Gumroad compared with Magpie

Gumroad vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Gumroad and Magpie both let a creator or a small business sell downloads, courses and memberships online. They are built around different things.

  1. Gumroad is a platform for selling digital products, memberships, courses and calls, with no monthly charge and a fee on each sale. It is built for creators who sell their work online: writers, designers, musicians, developers and teachers.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Store is one part of it. Beside the shop it includes courses, paid posts, booking pages, invoicing, a newsletter and a website. It is built for someone whose shop is one part of running the business.
Create account
Callahan Studio’s Store as a buyer sees it, in the Siena design: the shop’s name and menu in a red bar, “Prints and paper goods, made by hand in Chicago.” in large italic type, and the first of its prints below.

How is Magpie different?

1. The shop comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Store, the area this page is about, for downloads, physical products, bundles and gift cards
  • Courses for lessons at a school of your own, and Supporters for paid posts
  • Newsletter for email to subscribers, and Websites for a site with a blog
  • Meetings and Appointments for booking pages, and Invoicing for invoices paid online
  • Mail, Forms, Contacts, Accounting and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Gumroad covers selling: products, memberships, calls, emails to buyers and a storefront.

2. The payments are in your own Stripe account

Buyers pay through your team's own Stripe account, and Stripe pays the balance into your bank. Store, Courses, Supporters, Appointments and Invoicing use the same account. Store reports list each payout from Store sales. Gumroad takes the payments itself and pays you out from the balance it holds.

3. Physical products ship from the same Store

A Store sells physical products beside downloads, from one Cart. It has shipping zones and methods, pickup and local delivery, and stock with its history. Shipments carry tracking numbers, with packing slips and returns. A sale at a market can be recorded by hand and taken from the same stock.

Comparing Magpie and Gumroad

Gumroad does more for the creator selling downloads; Magpie does more around the shop. Every line in the tables below was checked against Gumroad's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatGumroadMagpie
Digital downloadsFiles the buyer gets after paying Yes Yes
CoursesLessons, video and files buyers work through Yes Yes
MembershipsMonthly or yearly payments that open members-only content Yes Yes
Free products for an email addressA download given away in return for an email Yes Partly
Paid callsA one-to-one call booked and paid for in one go Yes Yes
CommissionsCustom work with a deposit up front Yes Proposals
TipsA tip page, or a tip added at checkout Yes No
Physical products and shippingShipping rates, stock and tracking numbers Partly Yes
Gift cardsCards people spend in the shop No Yes
Selling in personA sale at a market, from the same stock No Partly
InstalmentsA product paid for in several payments Yes Courses only
Prices by country and currencyLower prices where money goes less far, in the buyer's currency Yes No
Sales tax and VAT handled for youTax collected and paid by the platform Yes Worked out by Stripe Tax
Emails to buyersAn email to the people who bought one product Yes Partly
Automatic email seriesEmails sent after someone buys or subscribes Yes No
AffiliatesA commission for the people who send you sales Yes No
MarketplaceNew buyers find your products among other sellers' Discover No
Storefront at your own domainYour products on a page in your colours and fonts Yes Yes
Licence keysA key for each buyer that your software checks Yes Keys you upload
Phone appSales, notifications and buyers' purchases on a phone Yes In the browser
Booking pagesPeople choose a time with you, free Calls only Yes
InvoicingInvoices paid online No Yes
Website editorA website with pages and a blog Profile pages Yes
Email at your domainInboxes at the business's own domain No Paid plans

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Adding a product

Both sell files to download, versions at their own prices, bundles and courses. Gumroad also sells free products for an email address and games played in the browser.

