What is the difference between Big Cartel and Magpie?
Big Cartel is a shop builder for artists and small businesses, with a free plan and no fee on sales. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Store is one area beside booking pages, invoicing, a newsletter and a website. Big Cartel does more for shipping and selling at markets; Magpie does more around the shop.
Does Magpie replace Big Cartel?
Yes, for a shop that ships its own products and wants the rest of the business in one place. Store sells physical products and downloads, with discounts, gift cards, reviews and checkout reminders on every plan.
Consider keeping Big Cartel if you buy shipping labels from the order page, use print-on-demand, or sell subscription boxes. Keep it too if you take cards at markets on your phone, or want no fee on sales. Big Cartel does each of these better than Magpie does today.
How much does Big Cartel cost?
Big Cartel has a free Gold plan with 5 products, and Platinum and Diamond, paid monthly, with 50 and 500 products. Platinum has a 7-day trial. Big Cartel takes no fee on sales, and Stripe or PayPal charges its card fees. The prices are on Big Cartel's pricing page.
How much does Magpie cost?
Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Store has no product limit on any plan. Files count toward the storage of Personal or the team the Store is in. That is 5 GB on Free, 100 GB for Personal on Pro, and 1 TB for a team on the Team plan. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales paid through Stripe. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.
Does Big Cartel take a fee on sales?
No. Big Cartel takes no fee on sales on any plan. The card fee from Stripe or PayPal comes off each payment. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales paid through Stripe, on top of Stripe's card fees.
Does Magpie have subscriptions for a monthly box?
No. Every Store product is paid once at checkout. Supporters charges monthly or yearly for posts, not for goods you ship. Subscription products are on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel charges subscribers monthly and makes each payment an order to ship.
Can Magpie print shipping labels?
No. Store does not buy labels or ask carriers for live rates. A shipment records the carrier and tracking number of a label bought elsewhere, and emails the buyer. Both are on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel buys discounted labels on the order page in the US, Canada and UK.
Does Magpie work with Printful or Printify?
No. Store connects to no print-on-demand or dropshipping service, so you pack and ship every physical order. Print-on-demand is on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel connects Printful, Printify and theprintspace.
Can I sell at markets with Magpie?
Partly. On the website, New order records a sale paid in cash and takes its items from stock. The Magpie app has a register with barcode scanning and a cash count. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play and takes no cards yet. Big Cartel's app takes cash and cards with Tap to Pay or a Stripe reader.
Does Magpie have a phone app for my shop?
Store's pages work in a phone's browser. The Magpie app has Store's orders, products, stock, discounts and reports, with a notification for each new order. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Big Cartel's app is free on iPhone, iPad and Android.
Can buyers pay with PayPal in a Magpie Store?
Partly. Store has no PayPal account to connect. With Payment methods turned on in Stripe, Stripe's checkout offers PayPal in the countries where Stripe supports it. Venmo is not offered. Big Cartel connects PayPal directly, with Venmo for US orders.
Does Magpie handle US sales tax for me?
Partly. With Stripe Tax on, Stripe works out and charges the tax for the places you registered in Stripe. You still register, file and pay it yourself. Big Cartel collects and pays US sales tax for shops selling in US dollars.
Can I add Google Analytics or a Meta pixel to a Magpie Store?
No. Store counts its own page views without a cookie and records where orders came from with UTM tags. No analytics or pixel code runs on its pages, and a template cannot run scripts. Ad tracking is on Magpie's roadmap. Big Cartel takes a Google Analytics tag and Meta, TikTok and Pinterest pixels on paid plans.
Can I password-protect products in Magpie?
No. A live product is open to every visitor. A preview password opens the whole Store only before it is published. Wholesale prices show only to business customers you approve. Big Cartel puts a password on chosen products on Diamond.
Does Big Cartel have pre-orders?
No. Big Cartel's help suggests writing in the description that an item is a pre-order. In Magpie, Sell when out of stock keeps an item on sale with an Expected to ship date.
Does Big Cartel have gift cards and reviews?
Through apps from other companies. Gift Up! sells gift cards on its own checkout for a 3.49% fee, and Fera collects reviews for a monthly price. Magpie includes both. Gift cards spend over several orders, and Store asks buyers for a review after their order ships.
Can I edit my Magpie Store's HTML and CSS?
Yes, on every plan. Edit code on Design opens the Store's whole template as one file of HTML and CSS. Each page has a preview. You can change it by hand or with an AI chat, and each published version is kept. A template cannot run scripts. Big Cartel's Code section edits its template too.
Can I move my shop from Big Cartel to Magpie?
Partly. Store imports a CSV file in its own columns, or a products file in Magpie's JSON format with the photos in a ZIP. A Big Cartel export has to be rearranged into one of them first. Your domain stays where it is registered and points at the Store with the records Magpie lists. Magpie gets the certificate.
Can I use Big Cartel and Magpie together?
Yes. A Big Cartel shop can link to a Magpie booking page, a Newsletter sign-up page or a form. Invoices from Magpie's Invoicing are paid online through your own Stripe account. Products and stock are not shared between the two.
What is included in Magpie's Free plan?
Store with any number of products, discounts, gift cards, reviews and checkout reminders. Booking pages, Invoicing, a website, the Newsletter, Forms and a team of 3 come with it. A paid plan adds email at your domain and the Store API, and raises storage.