What is the difference between Substack and Magpie?
Substack is a publishing platform for writers, with paid subscriptions, comments, chat and a reader app. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Newsletter is one area beside Supporters, Podcast, Store and a website. Substack does more for readers; Magpie does more around the writing.
Does Magpie replace Substack?
Yes, for a business whose newsletter goes free to a list of up to 5,000 people. Magpie imports your Substack list, schedules each email and keeps a web copy of it.
Consider keeping Substack if your paid posts go to readers' inboxes. Keep it if readers comment, chat or read in its app, or if recommendations bring you subscribers. Keep it too if your list is larger than 5,000. Substack does each of these better than Magpie does today.
How much does Substack cost?
Substack is free to start, with no monthly fee and no limit on subscribers. When readers pay, Substack keeps 10% of paid subscription revenue, and card fees come off as well. A custom domain is a one-time fee for each publication. The details are on Substack's going-paid page.
How much does Magpie cost?
Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free has 250 Newsletter subscribers and 1,000 emails a month; a paid plan has 5,000 subscribers and 50,000 emails. Magpie takes 4% of Supporters payments, and Stripe's fees come on top. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.
Can readers pay for my writing on Magpie?
Yes, in Supporters. Readers join a free tier, or a paid tier monthly or yearly, through your own Stripe account. A post can be kept for paying supporters, and others see its title and excerpt. Magpie takes 4% of each payment.
Does Magpie email paid posts to subscribers?
No. A Supporters post is read on the Supporters page, and nothing emails it out. Newsletter email goes free to every active subscriber. Emailing paid posts is on Magpie's roadmap. Substack sends each paid post to paying readers' inboxes.
Does Magpie have yearly subscriptions, free trials or discounts?
Yearly prices, yes; trials and discounts, no. A paid Supporters tier can offer a yearly price beside its monthly one, and each supporter chooses when they join. There is no free trial or discount code. You can give someone complimentary access to any tier, with an end date. Substack has monthly and yearly plans, a founding tier, free trials, coupons and gifts.
Can readers comment on my posts in Magpie?
No. Newsletter web copies and Supporters posts have no comments. A public Message Board takes posts and comments from anyone signed in to Magpie. It is separate from the newsletter. Substack has threaded comments with moderation on every post.
Does Magpie have a chat for subscribers?
No. No Magpie chat or board can be kept for subscribers or paying supporters. Team chat is for the team's members and guests. Substack gives each publication a chat for all readers, paying readers or founding members.
Does Magpie have anything like Substack Notes?
No. The Newsletter has no feed of short posts. Social Media publishes short posts to Bluesky, Mastodon and LinkedIn instead. Substack's Notes are short posts with likes, restacks and replies, in a feed readers follow.
Will new readers find my newsletter on Magpie?
No. Magpie has no directory of newsletters, no recommendations between writers and no referral rewards. New subscribers come from the signup page address you share. Substack shows recommended publications to each new subscriber, and rewards readers who refer others.
Does Magpie have an app for readers?
No. Subscribers read each email in their mail program or on its web copy. The Magpie app is for members and is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Substack has iPhone and Android apps for readers, with a feed and notifications.
Can I host a podcast on Magpie?
Yes. Podcast hosts MP3 episodes with a public page and an RSS feed, and Podcast Settings shows the steps to add it to Apple Podcasts and Spotify. The Recorder records you with guests in a browser. Free has 1 podcast with 10 episodes; a paid plan has 5 podcasts. Episodes are not emailed to Newsletter subscribers, as Substack's are.
Can I give paying subscribers a private podcast feed on Magpie?
No. A Podcast's RSS feed is public while the podcast is on. There is no feed for supporters only, and no transcript on an episode. Substack gives paying subscribers a private feed for their own podcast app.
Can I go live on video with my readers on Magpie?
No. Webinars runs live video with chat and a replay. It is not open to members yet. Substack's live streams have chat, a saved recording and RTMP for outside streaming software.
Can my Magpie newsletter use my own domain?
No. The signup page and web copies are at Magpie's address, under /newsletter/. Websites, Store and link pages can use your own domain, but the Newsletter cannot yet. Substack connects a custom domain for a one-time fee.
Does Magpie show who opened an email and what they clicked?
No, not for the Newsletter. An email's page shows how many copies were delivered, failed and skipped. Outreach, on a paid plan, lists the links each person followed when Click tracking is on. Substack shows opens and clicks for each post.
Can I put a signup form on my website?
Yes. Newsletter settings gives the signup form's code to paste into a page of your website. Visitors subscribe there and confirm their address by email. A Store home page can also show a Newsletter sign-up section. Substack has an embeddable subscribe widget.
Does Substack have a shop?
No. Substack's ways to earn are subscriptions, gifts, group plans, pledges and sponsorships. Its features page lists no shop for products or downloads. Magpie's Store sells both through your own Stripe account. A box at checkout adds the buyer to the Newsletter.
Can I use Substack and Magpie together?
Yes. Substack can carry your writing while Magpie runs your shop, booking pages, invoices and website. A Magpie website or booking page can link to your publication. Store exports its customers as a CSV file. Substack imports a CSV of subscribers who agreed to hear from you.
How do I move from Substack to Magpie?
Start a newsletter, then import your Substack subscriber export in Subscribers. Past posts cannot be imported, so Past emails starts empty. Paying subscribers cannot be imported either: each one joins again through Supporters and Stripe's checkout. Keep Substack until your readers have moved.
How many subscribers can I have on Magpie?
250 on the Free plan and 5,000 on Pro or the Team plan, with 1,000 and 50,000 emails a month. Personal and each team have one newsletter. Substack has no limit on subscribers.
What is included in Magpie's Free plan?
The Newsletter with 250 subscribers and 1,000 emails a month, scheduling and your own email design. Supporters with 3 paid tiers, a podcast, Store, booking pages, Invoicing, 1 website and a team of 3. A paid plan raises the limits.