Trello compared with Magpie

Trello vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

Trello and Magpie both let a team move its work through stages on boards of cards. Each card has a description, comments, a due date and a checklist. They are built around different things.

  1. Trello is a product for boards, lists and cards, with views, automation and Power-Ups added to it. It is built for teams that run their work on many boards. They sort cards with labels and fields, and let automation move them.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and Kanban Boards is one part of it. Beside the boards it includes To-dos, Calendar, Time Tracking, Invoicing, Mail, Documents and more. It is built for someone whose boards are one part of running the business.
Create account
Robin Mazur’s Autumn launch board in Personal, with cards in Inbox, To do, In progress and Done, some with a due date and To-dos.

How is Magpie different?

1. Boards come with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • Kanban Boards for work that moves through stages, with To-dos on a card
  • To-dos and Calendar for each person's day, across Personal and every team
  • Issues for bugs and product work, with labels, custom fields and rules
  • Time Tracking and Invoicing, so tracked time becomes a line on an invoice
  • Mail, Documents, Team chat, Contacts, Meetings and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. Trello holds boards and cards. Its Power-Ups connect them to the apps that hold the rest.

2. A team pays one price

The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, with no limit on boards. Adding a person to the team does not change the bill. Guests take no place on the plan. Trello's paid plans are priced per user.

3. People outside the team can suggest cards

A board's outside access lets anyone signed in to Magpie view it. It can also let them suggest cards, comment and heart. A suggested card lands in the Inbox column, marked Suggested. Moving it out approves it, and the board's creator gets an email. Each card shows how many hearts it has.

Comparing Magpie and Trello

Trello does more inside the board; Magpie does more around it. Every line in the tables below was checked against Trello's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatTrelloMagpie
Boards of cardsCards in lists that move through stages Yes Yes
LabelsNamed, coloured tags, several on a card Yes One colour a card
Several people on a cardEveryone working on it, shown on the card Yes One assignee
ChecklistsSteps on a card, each with a person and a date Yes To-dos on a card
Custom fieldsYour own fields, such as a number or a choice Standard and above No
File attachmentsDocuments and files on a card Yes Images only
ArchivePut finished cards away and bring them back Yes No
InboxJot tasks down, then sort them onto boards Yes To-dos
Calendar, timeline and table viewsThe same board seen another way Premium and above No
Board filterShow only the cards that match Yes No
AutomationRules, buttons and scheduled commands Yes No
TemplatesStart a board or a card from a ready-made one Yes JSON import
Live updatesTeammates' changes appear as they make them Yes Yes
Suggestions from outside the teamOutsiders add cards for you to approve No Yes
Power-Ups and integrationsSlack, Google Drive, Jira and more on a board Yes No
An assistant for the boardsAsk it to find, add and move cards Through an AI app Yes
AI apps through MCPClaude or ChatGPT working on your boards Yes Yes
Phone and desktop appsApps for phones, Mac and Windows, offline on phones Yes In the browser
Export a boardTake a board out as a file Yes No
SAML single sign-onSign in through the company's identity provider Atlassian Guard, separate No
Mail, documents and invoicesThe rest of the work in the same account No Yes

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Boards, lists and cards

Both hold a project as columns of cards that you drag from stage to stage. Trello also archives cards, folds a list away, and moves or copies cards to other boards.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Make a board for a project and lay out its stages as lists Source Yes Yes
Add cards and drag them from list to list as the work moves on Source Yes Yes
Make a board look like our own, with a background and pictures on the cards Source Magpie: A card can take any colour, which shades the whole card on the board. A board has no background, and a card's images show as a count on its front, not as a cover. Yes Partly
Paste a list of lines and get a card for each Source Magpie: A pasted list becomes the title of one card. A whole board of cards can be built at once by pasting JSON, which an AI assistant can write from the list. Yes No
Keep as many cards on a board as the work needs Source Magpie: A board holds up to 500 cards and 20 columns. A deleted card no longer counts, and nothing can be archived to make room. Yes Partly
Move or copy a card, or a whole list, to another board Source Magpie: A card moves only between the columns of its own board, and cannot be copied. To have it elsewhere, it is added again on the other board. Yes No
Put finished cards away without deleting them, and bring one back later Source Magpie: Delete card removes a card and its comments after you confirm, and nothing brings it back; its To-dos stay in To-dos. Otherwise a finished card stays in a Done column. Yes No
Fold a list away to just its name and card count Source Magpie: Columns are always open, and a wide board scrolls sideways. Yes No
Work a board from the keyboard Source Yes Yes

Good to know: A Magpie board has up to 20 columns and 500 cards. A board lists its keyboard shortcuts when you press the question mark key.

