yes No
Send a video to people by email Source Yes Yes
Put the video on my own website or inside another tool Source Magpie: A recording plays inside a Supporters post or a proposal, but there is no code to show it on another website or in another tool. Yes Partly

Good to know: Everyone who watches a Magpie recording is signed in to Magpie. Someone without an account gets a free one.

Engagement

Loom's viewers comment at a moment, react with emoji and reply with a video. Magpie's share page has buttons and a Form beside the video.

WhatLoomMagpie
Add buttons with the video that send viewers to a page Source Yes Yes
Collect answers from viewers in a form beside the video Source Loom: A call-to-action is a link to another page; the help describes no form shown with the video. No Yes
Let viewers comment at a moment in the video and react with emoji Source Magpie: The share page has no comments or reactions. People who were sent the recording by email can reply to that email. Yes No
Let viewers answer with a recording of their own Source Magpie: The share page has no way to reply with a video. Yes No
Be told when someone watches or comments on my video Source Magpie: Analytics shows who watched and how far, but nothing is sent to you when someone does. Yes No

Good to know: Important links shows up to 12 buttons below the video on every plan. Highlight puts one in the accent colour.

Viewer insights and branding

Both show who watched and how much of it. Loom adds completion rates, exports the figures and shows your own logo on the player.

WhatLoomMagpie
See who watched and how much of it Source Yes Yes
Download a video's viewing figures Source Magpie: Analytics is shown on its page, opened from the recording editor, and cannot be downloaded. Yes No
Show my videos with my logo and colours, without the recorder's name Source Magpie: The share page shows the Magpie wordmark above the recording, which plays in the browser's own video player. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's Analytics names each person who watched, with how far they got. It shows views per day over the last 30 days and where views came from.

Meeting recordings

Loom's notetaker joins Zoom, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls and saves the recording. Magpie's Video Chat holds the call itself.

WhatLoomMagpie
Have my Zoom, Google Meet and Teams meetings recorded, with notes and a recap Source Magpie: Meeting Notes, which records a meeting on your own device and writes a transcript and notes from it, is built but not yet open to members, so it counts as no for now. Video Chat holds the call itself. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's Meeting Notes records a meeting and writes notes from it. It is built but not yet open to members.

Admin and security

Loom's Enterprise plan adds single sign-on, directory sync, an activity log and retention rules. Magpie has a team audit log of who changed the team's members, guests and API keys, and none of the others.

WhatLoomMagpie
Sign in through my company's identity provider Source Magpie: People sign in with their Magpie account; there is no SAML single sign-on. Yes No
Add and remove people automatically from our company directory Source Magpie: Team admins invite and remove members by hand. Yes No
See who did what in our account Source Magpie: A team's admins open its Audit log: who changed its members, invitations, guests, API keys, Stripe account and owner, when and from which IP address, kept 12 months, with Export CSV. What people do with recordings is not in it. Yes Partly
Delete old videos automatically after a set time Source Magpie: A recording stays until its owner moves it to Trash. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie recording belongs to the person who made it, whichever team is selected. It stays until they move it to Trash.

Price comparison

How Loom charges

Loom charges by plan, per user: Starter, which is free, then Business, Business + AI and Enterprise. Starter keeps 25 videos a person of up to 5 minutes, at 720p, with no editing or download. Business adds unlimited recording, 4K, editing, uploads, calls to action and your own branding. Business + AI adds AI summaries and AI editing, and Enterprise adds single sign-on. Prices are on Loom's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. Screen Recorder follows your Personal plan. The Free plan records 1 recording a week of up to 3 minutes, at 720p. Pro records up to 30 minutes at 1080p, as many as your storage holds. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planLoomMagpie
Recording without paying25 videos a person, 5 minutes each1 a week, 3 minutes each
Longest recordingNo limit on Business and above30 minutes on Pro
Video quality720p on Starter; up to 4K on Business and above720p on Free; 1080p on Pro
Editing and downloadBusiness and aboveEvery plan
Calls to actionBusiness and aboveEvery plan, up to 12 buttons
AI summaries, chapters and edit by transcriptBusiness + AINot available
Your own brandingBusiness and aboveNot available
Single sign-on and directory syncEnterpriseNot available
Booking pages, invoicing and a websiteNot offeredIncluded

When to choose Magpie or Loom

  • Want to record, edit and download on the Free plan, with a teleprompter, a Form beside the video and the rest of the business in one subscription? Go with Magpie.
  • Want apps on every device, AI summaries, comments on the video, a team library and links anyone can open without an account? Loom is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a product or engineering team
Loom. Loom's Chrome extension, shared library and Slack and Jira connections suit a team that sends video daily. Its bug reports keep the page's console and network logs. Magpie's Screen Recorder has none of these.
For sending video to customers who have no account
Loom. A Public Loom link opens for anyone, with your logo on the player on Business. Every Magpie viewer signs in, and someone new gets a free account first.
For someone who reads a script to camera
Magpie. The teleprompter is on every plan, reads from a Document and can open in its own window. Loom's speaker notes are in its desktop app only.
For a coach, a teacher or a creator with paying supporters
Magpie. A recording plays inside a Supporters post, and Analytics names who watched. Courses and Newsletter are in the same team.
For a freelancer or a consultant
Magpie. A recording plays inside a proposal, with a Form beside it on its share page. Booking pages and Invoicing are in the same account.
For a larger company
Loom. Enterprise has single sign-on, directory sync, an activity log and retention rules. Magpie has a team audit log, and no single sign-on, directory sync or retention rules.
For a few short videos a month
Either. Loom's Starter keeps 25 videos of up to 5 minutes, without editing or download. Magpie's Free plan records 1 video a week of up to 3 minutes, with both. Choose by whether you record more or edit more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Loom and Magpie?

