Big Cartel compared with Magpie

Big Cartel vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Big Cartel and Magpie both give an artist or a small business an online shop at its own domain. They are built around different things.

  1. Big Cartel is a shop builder for artists and small businesses, with a free plan and no fee on sales. Apps from other companies add print-on-demand, reviews and email. It is built for bands, printmakers, illustrators and makers whose shop is the main thing they run.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Store is one part of it. Beside the shop it includes booking pages, invoicing, a newsletter, courses, a website and email at your domain. It is built for someone whose shop is one part of running the business.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s Store as a buyer sees it, in the Siena design: the shop’s name and menu in a red bar, “Prints and paper goods, made by hand in Chicago.” in large italic type, and the first of its prints below.

How is Magpie different?

1. The shop comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Store, the area this page is about, for physical products, downloads, bundles and gift cards
  • Newsletter for email to subscribers, and Supporters for paid posts
  • Meetings and Appointments for booking pages, and Invoicing for invoices paid online
  • Websites for a site with a blog, and Mail for email addresses at your domain
  • Courses, Forms, Contacts, Accounting, Inventory and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Big Cartel covers the shop, and adds email lists, reviews and gift cards through apps from other companies.

2. Every part of the shop is on every plan

Magpie's Free plan sets no limit on the number of products or images; files count toward the account's storage. Discount codes, stock tracking, checkout reminders, reviews, gift cards and a custom domain are on every plan. The paid plan raises storage and the team's size, and adds the Store API.

3. Pre-orders, personalisation and download limits are built in

A product can stay on sale after it sells out, with an expected ship date. Personalisation fields ask each buyer for text, a choice or a date, at an added price if you want. A download product sets how many days and how many downloads each order gets.

Comparing Magpie and Big Cartel

Big Cartel does more for the maker who ships and sells at markets; Magpie does more around the shop. Every line in the tables below was checked against Big Cartel's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Online shopProducts, a cart and checkout at your own address Yes Yes
Free planA shop that sells without a monthly charge 5 products Yes
Digital downloadsFiles the buyer gets after paying Yes Yes
SubscriptionsA monthly charge for a box you ship Yes No
Monthly support from fansSupporters pay every month Yes Supporters
Shop designDesigns with your colours, fonts and logo Yes Yes
Edit the shop's codeChange the HTML and CSS of every page Yes Yes
Shop at your own domainYour domain, with a certificate Platinum and above Yes
PayPal and VenmoBuyers pay with their PayPal account Yes PayPal through Stripe
Sales tax paid for youTax worked out, collected and paid by the platform US Worked out by Stripe Tax
Shipping labelsDiscounted labels bought on the order page Platinum and above No
Print-on-demandA service prints and ships each order Yes No
Selling in personCash and cards at a market, from the same stock Platinum and above Cash only
Phone appOrders, products and notifications on a phone Yes In the browser
Discount codesCodes and automatic discounts Platinum and above Yes
Gift cardsCards buyers spend in the shop Gift Up! app Yes
Product reviewsBuyers review what they bought Fera app Yes
Pre-ordersSell before stock arrives, with a ship date No Yes
Email newslettersEmails to a list of subscribers Mailchimp app Yes
Ad pixels and analyticsGoogle Analytics or a Meta, TikTok or Pinterest pixel Yes No
Booking pagesClients choose a time and get a confirmation No Yes
No fee on salesOnly the card fee comes off a sale Yes No

