Workable compared with Magpie

Workable vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Workable and Magpie both publish a business's jobs, take applications and move candidates through interviews to a hire. They are built for different amounts of hiring.

  1. Workable is a recruiting system with an HR side included in every plan. It is built for a company that hires often. It posts jobs to job boards, screens applicants with AI, schedules interviews and sends offers, and reports on each step.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Hiring is one part of it. Beside the jobs and candidates it includes staff files, the rota, payroll, e-signatures, the books and the rest. It is built for someone whose hiring is one part of running the business.
Create account
Hiring pipeline board for a fictional studio photographer job, with candidates in three stages and their reviewers.

How is Magpie different?

1. Hiring comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Hiring for a job board, application forms, a pipeline, interviews and scorecards
  • Staff for each person's file, onboarding and time off
  • Staff Scheduling for the rota, and Payroll for pay runs and payslips
  • E-Signatures for an offer letter or a contract, and Video Chat for interviews
  • Time Tracking, Expenses and Accounting for hours, receipts and the books
  • Invoicing, Store, Websites, Mail, Calendar and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. A hired candidate's page has Add to Staff and Add to Payroll. Each starts the person's record with their details filled in.

2. The Free plan includes Hiring

Hiring is part of every Magpie plan, Free included, with no limit on jobs. A team pays by plan, not by the size of the company. A free team has 3 members, and the Team plan 25. Applicants need no Magpie account.

3. Interviews find a time and hold the call

Schedule interview lists the start times when every interviewer is free. Magpie reads their working hours, Calendar, Meetings bookings and Google calendar. The interview goes into Calendar, and the candidate gets an invitation with a calendar file. On a paid plan, Video Chat holds the call, and the candidate joins without an account.

Comparing Magpie and Workable

Workable does more inside hiring; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Workable's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatWorkableMagpie
Jobs and application formsWrite a job, choose its questions and publish it Yes Yes
Careers page in your brandEvery open job on one page, in your look Yes Name and introduction
Posting to job boardsIndeed, LinkedIn and others in one step Yes Google for Jobs only
Pipeline of stagesEach candidate moved from stage to stage Yes Yes
ScorecardsEach interviewer's ratings and recommendation Yes Yes
AI writing and screeningJob descriptions written and applicants scored Yes No
Searching for people who have not appliedProfiles found for a job AI credits No
Interview schedulingA time when every interviewer is free Yes Yes
Candidates choose their own timeA link to pick an interview slot Yes No
Video calls for interviewsThe call itself, with no other service Meet, Teams or Zoom link Pro and Team plans
One-way video and assessmentsRecorded answers and aptitude tests Premier, or add-ons No
Automated emails and textsSent when a candidate applies or moves stage Yes Confirmation email only
Offer lettersAn offer made and signed from the candidate Yes E-Signatures, outside Hiring
Hiring reportsTime to hire, sources and drop-off Yes Counts only
Employee files and onboardingA record and a welcome for each new hire Yes Yes
Performance reviewsReview cycles for staff Premier, or an add-on No
Phone appsCandidates reviewed and moved on a phone Yes In the browser
Single sign-onSign in through the company's identity provider Yes No
Free planHiring without paying 15-day trial Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Jobs and job posts

Both write a job with its description, location and salary, and keep it a draft until it is published. Workable also writes the description, posts the job to job boards and sends new jobs for approval. They do these better than we do today.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Create a job with its description, location, employment type and salary Source Yes Yes
Have a job description written for me Source Magpie: You write the description and requirements yourself. Hiring has no writing help, and the assistant does not read or write Hiring. Yes No
Post a job to Indeed, LinkedIn and other job boards at once Source Magpie: A published job's page carries the job information that Google for Jobs reads, and Share job starts a Social Media post. Nothing sends the job to Indeed, LinkedIn or any other job board. Yes Partly
Have a new job approved, with its headcount, before it opens Source Magpie: A job has a number of openings and a hiring manager, and anyone with edit access in the team publishes it. Nothing asks for approval first. Yes No
Post a job in another language, with its form and emails in that language Source Magpie: The job board, the application form and the confirmation email to applicants follow the team's Language for customers: English, French, Spanish or German. Interview invitations are written in the language of the member who schedules them, and every job in a team uses the one language. Yes Partly
Check what the market pays for a role before setting the salary Source Magpie: A job shows the salary range the team sets, per year, month or hour. Magpie has no market pay data. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie sets no limit on jobs, on any plan. A job with a closing date stops taking applications at 11:59 PM on that day, in the job board's time zone.

