DocuSign compared with Magpie

DocuSign vs Magpie: an in-depth comparison

DocuSign and Magpie both send a document to people to sign online, with a record of who signed and when. They are built around different things.

  1. DocuSign is an electronic signature service, with forms, payments, identity checks and notaries built around the signature. It is built for a business that sends many agreements, including from inside other software such as Salesforce and Microsoft 365.
  2. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software, and E-Signatures is one part of it. Beside the signing it includes ready-made agreements, proposals, invoicing, contacts and the other areas a business runs on. It is built for someone whose contracts are one part of running the business.
Create account
Placing fields on Callahan Studio’s project agreement with Albers Coffee: a signature and a date field for Maria Szczepanski and for Robin Mazur, each in their own colour.

How is Magpie different?

1. Signing comes with the rest of the business

One Magpie subscription includes the areas a small business would otherwise buy one at a time:

  • E-Signatures, for any PDF, with starters, signing order, reminders and a certificate of completion
  • Agreements, with standard agreements from named publishers filled in by answering questions
  • Proposals, where the client chooses a package, signs and pays a deposit on one page
  • Invoicing, with recurring invoices and payment by card
  • Contacts, Documents, PDF Editor, Meetings, Mail, Websites and the other areas, in the same team

Everything is in one account with one bill. A contact's page lists the documents they signed, beside their invoices and proposals.

2. Sending for signature is free, with no limit

E-Signatures is on every Magpie plan, the Free plan included, and no plan limits how many requests you send. Signers pay nothing either. Magpie makes them a free account with no password, and their signed copy stays in it.

3. A proposal is signed and paid on one page

In Proposals the client reads your proposal, chooses a package and options, and Magpie works out the totals again. They accept and sign on the same page, then pay the deposit invoice by card. The signed PDF and its certificate are made at once.

Comparing Magpie and DocuSign

DocuSign does more around the signature; Magpie does more around the business. Every line in the tables below was checked against DocuSign's own pages, linked from each row, and against Magpie's code and Help.

Platform

WhatDocuSignMagpie
Electronic signaturesSend a document to people to sign online Yes Yes
Sending without payingSend for signature on a free plan No Yes
Reusable documentsA document saved with its roles and fields Yes Yes
Ready-made agreementsStandard contracts to start from Yes Partly
ProposalsPackages and options the client chooses, signs and pays for Partly Yes
Payment when signingThe signer pays by card as part of signing Business Pro and above Yes
Bulk sendOne document to a list, each person signing their own copy Business Pro and above No
Signing link for a websiteA link anyone can open, fill in and sign Business Pro and above No
Forms that fill in an agreementThe signer answers questions, and the answers fill the document Business Pro and above Partly
Identity checksA code by text message, or a photo ID Add-on No
Online notaryA notary over video Yes No
Advanced and qualified signaturesThe EU's higher eIDAS levels Enhanced plans No
Phone appsSend and sign in an iPhone or Android app Yes In the browser
Connections to other softwareGoogle Drive, Microsoft 365, Salesforce and more Yes No
APISend and track documents from your own software Business Pro and above Partly
InvoicingInvoices paid online No Yes
Contact recordsEvery document a client signed, on their record Through Salesforce and others, Enhanced Yes
Security certificationsISO 27001 and SOC 2 Yes No

Good to know: Where Magpie says No or Partly, the line under the row says what Magpie does instead. Each gap has an item on Magpie's roadmap, and the line changes on the day it ships.

Preparing documents

Both upload a document, place fields for each signer and save it to send again. DocuSign takes more kinds of file and field, shows fields by condition and places them by itself. They do it better than we do today.