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Products

Both sell products with photos, sizes and colours, stock and categories. Big Cartel limits how many products and photos each plan lists; Magpie sets no limit.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Add a product with photos, a price and a description Source Yes Yes
Sell sizes and colours, each with its own price and stock Source Yes Yes
Track stock so a product sells out by itself Source Yes Yes
Show a product as coming soon before people can buy it Source Magpie: A product can go live with its stock tracked at zero: shoppers see it marked sold out and can ask to be emailed when it can be bought. It says sold out rather than coming soon, and shows its price. Yes Partly
Have products go live by themselves at a set time Source Yes Yes
Keep some products for people who know a password, such as members or VIPs Source Magpie: A live product is open to every visitor. A preview password opens a whole Store only before it is published, and only for browsing, and wholesale prices show only to business customers you approve. Yes No
Change many products at once Source Yes Yes
Group products into categories shoppers can browse Source Yes Yes
Bring my products over from Etsy, Shopify or Squarespace Source Magpie: Store imports a CSV in its own columns, such as Handle, Title, Option 1 name and SKU, and a products file in Magpie's JSON format, or a ZIP of it with the photos. Update from Poshmark reads a Poshmark closet and brings its listings over with their photos. A Shopify CSV export's titles, options, SKUs, brands and tags are read as they are, but its price, description and stock columns have to be renamed first, and an Etsy or Squarespace file has to be rearranged. Yes Partly
Take pre-orders and back orders with an expected ship date Source Big Cartel: There is no pre-order setting. The help suggests writing in the description that an item is a pre-order and when it will ship, and selling it as usual. No Yes
Ask buyers how they want an item made, such as an engraving Source Big Cartel: Checkout has one free-text notes box for the whole order, which sellers ask buyers to use for custom details. Partly Yes

Good to know: Sell when out of stock keeps a sold-out product on sale, with an Expected to ship date. A Pre-orders tab in Orders lists those orders.

Digital products and subscriptions

Both sell files to download. Big Cartel also charges subscribers monthly for a box they ship. They do it better than we do today.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Sell files that buyers download straight after paying Source Yes Yes
Limit how long and how many times a buyer can download a file Source Big Cartel: Buyers can download their files as often as they like for as long as the product stays in the shop; the help says download counts cannot be limited. No Yes
Charge subscribers every month for a box I ship them Source Magpie: Every Store product is paid once at checkout. Supporters charges monthly or yearly for posts, not shipped goods, and Store's monthly payment plans are only for course prices and stop after a set number of payments. Yes No
Let fans support me with a monthly payment Source Yes Yes
Sell appointment times, such as a session or a class Source Big Cartel: There is no booking calendar. The help suggests listing each time slot as a variant with a stock of one, or linking to a booking tool such as Calendly. Partly Yes

Good to know: A Store download product holds up to 50 files of up to 500 MB each. It can give each buyer a licence key.

Shop design

Both offer designs with your colours, fonts and logo, and the template's code to edit. Big Cartel translates the shop's own words into the customer's language.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Choose a design for my shop and change its colours, fonts and logo Source Yes Yes
Edit my shop's HTML and CSS for a design of my own Source Yes Yes
Add pages such as my policies, a size chart or an About page Source Yes Yes
Show my shop at my own domain Source Yes Yes
Show my shop in my customers' language Source Magpie: The words Magpie adds to a Store, and the emails buyers get, follow the team's Language for customers: English, French, Spanish or German. Product text is shown as you wrote it. Yes Partly
Close my shop for a while, such as on holiday, with a message to visitors Source Magpie: Unpublish takes the Store offline and keeps its products, orders and settings, but visitors then see a page saying it cannot be found, or one asking for the preview password if one is set, never a message of your own. While the Store stays open, its Announcement line can say you are away. Yes Partly

Good to know: Edit code on Design opens the Store's whole template as one file, with a preview of each page. Each published version is kept, and any can be edited again.

Payments, checkout and tax

Both take cards and wallets through Stripe. Big Cartel also connects PayPal with Venmo, and pays US sales tax for you.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Take card payments online Source Yes Yes
Let buyers pay with PayPal or Venmo Source Magpie: Store has no PayPal account to connect. With Payment methods turned on in Stripe, Stripe's page offers PayPal in the countries where Stripe supports it; Venmo is not offered. Yes Partly
Let buyers pay later in instalments with Afterpay, Klarna or Affirm Source Yes Yes
Have US sales tax worked out, collected and paid for me Source Magpie: With Stripe Tax turned on, Stripe works out and charges the tax for the places registered in your Stripe account, with a tax category per product. You stay responsible for registering, filing and paying it. Yes Partly
Charge VAT or GST on sales outside the US Source Yes Yes
Share a link that fills a cart with products I chose Source Magpie: A buy link opens checkout with one item and a quantity, a bundle sells several chosen products as one product with its own buy link, and a signed-in shopper can share a wishlist, but no link fills a cart with several products. Yes Partly
Sell gift cards that buyers spend in my shop Source Big Cartel: The Gift Up! app sells gift cards on a separate checkout for a 3.49% fee and turns each into a discount code that has to be spent in one order. Paid plans. Partly Yes

Good to know: A Magpie Store can also take orders paid at pickup, on delivery or by bank transfer. You mark each order paid when the money arrives.