Careers page and applications

Both have a careers page and an application form with questions of your own. Workable's page has its own builder, and its job list can go inside your website. Workable also reads each resume for the applicant's details.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Have a careers page that lists every open job, in my own brand Source Magpie: Each team has a job board at a Magpie address, with a name and an introduction above its published jobs. It has no logo, pictures, sections or colours of its own, and cannot move to your own domain. Yes Partly
Show my open jobs inside my own website Source Magpie: Your website links to the job board's address. Nothing puts the list inside your own pages; a developer could read the jobs through the REST API with a Pro API key. Yes Partly
Choose the questions people answer when they apply Source Yes Yes
Turn away applicants automatically when they answer a must-have question no Source Magpie: Every application lands in the job's first stage whatever the answers, for someone to read and reject. Yes No
Have a candidate's details read from their resume Source Magpie: Applicants type their name, email address and phone on the form and attach the resume, and a candidate added by hand is typed in. The resume is kept as a file to download. Yes No
Let staff refer people for open jobs and follow their referrals Source Magpie: Adding ?source=referral to a job page's address marks the applications made from it as referrals. Staff have no place to refer someone or to see what happened to a referral. Yes Partly
Share a job on social media Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Applicants need no Magpie account. Their files are stored privately, never at a public address, and only people who can open Hiring can download them.

Finding candidates

Both add a candidate who applied another way. Workable also imports candidates in bulk, keeps a Talent Pool, and searches for people who have not applied.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Add someone who applied another way Source Yes Yes
Bring my candidates over from a spreadsheet or another hiring tool Source Magpie: Candidates come from the job page or are added one at a time. Help says Hiring has no candidate import. Yes No
Keep past candidates and people with no job yet, and find them for a new role Source Magpie: Candidates searches every application in the team by name, email address, job or tag, with any status, and tags such as future-role stay with the person. Every candidate belongs to a job, there is no general application, and nothing suggests past candidates for a new job. Yes Partly
Search for people who have not applied Source Magpie: Candidates are the people who applied or whom you added. Yes No

Good to know: Someone who applies again with the same email address gets a new application on the same candidate. Their tags stay with them across every job.

Reviewing candidates

Both move candidates through stages and collect scorecards that stay hidden until each interviewer submits their own. Workable adds AI scoring, anonymised screening, interview kits, one-way video and assessments.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Follow each candidate through stages of my own Source Yes Yes
Move a candidate to the next stage Source Yes Yes
Move, email or reject many candidates at once Source Magpie: Reject several rejects up to 100 active candidates with one reason and, if you choose, a personal copy of an email for each. Moving or emailing several without rejecting them is not possible. Yes Partly
Reject a candidate with a reason, and tell them or not Source Yes Yes
Collect each interviewer's ratings and recommendation Source Yes Yes
Give interviewers the questions to ask at each stage Source Magpie: A job has its own scorecard categories, which interviewers rate. There are no questions or notes for interviewers, and categories cannot be saved to reuse on another job. Yes Partly
Discuss a candidate with the team and bring a colleague in Source Magpie: Notes on a candidate are seen by the team and never by the candidate, and the activity list records them. A note cannot mention anyone, and nobody is told about a new note. Yes Partly
Hide names and photos while screening, to reduce bias Source Magpie: Candidates' names show on every list and on the Pipeline board, email addresses in the candidate list, and the phone number on the candidate's page. Nothing hides them while screening. Yes No
Have applicants scored against the job's requirements Source Magpie: People read each application. Nothing in Hiring scores or ranks candidates. Yes No
Have candidates record video answers to set questions Source Magpie: Interviews are live, on a Video Chat call or somewhere else. Candidates cannot record answers in advance. Yes No
Send candidates an aptitude or personality test Source Magpie: A question on the application form can ask anything, but nothing tests or scores the answers. Yes No
Keep my own details on each candidate, some seen only by some people Source Magpie: Tags, up to 20 a candidate, label people, and every application answer is kept. There are no fields of your own to fill in later, and everyone who can open Hiring sees everything. Yes Partly