Card details

Both give a card a Markdown description, comments, a due date and a checklist. Trello adds several members, labels, reminders and custom fields. They do it better than we do today.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Write a card's details and talk about it in comments Source Yes Yes
Put the people doing the work on a card Source Magpie: A card has one assignee, a member of the board's team, shown on the front of the card. Someone else can be given a To-do on the card instead. Yes Partly
Give a card a start date, a due date and time, and a reminder Source Magpie: A card has a due date with no time, shown on its front. It has no start date, no reminder and no way to mark it done. A To-do on the card can have a date, a time and an email reminder. Yes Partly
Have a card come round again on a schedule Source Magpie: A card does not repeat. A To-do on the card can, such as every Thursday, and each occurrence comes back in To-dos. Yes Partly
Sort cards with named, coloured labels Source Magpie: A card has one colour, which shades the whole card; the picker offers the colours already used on the board. There are no named labels. Issues has labels shared by the team. Yes Partly
Break a card into steps and tick them off Source Yes Yes
Attach files and links to a card Source Magpie: A card holds up to 10 images or screenshots from Your images, and comments can carry images. Other files, such as a PDF or a spreadsheet, cannot be attached; a link can go in the description. Issues attaches any file. Yes Partly
Keep my own fields on cards, such as a number, a date or a choice from a list Source Magpie: A card has its title, description, column, assignee, due date and colour only. Issues has custom fields of seven types. Yes No
Vote for the cards that matter most Source Yes Yes
Show one card on several boards, changed in one place Source Magpie: A card belongs to one board. Its To-dos also show in To-dos, but the card itself is seen only on its board. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie card's checklist is To-dos. Each is also in To-dos and on Calendar. It has its own date, time, reminder, repeat and assignee.

Inbox and Planner

Trello's Inbox collects cards typed in or sent by email. Planner books time for them on a calendar. Magpie's To-dos collects your tasks from Personal and every team.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Jot tasks down in one place, then sort them onto boards Source Magpie: To-dos is that list: add one on the To-dos page, from Dashboard or with the assistant, with a date or a repeat read from its title. A To-do cannot be turned into a card or moved onto a board. Yes Partly
Turn an email or a chat message into a task Source Magpie: Mail and Team chat cannot make a To-do or a card from a message, and a board has no email address. A Note can be turned into a To-do. Yes No
Set aside time on my calendar for the work on my boards Source Magpie: Calendar shows each team's dated To-dos, To-dos on its cards included, at their times beside its events, and Personal Calendar also shows meetings and Google Calendar events. A card cannot be dragged into a time, and Outlook does not connect. Yes Partly

Good to know: A To-do takes a date or a repeat from its title, such as every Thursday. Calendar shows dated To-dos at their times, beside the team's events.

Views, search and filters

On Premium and above, Trello shows a board as a calendar, a timeline, a table, a dashboard or a map. Any board can be filtered. A Magpie board is seen as columns, with every card showing.

WhatTrelloMagpie
See a board's cards on a calendar by their dates Source Magpie: Card due dates are not on Calendar. A To-do on a card shows on its team's Calendar on its date. Yes Partly
See cards on a timeline from start to finish Source Magpie: A board is seen only as columns, and a card has no start date to place on a timeline. Yes No
See cards as a table to sort and edit, on one board or across several Source Magpie: Cards are seen only on their board, column by column. Issues has a list that sorts and groups. Yes No
See charts of a board's cards by list, person and due date Source Magpie: Each column's header shows how many cards it holds; there are no charts. Yes No
Put cards that have a place on a map Source Magpie: A card has no place of its own; an address can be written in its description. Yes No
Show only the cards that match a person, a label, a due date or a word Source Magpie: A board always shows every card. The assistant lists a board's cards by column, assignee or due date, and Issues has filters and saved views for issues. Yes No
Search every board for a card Source Magpie: Search and Command-K find boards by name, not cards. The assistant searches the cards on every board by their title or description, and their comments by their words. Yes Partly

Good to know: The assistant searches the cards on every board by their words. It lists a board's cards by column, assignee or due date.

Automation

Trello runs rules, buttons and scheduled commands on every plan, within a monthly allowance of runs. Magpie's cards move by hand or through the assistant.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Have cards move or change by themselves when something happens Source Magpie: Cards move only by hand or through the assistant. Issues has rules that set an issue's status or priority when it changes. Yes No
Run several steps on a card with one button Source Magpie: Each step is done by hand; the assistant carries out several changes asked for in one message. Yes No
Keep a board tidy on a schedule or by due date Source Magpie: Nothing on a board runs on a schedule. A To-do on a card can repeat and send a reminder. Yes No

Good to know: The assistant carries out several changes asked for in one message. Issues, in the same team, has rules that set an issue's status or priority.

