FreshBooks compared with Magpie

FreshBooks vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

FreshBooks and Magpie both invoice clients, track time and expenses, and keep the books. FreshBooks does more around getting paid; Magpie does more around the rest of the business.

  1. FreshBooks is invoicing and accounting software for small businesses, with estimates, payments, time tracking, expenses and payroll. It is built for a freelancer or a small firm that bills clients and wants more ways to be paid.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Invoicing is one part of it. Beside the invoices it includes Proposals, Accounting, Payroll, booking pages, Store and a website. It is built for someone whose invoicing is one part of running the business.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s draft invoice CS-1044 to Maria Szczepanski at Albers Coffee: its dates and payment, then items for bag artwork, a menu board, an email template and proof review, each with its quantity, unit price, sales tax and amount.

How is Magpie different?

1. Invoicing comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a service business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Invoicing, with recurring invoices, reminders and card payments online
  • Proposals that clients sign, with a deposit invoice on acceptance
  • Meetings and Appointments for booking pages
  • Client Portal for each client's invoices, files and proposals
  • E-Signatures for any contract, and Store for selling online
  • Accounting, Expenses, Time Tracking, Payroll and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. FreshBooks covers invoicing, payments, projects, time, expenses and accounting, with no booking page or shop.

2. Every plan has every area

Accounting, bills, reconciling, Proposals and Payroll are on every Magpie plan, Free included. The Free plan limits how much, such as 5 invoices a month and 100 contacts. FreshBooks keeps double-entry accounting and proposals for Plus and above. Bills need Premium.

3. A team pays one price, payroll included

The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Payroll is in every plan, not an add-on. A pay run reads hours from Time Tracking or shifts. Each employee reads a payslip in Magpie. FreshBooks charges for each team member beyond the plan, and Payroll is a separate subscription.

Comparing Magpie and FreshBooks

FreshBooks does more around getting paid; Magpie does more around the business. Every line below was checked against FreshBooks' own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatFreshBooksMagpie
InvoicingInvoices with reminders and recurring schedules Yes Yes
Invoice templatesA choice of layout, colour and font Yes One layout
Saved items and servicesInvoice lines picked from a list Yes No
Late feesA fee added when an invoice is late Yes No
RetainersA monthly fee with hours counted against it Plus and above Partly
Estimates and proposalsAccepted and signed online, then invoiced Proposals on Plus and above Yes
Card payments on invoicesCards, Apple Pay and Google Pay Yes Yes
Bank and pay-later paymentsACH, Affirm, Klarna and Afterpay Yes No
AutoPayA saved card pays each recurring invoice Yes From proposals
Instant payoutsCard payments in the bank within minutes Yes No
A place for clientsClients see and pay what was sent to them Yes Yes
Time trackingA timer and timesheets for clients and projects Yes Yes
Project profitIncome against costs, the cost of time included Premium and above Partly
PayrollPay runs from salaries and hours, with payslips Separate subscription Yes
Payroll tax and direct depositTax worked out and filed, pay sent to the bank Yes No
Expenses and receiptsEach expense with its category and receipt Yes Yes
Receipt readingA photo of a receipt fills in its details Plus and above No
MileageTrips logged and valued per mile Yes No
BillsWhat the business owes suppliers Premium and above Yes
Double-entry booksChart of accounts, journal entries, reconciling Plus and above Yes
Bank feedsBank transactions come in by themselves Yes CSV statements
Business financingLoans and cash advances against sales Yes No
Booking pagesClients choose a time with you No Yes
Online shopProducts, a cart and checkout No Yes
Phone appsInvoices, receipts and time on a phone Yes In the browser
Free planInvoice clients without paying Free trial Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Invoices

Both send invoices with reminders, recurring schedules and tracked time. FreshBooks adds templates, saved items, late fees, credits and client statements. They do it better than we do today.