Good to know: The Hiring overview lists the scorecards you still owe and the newest applications. A candidate's page averages every scorecard by category.

Interviews

Both schedule an interview, add it to calendars and email the candidate. Workable also lets the candidate choose a time and books a series in one go. It sends a reminder the day before.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Schedule an interview and invite the candidate Source Yes Yes
See interviewers' Google or Outlook calendars when choosing a time Source Magpie: Magpie reads each interviewer's working hours, Magpie Calendar, Meetings bookings and busy times in their primary Google calendar. Outlook and Microsoft 365 calendars cannot be connected today. Yes Partly
Let the candidate choose their own interview time Source Magpie: The person scheduling picks the time from when every interviewer is free, and Help says candidates cannot choose their own. Meetings lets visitors book a time, but not for an interview. Yes No
Schedule several interviews back to back as one Source Magpie: Each interview is one time with its interviewers, so a series is scheduled one interview at a time. Yes No
Hold a video interview without a separate video tool Source Workable: A Google Meet, Microsoft Teams or Zoom link is added once that integration is connected, and the call happens in that tool. Partly Yes
Remind the candidate before their interview Source Magpie: The invitation carries a calendar file, so the candidate's own calendar can remind them. Magpie sends no reminder. Yes No

Good to know: A Video Chat interview's call opens 15 minutes before it starts. An interview can have up to 5 interviewers.

Emails and automation

Both email the hiring manager about each application and email a candidate from their page. Workable saves templates, sends emails and texts on its own, and keeps the candidate's replies with the application.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Be told when someone applies Source Yes Yes
Email a candidate from their page Source Yes Yes
Save my own email templates for candidates Source Magpie: Hiring's starter messages fill in the candidate's name, the job title and the company name, and every message can be changed before it is sent. You cannot save templates of your own. Yes Partly
Keep the candidate's replies with their application Source Magpie: Each email sent from Hiring is recorded in the activity list, but the candidate's reply goes to the sender's own mailbox and is not kept with the application. Yes Partly
Send emails automatically when a candidate applies, moves stage or is rejected Source Magpie: The confirmation email to a new applicant is automatic and can be turned off. Every other email to a candidate is sent by a person. Yes Partly
Text candidates and read their replies Source Magpie: Candidates are contacted by email; their phone number is shown so you can call or text from your own phone. Yes No
Ask candidates about their experience, anonymously Source Magpie: Hiring sends no survey. A form from Forms could be sent by link, but its answers are not tied to the job or the stage. Yes No

Good to know: Replies to Magpie's confirmation email and to interview invitations go to the reply-to address in Hiring settings. Each email sent from a candidate's page is in their activity list.

Offers and hiring

Workable makes an offer letter from a template and sends it for signature from the Offer stage. Magpie's E-Signatures sends any PDF for signature, outside Hiring.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Send an offer letter for the candidate to sign Source Magpie: E-Signatures sends any PDF, such as an offer letter, for signature. Hiring has no offer step: nothing makes the offer from the candidate's details or shows it on their application. Yes Partly
Pass a new hire on to HR and scheduling Source Yes Yes

Good to know: Add to Payroll on a hired candidate starts their Payroll employee. Add to Staff starts their file in Staff with their name, email address, phone number and application files.