WhatGumroadMagpie
Sell a file people download after paying, such as an ebook, a template or a music pack Source Yes Yes
Sell a course or tutorial: pages of lessons, videos and files that buyers work through after paying Source Yes Yes
Sell a game or web app that buyers play in their browser Source Magpie: Store delivers files to download, so a web game has to be sent as a ZIP. Websites can put a game on a page, but anyone with the address can open it, not only buyers. Yes No
Sell several versions of a product at different prices, such as PDF and EPUB, each with its own files Source Yes Yes
Sell several products together for one price Source Yes Yes
Give a product away free, in return for the buyer's email address Source Magpie: Every Store price and minimum price must be above zero, so Store cannot give a file away. Social Media's offers can: a person types their email address on the offer's page, with no account, and Magpie emails them a link to one PDF or ZIP file. Someone who opens that link is added to Contacts. An offer is made for a social post, and its file is not a Store product. Yes Partly
Ship physical goods, with shipping rates, stock and tracking numbers Source Gumroad: A physical product can charge shipping and ask for the buyer's address, and the sales export shows both. The help centre describes no shipping rates by place, stock counts or tracking numbers, and tells buyers to ask the creator about delivery. Partly Yes

Good to know: A Store download product holds up to 50 files of up to 500 MB each. A product can limit the download period and the number of downloads.

Memberships and services

Gumroad sells memberships with tiers, trials and yearly prices, and calls, commissions and tips as products. Magpie's paid posts are in Supporters, charged monthly or yearly. Appointments takes a service's price or a deposit when a customer books.

WhatGumroadMagpie
Sell a membership that charges every month or year and opens members-only content Source Magpie: Supporters sells a free tier and paid tiers that open the posts written for them, with text, pictures, video and polls. A paid tier is charged monthly and can offer a yearly price beside it, which supporters choose when they join. Members get no files, a video in a post can be opened by anyone with its address, and Magpie takes a 4% fee on Supporters payments. Yes Partly
Give new members a free trial or a discount on their first payment Source Magpie: A paid Supporters tier has a fixed monthly price, and can have a yearly one, with no trial and no discount code. An admin can give someone complimentary access to a tier, with an end date. Yes No
Let members move to another tier themselves, paying the difference Source Magpie: The Stripe customer portal paid supporters use changes the card, shows invoices and cancels, but does not switch tiers. A supporter joins another tier from the public page once the current paid tier has ended. Yes No
Sell a one-to-one call that the buyer books and pays for in one go Source Yes Yes
Sell custom work, taking half up front and the rest when it is done Source Magpie: Proposals can ask for a deposit, paid by card when the client accepts, and invoice the later payments, but each proposal is written for one client. A Store product is paid in full at checkout. Yes Partly
Accept tips from fans, on a tip page or when they pay Source Magpie: Store has no tip at checkout and no tip page. A Store product can let buyers pay what they want above a minimum, but it has to be a file or a shipped item, and Supporters charges a tier's price monthly or yearly. Yes No

Good to know: A Supporters tier can include courses, which a supporter opens without paying while their support lasts. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments.

Checkout and pricing

Both have a Cart, pay what you want, discount codes, wishlists and reviews. Gumroad adds upsells after Pay, prices by country and the buyer's own currency. They do these better than we do today.