WhatFreshBooksMagpie
Send a client an invoice with my logo and business details Source Yes Yes
Choose how my invoices look: layout, colour and font Source Magpie: Every invoice has one layout with the logo, business name, address and tax ID from Invoicing settings; its colours, font and layout cannot be chosen. Yes Partly
Write the emails my clients get with invoices and reminders Source Yes Yes
Share an invoice by a link instead of by email Source Yes Yes
Put tracked time on a client's invoice Source Magpie: Add unbilled time lists the admin's own billable Time Tracking entries for the contact and makes each an item; a teammate's time has to be typed in. Yes Partly
Bill a client for an expense, with a markup Source Magpie: Add unbilled expenses lists only your own expenses marked reimbursable for the contact, at their cost; there is no markup, and a purchase on the business card or a teammate's expense is typed onto the invoice. Yes Partly
Add invoice lines from my saved services and products Source Magpie: Each invoice line is typed. Proposals has a price list, and Store keeps products with prices, but neither feeds an invoice. Yes No
Bill each client in their own currency and language Source Magpie: Each invoice has its own currency. The invoice, its PDF and its emails use the team's one language for customers: English, French, Spanish or German. A proposal has its own currency and language. Yes Partly
Invoice a client the same thing on a schedule Source Yes Yes
Bill a monthly retainer and count the hours used against it Source Magpie: Make recurring bills the fee each month, quarter or year, and a Time Tracking project can have an hour budget, but the budget counts all the project's time ever, not each period's, and there is no retainer summary for the client. Yes Partly
Remind clients automatically when an invoice is due or late Source Yes Yes
Charge a late fee when an invoice is paid late Source Magpie: Payment reminders go out on the team's chosen days, up to 30 days after the due date, but no fee is added; a late fee has to be put on a new invoice by hand. Yes No
Know when a client has opened an invoice Source Magpie: An invoice's Activity shows each email and whether the email service accepted it; opening it is not recorded. Proposals do record each time they are opened. The Magpie app, not yet in the App Store or Google Play, will tell the person who made an invoice when it is paid in full. Yes No
Give a client a credit that comes off a later invoice Source Magpie: Record refund notes money given back on an invoice, and Void invoice cancels an unpaid one; no credit carries over to a later invoice. Store gives store credit on its own orders. Yes Partly
Send a client a statement of what they owe Source Magpie: Invoices shared to a client's Client Portal are listed there with what is left to pay, and Accounting's Accounts receivable report shows what each customer owes; there is no statement to send. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's Free plan sends 5 invoices a month to up to 100 contacts. A paid plan has no limit on either.

Estimates and proposals

Both send an estimate the client accepts online, then turn it into an invoice. FreshBooks adds a scope and a timeline to proposals on Plus and above. Magpie's proposals add packages, options and several signers.

WhatFreshBooksMagpie
Send an estimate the client accepts online, then turn it into an invoice Source Yes Yes
Send a proposal with a scope and timeline that the client signs Source Yes Yes

Good to know: When a Magpie proposal is accepted, its deposit becomes an invoice. Each later stage becomes one too. The Free plan sends 5 proposals a month.

Online payments

Both take cards, Apple Pay and Google Pay on an invoice through Stripe. FreshBooks adds bank payments, pay-later services, AutoPay, instalments and instant payouts. They do it better than we do today.