Orders and shipping

Both set shipping rates, email tracking, print packing slips and refund orders. Big Cartel buys discounted labels and works out USPS rates at checkout.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Set shipping prices for the places I ship to Source Yes Yes
Charge the carrier's live shipping rate at checkout Source Magpie: Store does not ask carriers for rates. A method charged by weight, or by size and weight, uses a table of prices you set. In a zone with Canada in it, Standard prices charges by Magpie's own table of prices by postal code and weight, which is not a carrier's live rate. Yes No
Buy and print discounted shipping labels Source Magpie: Store does not buy labels. A shipment records the carrier, tracking number and tracking address of a label bought elsewhere. Yes No
Email buyers when their order ships, with tracking Source Yes Yes
Find orders, print packing slips and export them Source Yes Yes
Cancel or refund an order and put items back in stock Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Magpie's shipping zones go down to a state or a postal code. Local pickup and local delivery on chosen dates are methods too.

Marketing and discounts

Both have discount codes, related products, search titles and feeds for Google and Meta. Big Cartel adds pixels for ads and a line saying few are left.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Make discount codes for a sale or a promotion Source Yes Yes
Apply a discount without a code Source Yes Yes
Email shoppers who left without paying Source Yes Yes
Tell shoppers when an item is almost sold out Source Magpie: Shoppers see whether an item is in stock or sold out, not how few are left. Low-stock alerts go only to the team, when stock reaches a reorder point. Yes No
Show related products on a product's page Source Yes Yes
Add buyers to my mailing list and send them news Source Yes Yes
Collect and show product reviews from buyers Source Big Cartel: Reviews come from the Fera app, which asks buyers for reviews and shows them with photos and videos; it is a paid app after a free trial. Partly Yes
Help search engines find my products Source Yes Yes
Show my products on Google Shopping, Instagram and Facebook Source Yes Yes
Measure my ads with Google Analytics or a Meta, TikTok or Pinterest pixel Source Magpie: Store counts its own page views without a cookie and records where orders came from with UTM tags, but no analytics or pixel code runs on its pages. Yes No

Good to know: Discounts, checkout reminders and reviews are on every Magpie plan. Big Cartel keeps automatic discounts and abandoned cart emails for Diamond.

Selling in person and through apps

Big Cartel's free app runs the shop and takes cards at a market. It also connects print-on-demand services and Zapier.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
Sell at markets and pop-ups, taking cash and cards on my phone Source Magpie: On the website, New order records a sale paid in cash and takes its items from stock. The Magpie app's Sell register, with barcode scanning and a cash count, is built, but the app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play and takes no cards yet. Yes Partly
Run my shop from an app on my phone Source Magpie: Store's pages work in a phone's browser. The Magpie app has Store's orders, products, stock, discounts and reports, with a notification for each new order, but it is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Have a print-on-demand service make and ship my products Source Magpie: Store connects to no print-on-demand or dropshipping service, so every physical order is packed and shipped by you. Yes No
Connect my shop to other apps with Zapier Source Magpie: Store's signed webhooks can start a Zapier or Make workflow that catches webhooks, and the Store API, which needs Pro, reads and changes orders, products and stock. Magpie has no app of its own in Zapier. Yes Partly

Good to know: The Magpie app has Store's orders, products, stock and a cash register. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play.

Dashboard

Both show visitors, orders, conversion and revenue for any dates. Big Cartel puts the period before beside the one you chose.

WhatBig CartelMagpie
See my visitors, orders, conversion and revenue Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Store reports also show Stripe fees, payouts, margins by product and where orders came from. Each table exports as CSV, and a summary can arrive weekly by email.