WhatDocuSignMagpie
Upload a document and send it to people to sign by email Source Yes Yes
Send a Word file, a spreadsheet or a picture for signature, not only a PDF Source Magpie: E-Signatures takes PDFs only. A Word file can be imported into Documents and downloaded as a PDF, and the PDF Editor turns pictures into a PDF and sends it for signature, so any other file takes a step first. Yes Partly
Place signature, initials, date and text fields for each signer Source Yes Yes
Add drop-down lists, option buttons and number fields that check what is typed Source Magpie: Fields are Signature, Initials, Date signed, Name, Email, Text with an optional maximum length, and Checkbox. An Email field refuses an entry that is not an email address, but nothing offers a list of choices or takes only a number. Yes No
Show a field only when another is answered, and work out amounts from what the signer enters Source Magpie: In Proposals the totals and payment schedule are worked out again from the package and options the client chooses. In E-Signatures every field is always shown, and no field is worked out from another. Yes Partly
Fill in details on the document myself before sending it Source Yes Yes
Have the signature fields placed for me Source Magpie: Send for signature on an agreement puts a signature field on each party's signature line and a Date signed field on each date line. On an uploaded PDF every field is placed by hand, or comes ready from a starter. Yes Partly
Save a document with its signer roles and fields to send again Source Yes Yes
Start from a ready-made agreement, such as an NDA, a services contract or a lease Source Magpie: The Agreements Library has standard agreements from named publishers for fundraising, confidentiality, services, software, data protection and partnerships, filled in by answering questions and sent with their fields already placed. It has no leases, loans, employment contracts or tax forms. Yes Partly
Make each client's contract from my own template, with their details filled in Source Magpie: A proposal starter of your own can hold fields such as the client's first name, filled in for each client, who then accepts and signs it on its page. Agreements fills in the Library's own texts from your answers. For any other wording, Mail merge in Documents makes a copy with its placeholders filled in, which is downloaded as a PDF and sent from E-Signatures with its fields placed by hand. Yes Partly
Let the signer answer questions in a simple form that fills in the agreement Source Magpie: An agreement's questions are answered by the member who starts it, but some Library agreements, such as a SAFE, let the member leave a party's address, or the name and title of whoever signs for a company, for that signer to type in when they sign, and the answers are printed on the signed copy. There is no form of questions for the signer, and an answer to a form in Forms does not lead to a signature. Yes Partly
Put a signing link on my website that anyone can open, fill in and sign Source Magpie: The sender names every signer by email address before a request is sent, and each signing link opens only for its own signer. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie request takes a PDF of up to 25 MB and 500 pages. The PDF Editor fills in, redacts or rearranges a PDF first, and its Send for signature starts the request.

Sending and routing

Both set a signing order, remind signers and let a request expire. DocuSign adds bulk send, scheduled sending, recipients who only approve, and delivery by text message.

WhatDocuSignMagpie
Sign a document myself Source Yes Yes
Choose whether people sign one after another or all at once Source Yes Yes
Add people who approve the document or receive it without signing Source Magpie: In Proposals a recipient can read only, reading the proposal and asking questions without signing, and a team can require an admin to approve a proposal before it is sent. In E-Signatures everyone on a request is a signer with at least one field, and anyone else gets the signed PDF from you. Yes Partly
Remind signers automatically, and set a date the request expires Source Yes Yes
Send the same document to a list of people, each signing their own copy Source Magpie: Each request is one document for its own signers, so sending to many people takes a request for each, which a starter makes quicker. Yes No
Schedule a request to go out at a later date and time Source Magpie: Send to signers sends at once, and a draft waits until someone sends it. Yes No
Fix a mistake in a request after sending it Source Magpie: Before someone signs, Change signer replaces a signer's name and address, and the expiry can be extended. The document and fields cannot change after sending: Void request and Duplicate request send a corrected copy, and the signers are emailed that the first was cancelled. Yes Partly
Send the signing link by text message Source Magpie: Invitations and reminders go by email. Get signing link copies a signer's link to send another way, such as a text message from your own phone. Yes Partly
Send documents for signature without paying, and without a monthly limit Source DocuSign: There is no free plan. Personal sends 5 envelopes a month, Standard and Business Pro 100 a user a year, and Enhanced plans a limit agreed with sales. No Yes

Good to know: Get signing link copies a signer's link, so you can send it another way. It opens only in the Magpie account at that signer's address.