WhatFreshBooksMagpie
Let clients pay an invoice online by card Source Yes Yes
Let clients pay an invoice by bank transfer Source Magpie: Invoices take card payments only; a bank transfer is recorded by hand or matched from a bank transaction in Accounting. Yes No
Let clients spread an invoice over time with a pay-later service Source Magpie: Invoices take cards only. A Store can offer every payment method turned on in its Stripe account at checkout, but an invoice cannot. Yes No
Ask for a deposit on an invoice or split it into instalments Source Magpie: A proposal's payment schedule issues a deposit invoice on acceptance and an invoice for each milestone. A single invoice has no deposit or instalments, and paying online takes the whole balance. Yes Partly
Let a client save their card so later invoices are paid automatically Source Magpie: A recurring schedule started from an accepted proposal charges the client's saved card for each invoice, and the client updates the card in their Magpie account; one made with Make recurring cannot, so its invoices are paid from their emails. Yes Partly
Charge a client's card myself, from a saved card or one given over the phone Source Magpie: Only a recurring schedule from a proposal charges a saved card; otherwise the client pays from the invoice's link. Store's Sell screen takes in-person sales. Yes No
Share a payment link for a product or service, without an invoice Source FreshBooks: Checkout Links are reusable links with a fixed price, to post anywhere or show as a QR code, but they stop working on 10 December 2026; FreshBooks suggests invoices shared by link instead. Partly Yes
Get card payments into my bank within minutes, any day Source Magpie: Card payments go to the team's own Stripe account and are paid out to the bank on that account's schedule; Magpie has no instant payout. Yes No

Good to know: Card payments on a Magpie invoice go to your own Stripe account. Magpie takes no fee on invoice payments; Stripe's fees apply.

Clients, projects, team and payroll

Both keep clients, track time, bring in a team and let the accountant in. FreshBooks adds rates for each person and project profit after the cost of time. Its Payroll, powered by Gusto, files payroll tax.

WhatFreshBooksMagpie
Keep each client's details, contacts and billing settings Source Yes Yes
Give clients one place to see and pay what I send them Source Yes Yes
Talk with a client about an invoice or a project, and share files Source Magpie: A Client Portal shares files both ways, and a client asks questions on a proposal's page; there are no messages on an invoice or in the portal. Yes Partly
Track time with a timer or a timesheet, for a client and project Source Yes Yes
Bill a project at a flat rate or by the hour, with a rate for each person Source Magpie: A project takes one hourly rate, after which the Contact's and the default rate apply, and an entry's own rate can replace it; there is no rate for each person or service, and a flat fee is simply invoiced. Yes Partly
See the profit on each project, counting what people's time costs Source Magpie: Accounting's Profit by project shares invoice income and expense and bill costs across Time Tracking projects, but time worked is not counted as a cost. Yes Partly
Bring in team members and choose what each can use Source Yes Yes
Give my accountant access to the books Source Yes Yes
Pay employees and myself by direct deposit Source Magpie: Payroll pays employees on a schedule, with pay runs from salaries and tracked hours, payslips and entries in Accounting. Magpie moves no money: the team pays from its own bank and marks the pay run paid. The Free plan pays up to 2 employees a pay run. Yes Partly
Have payroll taxes worked out, paid and filed for me Source Magpie: In Payroll, the tax withheld is entered as the accountant gives it, and Summary totals it to pay and report by hand. It files nothing. Yes No

Good to know: Payroll is in every Magpie plan. The Free plan pays up to 2 employees a pay run, and a paid plan pays everyone.

Expenses, accounting and reports

Both record expenses and bills, keep double-entry books, reconcile and report. FreshBooks connects to the bank, reads receipts and logs mileage. They do it better than we do today.