Loom is a video messaging product with apps, a Chrome extension, AI and a team library. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Screen Recorder is one area beside Video Chat, booking pages, invoicing, Documents and Forms. Loom does more for the video itself; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Loom?

Yes, for someone who records short videos for clients or supporters. Magpie records the screen with your camera, edits and downloads on every plan, and names who watched.

Consider keeping Loom if your viewers should watch without an account, or if you record on a phone. Keep it too if you want AI summaries, comments on the video or a team library. Loom does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Loom cost?

Loom has four plans, priced per user: Starter, which is free, Business, Business + AI and Enterprise. Starter keeps 25 videos a person of up to 5 minutes. Business adds unlimited recording, editing and downloads, and Business + AI adds Loom's AI. The prices are on Loom's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Screen Recorder's Free plan records 1 video a week of up to 3 minutes. Pro records up to 30 minutes at 1080p, with 100 GB of storage. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Can people watch a Magpie recording without an account?

No. Anyone with the link watches after signing in to Magpie. Someone without an account gets a free one first. A recording in a Supporters post open to everyone plays there for anyone. A Public Loom video opens for anyone with the link.

Can I keep a Magpie recording to named people?

No. Anyone signed in to Magpie who has the link can watch. Share by email sends it to the people you choose, but does not stop others with the link. Loom can restrict a video to the email addresses you add, on every plan.

Does Magpie have a desktop app or a Chrome extension?

No. Screen Recorder runs in a browser page on a computer, with nothing to install. The browser's chooser records a screen, a window or a tab. Loom has a desktop app for Mac and Windows and a Chrome extension.

Can I record on my phone with Magpie?

No. A phone's browser cannot share its screen, and the Magpie app does not record. The app uploads a video made with the phone's own screen recording. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Loom's phone apps record the screen or the camera.

Can I record only my camera in Magpie?

No. Screen Recorder always records a screen, a window or a tab. The camera is added to it as a bubble or a side panel. Loom's Camera only mode records the camera full screen.

Can I blur my background in Magpie?

Yes. Camera background in the recorder's Options blurs the room behind you, or removes it so you appear over your screen. Your browser does the work, on every plan. Loom blurs the background or puts a colour or one of its pictures behind you, in its desktop app and Chrome extension.

Can I pause a recording in Magpie?

No. Stop ends the take, and Discard throws it away so you can record again. Pausing is on Magpie's roadmap. Loom pauses from the camera bubble or with a keyboard shortcut.

Does Magpie transcribe recordings or add captions?

No. A Magpie Document you choose can show beside the video as its transcript. Nothing is transcribed for you, and the video has no captions. Loom writes a transcript and captions for every video, in more than 50 languages.

Does Magpie write AI summaries of videos?

No. A recording has the title you typed and no summary or chapters. The assistant finds recordings by title, but not by what was said. Loom's AI writes summaries, chapters and step-by-step guides on Business + AI.

Can viewers comment on a Magpie recording?

No. The share page has no comments, reactions or video replies. People sent the recording by email can reply to that email. Loom's viewers comment at a moment on the timeline and reply with a video.

Does Magpie have folders or a team library?

No. Recordings is one list of your own recordings, with each one's length, size, date and views. Others watch through the link, or under Sent to you. Loom has folders, an archive and spaces the team shares.

Can I edit and download on the free plan?

Yes in Magpie. Every plan trims, cuts out a part and places pictures over the video. It downloads an MP4 with your cuts. Loom's Starter has no editing and no download; both need Business or above.

Does Loom have a teleprompter?

Partly. Loom's desktop app opens speaker notes of up to 10,000 characters, which are not recorded. Magpie's teleprompter scrolls a script at a pace you set and reads from a Document. It can open in its own window. It is on every plan.

Can I get back a video I deleted?

In Magpie, yes. Move to Trash keeps a recording for 30 days, and restoring it brings back its link and download. Loom removes a deleted video at once and for good. Archiving is the way to keep one out of sight.

Can I see who watched my video?

Yes, in both. Magpie's Analytics names each person who watched and how far they got. Every viewer is signed in. Loom names signed-in viewers and counts the rest as anonymous. Loom's Business plans export the figures; Magpie's cannot be downloaded.

Does Magpie record Zoom or Google Meet calls?

No. Magpie's Meeting Notes records a meeting and writes notes from it. It is not yet open to members. Video Chat holds calls in Magpie itself. Loom's notetaker joins Zoom, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams calls from your calendar.

Can I use Loom and Magpie together?

Yes. A Loom link can go in Mail, Team chat or a Document like any other link. You can keep Loom for video and use Magpie for bookings, invoices and the website.

How do I move from Loom to Magpie?

Record new videos in Screen Recorder; your Loom links keep working in Loom. Screen Recorder has no upload of its own on the website. A video uploaded in a Supporters post is added to Screen Recorder. It must fit the plan's recording length. Loom downloads an MP4 on Business and above.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Screen Recorder with 1 recording a week of up to 3 minutes, the editor, downloads and Analytics. Booking pages, Invoicing, Store, a website, the Newsletter, Forms and a team of 3. Storage is 5 GB, and sharing a recording by email needs a paid plan.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Loom changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Loom's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Record your screen on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then make your first recording in Screen Recorder.

Create account