The signing experience

Both let a signer draw or type a signature on a computer or a phone, with nothing to install. DocuSign adds comments, file uploads from the signer, signing in person, more languages and your own branding.

WhatDocuSignMagpie
Let people sign without signing up or installing anything Source Yes Yes
Draw or type a signature, and use it in every place it is needed Source Yes Yes
Sign on a phone or tablet Source Yes Yes
Take payment when the client signs Source Yes Yes
Send a priced proposal that the client chooses from, signs and pays a deposit on Source DocuSign: A payment field can be added to any agreement, so the signer pays as they sign; the product pages describe no proposal with packages and options for the client to choose. Partly Yes
Discuss the document with signers in comments before they sign Source Magpie: On a proposal the client can Ask a question about the whole proposal or one section, or Request changes, and your reply is emailed to them and shown on the page. A signature request has no comments: a signer can decline with a reason, and other questions go by email. Yes Partly
Ask a signer to upload a file, such as a copy of their ID, when they sign Source Magpie: Signers fill in fields only; nothing asks them for a file. Yes No
Show signers the signing page and emails in their own language Source Magpie: The signing page and emails follow the team's Language for customers, or the signer's own: English, French, Spanish or German. Yes Partly
Have the agreement summed up in plain words, and ask questions about it Source Magpie: The assistant finds signature requests by title and status but does not read a document's text, and signers see only the document. Yes No
Have someone sign in person on my tablet or phone Source Magpie: Each signer signs in the Magpie account at their own email address, so on the sender's device they would first have to sign in there with a link or code emailed to them. There is no way to hand over a device for signing. Yes No
Let a signer hand the document to the right person to sign Source Magpie: The sender can replace a signer with Change signer before they sign; the signer cannot pass the document on themselves. Yes Partly
Show my logo and colours on the signing emails and pages Source Magpie: A proposal shows your logo, accent colour and fonts, and its email shows your business name with its button in the accent colour. E-Signatures' emails and signing page name the sender and their team, with no logo or colours of the team's own. Yes Partly

Good to know: A request linked to an invoice offers Pay once its contact has signed. Payment is by card, through your own Stripe account.

Signer identity and witnesses

Both limit a document to the invited address and can ask for an access code. DocuSign adds checks by text message, photo ID with a selfie, witnesses and online notaries.

WhatDocuSignMagpie
Make sure only the person invited can open and sign Source Yes Yes
Check a signer's identity with a code by text message or a photo ID Source Magpie: Identity rests on the signer's Magpie account at the invited address and an optional access code; nothing checks a phone number or an ID document. Yes No
Have a witness sign after a signer, as a deed needs Source Magpie: A witness can be added as a further signer with the role Witness, signing after the person they watch when signing is in order, and the certificate shows the role beside their name. The signer cannot name their own witness, and Magpie does not link a witness to the person they watched. Yes Partly
Have a document notarised online Source Magpie: Magpie does not notarise documents, as its Help says. Yes No

Good to know: A Magpie signer signs in to the account at their address and confirms it before Finish signing. The certificate records how and when they signed in.

Tracking, records and compliance

Both show who has opened and signed, and both make a certificate of completion. DocuSign adds folders, exported reports, a seal a PDF reader checks, and advanced signature levels.