WhatFreshBooksMagpie
Record an expense with its category, tax and receipt Source Yes Yes
Photograph a receipt or bill and have its details filled in Source Magpie: A receipt photo or file is kept with its expense or waits in Receipt Inbox, but its amount, date and merchant are typed in; nothing is read from it. Yes Partly
Forward receipts by email to have them added Source Magpie: Receipts are uploaded, dropped or pasted on Expenses, or photographed in a phone's browser; there is no address to forward them to. The Magpie app, not yet in the App Store or Google Play, will also take receipts shared from another app on the phone. Yes No
Have bank and card transactions come in by themselves Source Magpie: Each statement is downloaded from the bank's website as CSV and imported into its account in Accounting, which adds each transaction once; no bank connects to Magpie directly. Yes Partly
Track the miles I drive for work and what they are worth Source Magpie: Expenses records amounts spent; there is no trip log or rate per mile, so a mileage claim is typed in as an expense. Yes No
Record a repeating expense such as rent or a subscription Source Yes Yes
Record suppliers' bills and what is still owed on them Source Yes Yes
Pay a supplier's bill by bank transfer or cheque from the program Source Magpie: Record payment notes a payment made from the bank's own website, and the bank transaction is matched to it; Magpie sends no money. Yes No
Keep double-entry books with a chart of accounts and journal entries Source Yes Yes
Check the books against a bank statement Source Yes Yes
See profit and loss, the balance sheet and cash flow Source Yes Yes
Charge sales tax on invoices and see what was collected Source Yes Yes
See at a glance what is owed, earned and spent Source Yes Yes
Borrow against my sales when cash is short Source Magpie: Magpie offers no loans or cash advances. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's books fill in from Invoicing, Expenses, Store and Payroll. A bank statement is imported as a CSV file, and each transaction is added once.

Switching, apps and what else Magpie does

FreshBooks has phone apps, more than 100 connected apps and loans for eligible businesses. Magpie adds booking pages, a shop and E-Signatures in the same account.

WhatFreshBooksMagpie
Bring clients, invoices and expenses over from another program Source Magpie: Contacts and invoices come in as JSON written with the assistant, and Accounting imports a chart of accounts and a trial balance as CSV; there is no CSV import of contacts and no move of each invoice from another program. Yes Partly
Invoice, log expenses and track time from my phone Source Yes Yes
Run several businesses from one sign-in Source Yes Yes
Connect the other apps my business uses Source Magpie: Pro has an API with webhooks, and Magpie connects to Google Calendar, Zoom and Slack and to apps that use MCP, but there is no store of ready-made connections to other software. Yes Partly
Ask an AI assistant about my invoices and have it do the work Source FreshBooks: A free Claude connector answers questions about invoices, expenses, reports and cash flow, but only reads: it cannot create invoices or contact clients.Magpie: The Dashboard assistant, and Claude, ChatGPT or another app connected to Magpie, find invoices by number, customer, state and date and answer what the business made and is owed from the books; they cannot create, send or change an invoice. An invoice can be filled in from JSON an assistant writes. Partly Partly
Let clients book a meeting or appointment with me Source FreshBooks: FreshBooks' feature list covers invoicing, payments, projects, time, expenses and accounting, with no booking page. No Yes
Sell products and services from an online shop Source FreshBooks: FreshBooks has no shop; its reusable Checkout Links are being retired on 10 December 2026. No Yes
Send a contract or any document for signature Source FreshBooks: Only a proposal can be signed, on Plus and above, by turning on Require e-signature. Partly Yes

Good to know: One Magpie account holds Personal and several teams. Each team has its own invoices, books and members.

Price comparison

How FreshBooks charges

FreshBooks charges by plan: Lite, Plus, Premium and Select, with a free trial. The plan sets how many clients you can bill and what the books can do. Lite bills 5 clients and Plus 50. Extra team members, Advanced Payments and Payroll cost more each month. FreshBooks Payments takes 2.9% and a fixed fee on each card payment, and 1% on a bank payment. Prices are on FreshBooks' pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan too, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The plan sets how much you can do, not which areas you can use. Magpie takes no fee on invoice payments, and 4% of Store sales. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planFreshBooksMagpie
Clients you can bill5 on Lite, 50 on Plus, no limit on Premium and Select100 contacts on Free; no limit on paid plans
Fee on card payments of invoices2.9% and a fixed fee, through FreshBooks PaymentsNo Magpie fee; Stripe's fees apply
Fee on bank payments of invoices1% for ACH in the USBank payments not offered
Pay later6% and a fixed fee, through Affirm, Klarna or AfterpayNot offered
Instant payout1.5% in the US, 1% in CanadaNot offered; Stripe pays out on its schedule
Charging a client's saved card yourselfAdvanced Payments, a monthly add-on, included in SelectOnly for a recurring schedule from a proposal
Team membersA monthly charge for each one beyond the plan; Select includes two3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan
Accountant accessUp to 10 at no charge, on Plus and aboveAs guests: 10 on Free, 100 on a paid plan
PayrollA separate subscription, priced per month and per personIncluded: 2 employees a pay run on Free, everyone on a paid plan
Double-entry books and reconcilingPlus and aboveEvery plan
BillsPremium and SelectEvery plan
Receipt readingPlus and aboveNot available