WhatGumroadMagpie
Let buyers choose what they pay above a minimum, with a suggested price Source Yes Yes
Let buyers put several products in a cart and pay once Source Yes Yes
Make discount codes with an end date, a number of uses or a minimum spend Source Yes Yes
Offer an add-on or an upgrade at checkout, at a special price Source Magpie: A product's Goes with list shows other products on its page and in the Cart, at their usual prices. Nothing is offered once the buyer goes to pay, and there is no special price for taking the offer. Yes Partly
Suggest other products a buyer might like Source Yes Yes
Ask buyers my own questions when they buy, and make them accept my terms Source Yes Yes
Let buyers pay for a product in instalments Source Magpie: A course price can be bought in monthly payments, which give access from the first payment and pause it when a payment stays unpaid. Every other Store product is paid in full. Yes Partly
Lower my prices automatically for buyers in countries where money goes less far Source Magpie: Each item has one price wherever the buyer is. A discount can be limited to a saved customer segment, but not to a country. Yes No
Show prices and charge buyers in their own currency Source Magpie: A Store has one currency, which can be changed only until it is first published, and every buyer pays in it. Yes No
Take payment by card, PayPal or bank account Source Yes Yes
Buy a product as a gift and have it sent to someone else Source Magpie: Store sells gift cards emailed to someone with a message on a chosen date, personalisation can ask for a gift message, and a shipped item goes to whatever address the buyer gives. A download, though, belongs to the buyer's own Magpie account and cannot be sent to someone else's. Yes Partly
Place a test order to see what my buyers get, without paying Source Magpie: Store has no test payment, and a Store that is not published can be browsed but not checked out. New order can record a sale by hand to your own email address, which sends the usual confirmation and gives the downloads and licence keys without a charge, but it skips checkout and is kept as a real order. Yes Partly
Let shoppers save products to a wishlist and share it Source Yes Yes
Show buyers' ratings and reviews on product pages Source Yes Yes
Sell gift cards that people spend in my store Source Gumroad: Gifting sends one product to one person. The help centre describes no gift cards or store credit. No Yes
Sell in person at a market or pop-up, from the same stock as online Source Gumroad: The help centre covers selling online only, and the phone app shows sales and opens purchases; nothing records a sale made in person.Magpie: On the website, New order in Store's Orders records a sale paid in cash, such as at a market, takes its items from the chosen location's stock and can email the customer an order confirmation. Selling at a counter, with barcode scanning, a cash register counted at closing and emailed receipts, is in the Magpie app, which is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Neither takes cards in person. No Partly

Good to know: Store sells gift cards, emailed on a chosen date with a message. A refund can go back to the card or to the buyer as store credit.

What buyers get

Both give buyers one page of everything they bought and send them new versions of a file. Gumroad also streams video, stamps PDFs and gives each product a buyers' chat.

WhatGumroadMagpie
Give buyers one place to find everything they bought, on the web and in a phone app Source Magpie: Every paid order is kept in a Magpie account, made for the buyer's email address when needed, and Your downloads under Sent to you lists every file and licence key they bought, on a computer or in a phone's browser. There is no phone app to get: the Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play, and it shows the orders under Sent to you but not their files or licence keys. Yes Partly
Send buyers a new version of a file they already bought Source Yes Yes
Let buyers watch my videos online without downloading them Source Magpie: A course lesson plays its video in the browser, with captions, and gives no download button or lasting address, so a video can be sold as a course of one lesson. A video in a Store product is a file the buyer downloads. Yes Partly
Stamp each buyer's email address on the PDFs they buy, to discourage sharing Source Magpie: PDFs are delivered as they were uploaded. Downloads open only in the buyer's Magpie account, and a product can limit the download period and the downloads of each file. Yes No
Give each buyer a licence key that my software can check Source Magpie: You paste or upload keys you made, and each unit sold gets an unused one, shown on the order and in its email; keys are stored encrypted. Magpie does not make keys, and has no way for your software to check one. Yes Partly
Give buyers a private community or chat, or invite them to my Discord or Circle Source Magpie: Message Boards are private to a team or public to anyone, and a buyer gets in only as a member or guest of the team. Store connects to no outside community. Yes No

Good to know: Replace beside a file gives every buyer the new file from their order. It can email each buyer who can still download it.

Getting paid

Gumroad is the seller of record, so it collects and pays the sales tax and VAT. It pays you out from its balance. Magpie takes payment in your own Stripe account, and you stay the seller.

WhatGumroadMagpie
Have sales tax and VAT on my sales collected and paid for me Source Magpie: With Stripe Tax turned on, Stripe works out and charges the tax in each checkout for the places registered in your Stripe account, and can take business buyers' tax IDs. You stay the seller, and register, file and pay the tax yourself. Yes Partly
Get my earnings paid into my bank account Source Yes Yes
Refund a buyer in full or in part Source Yes Yes

Good to know: With Stripe Tax turned on, each Store checkout charges the tax for the places registered in your Stripe account. You register, file and pay it yourself.