Reports

Workable has ready-made reports, a report builder and scheduled report emails. Magpie counts published jobs, active candidates and hires.

WhatWorkableMagpie
See reports on time to hire, sources and where candidates drop out Source Magpie: The Hiring overview counts published jobs, active candidates and hires, and each job shows its active candidates and how many openings are filled. There are no reports over time, by source or by stage. Yes Partly
Download candidates and their answers as a spreadsheet Source Magpie: Each file downloads from the candidate's page, but there is no export of candidates or answers. The REST API reads them with a Pro API key. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's REST API, with an API key on Pro, reads jobs, candidates, stages, scorecards and outcomes. A developer can build a report of their own from it.

Team, privacy, connections and price

Workable limits each person to the jobs they hire for and deletes old candidates on a schedule. It has single sign-on and more than 70 integrations. Magpie gives everyone who can open Hiring every job.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Give each person access to only the jobs they hire for Source Magpie: Members have Can edit or View only access, a team admin can limit a member to some areas, and a guest can be given Hiring. Everyone who can open Hiring sees every job and application in the team. Yes Partly
Delete old candidates' data on a schedule, and let candidates remove their own Source Magpie: Delete candidate permanently removes a candidate with every application, note, interview and file, and files are never at a public address. Nothing is deleted on a schedule, and candidates cannot remove their own data. Yes Partly
Collect and report US equal opportunity data Source Magpie: Hiring asks no equal opportunity questions, and its Help advises against collecting data the team has no reason to keep. Yes No
Sign in through the company's identity provider Source Magpie: Members sign in with a password, an emailed link or code, a passkey, or Apple, Google, LinkedIn or GitHub. Yes No
See who changed what in the account Source Magpie: A team's admins see an audit log of who changed its members, the areas each can use, invitations, guests, API keys pinned to it, its Stripe account, owner and archiving, with the IP address, kept 12 months and exported as CSV. Changes to jobs and candidates are not in it; each application's activity list records who moved, assigned, noted, emailed, interviewed or decided it. Yes Partly
Connect my own software through an API Source Yes Yes
Connect the other hiring tools I use, such as background checks or Slack Source Magpie: Hiring works with Magpie's own Calendar, Video Chat, Social Media, Staff and Payroll, and reads Google Calendar. It connects to no other hiring tool. Yes No
Review candidates and act on them from a phone Source Yes Yes
Run hiring without paying for a separate hiring tool Source Workable: Plans are priced by company size, starting with Standard for companies of up to 20 employees. The pricing page offers a 15-day trial and no free plan. No Yes

Good to know: A team admin can limit a member to the areas they need. A guest from outside the team can be given Hiring alone. Members can have View only access.

HR after the hire

Both keep a file for each employee, welcome new hires with tasks and keep time-off balances. Every Workable plan also includes a directory and an org chart.

WhatWorkableMagpie
Keep a file for each employee, with a directory and an org chart Source Magpie: Staff keeps a file for each person: details and address, employment, pay, emergency contacts, documents, qualifications, time off and a history of every change, and each person keeps their own details up to date on My file. Staff's People list is for team admins and managers, and Magpie draws no org chart. Yes Partly
Welcome a new hire with tasks and documents to complete Source Yes Yes
Track time off and each person's leave balance Source Yes Yes
Run performance reviews Source Magpie: Magpie has no performance reviews of staff. Yes No

Good to know: Staff starts an Onboarding checklist when someone is added with a start date. Payroll is open to every team, and the Free plan pays 2 employees a pay run.