Templates

Trello starts boards from a gallery of templates, copies boards, and makes cards from template cards. Magpie starts every board with Inbox, To Do, In Progress and Done.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Start a board from a ready-made template Source Magpie: A new board starts with Inbox, To Do, In Progress and Done. There is no template gallery, but a board can be built from a JSON document, and Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write one. Yes Partly
Copy a board to start a new one like it Source Magpie: A board cannot be copied or exported. Its columns and cards can be written into a JSON document and imported as a new board. Yes No
Make new cards from a template card Source Magpie: Each card starts empty. Import JSON adds a set of prepared cards, with descriptions, due dates and colours, to a board in one step. Yes No

Good to know: Import a board from JSON builds a board with its columns and cards. Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write that JSON from a description.

Sharing and collaboration

Both bring a team onto a board and keep a log of its activity. On both, teammates' changes appear on an open board as they make them. Trello also notifies mentions and watchers, and keeps a board to chosen members.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Bring my team onto a board to work on it together Source Yes Yes
See teammates' changes on a board as they make them Source Yes Yes
Mention a teammate on a card, or follow a card, and be told when it changes Source Magpie: The person who added a card gets one email about the changes others make to it, and an app notification for each comment. There are no mentions, nobody else can follow a card, and an assignee is not told. Yes Partly
See everything that happened on a board Source Yes Yes
Keep a board to some people in the team, or let some only look Source Magpie: Everyone on the team opens all of its boards. Member access, set for the whole team, makes members View only or able to edit; a board cannot be kept to some members. Yes Partly
Let someone outside the team work on one board Source Magpie: A guest given Kanban Boards opens every board in the team, not one. A board's outside access lets anyone signed in to Magpie view it, or also suggest cards, comment and heart, but not edit. Yes Partly
Show a board to anyone with the link Source Magpie: Outside access shows a board to anyone signed in to Magpie. Someone signed out signs in first, and an email address with no account gets a free one. Yes Partly
Take card suggestions from people outside the team, and approve them Source Trello: On a public board, anyone with an account can comment and vote, but only board members add cards; suggested cards have no queue of their own. No Yes

Good to know: A Magpie board that takes suggestions lets anyone signed in suggest a card. It lands in the Inbox column, and moving it out approves it.

Power-Ups, AI and connected apps

Trello adds Power-Ups from a directory of more than 200, and AI that writes a card's text. Both connect to AI apps such as Claude and ChatGPT through MCP.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Add other tools to a board, such as Google Drive, Slack or Jira Source Magpie: Kanban Boards has no add-ons and no connections to other apps. The API and connected apps reach its boards from outside. Yes No
Have AI write or tidy a card's text Source Magpie: The assistant adds and edits cards and their descriptions from a message, and Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write a whole board. Nothing inside a card writes for you. Yes Partly
Let an AI app such as Claude or ChatGPT work on my boards Source Yes Yes
Ask an assistant inside the product to find, add and move cards Source Trello: Changing boards by chat goes through an outside AI app connected to the MCP server; the AI inside Trello writes text and plans time. Partly Yes

Good to know: Connected apps link Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor and others to Magpie. Free connects 2 apps and Pro 10.

Admin, data and apps

Trello has apps for phones and computers, and its phone apps work offline. It exports boards and offers SAML sign-in through Atlassian Guard. Magpie's boards work in the browser.

WhatTrelloMagpie
Have a large team on the same boards Source Magpie: A team has 3 members on Free and 25 on the Team plan. Guests take no place, up to 100 on a paid plan, and one given Kanban Boards can use every board. Yes Partly
Control who can create, delete and invite on the team's boards Source Magpie: Admins choose which areas each member opens and whether members can edit at all. Anyone who can edit can create and delete boards. Yes Partly
Sign in through our company's identity provider Source Magpie: People sign in with a password and two-factor code, a passkey, or a Google, Apple, LinkedIn or GitHub account. Yes No
Take a board out as a file Source Magpie: A board cannot be exported. The assistant and connected apps can read its cards. Yes No
Build a whole board, with its lists and cards, from a file Source Trello: Trello's help says a board cannot be re-created by importing JSON or CSV.Magpie: Import a board from JSON on Kanban Boards builds a board with its columns and cards, Import JSON in a board's More menu adds them to that board, and Copy the prompt has an AI assistant write the document. It reads Magpie's own format, so a Trello export does not load as it is. No Partly
Use boards on a phone Source Yes Yes
Keep working on boards with no connection Source Magpie: Boards need a connection: a change is saved to Magpie as it is made, and nothing is kept to work on without one. Yes No
Use boards in an app on Mac or Windows Source Magpie: Kanban Boards is used in a browser on a computer. Yes No
Group boards into collections Source Magpie: Kanban Boards lists Personal's or a team's boards in one list, with no grouping. Yes No

Good to know: Guests take no place on the plan: up to 10 on Free and 100 on a paid plan. A guest given Kanban Boards opens every board in the team.

