What is the difference between BambooHR and Magpie?
BambooHR is an HR system built around a file for each employee. Hiring, onboarding, time off, reviews and an AI assistant are beside it. Payroll and benefits are add-ons for the United States. Magpie is one subscription for a small business's software. Its staff areas are Staff, Staff Scheduling, Hiring, Time Tracking and Payroll, beside the books and the rest. BambooHR does more inside HR; Magpie does more around it.
Does Magpie replace BambooHR?
Yes, for a small business that wants staff files, the rota and pay runs beside its books. Staff keeps each person's file, documents, time-off balances, checklists and policies. Staff Scheduling, Hiring, Time Tracking and Payroll cover the rota, hiring, hours and pay runs.
No, for a company whose HR runs on reviews, benefits and payroll taxes. Consider keeping BambooHR if you need performance reviews, custom fields, an org chart, benefits administration or payroll taxes filed. BambooHR does each of these better than Magpie does today.
How much does BambooHR cost?
BambooHR has three plans, Core, Pro and Elite, priced for each employee each month. A company of 25 or fewer pays a flat monthly price. Payroll, Time Tracking, Benefits Administration and Global Employment are add-ons. The prices are on BambooHR's pricing page.
How much does Magpie cost?
Magpie has a Free plan and paid plans, each covering every area. On the Free plan a pay run pays 2 employees. Paid plans pay everyone, with no price for each employee. A free team has 3 members and the Team plan 25. The prices are on Magpie's pricing page.
Does Magpie keep employee files?
Yes. Staff keeps a file for each person, with their details, employment, pay, emergency contacts, documents, qualifications and time off. History lists every change, with who made it. Each person keeps their own details up to date on My file. BambooHR's file also takes custom fields, which Magpie's does not.
Does Magpie track time-off balances?
Yes. Staff keeps each person's balance for each time-off policy, with accrual, pro rata allowances, carryover and holidays. A request that would take a balance too low is refused. BambooHR keeps balances for any number of leave policies on every plan.
Does Magpie have onboarding checklists?
Yes. Staff starts an Onboarding checklist when someone is added with a start date, and a Leaving checklist when their end date is set. Items go to the person or their manager, with due dates and reminders. Magpie has no ready-made tax or work-eligibility forms, which BambooHR's new-hire packets include.
Does Magpie have performance reviews?
No. Magpie has no review cycles, goals or one-to-ones. Performance reviews are on Magpie's roadmap. BambooHR runs reviews with self, manager and peer feedback, and 360 reviews on Pro and Elite.
Does Magpie have an org chart?
No. Each Staff file names the person's manager, but Magpie draws no chart and lists no one's reports. BambooHR's org chart can be searched, filtered and downloaded.
Does Magpie have applicant tracking?
Yes. Hiring publishes each job on the team's job board and its own page, and takes applications through a form. Candidates move through stages with notes, tags, scorecards and interviews. A hired candidate goes into Staff or Payroll in one step. BambooHR's hiring also sends offer letters and limits open jobs by plan.
Can Magpie post jobs to Indeed and LinkedIn?
No. A Magpie job page carries the details job search engines read, such as Google for Jobs. Share job starts a Social Media post with the job's address. BambooHR sends jobs to Indeed, ZipRecruiter, LinkedIn and other boards.
Does Magpie run payroll?
Yes. Payroll works out pay runs from salaries and tracked hours, with overtime, and gives each employee a payslip. It pays in the team's currency. It does not work out or file tax, and it does not pay by direct deposit. You pay from your bank and mark the pay run paid. BambooHR's Payroll add-on does both, for employees in the United States.
Does BambooHR have shift scheduling?
Yes, in the Time Tracking add-on. It plans one-time and repeating shifts by team or location, around availability and time off. Its page lists labour cost, planned against worked hours and scheduling by qualification as coming soon. Magpie's Staff Scheduling has all three on every plan.
Does Magpie have a time clock?
Partly. A person starts Time Tracking from their published shift, from two hours before it, in a phone's browser too. Scheduled and worked compares that time with the shift. There is no kiosk, no time clock, no break recording and no location on clock-in. BambooHR's Time Tracking add-on has all of these.
Does Magpie have employee surveys?
Partly. A form in Forms can be shared with staff as a link, and its Summary counts the answers to each question. It is not anonymous for people signed in, and it works out no score. BambooHR runs eNPS and wellbeing surveys, with AI summaries of the themes.
Does Magpie have an AI assistant for HR questions?
Partly. The assistant on Dashboard reads Documents and Notes. People can ask it about a handbook kept in either, if they can open it. It reads nothing from Staff, Staff Scheduling, Hiring or Payroll, so it cannot answer about pay or time off. Ask BambooHR answers from HR data and chosen documents, with a source for each answer.
Does Magpie offer benefits administration?
No. Magpie keeps no record of benefits and arranges none. A deduction and the team's contribution can be standing lines on an employee in Payroll. BambooHR tracks benefits on every plan, and its Benefits Administration add-on runs enrolment.
Does Magpie have compliance training?
No ready-made courses. Courses teaches courses you write, with quizzes and each student's completion, and staff can be students. Nothing assigns training by role or deadline. BambooHR assigns EasyLlama courses, from 1 on Core to more than 300 on Elite.
Does Magpie have a SOC 2 report?
No. Magpie has no SOC 2 report or ISO 27001 certificate. BambooHR is independently audited against SOC 2 Type II.
Does Magpie have a phone app?
Not in the App Store or Google Play yet. In a phone's browser, staff see their shifts, ask for time off, sign documents and read their payslips. Managers approve requests in the browser too. BambooHR's iOS and Android app does these, with clock-in and reviews.
Can I use BambooHR and Magpie together?
Yes. BambooHR can keep the employee files, balances and reviews while Magpie runs the rota, hiring, hours and the books. Staff Scheduling's reports download as CSV files. An API key on a paid plan reaches Hiring and Staff Scheduling. Magpie sends nothing to BambooHR by itself.
How do I move from BambooHR to Magpie?
Staff's Import people reads a JSON document of people. It takes their details, employment, pay, emergency contacts, qualifications and opening time-off balances. Copy the prompt copies instructions for an AI chat, which turns BambooHR's export into that document. Payroll's Import employees reads each employee's pay and year-to-date totals. Keep BambooHR's records for anything Magpie has no place for, such as custom fields and reviews.
What is included in Magpie's Free plan?
Staff, Staff Scheduling, Hiring, Time Tracking, E-Signatures and Payroll for 2 employees a pay run. Accounting, Invoicing and the other areas are in the same plan. A free team has 3 members, and a Staff file needs no Magpie account. A paid plan pays every employee and raises the other limits.