WhatDocuSignMagpie
See who has opened and signed a document, and who is still to sign Source Yes Yes
Find sent documents and sort them into folders Source Magpie: Requests has a tab for each state, search by title, signer, request number or contact, and filters by contact, starter and sender. There are no folders. Yes Partly
Keep a record of who signed, when and how, as proof later Source Yes Yes
Seal the signed PDF so any later change shows when it is opened Source Magpie: The certificate records a fingerprint of the original and signed files, and the signed PDF keeps the original's bytes unchanged, so a copy can be checked against them. The PDF carries no digital certificate that a PDF reader checks by itself. Yes Partly
Sign at the EU's advanced or qualified electronic signature level Source Magpie: Magpie's signatures are simple electronic signatures, backed by the signer's account and the certificate of completion. Yes No
See reports on documents sent, signed and waiting, and export them Source Magpie: E-Signatures' Requests has tabs for All, Draft, Waiting, Completed, Declined, Expired and Voided, each with its count, and filters by contact, starter and sender, but nothing reports over time or exports the list. Proposals has reports on proposals sent, accepted, declined and expired, with a CSV download. Yes Partly
See every document a client has signed on their contact record Source DocuSign: Agreements reach customer records through the Salesforce, Microsoft Dynamics and NetSuite integrations, on Enhanced plans. Partly Yes
Check that the service holds independent security certifications Source Magpie: Magpie has no SOC 2 report or ISO 27001 certificate. Yes No

Good to know: Magpie's certificate lists each signer's name, address, time, IP address and browser. It also holds the SHA-256 of the original and signed files. Signers keep the signed PDF and certificate in their own accounts.

Teams and administration

Both share starters and sent documents with a team, with permissions for each person. DocuSign adds single sign-on on Enhanced plans.

WhatDocuSignMagpie
Share templates and sent documents with my team, with permissions for each person Source Yes Yes
Sign in through the company's identity provider Source Magpie: Members sign in with a password, an emailed link or code, a passkey, or Google, Apple, LinkedIn or GitHub; there is no SAML single sign-on. Yes No

Good to know: Requests and starters belong to Personal or a team. Members with edit access send them; members with view access see them and download the files.

Apps, APIs and integrations

DocuSign has phone apps, a full API with status updates, and connections to storage, chat and sales software. Magpie works inside its own areas, and they do this better than we do today.

WhatDocuSignMagpie
Send and sign from an iPhone or Android app Source Magpie: E-Signatures works in a phone's browser: upload a PDF or start from a starter, place fields by touch, send, remind and track requests, and sign documents sent to you. There is no app to install yet: the Magpie app is built but not in the App Store or Google Play. Yes Partly
Send documents for signature from my own software, and be told when they are signed Source Magpie: With Pro, an API key reaches E-Signatures in the version 1 API, listed in the OpenAPI file, to upload, set up and send requests and read their status. No webhook says when a signature request is signed (Proposals sends one when a proposal is accepted), and signing cannot be placed inside another site. Yes Partly
Connect it to the tools a team already uses, such as Google Drive, Salesforce and Microsoft 365 Source Magpie: E-Signatures works with Magpie's own Contacts, Invoicing, Agreements, Proposals and PDF Editor, and connects to no outside storage or sales tool. Yes No

Good to know: On Pro, Magpie's version 1 API uploads, sets up and sends signature requests and reads their status. Its endpoints are in the OpenAPI file.

Price comparison

How DocuSign charges

DocuSign charges by plan, Personal, Standard, Business Pro or Enhanced, billed monthly or yearly, with no free plan. Personal is for one person; Standard and Business Pro are priced per user. Each plan limits envelopes: 5 a month on Personal, and 100 a user a year on Standard and Business Pro. Bulk send, signing links, Web Forms, payments and the API need Business Pro or Enhanced. Text message delivery and ID checks are add-ons. Prices are on DocuSign's pricing page.