Price comparison

How Trello charges

Trello charges by plan and by user. Free has 10 boards and 10 collaborators for a team, with unlimited cards and Power-Ups. Standard, Premium and Enterprise are priced per user. Standard adds custom fields, advanced checklists and guests on one board. Premium adds the calendar, timeline, table, dashboard and map views. Single sign-on comes with Atlassian Guard, a separate subscription included with Enterprise. Prices are on Trello's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. The plan sets how many boards, team members and guests you have, not which areas you can use. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per user. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planTrelloMagpie
How a team paysPer user, per month, on Standard and aboveOne Team plan for up to 25 people
Free plan10 boards and 10 collaborators, unlimited cards1 board of up to 500 cards, a team of 3
Boards on a paid planNo limitNo limit
GuestsOn one board on Standard; on several boards on Enterprise10 on Free, 100 on a paid plan
Automation250 runs a month on Free, 1,000 on Standard, no limit on Premium and aboveNot available
Calendar, timeline and table viewsPremium and aboveNot available
File attachments10 MB a file on Free, 250 MB on paid plansUp to 10 images a card
Single sign-onAtlassian Guard, a separate subscription; included with EnterpriseNot available
To-dos, Time Tracking, Invoicing and MailNot offeredIncluded; Mail needs a paid plan

When to choose Magpie or Trello

  • Want your boards beside To-dos, time tracking, invoices, mail and documents, for one price for the whole team? Go with Magpie.
  • Want labels, automation, calendar and timeline views and Power-Ups, with apps that work offline? Trello is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a team that runs its work on many boards
Trello. Labels, custom fields, filters and the table view keep a lot of cards in order. Free has 10 boards, where Magpie's Free has 1.
For a team that repeats the same steps
Trello. Rules, buttons and scheduled commands move cards, add checklists and tidy boards. Magpie's cards move by hand or through the assistant.
For someone who works from a phone
Trello. Trello's apps for iOS and Android work offline and sync once back online. Magpie's boards work in a phone's browser, with a connection.
For a freelancer or a studio that bills by the hour
Magpie. A To-do on a card starts a Time Tracking timer. Billable time goes onto an invoice in Invoicing. The client's contact, Mail and Calendar are in the same team.
For a business that takes ideas from its customers
Magpie. People outside the team suggest cards and heart the ones they want. A suggestion waits in the Inbox column until you approve it.
For a small team with one shared board
Either. Both put cards in columns with an assignee, a due date, comments and a checklist. Choose by whether you need labels and automation, or the rest of the business beside the board.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Trello and Magpie?

Trello is a product for boards, lists and cards, with views, automation and Power-Ups. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its Kanban Boards is one area beside To-dos, Calendar, Time Tracking, Invoicing and Mail. Trello does more inside the board; Magpie does more around it.

Does Magpie replace Trello?

Yes, for a small team that runs its work on a few boards. A Magpie card has an assignee, a due date, a colour, comments, images and To-dos. The board keeps an activity log. The same team has Calendar, Time Tracking, Invoicing and Mail.

Consider keeping Trello if you sort cards with labels and custom fields, or let automation move them. Keep it too if you need calendar and timeline views, Power-Ups, or apps that work offline. Trello does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does Trello cost?

Trello's Free plan has 10 boards and 10 collaborators, with unlimited cards and Power-Ups. Standard, Premium and Enterprise are priced per user. Single sign-on needs Atlassian Guard, a separate subscription included with Enterprise. The prices are on Trello's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. Free includes 1 Kanban board and a team of 3. Pro and the Team plan have no limit on boards. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per user. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Does Magpie have labels on cards?

No. A card has one colour, which shades the whole card. The colour has no name, and a card cannot have several. Issues, in the same team, has named labels for issues. Trello's labels have a name and one of 30 colours, several on a card.

Can several people be on one Magpie card?

No. A card has one assignee, a member of the board's team, shown on its front. Someone else can be given a To-do on the card, with its own date. Trello puts any number of board members on a card.