When to choose Magpie or FreshBooks

  • Want invoices beside booking pages, signed proposals, a shop and payroll, for one price? Go with Magpie.
  • Want more ways to be paid, retainers, bank feeds and receipts read for you? FreshBooks is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a freelancer who works from a phone
FreshBooks. The FreshBooks apps send invoices, capture receipts, track time and log mileage. Magpie works in a phone's browser. The Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play.
For an agency on monthly retainers
FreshBooks. A retainer counts each period's hours against its fee. Projects bill each person at their own rate. Magpie bills the fee monthly, and its hour budget counts all of a project's time.
For a US business with employees
FreshBooks. FreshBooks Payroll, powered by Gusto, files federal and state payroll tax and pays by direct deposit. Magpie's Payroll takes the tax you enter and leaves paying and filing to you.
For a consultant or a coach
Magpie. Clients book a call, sign a proposal and pay its deposit invoice, all in one account. Contracts go out through E-Signatures, and a client can have a Client Portal.
For a business that sells products too
Magpie. Store sells online, and its orders and payouts go into Accounting by themselves. FreshBooks has no shop, and its Checkout Links stop working on 10 December 2026.
For a small team
Either. Magpie's Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, with Payroll included. FreshBooks gives each member a role, such as manager, contractor or accountant. Choose by whether one price or more payment options matters more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between FreshBooks and Magpie?

FreshBooks is invoicing and accounting software for small businesses. It has more ways to get paid, and connects to the bank. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Invoicing is one area beside Proposals, Accounting, Payroll, booking pages and Store. FreshBooks does more around getting paid; Magpie does more around the business.

Does Magpie replace FreshBooks?

Yes, for a business that sends invoices and proposals, tracks time and keeps its own books. Magpie sends reminders, takes cards online and fills in the books by itself.

Consider keeping FreshBooks if you charge late fees, bill retainers or want clients to pay by bank. Keep it too for bank feeds, receipt reading, mileage or payroll tax filed for you. FreshBooks does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does FreshBooks cost?

FreshBooks has Lite, Plus, Premium and Select plans, with a free trial. Lite bills 5 clients and Plus 50. Extra team members, Advanced Payments and Payroll cost more each month. Card payments cost 2.9% and a fixed fee, and bank payments 1%. The prices are on FreshBooks' pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free includes 5 invoices a month, 100 contacts and Payroll for 2 employees. A paid plan removes those limits, and the Team plan has 25 people. Magpie takes no fee on invoice payments. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have invoice templates?

No. Every invoice has one layout, with the logo, business name, address and tax ID from Invoicing settings. Its colours and font cannot be changed. More invoice designs are on Magpie's roadmap. FreshBooks has three templates, a choice of colour and font, and a banner image.

Does Magpie add late fees?

No. Reminders go out up to 30 days after the due date, but add no fee. A late fee is put on a new invoice by hand. Late fees are on Magpie's roadmap. FreshBooks adds a flat or percentage fee a set number of days after the due date.

Can I save my services and prices for invoices?

No. Each invoice line is typed in. Proposals has a price list and Store keeps products, but neither fills an invoice. A price list for invoices is on Magpie's roadmap. FreshBooks saves items and services with a rate and taxes.

Can clients pay a Magpie invoice by bank transfer?