How Magpie charges

Magpie charges by plan, Free or a paid plan, for everything in the account. E-Signatures has no limit on any plan. The Free plan sends 5 proposals and 5 invoices a month. A paid plan has no limit on either. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people. Prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

On top of the planDocuSignMagpie
Sending without payingNot offeredIncluded on the Free plan
Documents you can send5 a month on Personal; 100 a user a year on Standard and Business ProNo limit
How a team paysPer user on Standard and Business ProOne Team plan for up to 25 people
Bulk send, signing links and paymentsBusiness Pro and EnhancedPayments included; no bulk send or signing links
Delivery by text messageAn add-on, paid for each deliveryNot offered; copy the signing link to send it yourself
ID checksAn add-on, paid for each attemptNot offered
Proposals and invoicesNot offeredIncluded: 5 proposals and 5 invoices a month on Free, no limit on a paid plan
APIBusiness Pro and EnhancedPro

When to choose Magpie or DocuSign

  • Want free e-signatures beside your proposals, invoices, contracts and contacts, with no limit on how many you send? Go with Magpie.
  • Want bulk send, ID checks, online notaries, phone apps and signing inside Salesforce or Microsoft 365? DocuSign is the right choice.

Recommendations by kind of business

For a freelancer or a consultant
Magpie. Send a proposal the client signs and pays a deposit on, then invoice the rest. Sending for signature costs nothing on the Free plan.
For a business that sends one form to many people
DocuSign. Bulk send gives each person on a list their own copy. A signing link on your website takes signers you do not know yet. Magpie needs a request for each person.
For a firm that must check who signs
DocuSign. Codes by text message, photo ID with a selfie, witnesses and online notaries are all on offer. Magpie relies on the signer's account and an optional access code.
For a sales team on Salesforce or Microsoft 365
DocuSign. Its integrations send and track agreements from the software the team already uses. Magpie connects to no outside sales software.
For a startup raising money or signing its first customers
Magpie. The Agreements Library fills in a SAFE, an NDA or a services agreement from your answers. It goes for signature with its fields placed. The signed copy is linked to the contact.
For a small team that signs a few documents a month
Either. Both send a PDF, remind signers and keep a certificate of completion. Choose DocuSign for more ways to check a signer, and Magpie for signing beside the rest of the business.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between DocuSign and Magpie?

DocuSign is an electronic signature service, with forms, payments, identity checks and notaries built around the signature. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its E-Signatures area sits beside Agreements, Proposals, Invoicing and Contacts. DocuSign does more around the signature; Magpie does more around the business.

Does Magpie replace DocuSign?

Yes, for a business that sends its own contracts, proposals and forms to a few people at a time. Magpie sends any PDF for signature, keeps starters, reminds signers and makes a certificate of completion, on every plan.

Consider keeping DocuSign if you send one document to a list or put a signing link on your website. Keep it if you must check a signer's ID. Keep it too for a notary, advanced EU signatures, phone apps or signing inside Salesforce. DocuSign does each of these better than Magpie does today.

How much does DocuSign cost?

DocuSign has Personal, Standard, Business Pro and Enhanced plans, billed monthly or yearly, with no free plan. Standard and Business Pro are priced per user. Personal sends 5 envelopes a month, and Standard and Business Pro send 100 a user a year. The prices are on DocuSign's pricing page.

How much does Magpie cost?

Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. E-Signatures has no limit on any plan. The Team plan is one price for up to 25 people, not a price per user. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.

Can I send documents for signature for free?

Yes, in Magpie. E-Signatures is on the Free plan, with no limit on requests. Sending to many new addresses within an hour makes the page ask you to wait. DocuSign has no free plan.

Do signers need an account?

DocuSign signers need no account and nothing to install. Magpie makes a free account with no password at the signer's address. The email's button signs them in the first time. Nobody fills in a sign-up form, and the signed copy stays in their account under Sent to you.

Does Magpie have bulk send?

No. Each request is one document for its own signers, so sending to many people takes a request for each. A starter makes each one quicker, since it needs only a name and an address. Bulk send is on Magpie's roadmap. DocuSign's Bulk Send, on Business Pro, takes a list or a CSV file.

Can I put a signing link on my website?

Not in Magpie. Every signer is named by email address before a request is sent. Each link opens only for its own signer. DocuSign's PowerForms, on Business Pro, give a link anyone can open, fill in and sign.

Does Magpie check a signer's identity?