Price comparison

How Workable charges

Workable charges by plan, Standard, Premier or Enterprise, priced by the size of the company. It has a 15-day trial and no free plan. Standard is for companies of up to 20 employees. Premier adds one-way video, assessments, texting, performance reviews, referrals, approvals and custom fields. On Standard, several of these are add-ons. AI screening and searching use AI credits. Prices are on Workable's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan too, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. Hiring is on every plan, with no limit on jobs. Video Chat interviews need Pro or the Team plan, and an API key needs Pro. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planWorkableMagpie
How the price is setBy the size of the companyBy plan; 3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan
Hiring without payingA 15-day trialIncluded on the Free plan
AI screening and job descriptionsThe Workable Agent; paid plans start with 3,000 AI creditsNot offered
Searching for people who have not appliedA credit for each profile shownNot offered
One-way video interviewsPremier, or an add-on on StandardNot offered; live Video Chat interviews on a paid plan
AssessmentsPremier, or an add-on on StandardNot offered
Texting candidatesPremier, or an add-on on StandardNot offered
Approvals, referrals and custom fieldsPremier and EnterpriseNot offered
Jobs in other languagesOne more language on Standard, up to nine on Premier and EnterpriseEnglish, French, Spanish or German, one for the team
Importing candidatesOne free import on Premier; paid on other plansNot offered
Market salary dataA salary estimator, at extra costNot offered
Performance reviewsPremier, or an add-on on StandardNot offered

When to choose Magpie or Workable

  • Want jobs, candidates and interviews beside the rota, payroll and the books, with Hiring on a Free plan? Go with Magpie.
  • Want jobs posted to Indeed and LinkedIn, applicants scored by AI and candidates choosing their own interview time? Workable is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a company with a recruiter or a hiring team
Workable. Each role gets job board posting, AI screening, automated emails, interview self-scheduling and reports. In Magpie's Hiring, a person schedules each interview and sends each email, and nothing posts to job boards or screens with AI.
For a company hiring in several countries
Workable. The Language Kit puts a job, its form, its emails and the careers page in the job's own language. Magpie uses one language for every job in a team.
For a café, a shop or a restaurant hiring shift staff
Magpie. Hiring takes the applications. Add to Staff makes a hired candidate's file, and the rota uses the same people. Add to Payroll starts their pay. Daily Operations and Restaurant Reservations are in the same team.
For a small business hiring a few people a year
Magpie. Hiring is on the Free plan, with no limit on jobs. Jobs, interviews, scorecards and e-signatures are in the same account as the rest of the business.
For a growing company that hires every month
Either. Workable posts each job to job boards and scores applicants with AI. Magpie keeps hiring in the same team as the rota, payroll and the books. Choose by how many applicants each job brings in.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Workable and Magpie?

Workable is a recruiting system with an HR side. It posts jobs to job boards, screens applicants with AI and reports on every step. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Hiring is one area beside the rota, payroll, e-signatures and the books. Workable does more inside hiring; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Workable?

Yes, for a small business that hires a few people at a time. Hiring publishes jobs, takes applications, schedules interviews and collects scorecards. A hire goes into Staff and Payroll.

Consider keeping Workable if you post to Indeed and LinkedIn or screen many applicants. Keep it if candidates should choose their own interview time. Keep it too for offer letters from templates, automated emails and hiring reports. Workable does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Workable cost?

Workable has three plans, Standard, Premier and Enterprise, priced by the size of the company. There is a 15-day trial and no free plan. One-way video, assessments, texting and performance reviews come with Premier, or as add-ons on Standard. The prices are on Workable's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Hiring is on every plan, with no limit on jobs. A free team has 3 members and the Team plan 25. Video Chat interviews need Pro or the Team plan. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Can Magpie post jobs to Indeed and LinkedIn?

No. A Magpie job page carries the details job search engines read, such as Google for Jobs. Share job starts a Social Media post with the job's address. Workable sends a published job to Indeed, LinkedIn and a network of other boards.

Does Magpie screen applicants with AI?

No. People read each application, and nothing in Hiring scores or ranks candidates. The assistant does not read Hiring. The Workable Agent scores each candidate out of 100 against the job's criteria, using AI credits.

Can Magpie write a job description for me?

No. You write the description and requirements yourself, in Markdown. The Workable Agent writes them, with the application questions, after a short conversation about the role.