Marketing your work

Gumroad emails buyers by product, sends a series after a purchase, pays affiliates and lists products in Discover. Magpie's Newsletter sends each email to every subscriber, and Store has checkout reminders.

WhatGumroadMagpie
Email the people who bought a particular product Source Magpie: Buyers who tick the box at checkout join your Newsletter, but a Newsletter email goes to every active subscriber. Store's customer segments filter buyers by product, spending or tag and export them as CSV. Yes Partly
Send a series of emails automatically after someone buys or subscribes Source Magpie: Store sends its own order, shipping and review emails, and Newsletter sends one email at a time to every subscriber. Outreach sends a series to people you add, not to buyers when they buy. Yes No
Remind people who left without paying Source Yes Yes
Collect email subscribers on a page of my own or a form on my website Source Yes Yes
Bring my email list with me, and download my customers and subscribers Source Yes Yes
Pay people a commission for the sales they send me Source Magpie: Store has discount codes and records where each order came from, but nothing tracks or pays an affiliate. Yes No
Share each sale automatically with someone I made the product with Source Magpie: Every Store sale is paid into the team's one Stripe account, so a partner's share is paid by hand. Yes No
Be found by new buyers in a marketplace of many sellers' products Source Magpie: A Store is found at its own address, through search engines (it has a sitemap and product data), and through Google and Meta product feeds. Magpie has no marketplace. Yes No
Sell from my own website with a buy button, or a link straight to checkout Source Yes Yes
See sales, views and where buyers came from Source Yes Yes
Send my store's visits and sales to Google Analytics or a Meta Pixel to measure my ads Source Magpie: Store counts page views itself, with no cookie, and sends Google and Meta a product feed, but puts no analytics or pixel code on the storefront. Yes No

Good to know: Store reports show sales by source with UTM tags, conversion and new and returning buyers. Each table exports as CSV, and a weekly summary can be emailed.

Your store, domain, team and connections

Both give a storefront at your own domain, team roles and an API. Gumroad adds a phone app with a notification for each sale and a connection to Zapier.

WhatGumroadMagpie
Have a storefront page that shows my products, in my own colours and font Source Yes Yes
Show my store at my own domain Source Yes Yes
Have AI design my store's home page or a product's sales page Source Magpie: A Store's whole storefront is one template file of HTML and CSS, which you can paste into an AI chat from a copied prompt, then preview and publish. Every product page uses the template's product part, so one product cannot have a sales page of its own. Yes Partly
Let people on my team help, each with only the access they need Source Yes Yes
Connect my own systems through an API and webhooks Source Yes Yes
Connect my store to Mailchimp, Google Sheets and other apps without writing code Source Magpie: Store's webhooks can start a Zapier or Make workflow that catches webhooks, but Magpie has no app of its own in Zapier or Make. Yes Partly
Look after my store from an AI assistant such as Claude Source Magpie: Claude, ChatGPT and Cursor connect to Magpie through MCP with the assistant's tools: they read products, orders, customers, stock and sales, and can change a product's description, create a discount and adjust stock. They cannot add a product, change its price or publish it. Yes Partly
Follow my sales on my phone, with a notification for each one Source Magpie: Store's orders, products and reports work in a phone's browser, and the team's admins and owner get an email for each paid order, which Store settings can turn off. A phone notification for each order comes from the Magpie app, which is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly

Good to know: A Store's whole storefront is one template of HTML and CSS. You or an AI chat can change it, with a live preview before you publish.