Not online. Pay online takes a card, with Apple Pay and Google Pay where your Stripe account offers them. A bank transfer is recorded by hand or matched in Accounting. FreshBooks takes ACH in the US, pre-authorized debit in Canada, and Affirm, Klarna or Afterpay.

Does Magpie have AutoPay for recurring invoices?

Partly. A recurring schedule started from an accepted proposal charges the client's saved card each time. A schedule made with Make recurring sends each invoice to be paid from its email. FreshBooks lets a client save a card or bank account when paying a recurring invoice.

Does Magpie have retainers?

Partly. Make recurring bills the fee each month, quarter or year. A Time Tracking project's hour budget counts all its time, not each month's. There is no retainer summary for the client. FreshBooks retainers count each period's hours, on Plus and above.

Can I see the profit on each project?

Partly. Accounting's Profit by project shares invoice income and expense and bill costs across Time Tracking projects. The time people spend is not counted as a cost. FreshBooks gives each person a cost rate and shows each project's margin, on Premium and Select.

Does Magpie connect to my bank?

No. You download each statement from your bank as a CSV file and import it. Overlapping statements add each transaction once. Bank feeds are on Magpie's roadmap. FreshBooks connects to banks through Plaid or Yodlee on every plan.

Does Magpie read receipts?

No. A receipt photo is kept with its expense or waits in Receipt Inbox. Its details are typed in. Reading receipts is on Magpie's roadmap. FreshBooks reads receipts on Plus and above, and takes them by email.

Does Magpie track mileage?

No. A mileage claim is entered as an ordinary expense, with no trip log or rate per mile. Mileage is on Magpie's roadmap. The FreshBooks app logs trips, by itself on Android, on every plan.

Does Magpie pay payroll taxes or pay by direct deposit?

No. The tax to withhold is a line on each employee, as your accountant gives it. Summary totals it. You pay employees from your own bank and mark the pay run paid. FreshBooks Payroll, powered by Gusto, files and pays federal and state payroll tax. Direct deposit is free.

Does FreshBooks have booking pages?

No. FreshBooks covers invoicing, payments, projects, time, expenses and accounting. Magpie's Meetings and Appointments publish booking pages where clients choose a time. Appointments can take a service's price or a deposit by card when the client books. Both are in the same account as Invoicing.

Does FreshBooks have an online shop?

No. Its Checkout Links sell one thing at a fixed price, and they stop working on 10 December 2026. Magpie's Store sells online for 4% of each sale. Its orders and payouts go into Accounting.

Does Magpie have estimates?

Yes, as proposals. A client chooses packages and options, then accepts by signing. Its deposit and each later stage become invoices. FreshBooks has estimates on every plan, and signed proposals on Plus and above.

Can my accountant work in Magpie?

Yes. Invite them as a guest of the team with Accounting. They keep the books and see nothing else. A free team can have 10 guests. FreshBooks includes up to 10 accountants at no charge on Plus and above.

Does Magpie have a phone app?

Invoicing, Expenses, Time Tracking and Accounting work in a phone's browser. A receipt can be photographed there. The Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. FreshBooks has apps for iPhone and Android.

Can I use FreshBooks and Magpie together?

Yes, but they do not connect. You could keep invoicing in FreshBooks and use Magpie for booking pages, proposals and a shop. Each keeps its own clients and payments.

How do I move from FreshBooks to Magpie?

Import a chart of accounts and a trial balance into Accounting as CSV files, as your opening balances. Unpaid invoices arrive as totals, not one by one. Contacts and invoices can come in as JSON written with the assistant. Keep FreshBooks until you no longer need its history.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Invoicing with 5 invoices a month, 100 contacts and 5 proposals a month. Accounting, Expenses, Time Tracking, and Payroll for 2 employees are included. Booking pages, Store, a website and a team of 3 are too. A paid plan raises the limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

FreshBooks changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for FreshBooks' own team as much as for anyone who uses FreshBooks.

Send your invoices beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then send your first invoice.

Create account