Can candidates choose their own interview time in Magpie?

No. The person scheduling picks the time from when every interviewer is free, and the candidate is sent an invitation. Workable sends a link that shows the candidate open times from the interviewers' calendars.

Does Magpie send offer letters?

Partly. E-Signatures sends any PDF for signature, such as an offer letter, and keeps the signed copy. Hiring has no offer step, so nothing fills the letter in from the candidate. Workable fills a template with the salary and start date and shows whether the offer was accepted.

Does Magpie send automatic emails to candidates?

Partly. The confirmation email to a new applicant is automatic and can be turned off. Every other email is sent by a person, from a starter message they can edit. Workable sends emails and texts by itself when a candidate applies, moves stage or is rejected.

Can Magpie reject many candidates at once?

Yes. Reject in Hiring's candidate list rejects up to 100 active candidates with one reason. Each can get their own copy of an email. Moving or emailing several candidates without rejecting them is not possible. Workable moves, emails or rejects any ticked candidates.

Does Magpie read resumes?

No. Applicants type their name, email address and phone number, and the resume is kept as a file to download. Workable reads each uploaded resume for the candidate's details, in any language.

Does Magpie have hiring reports?

Partly. The Hiring overview counts published jobs, active candidates and hires. Each job shows its active candidates and how many openings are filled. There are no reports over time, by source or by stage. Workable has ready-made reports, a report builder and dashboards.

Does Magpie have a careers page?

Yes. Each team has a job board at a Magpie address, with a name and an introduction above its published jobs. It has no pictures or colours of its own and cannot move to your domain. Your website links to it. Workable builds a branded careers page and puts the job list inside your own site.

Does Workable have its own video calls?

No. Workable adds a Google Meet, Microsoft Teams or Zoom link once that service is connected. Magpie's Video Chat holds the interview call on Pro and the Team plan. The candidate joins from the invitation without an account.

Does Workable have a free plan?

No. Workable has a 15-day trial, and its plans are priced by the size of the company. Magpie's Free plan includes Hiring, with no limit on jobs.

Does Magpie keep employee files and onboarding?

Yes. Staff keeps a file for each person, with their details, employment, pay, documents and time off. It starts an Onboarding checklist when someone is added with a start date, with tasks for them and their manager. Magpie draws no org chart. Every Workable plan includes employee profiles, a directory and an org chart, and Workable has an onboarding portal.

Does Magpie have performance reviews?

No. Magpie has no review cycles for staff. Performance reviews are on Magpie's roadmap. Workable runs reviews with self and manager forms, on Premier or as an add-on on Standard.

Does Magpie have single sign-on?

No. Members sign in with a password, an emailed link or code, a passkey, or an Apple, Google, LinkedIn or GitHub account. Workable lists single sign-on in every plan.

Can I hire from my phone with Magpie?

Yes, in a phone's browser. You can change a candidate's stage, add notes, schedule interviews, email them, submit a scorecard, and reject or hire. The Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Workable has apps for iPhone and Android.

Can I use Workable and Magpie together?

Yes. Workable can run the hiring while Magpie runs the rota, payroll and the books. A new hire is added to Staff or Payroll by hand. A developer could connect the two through each product's API. Magpie sends nothing to Workable by itself.

How do I move from Workable to Magpie?

Make each open job again in Hiring and publish it. Magpie has no candidate import. Add current candidates one at a time with Add candidate, or through the REST API with a Pro key. Workable's candidate report downloads as a CSV file, so you can keep a copy of the rest.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Hiring, with no limit on jobs, Staff, Staff Scheduling and Time Tracking. Payroll pays 2 employees a pay run. Accounting, Invoicing and the other areas are in the same plan. A free team has 3 members. A paid plan adds Video Chat interviews and raises the limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Workable changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Workable's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Hire your next person beside the rest of the business.

Create a Magpie account, then add your first job in Hiring.

Create account