Price comparison

How Big Cartel charges

Big Cartel charges by plan: Gold is free, and Platinum and Diamond are paid monthly, with a 7-day trial of Platinum. The plan sets how many products and photos you list, and what the shop can do. Discounts, inventory tracking, a custom domain and shipping labels start at Platinum. Scheduled drops, automatic discounts and abandoned cart emails need Diamond. Big Cartel takes no fee on sales; Stripe or PayPal charges its card fees. Prices are on Big Cartel's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account: the shop, bookings, invoicing, the newsletter and the rest. The plan sets storage and the team's size, not which parts of the shop you can use. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales paid through Stripe, and Stripe's card fees apply too. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planBig CartelMagpie
Fee on shop salesNone4%
Card feesCharged by Stripe or PayPalStripe's fees, through your own Stripe account
Products5 on Gold, 50 on Platinum, 500 on DiamondNo limit on any plan
Images per product1 on Gold, 5 on Platinum, 25 on DiamondNo limit; files count toward 5 GB on Free, 100 GB on a paid plan
Discount codes and stock trackingPlatinum and aboveEvery plan
Abandoned cart emailsDiamondEvery plan
Gift cards and reviewsApps from other companies, at their own priceIncluded
Email newslettersMailchimp or Omnisend, at their own priceIncluded
Shipping labelsPlatinum and above, in the US, Canada and UKNot available; labels are bought elsewhere
Booking pages and invoicingNot offeredIncluded; 4% of payments taken when booking

When to choose Magpie or Big Cartel

  • Want the shop beside bookings, invoices, a newsletter and a website, with every part of the shop on the Free plan? Go with Magpie.
  • Want no fee on sales, shipping labels, print-on-demand, subscription boxes and a phone app that takes cards? Big Cartel is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a band or an artist selling prints and merch
Big Cartel. Printful, Printify and theprintspace print and ship each order. The app takes cards at a gig or a market. Magpie connects to no print-on-demand service, and its register takes cash only.
For a maker who ships every day
Big Cartel. Discounted labels from USPS, FedEx, Canada Post and others are bought on the order page. Checkout charges live USPS rates. In Magpie you buy labels elsewhere and type the tracking number.
For a shop with made-to-order products
Magpie. Personalisation fields ask each buyer for an engraving or a choice, and pre-orders carry a ship date. Big Cartel has one notes box for the whole order.
For a shop with a large catalogue
Magpie. Magpie sets no limit on products or images. Discounts, stock tracking and checkout reminders are on every plan. Big Cartel lists up to 500 products, on Diamond.
For a business that sells and also books clients
Magpie. Booking pages, invoices paid online and a newsletter are in the same team as the shop. Appointments takes a service's price or a deposit when a client books. Big Cartel suggests listing time slots as products, or a booking service elsewhere.
For a small shop starting out
Either. Big Cartel's Gold plan sells five products with no fee on sales. Magpie's Free plan sells any number, for 4% of each sale. Choose by how many products you have and how much you sell.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Big Cartel and Magpie?

Big Cartel is a shop builder for artists and small businesses, with a free plan and no fee on sales. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Store is one area beside booking pages, invoicing, a newsletter and a website. Big Cartel does more for shipping and selling at markets; Magpie does more around the shop.

Does Magpie replace Big Cartel?

Yes, for a shop that ships its own products and wants the rest of the business in one place. Store sells physical products and downloads, with discounts, gift cards, reviews and checkout reminders on every plan.

Consider keeping Big Cartel if you buy shipping labels from the order page, use print-on-demand, or sell subscription boxes. Keep it too if you take cards at markets on your phone, or want no fee on sales. Big Cartel does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Big Cartel cost?

Big Cartel has a free Gold plan with 5 products, and Platinum and Diamond, paid monthly, with 50 and 500 products. Platinum has a 7-day trial. Big Cartel takes no fee on sales, and Stripe or PayPal charges its card fees. The prices are on Big Cartel's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Store has no product limit on any plan. Files count toward the storage of Personal or the team the Store is in. That is 5 GB on Free, 100 GB for Personal on Pro, and 1 TB for a team on the Team plan. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales paid through Stripe. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Big Cartel take a fee on sales?