Does Magpie have custom fields on cards?

No. A card has a title, a description, a column, an assignee, a due date and a colour. Issues, in the same team, has custom fields of seven types for issues. Trello's custom fields are a checkbox, date, dropdown, number or text, on Standard and above.

Does Magpie have automation like Trello's?

No. Cards move by hand or through the assistant, and nothing on a board runs on a schedule. Issues has rules that set an issue's status or priority when it changes. Trello's rules, buttons and scheduled commands are on every plan. Free has 250 runs a month and Standard 1,000.

Does Magpie have a calendar or timeline view of a board?

No. A board is seen only as columns. A card has a due date but no start date. A To-do on a card shows on its team's Calendar on its date. Trello's calendar, timeline, table, dashboard and map views are on Premium and above.

Can I archive a card in Magpie?

No. Delete card removes a card and its comments after you confirm, and nothing brings it back. Its To-dos stay in To-dos. A finished card can stay in a Done column instead. Trello archives cards and lists, and restores them from Archived items.

Can I attach files to a Magpie card?

Images only. A card holds up to 10 images or screenshots from Your images, and comments can carry images. A PDF or a spreadsheet cannot be attached, but a link can go in the description. Trello attaches any file, up to 10 MB on Free and 250 MB on paid plans.

Do teammates' changes show on a Magpie board straight away?

Yes. Cards that others add, move, edit or delete appear on an open board within a few seconds, without a reload. The initials of the others who have the board open are in the page bar. People outside the team who open a shared board see changes when they reload it. Atlassian's help says Trello shows each change as it is made.

Does Magpie tell me when a card changes?

Partly. The person who added a card gets one email about the changes others make to it, comments included. Cards have no mentions, nobody else can follow a card, and an assignee is not told. Trello notifies mentions and watched cards, lists and boards by email, in the browser and on phones.

Can I move or copy a card to another board in Magpie?

No. A card moves only between the columns of its own board, and cannot be copied. To have it on another board, add it again there. Trello moves and copies cards and lists to any board. It mirrors a card on Standard and above.

Does Magpie have Power-Ups or integrations?

No. Kanban Boards has no add-ons and connects to no other apps. Magpie's API and Connected apps reach its boards from outside. Claude or ChatGPT can work on them through MCP. Trello's directory has more than 200 Power-Ups, unlimited on every plan.

Does Magpie have an AI assistant for boards?

Yes. The assistant lists boards, finds cards and reads their comments. It makes boards and columns, and adds, edits and moves cards from a message. It deletes only after you confirm. Trello's AI writes and tidies a card's text. Its MCP server lets an outside AI app change boards.

Can people outside my team suggest cards?

Yes, in Magpie. On a board that takes suggestions, anyone signed in to Magpie can suggest a card. It can have a description and images. It lands in the Inbox column marked Suggested, and moving it out approves it. On a public Trello board, people with an account can comment and vote, but only members add cards.

Can a client see one board without seeing the rest?

Partly. A guest given Kanban Boards opens every board in the team. A board's outside access lets anyone signed in to Magpie view that one board. It can also let them suggest cards, comment and heart. Trello's Standard plan has guests on a single board. A public Trello board opens for anyone with its link.

Does Magpie have recurring cards?

No. A card does not repeat, but a To-do on the card can, such as every Thursday. Each occurrence comes back in To-dos. Trello's recurring due date moves on when the card is marked done, and the card opens again.

Does Magpie have phone and desktop apps?

No. Kanban Boards works in a phone's browser, where a card opens to edit, comment and move. The Magpie app shows a board a column at a time. It is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. Trello has apps for iOS, Android, Mac and Windows, and its phone apps work offline.

Can I use Trello and Magpie together?

Yes. Trello can hold the team's boards while Magpie runs the invoices, time tracking, mail, bookings and website. Nothing links the two by itself, so a Trello card and a Magpie invoice are not connected.

How do I move from Trello to Magpie?

Export each board from Trello as JSON, which any member can do. In Magpie, Import a board from JSON builds a board with its columns and cards. It reads Magpie's own format, so the Trello file does not load as it is. Copy the prompt has an AI assistant convert it. Each card keeps its title, description, due date and colour. Cards arrive unassigned, without comments or attachments.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

1 Kanban board with up to 500 cards, To-dos, Issues, Time Tracking, Calendar and Invoicing. A team of 3, 10 guests and 2 connected apps. Pro and the Team plan have no limit on boards, and Mail needs a paid plan.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Trello changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for Trello's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Plan your team's work on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then make your first Kanban board.

Create account