Price comparison

How Gumroad charges

Gumroad has no plans and no monthly charge. Its pricing page shows a fee of 10% plus a fixed amount per transaction on sales through your profile or direct links. Sales through its Discover marketplace pay 30%. Every account gets every part of Gumroad. As the seller of record, Gumroad collects and pays the sales tax and VAT on each sale.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The plan sets how many courses, students, subscribers and team members you have, not which areas you can use. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales and 4% of Supporters payments. It takes 4% of payments for appointments. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planGumroadMagpie
Monthly chargeNoneNone on Free; a paid plan raises the limits
Fee on direct sales10% plus a fixed amount per transaction4% of Store sales
Fee on marketplace sales30% through DiscoverNo marketplace
Card feesNot listed separately on the pricing pageStripe's fees, through your own Stripe account
Sales tax and VATCollected and paid by GumroadWorked out by Stripe Tax; you file and pay it
MembershipsSame fee as other sales4% on Supporters
CoursesSame fee as other sales1 published course and 50 students on Free; no limit on a paid plan
Booking pages, invoicing and a newsletterCalls sold as products; emails to followers and buyersIncluded; 4% of payments for appointments
People who can helpTeam members with roles3 in a free team, 25 on the Team plan

When to choose Magpie or Gumroad

  • Want your shop beside courses, booking pages, invoices, a newsletter and a website, with payments in your own Stripe account? Go with Magpie.
  • Want to sell downloads and memberships with tax handled for you, affiliates, a marketplace and no monthly charge? Gumroad is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a writer or designer selling downloads
Gumroad. Gumroad gives products away for an email, lowers prices by country and stamps PDFs. It sends a series of emails after each sale. Gumroad also handles the sales tax and VAT, which Magpie leaves to you.
For a developer selling software
Gumroad. Gumroad makes a licence key for each sale and has an API that checks it. Magpie delivers keys you made, and your software cannot check one.
For a shop with physical products
Magpie. Shipping zones, stock, tracking numbers, returns and gift cards are in Store, beside the downloads. A sale at a market comes out of the same stock.
For a teacher selling a course
Either. Both sell lessons with video and files that buyers work through. Magpie's Courses adds quizzes, assignments, certificates and live sessions at a school of your own. Choose by whether the tax handled for you or the school matters more.
For a coach or consultant
Magpie. Appointments takes a session's price or a deposit when a client books. Proposals with a deposit, invoices paid online and a newsletter are in the same team.
For a creator who wants new buyers to find them
Gumroad. Discover lists products among other sellers' work. Through Gumroad Affiliates, anyone can earn 10% for selling them. Magpie has no marketplace; a Store is found through search engines and product feeds.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Gumroad and Magpie?

Gumroad is a platform for selling digital products, memberships, courses and calls, with a fee on each sale. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Store is one area beside courses, booking pages, invoicing, a newsletter and a website. Gumroad does more for selling downloads; Magpie does more around the shop.

Does Magpie replace Gumroad?

Yes, for a business that sells downloads, courses or physical products beside the rest of its work. Store delivers files, bundles and gift cards, Courses runs a school, and Supporters sells paid posts.

Consider keeping Gumroad if you want the sales tax handled for you or sell to buyers in many countries. Keep it if you rely on affiliates or Discover. Keep it too if you give products away for an email address. Gumroad does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Gumroad cost?

Gumroad has no monthly charge and no plans. Its pricing page shows 10% plus a fixed amount per transaction on sales through your profile or direct links. Sales through Discover pay 30%. Gumroad collects and pays the sales tax and VAT as the seller of record.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free includes Store, 1 published course with 50 students, and a team of 3. Magpie takes 4% of Store sales and 4% of Supporters payments. Stripe's card fees come on top. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie handle sales tax and VAT for me?

No. With Stripe Tax turned on, Stripe works out and charges the tax in each checkout. It covers the places registered in your Stripe account. You stay the seller, and register, file and pay the tax yourself. Gumroad collects and pays sales tax and VAT around the world as the seller of record.

Can I give a product away for free on Magpie?