No, beyond the signer's Magpie account at the invited address and an optional access code. Nothing checks a phone number or an ID document. The certificate records how and when the signer signed in. DocuSign offers codes by text or phone, and photo ID with a selfie as an add-on.

Does Magpie notarise documents?

No. Magpie's Help says so, and an online notary is on Magpie's roadmap. DocuSign connects signers with a notary over video.

Does Magpie offer advanced or qualified electronic signatures?

No. Magpie's are simple electronic signatures, backed by the signer's account and the certificate of completion. DocuSign's Enhanced plans add advanced and qualified signatures. These come with an identity check and a certificate from a trust service provider.

What proof does Magpie keep of a signature?

A certificate of completion for every finished request. It lists each signer's name, address, account, signing time, IP address and browser, and the consent they gave. It also has the activity list and the SHA-256 of the original and signed files. Every signer keeps it in their own account.

Can a client pay when they sign?

Yes, in both. A Magpie request linked to an invoice offers Pay once its contact has signed. Payment is by card, through your own Stripe account. DocuSign Payments takes card, bank or wallet payments during signing, on Business Pro and Enhanced.

Does DocuSign do proposals?

Not as Magpie's Proposals do. A DocuSign payment field can go on any agreement, but its pages describe no proposal with packages and options. In Magpie the client chooses a package and options, signs and pays the deposit on one page.

Can I send a Word file for signature?

DocuSign takes Word, Excel, PDF and other common files. Magpie's E-Signatures takes PDFs only. A Word file can be imported into Documents and downloaded as a PDF first. The PDF Editor turns pictures into a PDF.

Does Magpie have ready-made contracts?

Yes, in Agreements. The Library has standard agreements from Y Combinator, Common Paper, Bonterms, oneNDA, Papertrail and Series Seed. You answer questions, and the agreement goes for signature with its fields placed. It has no leases, loans, employment contracts or tax forms, which DocuSign's template gallery has.

Does Magpie have a phone app for signing?

E-Signatures works in a phone's browser. You can upload a PDF, place fields by touch, send and track requests, and sign. The Magpie app is not yet in the App Store or Google Play. DocuSign has apps for iPhone, iPad and Android on every plan.

Does Magpie connect to Google Drive or Salesforce?

No. E-Signatures works with Magpie's own Contacts, Invoicing, Agreements, Proposals and PDF Editor. It connects to no outside storage or sales software. DocuSign connects to Google Drive, Microsoft 365, Salesforce and more than 1,000 partners, depending on the plan.

Does Magpie have an API for e-signatures?

Partly. On Pro, the version 1 API uploads, sets up and sends requests and reads their status. No webhook says when a request is signed, and signing cannot be placed inside another site. DocuSign's APIs, on Business Pro and Enhanced, do both.

Does Magpie have SOC 2 or ISO 27001?

No. Magpie has no SOC 2 report or ISO 27001 certificate yet, and an independent audit is on its roadmap. DocuSign lists both on every plan.

Can I use DocuSign and Magpie together?

Yes, side by side, though they do not connect. A business might send ID-checked or bulk documents from DocuSign and its proposals, invoices and everyday contracts from Magpie.

How do I move from DocuSign to Magpie?

Upload each document you send often to E-Signatures as a PDF, place its fields, and use Save as starter. A new request then needs only each signer's name and address. Keep your DocuSign account until you have the signed copies you need from it.

What is included in Magpie's Free plan?

E-Signatures with no limit on requests, Agreements, the PDF Editor and Contacts. Proposals sends 5 a month and Invoicing 5 a month. A team of 3, and the other areas, are included too.

If a line on this page is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

DocuSign changes, and so does Magpie. If a line is out of date about either product, email support@magpie.diy with the page that shows it. We check the line against that page, change it, and give it the new date. That goes for DocuSign's own team as much as for anyone who uses it.

Send your first document for signature on Magpie's Free plan.

Create a Magpie account, then upload a PDF to E-Signatures.

Create account