No. Big Cartel takes no fee on sales on any plan. The card fee from Stripe or PayPal comes off each payment. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales paid through Stripe, on top of Stripe's card fees.

Does Magpie have subscriptions for a monthly box?

No. Every Store product is paid once at checkout. Supporters charges monthly or yearly for posts, not for goods you ship. Subscription products are on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel charges subscribers monthly and makes each payment an order to ship.

Can Magpie print shipping labels?

No. Store does not buy labels or ask carriers for live rates. A shipment records the carrier and tracking number of a label bought elsewhere, and emails the buyer. Both are on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel buys discounted labels on the order page in the US, Canada and UK.

Does Magpie work with Printful or Printify?

No. Store connects to no print-on-demand or dropshipping service, so you pack and ship every physical order. Print-on-demand is on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel connects Printful, Printify and theprintspace.

Can I sell at markets with Magpie?

Partly. On the website, New order records a sale paid in cash and takes its items from stock. The Magpie app has a register with barcode scanning and a cash count. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play and takes no cards yet. Big Cartel's app takes cash and cards with Tap to Pay or a Stripe reader.

Does Magpie have a phone app for my shop?

Store's pages work in a phone's browser. The Magpie app has Store's orders, products, stock, discounts and reports, with a notification for each new order. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Big Cartel's app is free on iPhone, iPad and Android.

Can buyers pay with PayPal in a Magpie Store?

Partly. Store has no PayPal account to connect. With Payment methods turned on in Stripe, Stripe's checkout offers PayPal in the countries where Stripe supports it. Venmo is not offered. Big Cartel connects PayPal directly, with Venmo for US orders.

Does Magpie handle US sales tax for me?

Partly. With Stripe Tax on, Stripe works out and charges the tax for the places you registered in Stripe. You still register, file and pay it yourself. Big Cartel collects and pays US sales tax for shops selling in US dollars.

Can I add Google Analytics or a Meta pixel to a Magpie Store?

No. Store counts its own page views without a cookie and records where orders came from with UTM tags. No analytics or pixel code runs on its pages, and a template cannot run scripts. Ad tracking is on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel takes a Google Analytics tag and Meta, TikTok and Pinterest pixels on paid plans.

Can I password-protect products in Magpie?

No. A live product is open to every visitor. A preview password opens the whole Store only before it is published. Wholesale prices show only to business customers you approve. Big Cartel puts a password on chosen products on Diamond.

Does Big Cartel have pre-orders?

No. Big Cartel's help suggests writing in the description that an item is a pre-order. In Magpie, Sell when out of stock keeps an item on sale with an Expected to ship date.

Does Big Cartel have gift cards and reviews?

Through apps from other companies. Gift Up! sells gift cards on its own checkout for a 3.49% fee, and Fera collects reviews for a monthly price. Magpie includes both. Gift cards spend over several orders, and Store asks buyers for a review after their order ships.

Can I edit my Magpie Store's HTML and CSS?

Yes, on every plan. Edit code on Design opens the Store's whole template as one file of HTML and CSS. Each page has a preview. You can change it by hand or with an AI chat, and each published version is kept. A template cannot run scripts. Big Cartel's Code section edits its template too.

Can I move my shop from Big Cartel to Magpie?

Partly. Store imports a CSV file in its own columns, or a products file in Magpie's JSON format with the photos in a ZIP. A Big Cartel export has to be rearranged into one of them first. Your domain stays where it is registered and points at the Store with the records Magpie lists. Magpie gets the certificate.

Can I use Big Cartel and Magpie together?

Yes. A Big Cartel shop can link to a Magpie booking page, a Newsletter sign-up page or a form. Invoices from Magpie's Invoicing are paid online through your own Stripe account. Products and stock are not shared between the two.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Store with any number of products, discounts, gift cards, reviews and checkout reminders. Booking pages, Invoicing, a website, the Newsletter, Forms and a team of 3 come with it. A paid plan adds email at your domain and the Store API, and raises storage.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Big Cartel changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Big Cartel's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Open a shop on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then set up your Store.

Create account