Partly. Every Store price must be above zero, so Store cannot give a file away. Social Media's offers can: a person types their email address on the offer's page, and Magpie emails them a link to one PDF or ZIP file. Free products in Store are on Magpie's roadmap. Gumroad sells a product at no price in return for an email address, with no fee.

Does Magpie have affiliates?

No. Store has discount codes and records where each order came from, but nothing tracks or pays an affiliate. Affiliates are on Magpie's roadmap. Gumroad gives your affiliates a link and the rate you set, and credits them for 30 days after a click.

Does Magpie have a marketplace like Gumroad Discover?

No. A Store is found at its own address, through search engines and through Google and Meta product feeds. Gumroad's Discover lists products by category once an account has passed a review, and takes 30% of sales made there.

Can buyers pay in their own currency on Magpie?

No. A Store has one currency, and every buyer pays in it. Prices do not change by the buyer's country either. Gumroad charges card purchases in about 30 currencies, and can lower prices by country with purchasing power parity.

Does Magpie send emails automatically after a purchase?

Store sends its own order, shipping and review emails, and one checkout reminder after a checkout expires. It sends no series of emails of your own. The Newsletter sends one email at a time to every subscriber. Gumroad's workflows send a series after a purchase, a new subscriber or an abandoned cart.

Can Magpie stream videos to buyers?

In Courses. A course lesson plays its video in the browser, with captions, and gives no download button. A video sold as a Store product is a file the buyer downloads. Gumroad streams any product's videos and can set them to stream only.

Does Magpie have yearly memberships or free trials?

Yearly payments, yes; free trials, no. A paid Supporters tier can offer a yearly price beside its monthly one, and supporters choose when they join. There is no trial and no discount code, and trials are on Magpie's roadmap. Gumroad's memberships have a price for each payment frequency you turn on, such as monthly or yearly. They can start with a free trial or a discount.

Does Magpie sell courses?

Yes. Courses builds a course of modules and lessons with video, text, files, quizzes and assignments. Store sells it. A course sells at a price, in 2 to 12 monthly payments, or with a Supporters tier. Students take it at your school's address, and finishers can get a certificate.

Can I sell a paid call on Magpie?

Yes, in Appointments. A service can take its full price or a deposit by card when the customer books. The appointment is booked once the payment goes through, and Magpie's fee is 4%. Meetings books a time without payment. Gumroad sells a call at a price for each length, booked and paid for in one go.

Does Gumroad sell gift cards?

No. Gumroad's gifting sends one product to one person, and its help centre describes no gift cards or store credit. Magpie's Store sells gift cards that are emailed on a chosen date and pay for items and shipping.

Can Gumroad ship physical products?

Partly. A Gumroad product can charge shipping and ask for the buyer's address. Its help centre describes no shipping rates by place, stock counts or tracking numbers. Magpie's Store has shipping zones, stock, tracking numbers, packing slips and returns.

Does Magpie have a phone app?

Not yet. Store's orders, products and reports work in a phone's browser. Each paid order is emailed to the team's admins. The Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Gumroad's app shows sales with a notification for each one, and buyers have an app for their purchases.

Does Magpie make licence keys?

No. You paste or upload keys you made, and each unit sold gets an unused one. It is shown on the order and in its email. Your software cannot check a key with Magpie. Gumroad makes a key for each sale and has an API that checks it.

Can I use Gumroad and Magpie together?

Yes. Gumroad can sell the downloads while Magpie runs your booking pages, invoices, newsletter and website. A Magpie website can link to Gumroad products.

How do I move from Gumroad to Magpie?

Download your customers and followers from Gumroad as CSV. The Newsletter imports a CSV of people who gave permission. Add your products in Store, by hand or from a CSV file, and upload their files.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

Store, 1 published course with 50 students, Supporters, booking pages, Invoicing, a website, the Newsletter with 250 subscribers, Forms and a team of 3. A paid plan adds email at your domain and raises the limits.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Gumroad changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Gumroad's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Open a Store on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then add your first product to Store.

Create account